Episode 1: Geographic Luck
Printable Version: Download as a PDF
[233k]. Download free Adobe
This lesson is designed for students studying geography, world history, economics, and life science in grades 6-12.
Students will be able to:
- Hypothesize about why some countries have accumulated great riches
over time while other remained historically poor and share these ideas with classmates
in small and large group discussions.
- Discuss the features of various land masses using The
World from the Guns, Germs and Steel
- Use listening and note taking skills to view the film segment and complete the accompanying viewing guide accurately.
- Discuss what they have learned by providing specific reasons, facts, and examples from the film and their notes.
- Utilize a number of primary sources to conduct research about plants and animals.
- Teach others what they have learned by creating a game based upon their research and directing/interacting with other students as they play the game.
- State their opinions about Jared Diamond’s theory and support these opinions with specific reasons, facts, and examples.
Relevant National Standards:
Geography – The World in Spatial Terms
- Standard 27: Understands how European society experienced political,
economic, and cultural transformation in the age of global intercommunication between 1450
- Standard 29: Understands the economic, political, and cultural interrelations among peoples of Africa, Europe, and the Americas between 1500 and 1750.
Places and Regions
- Standard 1: Understands the characteristics and uses of maps, globes, and other geographic tools and technologies
- Standard 2: Knows the location of places, geographic features, and patterns of the environment
- Standard 3: Understands the characteristics and uses of spatial organization of Earth’s surface
- Standard 4: Understands the physical and human characteristics of place
- Standard 5: Understands the concept of regions
Uses of Geography
- Standard 9: Understands the nature, distribution, and migration of human populations on Earth’s surface
- Standard 12: Understands the patterns of human settlement and their causes
Science – Life Sciences
- Standard 17: Understands how geography is used to interpret the past
Language Arts – Writing
- Standard 6: Understands relationships among organisms and their physical environment
- Standard 4: Gathers and uses information for research purposes
Listening and Speaking:
- Standard 7: Uses reading skills and strategies to understand a variety of information texts.
- Standard 8: Uses listening and speaking strategies for different purposes
Standard 9: Uses viewing skills and strategies to understand and nterpret visual media.
Thinking and Reasoning:
Working With Others
- Standard 1: Understands and applies the basic principles of presenting an argument
- Standard 5: Applies basic trouble-shooting and problem-solving techniques
- Standard 6: Applies decision-making techniques
- Standard 1: Contributes to the overall effort of the group
- Standard 4: Displays effective interpersonal communication skills
Approximately 3 x 90-minute or 5 to 6 x 45-minute class periods
- Internet access to allow for viewing of companion website's
The World map feature and conducting
- Television/VCR for viewing Guns, Germs and Steel:
Episode One content.
- Viewing Guide handout for each student (Download
PDF here. [208k] Requires free Adobe
- Viewing Guide Answer Key for Teachers (Download
PDF here. [218k] Requires free Adobe
- Library/primary resources for conducting research
- Research Project Guidelines for each student
PDF here. [234k] Requires free Adobe
- Assorted art supplies including poster board, construction paper,
markers, glue, colored pencils, re-sealable bags, etc. for construction
of games and packaging
Backgrounder for Teachers:
Jared Diamond’s basic theory is that some countries developed
more rapidly than others and were able to expand and conquer much
of the world because of geographic luck. The natural resources available
to them coupled with the native species and climate provided by their
geography led them to become more agricultural and less reliant on
hunting and gathering for sustenance. This agrarian lifestyle, in
turn, allowed for the development of “specialists” within
the civilization who could work on developing and perfecting the technologies
necessary to make these civilizations more profitable, stronger, and
more powerful than others around them. Diamond asserts that those
living in temperate climates with indigenous animals that could be
domesticated were more likely to develop advanced civilizations.
Assumed Student Prior Knowledge
Students will need to have a basic understanding of latitude and longitude
and the location and size of the world’s continents. In addition,
students will need to understand the words “cultivate”
Part 1: Geographic Luck
- The land of riches and opportunity is how most people worldwide
would describe America. We are, undisputedly, the richest nation on Earth. Yet when we examine
America’s history, we learn that our riches do not date back thousands of years like China or the areas of the Middle East once referred to as the “Fertile Crescent”.
Rather, America has gained its riches over a relatively short period of time.
- To get students interested in and focused on the topic, have them answer the following question quietly, in writing.
• Why do some countries have an abundance of wealth and riches
while others have remained poor for most of their history? Once students have answered this question in writing, have them
work in pairs or small groups to share their answers with one another.
Provide 2-3 minutes for students to share their answers and discuss
their ideas with one another.
- Next, introduce students to the The
World feature from the Guns, Germs and Steel website
available at www.pbs.org/gunsgermssteel/world/index.html Click
on each of the featured sections of the map and read the information
related to that section.
Then discuss the map using the following questions:
Explain to students that Jared Diamond, a famed author and professor,
has spent more than 30 years developing a theory about why some
civilizations have developed more quickly than others. His idea
that geography determines the wealth of a civilization is explained
in Guns, Germs and Steel Episode One.
Use this introduction, along with the Viewing Guide to introduce
the film. Have students view Episode One in its entirety. Pause
to discuss questions from the Viewing Guide as needed.
Once all students have had a chance to view Episode One and complete
the Viewing Guide, facilitate a classroom discussion about the questions presented
on the guide. Encourage students to give specific examples from the program to support their
Part 2: Which Plants and Animals Made People Geographically
- Looking at the map, why do you think areas like North America,
Europe, and Asia have some much technological development and wealth
while huge continents like Africa have high rates of poverty and
disease and remain relatively undeveloped?
- How has a relatively isolated continent like Oceania managed
to advance technologically and build the relatively wealthy nation
of Australia and have other areas, such as Papua New Guinea, where technological
advances are few and wealth are much less?
- After studying the map and reading the information about
each key area, what theories do you have about why most of the wealth
in the world is found in areas north of the Tropic of Cancer (23.5
degrees N. latitude)
- Explain to students that they will now be working to learn more
about how the U.S. became the richest nation on earth. They will
do this by exploring Diamond’s theory of geography and how
it applies to the U.S.
- Use the Guns, Germs and Steel web
site section entitled Variables
available at www.pbs.org/gunsgermssteel/variables/index.html,
and pay specific attention to the content in the sections entitled
Crops and Animals. Using this
information along with other primary sources, students will work
in pairs or small groups to learn about how a specific plant or
animal was introduced to the U.S. and discuss how this impacted
the country. Each pair or group will focus on a specific plant
or animal and present their findings to the class.
- Using the Research Project Guidelines, have students begin work
on their projects. Provide classroom time for researching and
- Once all projects have been completed, each pair/group should
take 1-2 minutes to present the game they have created to the
class. Students will then take turns playing one another’s
games in order to learn about each specific plant or animal.
- After all games have been presented and played, ask students
to respond to the following question in writing using specific
things they have learned to support their opinions.
- Do you agree or disagree with Jared Diamond’s theory
about geography being the main determining factor in which countries
became rich and powerful through the development of technology
and conquest and which countries remain impoverished and underdeveloped
in relation to the rest of the world. Explain your reasons why
using specific reasons, facts, and examples.
- Students could receive participation scores/grades for involvement in class discussion, group presentation, and game-playing activities.
- Students could receive completion or accuracy grades for their work on the Viewing Guides.
- Students could complete peer evaluations or be graded using a scoring guide for completion of the research project/production of the games.
- Students should receive individual grades on the follow-up written opinion essay asking them to discuss their opinions about Diamond’s geographic luck theory.
- Have students share what they have learned by using the games they have created to teach students in younger grades about the historical significance of the plants and animals they studied and about how cultivation and domestication of these animals
was important to creating civilizations around the world.
- Expand student research and have the class look at some of the most historically important societies that have evolved throughout history. Research the importance
of plants and animals in the development of the great Greek, Roman, Egyptian, Inca, Mayan, Zulu, Khoi San, and Chinese, and other empires. Report these results back using the creation of games of by creating museum-type displays of what was learned.
Guns, Germs and Steel web site sections
The World (interactive map activity) www.pbs.org/gunsgermssteel/world/index.html
Variables (“The Story of…” features content about
various crops, animals, technology and germs) www.pbs.org/gunsgermssteel/variables/index.htm
Provides a short history of common farm animals and crops and how these have evolved over time as agriculture has advanced technologically
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Provides links to a variety of animal species along with information about how these animals shaped the development of civilizations
U.S. Department of Agriculture
Find information and resources about the genetic engineering of plants.
About the Author:
Lisa Prososki is an independent educational consultant who taught
middle school and high school English, social studies, reading,
and technology courses for twelve years. Prososki has worked extensively
with PBS authoring and editing many lesson plans for various PBS
programs and TeacherSource. In addition to conducting workshops
for teachers at various state and national meetings, Prososki also
works with many corporate clients creating training programs and
materials, facilitating leadership and operations workshops, and
providing instructional support for new program rollouts. Prososki
has authored one book and also serves as an editor for other writers
of instructional materials.