Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
art:21
art in the twenty-first century the series the artists education events discuss

teaching materials:
search the online lesson library:
Labor & Craftsmanship

overview

LESSON TITLE:
Traditional Crafts to Contemporary Ideas

ARTISTS:
Puryear, Mann, Suh, Sikander, Antoni

LEVEL:
Grades 9-12

SUBJECT AREA:
Social Studies

NATIONAL STANDARDS:
#1 Culture & cultural diversity
#2 People over time
#3 People & environments
#8 Science, technology, & society

THEMES:
Time

LESSON CONTRIBUTOR:
Kristine Bowen, Visual Art Teacher, High School for Legal Studies, Brooklyn, NY













"A lot of my work comes from an interest in how things are made and how things are done. And the way the materials are manipulated and used and the whole history of that in mankind’s past."
— Martin Puryear















"...My whole purpose of taking on the subject was to break the tradition, to experiment with it, to find new ways of making meaning."
— Shahzia Sikander














"There’s an organic aspect in much of my work that maybe has to do with keeping the 'rules' really open. And there’s this hand-made aspect in a lot of the work that just by nature creates its own signature..."
— Tim Hawkinson









 





"In the making process one has to try to leave space for the object to make itself. Making is a struggle between what you want the object to do and what the materials want to do."
— Janine Antoni
detail of Sikander's "Venus' Wonderland"
Shahzia Sikander: Venus's Wonderland, 1995-97
detail of photo from Mann's "Mother Land" series
Sally Mann: Mother Land series, 1996
Lesson 2—Traditional Crafts,
Contemporary Ideas

Many contemporary art-making practices call into question the very notion of “making” itself. Where does the “art” reside? In the idea? In the action? In the product? How has the artist incorporated the skills and techniques of the past into contemporary practices, and what do current skills and techniques tell us about who we are as a society and a culture?

The artists included in this lesson embody a variety of approaches to the notion of labor and craftsmanship. Martin Puryear combines practiced woodworking skills with a sensibility towards simplified forms. Sally Mann cultivates “flaws” in her photographic prints by using an antique photographic process. Do-Ho Suh constructs transparent fabric sculptures based on his familial home with the assistance of traditional craftspeople. Shahzia Sikander specializes in traditional Indian and Persian miniature painting while infusing it with personal history and contemporary context. Janine Antoni incorporates domestic crafts including spinning and weaving into her installations and sculptural work.

The lesson explores the role of labor and craftsmanship, tools and techniques in contemporary art, and how and when these practices impact meaning. Students will make connections between the use of traditional tools and techniques with contemporary artistic practices while researching the importance of artifacts in archeological investigation.
objectives

• Students will examine the notions of labor and craftsmanship as they study how cultural tools and techniques apply to artistic practice.

• Students will consider the use of tools and techniques as vehicles for understanding culture.

• Students will complete an archeological record and a social history incorporating research and personal opinion about historic and contemporary tools and techniques.


materials & resources

Art:21 Web Site
Touch & Moor - Janine Antoni interview & clip
Collodian Process - Sally Mann interview & clip
Mother Land series - Sally Mann art work
Stone Carving - Martin Puryear interview & clip
Abstration & Ladder... - Martin Puryear interview & clip
Islam and Miniature Painting - Shahzia Sikander interview & clip
Venus's Wonderland - Shahzia Sikander art work
Korea: Home and Displacement - Do-Ho Suh interview & clip

Additional Web Sites
http://www.clyes.clara.net/essays/artifacts.html
  The study of artifacts—archeology
http://www.aaanet.org
  Anthropology resources on the net
http://archnet.asu.edu
  A virtual library for archeology

Classroom Materials
• Examples of traditional and contemporary tools from current and historic usage
• Works of student art

critical questions

• What can we learn about past or distant cultures through the tools, techniques and products they create?

• How do anthropologists study the artifacts of the past to learn about isolated or ancient life and events?

• How might anthropologists in the future look at the tools and artifacts we currently use to create a social history of our time?

• How have we improved technology to improve our lives and change the way we do things?

• What are the tools visual artists use and how do they relate to other tools used in contemporary life?

• How have major innovations in technology impacted the way artwork is made?

• Does the word innovation always describe an advancement or an improvement?

• How is innovation related to the tools and skills of the past, and the tools and skills we utilize now?


activities

Traditional Tools and Technologies
Select a historical period (Colonial America, Ancient Egypt, Native Americans from the Southwest, etc.) and have students research the tools and technologies used in that culture. What special skills and tools did artists and artisans use and create? How did they learn these skills? If new tools or technologies became available, how did they impact artistic output?

The sculptor Martin Puryear says:

“As a woodworker, I use tools all the time. And just paying attention to tools, the evolution of woodworking tools in itself—there’s a certain art history to that. You look at the forms that various utilitarian things have taken throughout history and there’s a shifting sense of beauty with the way that the different cultures have shaped things that fit the hand and are used to do a job.”

Have students research the history of a tool from its first conception to contemporary time and document its impact on society. What human need was addressed by its invention? How did its use and design evolve over time? Is this tool still in use today or has it been surpassed by more recent inventions?
(Time: One 45 minute session)


Contemporary Practices
View the Art:21 segments on Season Two artists Martin Puryear, Do-Ho Suh, Janine Antoni, and Season One artists Sally Mann, and Shahzia Sikander, and read their transcript pages found on this Web site. Discuss with your students the relationships each of these artists has with traditional tools and techniques. Ask students to identify what traditional tools and techniques they use and what traditional tools and techniques are manipulated for use in a non-traditional manner. Discuss the importance of craftsmanship in each artist’s work. When and how does craftsmanship alter the meaning of the artwork? What might an anthropologist from the future infer about our culture if he or she found a work of art from each of these artists?
(Time: One 45 minute session)


Family Traditions
Janine Antoni talks about making things with her mother and the rest of her family. She describes her interest in the handmade and the important connections she makes between an object and its maker. Interview a family member about a skill or craft they use. Have students find out how their family member learned this particular skill or craft and the context in which they learned it. What do they do with the products of their labor? After interviewing their family member, have students research the history of this skill or craft and write a report locating your family member within this tradition. Alternately, students may research a skill or craft that was employed by their ancestors and incorporate a fictionalized personal story with historical research, or create a work of art incorporating that skill or craft.
(Time: Two 45 minute sessions)


Excavating Contemporary Artifacts
Ask students to research an archeological excavation site and the civilization or culture that resided there. Have students examine what kinds of artifacts were discovered during the excavation and what archeologists were able to infer about the civilization from these artifacts. Have students present their findings to the class.

Now ask students to imagine that an archeologist 1,000 years in the future will excavate the site of your school or town. Ask students to describe some of the objects they might discover and what conclusions an archeologist might make about the culture from analyzing these objects. Are there any objects that may lead them to incorrect conclusions?

Have students create an archeological record based on a work of art created by a fellow student in their class. Ask students to imagine that they have found this work of art at an archeological site of the future, and then as students to analyze the source of the skills, techniques, ideas, and come to a conclusion about what he or she has made. Then, have students write a social history of the culture from which this artifact has come from, with the perspective of this future archeologist.
(Time: Four to five 45 minute sessions)


reflection & evaluation

• Have students reflected on the relationship of labor and craftsmanship to artistic practice and cultural tools and techniques?

• Have students considered the value of studying artifacts and tools to understand culture?

• Have students created an archeological record and a social history incorporating research and personal opinion about historic and contemporary tools and techniques?


Find out how this lesson correlates to your state's education standards! On PBS TeacherSource do a search for "Art in the 21st Century" and click on the Standards Match icon.

going further

While this lesson focuses on the use of labor and craftsmanship by the artists Martin Puryear, Sally Mann, Do-Ho Suh, Shahzia Sikander, and Janine Antoni, it can be altered to include other artists or combined with other lessons to form a unit such as:

Dictators, Collaborators, Managers and Soloists
Converging Media and New Materials
Mediating Media
New Tools, New Materials


Did you use this lesson or generate your own activities based on ideas inspired by the lesson? Submit student art work, new lesson plans, and your comments to Art:21 and have them posted on the site. Help the Online Lesson Library grow!

additional lesson plans on featured artists

Janine Antoni
Converging Media
New Rituals

New Tools, New Materials
Personal Stories in the Public
Traditional Crafts, Contemporary Ideas

Sally Mann
Landscape & Place
Ode to a View
Traditional Crafts, Contemporary Ideas
War on Film

Martin Puryear
Honoring Heroes & History
Dictators, Collaborators, Managers & Soloists
Describing the Real
Public Façades, Private Interiors
Traditional Crafts, Contemporary Ideas

Shahzia Sikander
Confronting Conflict
Migrating Viewpoints
Remaking Myths
Traditional Crafts, Contemporary Ideas

Do-Ho Suh
Honoring Heroes & History
Migrating Viewpoints
Model Homes
Understanding Home
Traditional Crafts, Contemporary Ideas
Wartime Voices
Yearbook Tribes & Nomads
Copyright Art21, Inc. 2001-2006. All Right Rreserved. terms of use site map help credits go to top