Participation »

Underwritten by John S. and James L. Knight Foundation

Idea Lab is a group blog by innovators who are reinventing community news for the Digital Age.

Read more about Idea Lab »

  • Check out Idea Lab Sponsorship opportunities!

  • Follow us on Twitter »
  • Each Idea Lab blogger is a winner of the Knight News Challenge grant to reshape community news.

    Learn more about the Knight News Challenge »

    Stack Overflow Sets an Example for News Commenting Systems

    Knight 2008 News Challenge Winner

    Here's a poorly-kept secret: I hang out with Web developers all day. And by their nature, Web developers tend to be Web savvy, and Web natives. Which means they are already using and hacking and rebuilding the next big thing online before most of us have ever laid our eyes on it.

    Like this one: Stack Overflow.

    stackoverflow_ss.png

    Stack Overflow is a service where programmers can ask and answer questions.

    That's all. Not too complicated when you describe it that way. But hidden in that description is a valuable system of voting and rating, where users earn points (call it Karma if that seems familiar) for asking and answering questions.

    The most novel thing I've found about the site so far is that the user who asks a question can flag the correct answer, which then gets nailed to the top of the comment thread full of possible solutions. The user who submitted the right answer? Extra points for them.

    So it's one part Slashdot, one part Digg, and a lot of thought about the value of voting systems as a way to filter content.

    I've spent a lot of time talking about commenting systems for news sites over the past few years, and it usually comes down to a choice between ratings systems (think: Digg) and identity systems (think: Facebook).

    How much value would a vote-for-the-right-answer recommendation engine like this have to a news organization? To a local community?

    See also:

    Rate this entry

    • Currently 3.2/5
    • 1
    • 2
    • 3
    • 4
    • 5

    Rating: 3.2/5 (4 votes cast)

    Check out MediaShift Sponsorship opportunities!

    Featured Comment

    I think newspapers, blogs, and magazines should all be doing audio versions. I grew up enjoying and listening to audiobooks and now I don't have the same option for the short form content that I prefer to consume.

    Will Mayo
    Do Touch That Dial: Turn Your Newspaper Into a Radio Station

    Newsletters

    MediaShift delivers the best news on media and technology directly to your in-box.

    Monthly Archives