Feature

Where Is the Best Ice Cream in New Jersey?

Boy Eating Ice Cream

During the warm Summer months, everyone has frozen treats on their minds, but where can you get the very best ice cream? We asked PBS fans to nominate their favorite spots, and here are the votes for the best ice cream in New Jersey.

Submit your suggestions using the form at the bottom of the page and we’ll add it to the list.

    Ocean City

    A La Mode Ice Cream Parlor

    301 E 55th St
    Website

    Sparta

    Alpine Creamery

    14 White Deer Plaza
    Website

    Montclair

    Applegate Farm Homemade Ice Cream

    616 Grove Street
    Website

    Teaneck

    Bischoff’s Ice Cream & Candy

    468 Cedar Ln
    Website

    Middlesex

    Blizzard Island

    111 Mountain Ave
    Website

    Ledgewood

    Cliff’s Homemade Ice Cream

    1475 U.S. 46
    Website

    Colonia

    Colonia Dairy Maid

    1075 St Georges Ave
    Website

    Medford

    Coneheads Homemade Ice Cream

    617 Stokes Rd
    Website

    Rumson

    Crazee’s

    2 W River Rd
    Website

    Riverdale

    Curly’s Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt

    30 State Route 23
    Website

    Ocean Grove

    Day’s Ice Cream

    48 Pitman Ave
    Website

    Denville

    Denville Dairy

    34 Broadway
    Website

    Mantua

    Dippy’s Custard and Ice Cream

    245 Bridgeton Pike
    Website

    Wildwood Crest

    Duffers Restaurant and Ice Cream Parlor

    5210 Pacific Ave
    Website

    Villas

    Fleck’s Ice Cream

    1600 Bayshore Rd
    Website

    Sea Bright

    Gracie and the Dudes Ice Cream

    1062 Ocean Ave
    Website

    Lawrenceville

    Halo Farm

    970 Spruce St
    Website

    Princeton

    Halo Pub

    9 Hulfish St
    Website

    Spring Lake

    Hoffman’s Ice Cream & Yogurt

    569 Church St
    Website

    Edgewater Park

    Holiday Ice Cream

    4159 Rt. 130 South
    Website

    Bloomfield

    Holstein’s

    1063 Broad St
    Website

    Manalapan

    Jake’s Cree-Mee Freeze

    337 New Jersey 33
    Website

    Lake Hopatcong

    Jefferson Dairy

    741 Route 15 South
    Website

    West Creek

    Jeffreeze Old Fashioned Ice Cream

    381 Main St
    Website

    Clinton

    JJ Scoops

    1 Main St
    Website

    Ocean City

    Kessel’s Korner

    2760 Asbury Ave
    Website

    Cape May

    Kohr Brothers Frozen Custard

    512 Washington St
    Website

    Lindenwold

    Lena’s Water Ice and Custard

    615 Laurel Rd
    Website

    Madison

    McCool’s Ice Cream Parlor and Coffee Bar

    26 Main St
    Website

    Milltown

    Milltown Ice Cream Depot

    87 Washington Ave
    Website

    Forked River

    Mrs. Walker’s Famous Homemade Ice Cream

    132 S Main St
    Website

    Ocean Grove

    Nagel’s Apothecary Cafe

    43 Main Ave
    Website

    Lambertville

    OWowcow

    237 N. Union Street
    Website

    Hamilton

    Parfait House Ice Cream Parlor

    411 Route 33
    Website

    Bernardsville

    Penguin Ice Cream

    3 Claremont Rd
    Website

    Lawrenceville

    Purple Cow Ice Cream

    2685 Main St
    Website

    Tom’s River

    Rich’s

    State Highway 37 E & King
    Website

    Various

    Rita’s Ice

    various
    Website

    Port Jervis

    Riverside Creamery

    5 Water St
    Website

    Wildwood

    Sea Shell Motel & Ice Cream Parlor

    250 E Rio Grande Ave
    Website

    Morristown

    South Street Creamery

    146 South St
    Website

    Stone Harbor

    Springer’s Homemade Ice Cream

    9420 3rd Ave
    Website

    Avalon

    Sundae Best Homemade Ice Cream

    2900 Dune Dr
    Website

    Berlin

    Sundaes

    185 New Jersey 73
    Website

    Parsippany

    Super Scoops Ice Cream

    325 Parsippany Rd
    Website

    Allentown

    Swal Dairy

    33 S Main St
    Website

    Princeton

    The Bent Spoon

    35 Palmer Square W
    Website

    Scotch Plains

    The Double Dipper

    38 S Martine Ave
    Website

    Collingswood

    The Pop Shop

    729 Haddon Ave
    Website

    Medford Lakes

    The Sand Stand

    1 Trading Post Way
    Website

    Georgetown & New Brunswick

    Thomas Sweet

    55 Easton Ave
    Website

    Ocean City

    TJ’s Ice Cream Plus

    100 E Atlantic Blvd
    Website

    Jersey City

    Torico’s

    20 Erie St
    Website

    Ridgewood

    Van Dyk’s

    145 Ackerman Ave
    Website