Feature

Where Is the Best Ice Cream in Indiana?

Boy Eating Ice Cream

During the warm Summer months, everyone has frozen treats on their minds, but where can you get the very best ice cream? We asked PBS fans to nominate their favorite spots, and here are the votes for the best ice cream in Indiana.

Submit your suggestions using the form at the bottom of the page and we’ll add it to the list.

    Noblesville

    Alexander’s On the Square

    864 Logan St
    Website

    Fort Wayne

    Atz

    3235 N Anthony Blvd. & 211 E Tillman Rd.
    Website

    New Harmony & Mount Vernon

    Bliss Artisan

    610 Church St, New Harmony & 111 Water St, Mt. Vernon
    Website

    Mishawaka

    Bonnie Doon Drive-In

    2704 Lincolnway W
    Website

    Indianapolis

    BRIC’s (Broad Ripple Ice Cream Station)

    901 E 64th St
    Website

    Goshen

    Chief Ice Cream

    502 W Lincoln Ave
    Website

    Bloomington

    Chocolate Moose

    401 S Walnut St
    Website

    Farmland

    Chocolate Moose

    101 N Main St
    Website

    Hammond

    Dairy Belle

    7102 Calumet Ave
    Website

    Greencastle

    Dairy Castle

    801 Indianapolis Rd
    Website

    Albany

    Dairy Dream

    805 W Walnut St.
    Website

    Evansville

    G.D. Ritzy’s

    601 N Green River Rd, 4320 N 1st Ave, & 2641 N Cullen Ave
    Website

    Lansing & Schereville

    Gayety’s

    3306 Ridge Rd, Lansing & 36 US 41, Schereville
    Website

    Anderson

    Good’s Candy Shop

    1423 W. 53rd St.
    Website

    Fishers

    Handel’s Homemade Ice Cream & Yogurt

    8760 E 116th St, Fishers
    Website

    Howe

    Happiness Is Ice Cream

    401 Defiance
    Website

    Bloomington

    Hartzell’s

    107 N Dunn St
    Website

    Lebanon

    Ice Cream Paradise

    1416 W South St
    Website

    Upland

    Ivanhoe’s

    979 S. Main St.
    Website

    Pendleton

    Jimmies Dairy Bar

    7065 S State Road 67
    Website

    Evansville, Newburgh, Vincennes

    Lic’s Old Fashioned Deli & Ice Cream

    Various
    Website

    Lizton

    Lizton Dairy Bar

    102 W Main St
    Website

    Indianapolis

    Maggie Moo’s

    3449 E 86th St, Indianapolis
    Website

    South Bend

    Palateria y Neveria La Rosita

    2909 W. Western Ave.
    Website

    Franklin

    Ritter’s Frozen Custard

    Various in Indiana
    Website

    Nappanee

    Rocket Science Ice Cream

    401 E Market St
    Website

    Angola

    Scoops Ice Cream

    3331 Indiana 127
    Website

    Batesville

    Snikkers and Peanuts

    101 N Main St.
    Website

    Des Moines

    Snooki’s Malt Shop

    1810 Beaver Ave
    Website

    Indianapolis

    Sundaes Homemade Ice Cream

    9922 E 79th Street
    Website

    Logansport

    Sycamore Drive-In

    316 20th St # Lo
    Website

    Decatur

    The Old 27

    168 S 2nd St
    Website

    Indianola

    The Outside Scoop

    602 N Jefferson Way
    Website

    Huntington

    The Party Shop

    413 N Jefferson St
    Website

    Zionsville

    Trader’s Point Creamery

    9101 Moore Rd
    Website

    Valparaiso

    Valpo Velvet

    55-57 W. Monroe Street
    Website

    Indianapolis

    Wyliepalooza Ice Cream Emporium

    5535 E Washington St
    Website

    Columbus

    Zaharakos Ice Cream Parlor

    329 Washington St
    Website