Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

Enter Keyword:

-Search tips
Onstream Media Powered Video
Teacher Resources

Non Native Species:
English Ivy-Landscape Plant or Deadly Killer?

Download a printable version (PDF)

Overview
Grade Level: 9-12
Background Information:

Biodiversity is simply the variety of life in an area. It includes all types of plants, animals, fungi, and microorganisms. A wide variety of organisms are necessary to maintain a healthy ecosystem and most organisms in an ecosystem are dependant on each other (interdependence). According to the Sierra Club, 'the "ecological services" provided by biodiversity include the supply of oxygen to the atmosphere, water purification, the prevention of floods and soil erosion, nutrient recycling, and pollination. Nearly half of all medicines used today originally came from wild organisms.' Link to Sierra Club Page

Biodiversity is currently being reduced by a number of human activities including agriculture, development, and the introduction of non-native species. Non-native species are plant or animal species that do not naturally occur in an area. These might be introduced by a number of different means. Some, such as Kudzu and English Ivy, are brought to an area as landscape plants. Others, such as cheat grass, were brought to western regions to help feed cattle. Still others come to an area without knowledge of people, as did the zebra mussel, which colonized ships and eventually overran the great lakes.

Organisms compete for resources in the ecosystem. Some of these resources include nutrients, space, water, and sunlight for plants. When non-native species are introduced into an ecosystem, they often don't have any natural predators or diseases and thus there is nothing to control their spread. When climatic conditions are right for them, they tend to out compete native species, taking more of the resources for themselves and leading to a decrease in diversity.

This activity will allow students to compare the biodiversity of areas that have been overrun by invasive species with more natural areas using tools that ecologists might use.

 

Content Standards
Related National Standards

This lesson addresses the following National Content Standards found at: http://books.nap.edu/html/nses

 

Content Standard C: As a result of their activities in grades 9-12, all students should develop understanding of:

  • Interdependence of organisms

Content Standard F: As a result of their activities in grades 9-12, all students should develop understanding of

  • Natural and human-induced hazards:
Extension Web Sites from PBS:

Scientific American Frontiers - Mediterranean on the Rocks
This is a good site that describes problems due to another real world invasive species, an alga in the Mediterranean, which escaped from an aquarium and has no natural predators.

Mediterranean on the Rocks: The Green Invader
A teacher resource with a related activity.

Scientific American Frontiers - Backyard Science: How Ecosystems Work
This is an excellent activity applying similar techniques to the real world and connecting to the tropic pyramid.

 

For sites with examples of research and species counts related to biodiversity, try the following two sites:

The Living Edens - Kakadu
Lists species in an area in Australia with high biodiversity.

Journey to Amazonia - Powerful Plants
This site contains a description of a study of biodiversity in the Amazon. In it, scientists use similar techniques to the ones students will use in this activity.

Activity 1: English Ivy-Landscape Plant or Deadly Killer?
Time Allotted:

One 45 minute class period

 

Materials:

Photocopy the grid on to overhead transparencies or tracing paper. One grid per group.

Photocopies of each of the forest floor photos. One copy of each per group.

Another option is to download the SpeciesMap.doc MSWord file. Students can use this file to do the activity on their computers. Simply grab the grid and drag it on top of the photo.

 

Objectives:
  • Students will be able to describe differences in flora between an area overrun by invasive species and one with native species.
  • Students will understand how competition for resources is affected by invasive species through a quantitative species count.
  • Students will learn how to measure percent cover and diversity of different species.
  • Students will demonstrate how competition from invasive species leads to decreased diversity of species by quantitative methods.
Watch the AFG Video Segment:
Play This Clip
Restoring Wildlife Habitat
One Oregon couple demonstrates how they created a lush wetland and diverse habitat on a working farm.

Note: Watch this video to introduce the concept of biodiversity. Clip starts at 'While the Halsey's wetland is a success, this forest presents a real predicament.' Stop the clip after hearing 'we have no mosquito problems, not at all, not at all.'

 

Discussion Questions for Video Segment:
  • Douglas Fir forests are a natural ecosystem in the Pacific Northwest where the Halsey's ranch is located. Why do you think they might be willing to cut it down in favor of oak savanna? Think in terms of regional biodiversity.

 

Classroom Activity:

The purpose of this activity is to have students calculate the percent cover and diversity of species in an area that has been overcome by English Ivy and one that hasn't (you may want to change the directions and the maps to represent species found in your own area, for instance Kudzu in the southeast has similar coverage patterns as English Ivy has in the Northwest). Diversity is the total number of plant species in an area while percent cover is how much of the land is covered by each species. Areas with higher diversity can provide for a richer ecosystem. However, since other factors such as rainfall and temperature also have an impact, diversity alone cannot account for ecosystem health. In this activity students will compare two squares from the same ecosystem.

Students may work in groups of 2 or 3.

Hand out the maps and grids (one set includes a copy of each map and 1 grid). Or, sign out a computer lab and download the photograps and grids as described above.

Have students:

  1. 1. Place the grid over the map. Note that the grid provided is smaller than the photos. Students should place the grid so that it fits somewhere entirely on the map. Each group will place it slightly differently so that the have slightly different results. This is meant to simulate some of the conditions that students would encounter when working in the field. You can use this activity to discuss with your students how scientific research is conducted.
  2. Look at each place on the grid where two lines cross and note which type of plant is there or if there is forest floor. Students can try to identify species if you want them to. Otherwise, the activity is written so that they just need to recognize the same species for counting.
  3. Make a data table that shows how many occurrences of each species there are in the area represented (a meter square). See sample below.
  4. Calculate the percent cover for each species. This should be the number counted divided by 25 (the total number of crosses).
  5. Repeat for the second map.
  6. You may want to have students make a bar graph or a pie chart showing percent cover for each of the two maps.
  7. Answer the analysis questions on the Student Instructions Handout.
Species Salal Sword Fern Forest Floor Ivy
Number 2 4 2 17
Percent cover 8% 16% 8% 68%

(note: this is only an example)

 

Watch the AFG Video Segment:
Play This Clip
Protecting the Karner Blue Butterfly
The Department of Natural Resources is taking an active role in protecting the habitat of the Karner blue butterfly.

Note: To help students answer the analysis questions, watch the video on the Karner Blue Butterfly. Start at the beginning and end after hearing 'which of course does not include wild lupin and nectar plants.'

 

Assessment:

Plants present on the native forest floor map include: bracken fern, trailing raspberry, vine maple, ducksfoot, and clematis.

The only plant present in the Ivy map is ivy.

Answer key to Analysis Questions:

  1. In the ivy desert, ivy accounted for most of the cover. Amounts might vary slightly by group depending on placement of grid.
  2. Percent cover measures how much sun each species receives.
  3. It's called an ivy desert because not much is growing there besides ivy. Some groups also use the term 'ivy wasteland' since deserts do have their own rich biodiversity. The term is to imply the sterility and monotony that occur when a single species dominates an area. (www.noivyleague.com)
  4. Almost no forest floor is visible in the ivy desert meaning that other species haven't got a chance to gain a foothold unless they can grow without sunlight.
  5. Ivy will continue to grow and kill trees and other native plants in the area. The park may become a giant ivy desert.
  6. Ivy reduces the biodiversity of the area.
  7. If there is lower diversity of flora, then fauna will start to decrease too. Some organisms are dependant on particular plant species; if these disappear then the other organisms will disappear too (see video clip on the Karner Blue Butterfly).
  8. The "ecological services" provided by biodiversity include the supply of oxygen to the atmosphere, water purification, the prevention of floods and soil erosion, nutrient recycling, and pollination. Nearly half of all medicines used today originally came from wild organisms. (from the Sierra Club)
  9. Remove the ivy, replant native species, stop human interference with the ecosystem.
  10. Counting each plant is too time consuming. If a scientist makes these kinds of measurements, he or she will get the basic picture although they might miss a few details.

 

Watch the AFG Video Segment:

Kudzu
Brought to the US as an ornamental plant from Asia, Kudzu has quickly taken over much of the South despite efforts to stop it.

Note: Ask students to make note of how fast kudzu spreads and to look at what happens to other species caught in its way.

 

Classroom Activity:

Measure the size of your classroom. At the rate kudzu grows, how long would it take to fill your classroom assuming it was lined up along one edge ready to grow?

 

Discussion Question for Video Segment:

What do you think happens to the plants covered by the kudzu? Why?

 

Activity 2: Measuring Biodiversity in Your Own Backyard
Time Allotted:

One and a half 45 minute class periods

 

Materials:

Examples of invasive species and native species from your local area

Plant I.D. books

Meter square quadrants (click to view directions for making your own quadrant)

 

Objectives:
  • Using ecologist's tools, students will compare diversity in the field.
  • Students will understand how greater plant biodiversity leads to greater animal biodiversity.
  • Students will learn how to fight back against native species.
Classroom Activity

Take students outside to measure diversity and percent cover in your area. You can make a grid for measuring out of PVC pipe or wood and string. Where are the directions. If there are no natural areas near your school, try measuring the diversity in a lawn compared to the diversity in a less manicured area such as under a tree or in a more native meadow. Or try comparing diversity in a chemically controlled lawn with that in a more naturally growing lawn.

 

Watch the AFG Video Segments:

Eradicating Non-Native Species from Milwaukee Parks
Milwaukee-area volunteers are working to remove invasive garlic mustard and buck thorn from local parks and restore natural plant species.

Note: Start at the beginning and stop after hearing '…able to displace them almost entirely.'

 


War on Weeds
To combat invasive, non-native plants, biologists are focusing on the plants' natural predators: insects.

Note: Start at the beginning and stop after hearing 'the loosestrife treatment is working.'

 

Discussion Questions for Video Segments:
  • What are some strategies that allow non-native species to outcompete the native species?
  • How do you think you might fight back against non-native species?
  • Think of at least two methods, other than biological controls, that people might use to try to get rid of invasive weeds? Are these better or worse than biological controls
  • Why do we have to be very careful before releasing a new insect into the ecosystem.

 

Extension Activities:
  • Research an invasive species from your area. You might start by looking at the Nature Conservancy's Wildland Invasive Species Program which has a map of the US that will help you identify some invasive species in your area. It also has a pretty comprehensive index of species and control methods.
  • Or check out this site produced by the Forest Park Ivy Removal Project for information about invasive species and ideas for research projects.
  • Conduct research on biodiversity and farming practices. How do monocultures (single species crops) affect biodiversity? How does genetic engineering affect biodiversity?