Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
Independent Lens
Search Indie Lens

About Program Guide Video Community Cinema Classroom Your Lens Inside Indies

Still Life With Animated Dogs

navigation






Behavior

Watch these video clips
by using Realplayer Basic.

Spinnaker in 'follow me' pose
video clip

I used to believe that this stance, what Spinnaker is doing right here, was just a dog's way of saying let's play. But as Spinnaker grew out of his playful years, I recognized that the purpose of this signal is to make me now follow him.

He's now waiting for me to say, "Which way do you want to go?" So I'll say it, "Which way, Spinnaker?" And he leads me onto the path which will take us down to the stream. What's interesting about this is that we are both practicing anthropomorphism because my dog uses the same signals with me as he would use with any other dog.

Paul at his desk with Spinnker
video clip

My current dog, sleeping here at my feet (I won't use his name, because I don't want to disturb him) registers every nuance of my behavior, especially when it has something to do with his own desires or fears. For instance, he can always tell whenever the thought of... you know..."taking a break" enters my mind. But I really have no predictable routine, so it's not that there's some inner clock that would alert him. Now, I can talk about this, but since I have no true intention in "taking a break" at the moment, he sleeps on.

Just now, I had a real thought of getting up and taking a break. It just flashed across my mind, and look! Look at this. It never fails! And I haven't even put down my pencil, or anything to create a familiar sound... yet, he stretches... look, he's yawning ... and here he comes. Spinnaker! What infinitely small change would you have noticed in my behavior, huh? And which one of his senses is always linked to which one of mine?


Several times a day we walk through the nearby woods and fields. Separated from spoken words, natural instincts quickly overcome us.

Man's Best Friend
There are over one hundred million pets in the United States today. That's a lot of kibble. Typing "dog" into a search engine yields almost four million pages. Over half of all American families have at least one pet. The vast majority of these pets are dogs and cats, the only truly domesticated animals that we've brought into our homes. What is there in our hundred-millennia-long human-dog relationship that has created such an affectionate bond between humans and their dogs? Many people consider their dogs as family members and studies show that having a family dog enhances the quality of a person's life. Dog owners have lower blood pressure and cholesterol, make fewer visits to the doctor and are less susceptible to depression. There is evidence that animal companionship reduces loneliness and gives a person a sense of well-being. Children who have dogs have greater self-esteem and score higher on tests of popularity, social skills and compassion for others.

What Humans Think
Dogs seem to experience sadness and joy. They can also appear to demonstrate powers beyond our understanding. Since dogs can't talk, or rather, we can't understand if a particular bark means, "Timmy's trapped in the mine shaft" or "Is it time to play," we rely upon scientists and animal behaviorists to interpret their actions for us. There's a considerable difference of opinion among these animal experts.

Traditionally there have been two schools of thought. The Pavlovian approach saw dogs as largely mechanistic beings subject to conditioning. Any apparent emotional expression was considered mere projection from their human counterparts. The other theory viewed dogs from an anthropomorphic perspective and saw them as human-like - subject to human feelings and emotions. There's certainly a lot of anthropomorphism going on in the world of dog owners. (Can a dog understand the concept of a birthday party? Do dogs actually play poker when we're not looking?) In recent years there has developed a third school, one that aims to study dog's minds from the perspective of their own "dogginess" or wolf-nature. Within this school there are great differences as well. At one end of the spectrum is Stephen Budiansky's ideas in The Truth About Dogs, where he posits that dogs are basically charming parasites who only pretend to like us in order to gain food and shelter. At the other end sits scientist Dr. Rupert Sheldrake. His book, Dogs That Know When Their Owners Are Coming Home: and Other Unexplained Powers of Animals sets out to demonstrate the idea that "morphic fields" exist between humans and dogs who bond together, and that these fields act "as a channel for telepathic communication." It's certainly true that most dog owners have experienced a moment when their dog seems to know their very thoughts. Perhaps we really are in touch with each other in ways that science has yet to explain.

Sources:
"The Psychological Benefits that Dogs Have on Humans" by Stacey Stewart, woofs.org online newspaper
"The Truth About Dogs" by Stephen Budiansky, The Atlantic Monthly, July 1999
(available to subscribers only)
Dogs That Know When Their Owners Are Coming Home: and Other Unexplained Powers of Animals by Rupert Sheldrake, Three Rivers Press, 2000




history Resources The Filmmakers Speak! Dog Tales Postcards from the Hedge Fido Facts Wag the Dog Animation The Story