 |
 |
|
|
Tell us what you think >>
Selected submissions will be posted here, so check back regularly.
How to Help
In response to some of your questions, the filmmakers have provided suggestions on ways individuals can help end dangerous child labor in Bolivia. Resources for community engagement and links to aid organizations are also available. Find out how you can get involved >>
04/26/2009
Emma
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
I became aware of this film through our Tour Leader when I went to South
America in 2007. I have been to one of the mines in Potosi, one of the
better one I might say. I tried to chew the coca leaves just as the miners did. Spent a few hours down in the mine, gave an offering to "El Tio". My heart jumped out of my chest when I heard several explosions while I was done there, I crawled through the dusty and cramped tunnels, tried my hand at manually drilling through the rocks to get a dynamite stick in and tried to push the wheelbarrow the miners push and run with in the tunnels. I counted that as an "experience" as part of my travels. This is real life for thousands of adults and children.
I will make sure that I do my part in raising awareness for the children and for all those who work in the silver mines.
It's a great film, quite moving and very powerful.
04/25/2008
i just saw the film in the weekend. i saw the video with my brothers. after watching the video i was just heartbroken it is so sad to see children working in those conditons. but that is the reality in some contries. it is sad to see how the inocence of these children is taken away. but they should be so proud. and i have learned that we should think about others and just about us.
10/03/2007
Lillian
Folsom, CA
The story of Basilio and Bernardino's life in the mines has touched my heart so much that it has changed the way I see my life. As I look into Basilio and Bernardino's eyes, I saw my sons' eyes. As I watched them play, I saw my sons' play. They even shared the same disappointment of not having a father in their life and they also shared the same dreams for their future. Unfortunately, Basilio and Bernardino were living a life of two realities - that of a child and that of an adult. Their mother, Manuelita Vargas, and I share the same worries for our sons. We share the same proud look on our face as they head off to school. We both wish only the best for our boys. Our lives are so different, and yet they are same. I had the opportunity to see their life story and it has changed and inspired me to help other families like them make their childrens' dreams come true. If I accomplish anything in this life, I would like to have accomplished that. Basilio and Bernardino's life has touch me more than I could have imagined. Thank you for this gift!
4/25/07
Paulo
San Francisco
An outstanding documentary.
That children are forced to work in such conditions in this day and age is astounding.
I've lived in the third world and thought I've seen a few things, but the conditions in those mines were truly saddening and dismaying.
I've done my bit, given a nice donation in addition to my regular donations to CARE. I hope everyone else does too...
1/19/07
Gabrielle
Wow. I watched the devil's miner and that was amazing. it taught me so much. it opened my eyes to a lot of things. at first i thought it was nothing that interesting but as soon as it started iwas hooked. i couldn't stop watching i had to see everything. Basilio is amazing a true hero. he took the place of his father and worked in the mines even though it would ruin his health. i can honestly say that the devil's miner really touched me. :)
12/19/06
ana
raleigh, NC
I love the film. I watched it in Spain, so I could hear the children talking in spanish and their own language. It was very beautiful and this film should be show it 'by law' in every school of the rich and properous countries, so the children could see the affortunate that they are because they go to school every day. Maybe they can learn hoe important is the education...Thank you for making and filming such a wonderful film...
11/16/06
Catarina
Hinsdale
I thought that the movie was depreesing. I feel very bad for all men and children that have lost their lives in the mines. If I was one that was wise, I would have not of let so many children work in the mines I would not let children work in mines at all. For all children should go to school and mothers and fathers both should work fultime but if one parent dies the other parent should get twice the pament for only one parent forthe whole family. What I thought was kind of cool was the Tio. But for those who have died I give you my word in prayer,even if i don't know you. For all children I would have to say that you might want to find a different job then mining but if you do decide to be a miner than you might want tostay out of smoke and dust.
11/15/06
NiKkI
Hindale
i like the movie the devils miner becaues it is very intresting. i feel bad for the boys because the have to work in the mine to get money for there family so there risking there lives for thre fammilys.the tio is a scare little devil. the exploions would scare me and i would not wana go in there if they blow up the walls. the cellindg coulg fall with is. and i would not wana work in the mine at only 12 or 14 that is 2 younge to be working is such a bad job they sould go to school and enjoy it while they r younge.that is all i have to say about the devils miner.
11/15/06
Jessica Pinkard
Hinsdale, New york
i think that working in the mines is very crucial...i would not want to work in the mines. who ever goes into the devils miner is actually risking their life. i feel bad for basillio's family because, they are very poor...Basillio worked very hard for the money he made for his family....
11/15/06
Dana Magara
Hinsdale N.Y
I think that Basieo did the rite thing I hope he makes the rite chiose. I hope he gets rich and don't die at a young age. I hope he get's a good edecation at school And his family makes it.
11/15/06
hinsdale ny
I thought that the movie was very sad because I think that people under the age of twenty should not be working in the mines. But hes doing it because he has to make money for his family. I also dont like the part where they kill the llama for the tio. I would be very scared to go into the mines because of all the explosions. I also would be afraid of the tio because when the cross is gone the tio runs free in the mines. I feel bad for the families because they lose their teeth and cant take care of themselves because of the lack of money. They should be paid at least ten dollars a day but then again every body is sort of poor. I'm just happy that they are selling kitchen utencils now and away from that mine.
11/15/06
Michael DiMarco
Hinsdale, NY
This movie is really interesting. I never knew that children worked in mines. Wow. Poor people. I think that the movie was very profeonnaly done and enjoyed watching it. I felt rather sad it some points, but i'm gland to know that the boy is living a better life now.
11/14/06
cody
hinsdale n.y
the movie was ok but i dont think it was right for the 2 boys but they had to do it because they needed money for food and there mom. i am 14 and i dont have a job yet. it was a sad but yet it was intersting to me i would not like to work for only 4 dollers a day. that is not very much at all. do you think you will ever leave the mines. if it was me i would go to work only for my family. i think you did the right thing. you are a brave kid.
11/14/06
raymond lamb
hinsdale N.y
the movie made me think about what else happens in the world. i did'nt think it was right for basillo to work in the mines at age 14. i think this movie gave me a view about how much poverty is in the world. And is younger brother bernador working in the mine with basillo. i am very happy that basillo and his family got of the mountain and into the city. i am glad that basillo and his family are selling kitchen untensils.
11/14/06
Ashley Kwiatkowski
Hinsdale,Ny
I thought that it was sad how the children had to work in mines to support their family like Basilio. Its sad because how dangerous the mines are in bolivia. Also i learned that many people died in the mines. Also that Basilio got out of the mines and started going to school full time. I learned how hard the miners had to work. Also that some people worked 24 hours 7 days a week.
11/14/06
Sammie
Hinsdale
I enjoyed watching the documentary "The Devil's Miner". I learned a lot about Basilio and his family. He has taken on a lot of responsibility since he doesn't have a father. I am 15 and do not have a job so i don't think a 14 year old boy should already have a job. Especially a job thats involves so much labor.
11/14/06
enjoyed watching this documentary. It inspired me to not worry about my petty problems of whether or not to trade in my car, and what to do about my work and college. I have so much and yet in my eyes, I tend to see it as so little. I'm sadden to say that it took watching this film for me to realize that there are far more people in the world doing without in their lives. I should stop worrying about petty things and ask God to show me ways to help families like his. I am 23 years old and I have had no trouble with or in my life like this young man has had. He is such an inspiration. I wish him and his family all the best. I would like to tell him thank you for making me realize how selfish I really am, and making me aware of it so that I may change my ways.
11/10/06
Nick Grant
Hinsdale NY
I thought this movie was very depressing. That Human beings live in such poverty and depression, slaving in the mines just to buy some food, it shows that no child in America is worse off than elsewhere; they don't have to work in the mines at age 14.
11/10/06
Hinsdale
In the document the Devil's Miner I it showed how tough it wast to be a miner. I liked the film and i thought that is was interesting how strong the belived in the tio. I think that they are to much conited to there god went they sacrifice the llama but its not all that bad because they ate the llama and did not wast it.
11/10/06
Samantha
Hinsdale,NY
This movie was very eyeopening as to how the children in Bolivia are living. I am glad to know that they have now left the mines and are in a better situation now. I give the miners great respect and kudos for working in those mine. They are sacrificing a lot for their families and I find that as a great show of affection to their families.
11/10/06
micheal penn
hinsdale, NY
this movie was very interesting. I really liked it. im so glad that that you guys are out of the mines. after watching this movie i really got to understand what really happens when you have poor conditions in a small place. this movie really opened my eyes to see what hard life is. im glad that you guys are in a better condition. :)
11/9/06
Jordan
Hinsdale, NY
I enjoyed watching the documentary "The Devil's Miner". I learned a lot about Basilio and his family. He has taken on a lot of responsibility since he doesn't have a father. I am 15 and do not have a job so i don't think a 14 year old boy should already have a job. Especially a job thats involves so much labor. People who take money for granted should definitely watch this film.
11/9/06
Ashley
Hinsdale, NY
After watching this documentary, i have a whole new appreciation for little things in life. For example, food and money. Since Basilio didn't have a father, he had to work in the dangerous mines to support his family. He had to work so hard just for a small amount of money. It made me sad to see a young boy of his age working in this field of work. I think the acceptable age to ask a child to start contributing financially would be 16 or 17 years old. Otherwise, working is taking away from a fun childhood they could have. Keep on telling Basilio's story, it WILL have an effect on people.
11/9/06
Hinsdale, New York
I think that making this film was a good idea because it gave a good view on how hard life is for some children who get stuck working in the mines everyday. I couldnt imagine working in these conditions. I enjoyed watching the film. It gave me a good understanding on child labor in Bolivia. I think that working at age 10 is way too young to start working.
11/9/06
Hinsdale, New York
This movie was inspiring to me. I seen yesterday and today in my spanish class. It made me feel how lucky I am and how the people live in Bolivia
10/30/06
Paul Liggitt
Leasburg, NC
Thank you for making a documentary on the tragic conditions of the miners in Bolivia. I have also produced a documentary for The International Miners' Mission. They work with Miners in many countries to bring them the good news of Jesus Christ. I have been in the mine in Potosi on two occasions, once to video and once to photograph.
Keep telling the story.
10/5/06
Juan Peredo
NY
Bolivia, Potosi after so many centuries you still crying
Cerro rico the Indian Huallpa found you
between 1503 and 1660, 185 thousand kilos of gold and 16 million kilos of silver
went to different countries
at what price?
eight millions dead Indian slaves XVIII century
After that how many more......
TB, .........?
Why you eat my people alive!
my people so poor and humble, they just want food,
You Still crying, you still crying in those miners, in those childrens,
After so many centuries your wealthness makes you so poor
Bolivia, the one of the most rich in natural resources,
The second Country most poor in this continent.
My Cerro Rico Still crying, still bleeding
10/2/06
Cindy
NY, NY
I saw this documentary last night with my boyfriend and our son(13). We were all so moved by everything that Basilio and Bernardino went through. We were all born here in the US but are of Ecuadorian descent. It was an inspiration to me to see this child be a father figure to his younger siblings and not complain about it.
When you live in the US it is so easy to forget the poverty and hardship faced in other countries, especially the children who comparatively speaking, are forced to grow up at an early age. My son was so taken aback that he could not help but ask question after question, which I greatly encouraged. I am so glad to see these sort of films on PBS so that everyone will see what life is like in other parts of the world. Because this is our world's reality NOT the crap shown on other networks.
THANK YOU PBS FOR INTRODUCING AMERICA TO THE REST OF THE WORLD. So that maybe one day we can all do something to help the poverty stricken people all over the world.
9/29/06
beth
west orange, nj
wanted to sit down and relax with my husband in front of the TV after several 60 hours/week work when I happened to see this. What should have just been a "relaxing time" turned out to be one of the most moving things I have ever seen on TV. I could not sleep, and so early this morning I looked in the TV programming when this film was going to be shown again. I want my children (one son is 14) to see this film. Please say you will show it again. From the comments, I did not realize this has been shown since May!
My husband and I want to do something. We already do things for the Philippines (the country we are from), but maybe we can also do something specifically for these children. I will read the section on how we can help after I type this up.
9/29/06
Gerry Molina
New York City, NY
Both my parents were born in Ecuador and I was born in the USA. I myself have seen in my only 15 yrs. of age how children in Ecuador same as Bolivia are suffering by working , espcially the very POOR CHILDREN work their selves off to help their families. Everyday they would go from early in the morning about 4am until late in the night around 12am. These CHILDREN and PEOPLE NEED OUR HELP! They need someone who will tell them everything will be fine because we will help you. Please help those who need it. They REALLY need OUR HELP!
9/11/06
Jennifer
Derwood, MD
My father is from Bolivia, I was born in the USA. Films such as the Devil's Miner, make me more and more proud to be of Bolivian heritage. Most of the time, people are not even able to conceive the idea of what TRUE poverty is, but this film conveys that exactly. The majority of Bolivia lives in poverty, and kids such as Basilio show the true Bolivian courage. To knowingly live a life of poverty, and be able to take on the responsibility that he does, without complaint or regret,with only an expression of hope and humbleness, that is what I call a true Bolivian. I go to La Paz, Bolivia with my family to visit the people who live in the mountain, we hand out food, money, clothes because knowing what is out there on those mountains, in that country, all that poverty, I REFUSE to turn my back on that. I REFUSE to turn my back on the kids and families such as Basilio's, and I do not see how anybody else could not do the same. It is one thing to be ignorant of the poverty in Bolivia, but to know of it, and turn your back on it, is a true crime. Many kids like Basilio NEED our help. I implore everyone, to please, join a cause, an organization, and help kids like Basilio you do not know what a mere $10 a month or even as a one time donation does to families like Basilio's, it gives them hope for a better life, a life like yours. So, please, if you've watched this movie, I beg of you, DO NOT turn your back.
8/9/06
Elizabeth
The film is a true inspiration for us all. Born in Peru, lived in Puno many years and traveled to Bolivia many times, I was so over taken by the images!! These two boys are a example to every teenager and head of house hold. Can you imagen to have such a responsability at 10? To care for your younger sibblins and mother? To pay for your education? Things that young adults here in the US do not even do! And the worst part is that like him there are children all over the planet! We do not know the true value of money, and these boys do! My respects to the film makers and my prayers with them always.
The most beutifull film I have ever seen based on a real factor, and given to the public as it is.
The lesson is to be thankfull for what you have and help other people with out especting something back!
May God take care of all those children in Potosi, in Peru, in the world!
8/9/06
Eleanore Greig
Oak Harbor WA
What a heartbreaking and heartwarming story created by these two filmmakers. I am glad to know this family got the help needed to get out of the mines and put the children in school full time. I wish this film would be shown to ALL American school children. Thank you so much for showing this - a repeat would be good too.
Although many American children did as these boys, it was so long ago, no one seems to want to remember.
Blessings on those two men for their love of humanity and care for the children. How could that be wrong?
What a deserving person is Basilio- responsible, proud and goes with dignity. I wish him the very best life can offer.
7/24/06
Richard Pajuelo
North Hollywood, CA
I am at a loss for words after only watching half of the documentary. I will watch the rest of it, but I felt like I needed to find a feedback area on IL's website in order to convey the emotion and sadness I am feeling right now. Those poor boys.
It is an incredible piece of film making which I hope all can see at some point in their life.
Kudos to the filmmakers.
6/28/06
Nancy Murzyn
St. Paul. Minnesota
I happened to see The Devil's Miner a few nights ago. I can't remember the last time a film left so many images seared into my heart and mind.
It was heartbreaking to watch Basilio and Bernardino doing difficult and dangerous work in the man-made hell beneath the earth in the mines. They tried to be brave and courageous, but it was disheartening to see these children take on such heavy responsibilities at such a young age. At the end of the film when Basilio starts to talk about what life might have been like if his father had lived, we see the sadness for what a child should have - education, family, safety, a life away from the danger of the devil's mountain.
What an engaging mind, heart and soul Basilio has! I don't know how the filmmakers could have done anything other than what they have done and help the Bolivian child laborers. God bless them. They are stepping in and doing what governments don't seem to be able to do, but should do - educate and care for all of the children.
6/22/06
Ceres Bainbridge
St. Michaels, Maryland
"The Devil's Miner" was one of the most poignant films I've ever watched. Those dear boys, Basillio and his little brother, touched my heart. While it is truly tragic to see these boys so vulnerable to injury or death, how wonderful that they care enough about their mother and sister to try and support them. However, it is Basillio's love of learning that will save him, and the family. I just hope he has the opportunity to complete his education.
I believe the film makers not only have a right, but an obligation to assist the children of the mines in whatever way they can. Quite frankly, their obligations as film makers pales in comparison to our obligation to help other human beings.
All over Latin America, the governments must encourage people to attend school for themselves and for their communities. Exploitation of minerals and resources is risky, destructive, and has no insurance for the future. If they learn to read, write, calculate, and compute, the citizens can find jobs anywhere in the hemisphere. This sea change should be encouraged and implemented with the same earnestness as Basillio showed when facing the Tio.
6/21/06
Maria Eugenia
I got to watch only the last part of this film on PBS just today and have been moved deeply by the strength of the main character....Basilio. What a child....what a man! What freshness of expresion on his face. No resentfulness, no complains, only a deep sense of responsability, a great desire to succeed. And the great joy he shows at being with his family..... We don't see that in our teenagers here in USA.
This is one of the most beautiful films I have seen in a long time. A true reality show. As many others, my first response has been "I want to help such valiant child" "I want to do something for Basilio, and if he is already being helped, I want to help other kids in need."
Thank you for making such a powerful film. It has moved our souls. I cannot sleep now. It is 2am......
6/13/06
Kim
Jacksonville FL
I thought this film was incredible. It really captures this young Bolivian miner's point of view without imposing anyone elses viewpoint. At the same time it delivers an idea of how things likely are for many child laborers in his region, and aroung the world today. It's a good eye opener, and fuels my already existant fire to give back to the world. Thank you for making this movie!
6/12/06
Albert Poledri, Jr.
Florida
I was in Potosi over a dozen times in the past 4 years, up in the mines...and it's all true.
It is what it is.
6/8/06
Baltimore, MD
I loved it;I loved the boys'optimism in what they wanted to do in life and their studies. Even with all the financial & physical struggles, they still had their innocence, playing soccer or watching t.v.
In watching back & forth, from the other PBS station that night, from what I saw, I was impressed with Basilio maturity & yet felt bad; he was still only a child. Yet, he already had experience as a miner at age 14.
6/7/06
Laura
Michigan
I echo all the sentiments others have already expressed about their admiration for the filmmakers and compassion for the Vargas family. This was a beautiful documentary and deserves all the awards it received and more. I feel blessed and fortunate to have seen the film.
I am curious about the social lives of the boys. When Basilio went to school, he commented that his day was "pretty good" except that "no one wanted to talk to me." I'm wondering if he and his brother have made friends since then or whether they were ever teased about being miners. Basilio commented that other kids would call him "dust sucker" and other names if they knew he worked in the mines. I hope he did not have to suffer such hurtful words.
God bless the Vargases and other families with a similar fate.
6/6/06
Renee G Leboffe
Fairfax, VA
Thank you a million times for such a wonderful documentary!!!
I aplaud you and commend you,you are a wonderful huamn beings, that make us realize, how good we have it in this country, but most of all,I was moved and sad for the children and the mother God bless them all!!!
Thank you again!!!
6/6/06
Frida Johansen
McLean VA
I wonder who is the owner of the mines. The owner should be accountable for the miners' livelihoods and avoidance of child labor--better conditions can be provided (eg. safety means) especially now that the price of silver has greatly increased!
What are the mining rules in Bolivia?!
6/5/06
Charles Beardsley
Columbia, MD
In my many years of teaching English as a Second Language here in the USA I have had numerous (many) students from Latin America. Through them I have come to know the realities of their lives. I'm glad to see a film like THE DEVIL'S MINER that portrays their daily life/struggles in a realistic way. Thanks for showing it. I was sincerely touched by the film.
6/5/06
June
Arlington, VA
Thank you for this wonderful film. Basilio and Bernardino - two brothers - inspired me to be better.
6/5/06
GEY
I just caught the last 25 minutes of this fascinating movie, and was impressed on multiple levels. I am Boivian myself, but have lived in the US for most of my life. My parents lived in Potosi, where my father managed some mines. They always talked about the beauty of the city and the wonderful times they had there. Seeing the hard work that the boys put in and their sincerity at wanting to contimue studying and "make a better life" for themselves is both uplifting and depressing. I just wish that there could be something done for all the miners that would make their work, which is important, safer. Knowing how that work will shorten their lives, yet doing it b/c there is no alternative is sobering.
I am glad that at least one family will get help and perhaps more will in the future.
In the meantime, maybe looking at other products that the country has to offer would open up other fileds of work for these people.
6/5/06
jose mamani
sunnyvale, california
I went by Basilio's former place of work countless times as a younger fellow on top of a truck's cargo in my way to Tarija-Bermejo from La Paz, never ocurred to me that only few feets away a Basilio was working the mines underneath, ... is over week since I saw the film still sadness by it. I see in Basilio the next Evo Morales (google it, to find out who he is). Basilio, Evo and people like them dignify our race the Aymaras and Quechoas.
5/31/06
Jill
Shickley, Nebraska
I wanted to say thank you for such a moving film. I was taken to this country and shown the hardships of these children in a very moving way.
I am a teacher and it is inspiring to see these children who want to learn, as it is a fun thing for them to do. I wish their country would do more for these under priviledged children. They do not deserve this life!
I would like our students here to watch this film, they too often wish they weren't in school. I would like them to see what wonderful opportunties they do have.
I am excited to read that Basilio and his family are doing better. I feared the worst for them, but thankfully I was wrong.
Thank you again for an awe inspiring film. I do plan on getting involved.
5/31/06
San Diego, CA
This film was amazing and so sad. I just could not believe what these children go through and how courageous and resilient they are. Here we are complaining about things that in the "big picture" don't matter. We need to help these children, we need to be there voice.
5/31/06
LYNDA GENDREAU
ANAHEIM CALIFORNIA
Hello, I turned the TV on one night and saw your film about the children who are miners. I was deeply touch and cried my heart out. I thought to myself I have to find these kids and help them. I searched you on the internet. I want to help and make a differnce. We take life for granted in the US don't we. We have it all while others are suffering in other parts of the world. Thank you for your time. I will make a difference.
5/31/06
Arneeta Smith
Pittsburgh Pa
I was very touched by this true story and also proud of the young miner who was truly responsible for his family. I know some grown men who are not nearly as dedicated. I have 3 children of my own and reminded my youngest(11 1/2) of how blessed and fortunate he really is.
5/30/06
Leena
San Francisco, CA
The film was amazing, I'm still thinking about these people a week after seeing it!Despite the unbearable living conditions, these people had an amazing dignity about them!I hope something wonderful will happen to Basilio and his family.....
5/30/06
Barbara
Gainesville, Florida
This film moved me very deeply--I don't know when I've seen something so profound on TV. Thank you, Independent Lens, for bringing this important film to American television audiences! I consider this film a modern-day equivalent of Charles Dickens' novels, which, during the 1800s, opened middle-class readers' eyes to the exploitation of children in Victorian London; readers were so agast at the widespread abuses of child workers in their own country that citizens began to demand the end of child labor. One hundred fifty years later, THE DEVIL'S MINER is having a similar effect on viewers worldwide, who are taking action to save the child miners.
5/30/06
Incredible,fascinating, and absorbing. Basillio is an incredible kid - i have forwarded to several yahoo groups and friends and radio and TV show to recommend - i could not turn it off. this is what i wrote right after the show:
"These mines were worked by kids for emperors, kings, than colonial slavers and now western mine owners..
This was so weird - they still make live sacrifices at the mines - once perhaps(?) human now lamas.. ick
First they go to local catholic church to pray for protection but they regularly take offerings including the weekly blood sacrifice to the mine's "TIA" a devil like figurine in every mine - you have to see it to believe it - looks like a satan image - no wonder neocons invest in these sites...
The landscape in the mountains is as barren as Mars and as unforgiving.
Sweet kid they followed thru his mining jobs - only fourteen but with no father - the poor kid has been a miner since ten - tough and smart kid too.. i wish he was mine...
Interesting looking people - the miners are real indigenous - look like Inca drawings - they do have very mongolian features and build.
fascinating
Weird mine info too - unlike a cave which is usually cool; these mines are hot up to 115 F and full of co and methane and the silver mine has pockets of arsenic?
who would have 'thunk' it ?
Worth the time to watch !!
5/30/06
Maureen
Temple City, CA
Thank you to the film makers of The Devil's Miner in bringing this honest look into the life of the Vargas family and their struggle to survive in such a harsh environment. Basillio's courage, dedication and love of his family is overwhelming. I'm glad to learn that he has been able to follow his dream to pursue his education and his family has been able to start a new life in town.
After watching this mesmerizing film, you have to ask yourself "what can I do to help?" Thanks for providing information on what we can do to give the children of the mines a chance for a better life.
5/30/06
The message--powerful. . .The location--exotic. The producers sought aid for kids stuck for life in dangerous and ultimately fatal mines. Yes, the producers got their point across, and I believe that the biproduct was one of the finest films ever made. It ranks with the classics, because this expertly filmed, directed, and edited movie induces compassion and gets us to think. It is captivating from beginning to end.
Though the plight of kids in Bolivian mines is bleak, they still are in contact with their families, and their land is not being destroyed. Around the world kids are not as lucky.
For example: C&H sugar, in the Dominican Republic, employed harvestor kids who ate only sugar cane, and were out of contact with their families.
Another example: When Texaco found oil, the local South American tribe was excited because and thought that they were rich because the oil was found on their land. But only their chieftan was paid, and even that was a pitance. Their land was spoiled by foul smelling and dangerous chemicals which chased away game and forced them to cart in water to drink.
How do we fix the problem of foreign child slaves? In 2004, Presidential candidate, John Kerry, proposed trade embargos on nations which exploit kids or endanger employees. Embargos force humane conditions and end dollar per day labor so that US companies can finally compete.
Currently the bulk of US manufacturing is done abroad, and US factories have been built on foriegn soil to exploit cheat labor.
5/30/06
Amy
Los Angeles, CA
An eye-opener. I thank Davidson and Ladkani for bringing the story to us. Now that we know, we should do what we can as more privileged people.
5/30/06
Miramar, Florida
1.- At what time is acceptable to ask a child to contribute financially? Never, while a child is under 18. It is a parent's responsibility ( single parent included) to make ends meet.
I think the mother in the film is quite passive about her role as the supporting parent. Maybe it is cultural, if she does not have a husband, her older child will help take care of the house. Perhaps poverty plays a huge role on who works and at what age. The film made us think how fortunate we are and how blessed our children are.
2.- We should be able to have more films like the DEVIL'S MINER, it forces us to look inside ourselves and reach down to our inner core and come out to help. Without films like this one we would have never known how many children are suffering. Because of this film we decided to be active and help. We are flying to Bolivia this summer (2006) and will be visiting the mine. Davidson and Ladkani did a wonderful job. Congratulations for a job well done.
3.- The government should be responsible for creating jobs, so the parents can work and make ends-meet. The government should be responsible for free education. However,I do not believe that the government should be in the business of handing money or food stamps or encouraging welfare, it only makes people lazzy and teaches them to be beggars. Parents should be responsible and work in order to bring food to the table.
5/30/06
Karen
Los Angeles
As to the fillmakers' decision of helping the Vargas family- it is unhuman if they didn't help. It is more important to have compassion than to be objective, don't you think ?
5/30/06
Amalia
Champaign Illinois
Hello, I was born in Bolivia. I moved to the States in 12 years ago. I'm married, with 2 kids and I own a business. I was so touched to see my people in that situation. I got reminded of how hard is for some families to survive. I'm so mad at past presidents and other leaders of Bolivia who made themselves richer and made stupid decissions.
I got emotional when I was this childs eyes while he was in the mines. He had no choice but to work since they lost their dad. That look on his face spoke a thousand words.
I think the goverment should have some kind of aid for low income sudents, It should be at the top list. It is so important to have more educaded people to have a better future for bolivia.
5/30/06
Vancouver WA
At the age of 20 (1965), I went to South America and visited Bolivia (among other countries). At that time I was struck by the level of extreme poverty and the seeming hopelessness of the lives of the children. After seeing The Devil's Miner, it is apparent that not much has changed in 40 years. This is a powerful film, in the words of Basilio and his family, about life - what it is and what it should and could be. I am so happy for this family that the children are now in school and hope that Basilio one day is able to visit all the far-off lands he dreamed of seeing. I also hope that one day the children of Bolivia (and other nations) no longer have to work under conditions like these. And I hope I live to see it. Thank you for bringing these beautiful children into our living rooms.
5/30/06
Melanie
Oh my goodness! What a film.I honor the filmmakers for just showing the truth, and definately doing the right thing.It was disturbing but honest,and sometimes the truth hurts.I am still concerned about it! I was so sad,that these small boys in Cerro Rico(amongst many others),were forced,by their circumstances,to sacrifice their youthful spirit and live in the bowels of the earth,under the shadow of Tio and constant fear. The Government should be eld responsible for this abuse of children.
They should be outside, free and happy.In school,laughing,learning and being children.Not ostracized at school,because they were miners!
Their mother tried so hard.
When Basilio was at the drilling level,it was like he was entering Hell! I cried,because it was like observing souls in Hell!
He was terrified and on the road to a quick death(lungs).When his,very kind,foreman said,'hopefully,the boy would become a driller',I just wanted to scream.And,Bernadino was left all alone to face Tio in the smaller mine! The boys are beautiful children.They don't deserve to spend their innocense in Hell!
It was a remarkable documentary and we should have a follow-up programme,on the same.
5/30/06
Hubert Pizarro
Chicago IL
Congratulation!! Kief Davidson and Richard Ladkani for this great job.I am from Ecuador,I was poor when I was a child too, but I didn't worked so hard like this children are doing now. I am really very proud of these children because they work hard, and help their mom with some money in special Basilio.
I hope that Basilio,his brother and sister continunig going to school for then in the future not depend from those terrible mines.
!!God bless these children!!
5/30/06
Dale Orr
Wichita, KS
25 years ago I lived in the mountains of Bolivia and learned first hand the harsh realities of life for those poor people. I lived in those same adobe/rock homes with the sheet metal roofs, and the dirt floors.
It was pitiful from my American point of view but there was always one thing you could count on day after day... those beautiful smiles from all those little children. They may have played with rocks, sticks and discarded tin cans but the glory of youth shone through those dirty brown faces. I loved my time in Bolivia. These people changed my life and I was proud to be taken back there if only for a brief while.
I went down in mines like those shown in the film but only as a guest. I couldn't even imagine wearing my life away in those dark and dismal tunnels. The mines haven't changed in 25 years and as I watched the film I couldn't help but feel an abiding shame as I thought... I should have told this story many years ago. If I had maybe this little boy's life could have been different. I'm so sorry.
5/30/06
Orren Vigil
Oakland, CA
Deeply moving film I couldn't stop thinking of the plight concerning Basilio's family. We here in America are so arrogant in our selfish ways of materialistic consumption, including me. The film allows me to view my so called "hard life" in a different frame. It is nowhere near what these people endure. It is not a question of a childs responsibility to help, it is merely a matter of survival. It's easy to sit in our comfortable homes questioning the role and responsibility of children. The dire circumstances that arose from early colonialism are still in powerful play. It just goes to show that nothing has really changed from hundreds of years ago, indigenous peoples resources are stolen and the people put in bondage for the love of making money out of silver and other precious minerals. It seems that we as humans have progressed very little in terms of compassion after all that has historically transpired. The film inspires me to work harder and not complain about my present conditions. Thanks for a great important film!
5/30/06
Bernard Susanto
San Mateo, California
I was in the Cerro Rico mine tunnels early March this year, and it was one of the most 'moving' experiences in my life. I was determined to go to the tunnels even days earlier having spent 6 days in a hospital in La Paz due to a severe soroche. I would like to share this with family and friends but they could not appreciate the depth of the sufferings and how this changed me and so thanks this film will help.
5/30/06
Susan B. Rosenthal
Oakland Park Florida
What an extraordinary film! I haven't been so moved since Gregory Nava's "El Norte," and that was decades ago. This is one of those rare works that actually makes you want to DO SOMETHING about the problem right then and there, before you even finish watching it.
How is it that the human species can allow so many of its members to exist in such conditions? When will we realize that what happens in places like New Orleans, Darfur, Bolivia, Tibet, Gaza, and all over the globe (tragically) diminishes us all?
5/30/06
April
Atlanta, GA
I caught this movie in the middle or so just flipping through channels. I could barely stomach that child going into that dangerous mine. This documentary was very powerful. My heart goes out to those children faced with these hardships. It definitely made me think about my life and the life of my 13 year old. Where this kid had to work in these dangerous mines to pay for his schooling, that was power within itself.
5/30/06
JSD
louisville Ky
I would like to say hurray!! I have been very fortunate to visit Bolivia and especially Potosi. I just returned and witnessed first hand this exact situation still going on currently. My wife and daughter are from LaPaz Bolivia, my wife was full of tears through out the entire film because it brought back many memories of her country in which her remaining family still resides. Hurray to Davidson and Landkani on a wonderful film! This is absolutely without a doubt the exact way the children in Potosi work. There is absolutley no exageration here at all. Please understand that it is absolutley real and it is very common not just a isolated incident! Please also understand that Bolivia is a beautiful country and I am still amazed each time we visit. I suggest anyone to visit this beautiful place and share your love as it is truly a beautiful country!!
5/30/06
Kathy Chapman
Rochester, NY
I became completely captivated by the Vargas brothers and their work in the mines. It is so heartwrenching to imagine bright, mature young children working in such dangerous conditions in order to support their family. I fervently hope that Basilio and Bernardino continue to go to school and realize their dreams.
5/26/06
Ricardo Oporto
Salt Lake City
I was born in Bolivia....I got very luky and was able to come to the States with a family that adopted me. I thank you for making a movie about the children in Bolivia. I have not even seen the movy yet but my wife told me it is something else. She is going to buy it for me. I look a pictures of my childhood and what now I have been able to do and I thank God for the opportunity.
5/26/06
Emma
Dallas, TX
Wow! What an incredible film. Davidson and Ladkani have done a masterful job of presenting this story - they gave these children (and others like them) a voice. It's not as though those of us in the developed world don't know that situations like this exist, but to hear the Vargas family tell their own story was very moving. I appreciate that "The Devil's Miner" was able to present the sadness of the situation, but also the hopes of these two young boys. I am so glad that they are now able to attend school! As for the question of whether the involvement of the filmmakers in humanitarian efforts crosses a line of objectivity, I say, who cares! How could they ethically do otherwise! Thanks for presenting an excellent film!
5/26/06
F Bonner
Albany, New York
Bravo, filmmakers of THE DEVIL"S MINER, bravo Independent Lens and PBS, for the production and the presentation of this most extraordinary document. Heroically filmed and brilliantly edited, this personal and simply-told story of one boy's plight cannot but produce a profound, far-reaching impact on the struggles of the many Basilios who toil in the mines.
To other viewers' comments ("powerful", "moving", "mesmerizing", "eloquent", "important", "eye-opening", "unforgettable", "a masterpiece", "WOW"), I would add "sublime", for this IS the documentary as art form. Whatever awards are hanging around, this film deserves them.
Like other viewers, I found myself drawn into the story and later could not get it out of my mind. What skillful and effective filmmaking! There is no need for lecture, pontification, or recital of dry statistics; this story of one boy and his family--a simple presentation of the facts of the matter--makes the point all by itself.
Occasionally we readers and viewers are presented with disturbing news stories about child labor, sweatshops, bondage, etc., but rarely do we see such up-close and personal a tale as this. Reality TV, indeed! Also, it is one thing to be presented with the sad yet distant facts of child labor and yet another to witness the other side of those lives--their hopes and their dreams, their loves and their fears--the dignity and pathos which they embody--the touchstones of our common humanity. How could a viewer NOT identify, not be moved? The film is a triumph.
Thank you for your outstanding efforts. And, once again, bravo!
5/26/06
S. Rocha
Milwaukee, Wi
Unfortunately, I didn't get to see the first twenty minutes of the documentary.
Having grown up in Central America I got to see the poverty that these children are inmersed in. The maturity of these two boys and the sense of responsibility they feel for their family is remarkable and touching. I was moved by the love they have for each other, their mother, and their sister. I was also moved when Basilio describes how their situation is caused by the fact they don't have a father. Sadly, I think that even if they had a father, the level of poverty in which they live would still force them to work at such young age.
I agree with the filmmakers helping this family. I would also hope that they don't stop with just this family. I don't think helping them constitutes overstepping boundaries. Just as much as the filmmakers benefit by featuring this kids in the production of this story, I hope these children benefit from the generosity of all of us. It is amazing how just a few dollars can go a long way in Bolivia, Haiti, Nicaragua, or any other third-world country. We, in the U.S. and other industrialized nations, spend more by going out to eat one night than these people earn in one month.
Thank you for the story.
5/25/06
Kathyleen
Charleston, SC
I recently watched the film and was deeply touch by this young man's determination and spirit to take care of his family and himself. I was happy to see that he nolonger works the mines and is in school full-time. I know that with his great will and exceptional character he will accomplish whatever he sets his mind to.
5/25/06
Greta
Charlottesville, Va
I was just about to go to sleep last night when I happened upon another beautifully developed episode of Independent Lens. I couldn't stop watching and I can't stop thinking "What is wrong with this world when in 2006 children are working in mines?" This morning on our way to school, I shared what I had seen with my 12 year old daughter. She had no words, for there are no words for such tragedies.
5/25/06
Winnie Strainer
Helena, Montana
I have watched Independent Lens once before and was hoping for another moving topic...you did not disappoint. Thank you so much for the taking me to Bolivia and showing me a truly heart-wrenching and inspirational family. There aren't words to describe what I felt as I watched and prayed for the safety of those children. You moved me...I will be purchasing the DVD for our local school.
5/25/06
San Jose, CA
I was deeply moved by your wonderful movie last night. I was literally glued to my chair the whole time. Living in such tough conditions, Basilio and Bernardinoís joy and hopes for a better future is very touching. Their family spirit and the children desire to learn is admirable. I applause the film makers for helping the families now and succeeding in getting grants for this poor town that depends on the mine. This movie should be a must see for todayís American youth.
5/25/06
Anila Maharaj
Point Fortin, Trinidad&Tobago
Hi,I am from Trinidad&Tobago.
"The Devil's Miner" caught my attention as I was channel surfing around 3am.I was curious to find out why Basilio and his brother worked in these mines,but more so shocked that children actually did this!I am 19 years old and I cannot imagine working from just 10 years old of age.
Kudos to the filmmakers for producing this documentary.From experiencing life in the mountainside of Bolivia and through the eyes of Basilio,it made me think about my own life and how we tend to take so many things for granted.(I remember many days staying home from school-just because I was sleepy and lazy!)
It is really refreshing to see life from a different point of view,that takes you away from your present surroundings and actually makes you think about life.Thanks for opening my eyes to the REAl World that we live in.
5/25/06
Gabriela Forbes
Calgary, Alberta
I saw the documentary very late last night. It really touched me deeply.I am originally from Peru and I have seen some of the kind of poverty, not first had, but it was always there. I can't believe how ignorant I was of what really goes on with families like the Vargas family. WHat struck me the most what the dignity of these children, how they endure the harsh life and still hope for a better future.
Us all need to know the difficult reality that others go through in other parts of the world, so we dedicate ourselves to a higher purpose. Ignorance is what keeps us apart and what keeps injustice and poverty in this world. With knowledge, most compasionate people will do something to make a difference. I applaud the filmmakers efforts. You really did an excellent job.
5/25/06
Erika Barragan
Sahuarita, Arizona
As a bolivian born and raised, I was taken by this story of Basilio and his family.I grew up in Oruro Bolivia also a mining city and knew some about the life of a miner but until I saw this film I didn't realize I how hard life is for so many of our people, especially miners.As a mother of an 11 year old, it breaks my hart to see that children have to grow up an live the hardships of an adult.This film really opened my eyes.Although I have been living away from my country, I still ache for my people and I hope to get involved.I will pass this on to as many friends as I can.
Thank you for featuring this brave young man in your film, I have run across many Basilios growing up but never took the time to know more about them.
5/25/06
Ashley S.
Dallas, TX
I couldn't stop watching this film last night. I cried and cried...knowing that for so many of these children there is no hope! This is their life...and they are SOOOOO innocent! They didn't choose this life it was given to them and they have no choice but to take it!
I came to the website hoping to get information on charities that would help children like Basilio, which I did! I think giving through KNH would be a good start. I want to fight for the children of Potsoi and others around the world.
5/25/06
kathleen deuel
henderson nevada
What an amazing child I met through your lens into the Bolivia mines. I was moved to tears several times as I saw the innocense and the goodness in that child. Thank-You for giving me such a more open world view as I have been learning so much through watching your program. I still am concerned about his faith and fear of the idol God and I hope he is getting good Christian teaching so he and his little brother who was also precious, don't have to fear anymore.
I am so relieved that they are out of that Hell on earth!
5/25/06
Brian Gorst
Arvada Colo
I was really moved by the Devil's miners story, its hard to believe things like that still exist in this world But i would also like to see that story showed in every school in the United States, it would really wake up some of the " I have to have everything" kids in this country . What a shocker. Thanks
5/24/06
D. Motta
Alberta, Canada
I saw most of THE DEVIL'S MINER last night and couldn't stop watching. At first, it was just the fact that I could understand what these boys on the other side of the world were saying that grabbed me ( I grew up in Central America), but soon it was the beauty and poignancy of their lives and community that held me. Thank you for such an incredible film! And for this website. I was also very touched to read people's responses to the film. As many have expressed, I too wish that the children in North America and their families could see this amazing glimpse into another world, another reality. I appreciate the update about Basilio and his family. It was an incredible experience watching this film, thank you for the eye-and heart-opening experience.
5/24/06
cynthia zak
miami beach, florida
First of all I want to thank you for the deep sadness and at the same time beauty of the whole documentary.
I am an argentinian journalist living in US for the last 13 years, raising two kids with all the confort and easyness of this life..also publishing a communitary newspaper to help immigrant in this country...
but yesterday night you took me back to my heart, to my mision as a journalist, to my place as a parent..
A profound feeling for those kids and for all human beings in terrible situations acompany my day...
I think that all schools in US should show this piece of real life to all kids in this country..
even as an aware adult the film shook me in a way that I cannot explain...open many questions to my life...
what are we doing?
why are we complaining?
where is my mind all day long?
and my heart?
where do I put my prayers and energy?
Those kids has a enormous integrity, dignity is the right word..
such an example
a lesson for all of us..
I cannot thank you enough for your reminder that our world is not the only one, neither the center of the universe..
Thanks again!
5/24/06
Steven Tanyko
Arlington Heights, Illinois
The Devil's Miner was truely a very moving and powerful documentary. Everytime Basilio and Bernardino would enter the mine, I found myself hoping they would be okay.
I am glad I came across this film last night. I was flipping through channels, and for some reason stopped a second at the beginning intro. I couldn't turn away.
The one thing I couldn't stop thinking about was the fact that they had to work in those mines. I imagine a lot of people were more upset with the government and the situation, but we truely got to see a family make a very hard and terrifying (concering the safety) decision.
The Vargas' are a real family. All of them work for how little they have, but they do it together. Basilio is clearly the most able of the family, and he takes on the father role. He watched Bernardino in the mines to make sure he was okay. But when he was in his new mine, you could clearly see he was just a child, as everyone else watched out for him.
Vanessa even has a job as in helping her mother watch the tools. Bernardino hates his brother being gone, and is scared for him.
Just such an awesome and a moving film. I can't say enough about it.
5/24/06
clelia ayreyu-wilmeth
surprise, az
As a Bolivian living in the comfort of my home in USA, I was touched for your film, that brought memories of Potosi.
Touched by Basilio and his dreams, not matter what is going on in his live. Touched by his love for his family, love between siblings...
Also, the film reminder me that, as a Bolivian I can do more for my country, writing to the government, the press and every friend in Bolivia to bringing up the cruel reality of poverty.
To all of you that don't know Potosi and it's people, I want to tell you, that the Potosinians are the best people of Bolivia. They are as the film show, loving, caring, warriors and always with the highest dreams for better life.
So, I invited you to visit my people they are unforgettable like Basilio...
Finally, I would like to tell the filmmakers that the films was so beautifully made and don't forget that other part of the mining live are the "palliris", women working around the mines.
5/24/06
Chicago, IL.
Thank you for sharing the adventure and sadness of the boys of Cerro Rico. I will pray for their dreams to come true.
5/24/06
Monica
AZ
I stumbled upon The Devil's Miner last night while channel surfing. Basilio's eyes caught my attention as I tuned in. I was mesmermized for then next hour hoping and praying Basilio would find his way to school full time. I kept thinking "please don't let this have a bad ending." I was held captive by Basilio's strength, wisdom and maturity and yet couldn't help but wait for the moment when the 14 year old boy would be uncovered beneath a miner man's dust. As Basilio's tears welled up I knew then he was just a boy wishing for a childhood that was taken from him when his father died.
I am saddened by Basilio's fate but hopeful he will continue with school and learn his beloved French. As I watched my two small children sleep comfortably in a bed, I thought of Basilio and prayed God, and not Tio, was watching over him.
Thank you for sharing Basilio's courage and hope.
5/24/06
Ame
Chicago IL
This film takes me back to my roots and my country, being born in Mexico at a young age living in poverty, until my mother decided to migrate to the U.S. Now I am 21 and have not visited MExico in 16 years. The whole film was inspirational, powerful and beautiful. I was disturbed when I would see the boys eat the coca leaves, along with the worshiping of the TIo. Every time the wagon would come down the mines, and basilio would be by the tracks, I would close my eyes, and hope it wasent going to hit him. I loved the film, i loved the directing, thank you PBS for showing such masterpiece. I am also EXTREMELY happy to know basilio and his family are doing well. Thank you
5/24/06
Phil Wallace
Portland, Oregon
I'm at work today but so emotionally distracted by last night's film I can't get anything done. My heart hasn't been moved in such a way for years. I'm so relieved to learn the boys are out of the mines but it's only a place to start. I feel personally indebted to those who bravely made this film and obliged by my faith to do whatever I can for as long as I can for Basilio's lovely family and all who suffer in poverty and fear.
5/24/06
Basilio Zamora
Eagle Pass, Tx
I'm stunned with the amazing work that this two brave professional reporters did on this documentary. I want to congratulate them because on this type of environment you need the guts to get into the mines and observe how this poor children work so hard just to survive. I think this type of documentaries should be presented on public schools for students to appreciate which they have everything and others not even a handful of food or supplies to attend school. I live from three hours from a mine named Pasta de Conchos where it took place a catastrophe about two or three months ago. Majority were adults miners, but still is sad to see how people suffer and how they work so hard on this places. Still corps are inside they never retrived them because of severity of danger.
5/24/06
Anchorage, AK
The show made me want to adopt the whole family and bring them to my home. What remarkable children! My sons are up for it too.
5/24/06
Debbie
Woodway Texas
The life of Basilio and his family have moved me like no other. Kief Davidson and Richard Ladkani, what a fantastic film, there has been no other as moving as this one. It makes you want to get involved and help on a personal level. My son will be getting off of his PS2 and watching this! Thanks for a great film!
5/24/06
Katharine Sprecher
Portland, OR
Please have more documentaries like The Devil's Miner and more cutting-edge journalism like Frontline. The Independent Lens and Frontline make for incredibly relevant viewing in these times. Understanding our heroes and histories is important, but our age of apathy begs for more material that engages and motivates. So few Americans truly understand the relationship between their daily choices - what they buy, who they vote for, etc. - and the profound effects they have on other peoples' lives, on both local and global levels.
Bravo to the makers of Devil's Miner. PBS, thank you, and please bring us more.
5/24/06
Martha Mendez
Chicago Heights IL
I believe that the filmmakers achieved their goal with this film. My husband and I watched this movie together and we couldn't hold back our tears. This film brings everything into perspective, you realize what suffering really is. That not being able to have name brand clothes or cars aren't as big of a problem as not having food or education. It makes you want to not complain about your job, because even this child went to this horrible job day after day without complaints. I also feel very happy to know that the filmmakers are doing something to help these people. It would have been horrible if after seeing all this horrible events they turned their heads and didn't do anything. That's what most of us do, we see these films and we feel horrible and wish to do something but soon the feeling wares off and we return to our daily lifes and we forget about the people who suffer and need our help. I really hope that each and one of us will try to do something to help these children, even if it is just keeping them in our prayers. But lets not forget them, lets not ignore the situation. Let us not forget them.
5/24/06
kimberly carder
miami, oklahoma
I cant believe this little boy has to bear the berdun of a adult at 10. Why do the Adults think it is alright for the kids to work as hard as them and as dangerous. my heart just breaks for them. i have 3 boys of my own and i would do anything i could to keep them from working til they were at least 16. I would try my best to do it all because i am the adlut not the child I should take care of my chilren not the other way around.
5/24/06
Sandra
Chicago (Pilsen), IL
This is one of the most moving documentaries I've seen in recent years. My heart broke each time Basilio got ready to go into the mines again and when he'd say, matter of factly, that it was all because he didn't have a father to take over that responsibility.
I couldn't sleep after watching this amazing piece of work. And that's why I'm here. I needed to know more. I need to do more.
5/24/06
Sylvia Manning
Seguin TX
We almost never watch television but something allowed us to see this very important film last night. I want everyone I know to see it; I want every child miner in Cerro Rico to have a way out. I think this film can and will change lives. And the filming itself! Every time I saw Basilio and Bernardo going into impossibly small places I had to remind myself that the cameraman was already there!
5/24/06
TUCSON, ARIZONA
THANK YOU FOR THE FILM, IT WAS AN EYE OPENER! I CAN'T BELIEVE OUR GOVERMENT WOULD ALLOW THIS!!!
MY THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GO OUT TO THESE CHILDREN WHO ARE LIVING UNDER THESE CONDITIONS.
5/24/06
Mary Circle
Pinellas Park, Fl
Watching The Devil's Miner was a truly unforgetable experience. I am so moved and touched by Basilio's amazing courage and strength, the touching manner in which he protects his younger brother and watches over him,his determination to become educated, his intelligence and his sense of responsibility and his dignity.
While I believe that it is never "acceptable" to ask a child to contribute financially, I know that in areas where extreme poverty exists, it is necessary for survival.Every child should have the right to learn and grow, to develop their talents and expand their intelligence, to be protected and nurtured. The exploitation of the poorest among us is criminal and deplorable. It is up to the more fortunate in this world to honor the courage and spiritual strength of children like Basilio and Bernardino and make their sacrifice unecessary.
I applaud the filmakers for their decision to become involved in helping to alleviate the suffering of these children. Maintaining objectivity in a situation like this would just be a way of excusing a different form of exploitation. Davidson and Ladkani have not only performed a great service by presenting this magnificent documentary, they are making it possible for all of us to find a way to make things better. They have my gratitude.
5/24/06
Amy Lynch
Nashville Tennessee
I want to comment on the work of Kief Davidson and Richard Ladkani. The film is powerful beyond belief. And "objectivity" in journalism is badly misunderstood if we think it means that the filmmakers should remain handsoff in a case like this. I say WONDERFUL FILM and HUMANE and APPROPRIATE FOLLOWUP with aid.
About the making of the film itself. I was bothered late in the film when Basilio wne to work in the larger mine. there he worked a day without a mask, and the jeffe had all sorts of excuses for that. I had to wonder if the jeffe was making a point for the filmmakers (and for us) that might not have been made otherwise. It was painful to watch, and you always wonder about the affect of having a writer or filmmaker present. I wonder if you, as filmmakers, were in a bad spot at that point, not knowing if you had brought this up on a child unwittingly? What was going through your minds?
Thank you for this powerful work!
5/24/06
Marzette McMenamy
Denton Texas
I watched your program which aired last night in my area and have not been able to get it out of my mind. It was one of the most moving documentary films I have ever seen. It was a relief to read the current state of the Vargas family and I am fully in support of the filmmakers helping the family. If they hadn't, then I think I would have had to get on a plane for Bolivia myself - that is how compelling this film is. It is a tragedy that so much child labor continues and the only thing that will change it is public outrage and demand that all of these wealthy governments develop a conscience. Conscience over greed. If we could all agree that a person's welfare is more valuable than the welfare of our individual pocketbooks then none of this would be happening. The money is there. As for the Vargas family, they showed more dignity, respectability, decency and perseverance than I have seen in a long time. The sight of Basilio dressed so neatly for school and listening to him and his younger brother discuss their favorite subjects in school, while covered with dust in a mine, broke my heart. Every child in America should be shown this film in school. This family puts so many of us to shame and at the same time motivates us too. Well done. Thanks for the list of organizations so we all can help.
5/24/06
preston d. keys
toledo, ohio
In a perfect world, families wouldn't have to make this decision (between sending a child to school and having a child help support his family).
Sharp-eyed Braulio could see this perfect world.
5/24/06
Oswego, IL
I saw this film last night for the first time and it breaks my heart to see how these young children are stripped of their childhood for basic necesseties. It's hard for me to understand why government doesn't care and how irresponsible we've all become in allowing this to happen! My silence and lack of involvement makes me just as guilty.
5/24/06
Christine Chapman
Allen, TX
I watched the movie last night on PBS, and it was incredible. I have not stopped thinking about it! I am a Spanish teacher in Texas, and I just ordered the DVD. I can't wait to show my students the REAL life of this young boy, his family, and Bolivia. My school district is very wealthy, and I feel that my students could learn so much from this film. I would want them to see how this family tries to "eek out a living", how there is no "worker's compensation" in the mine, how such a beautiful young family has to struggle to survive; and how rich the culture is in Bolivia. Thank you for creating this wonderful film. I am so happy to hear the Basilio and his family are in the city and have improved their living conditions!
5/24/06
Michelle
I've been to Bolivia and seen some of the extreme poverty. I have friends ther who are involved in trying to make a difference for children in and around Cochabamba. This film touched me deeply in some ways I found surprising. I did not expect to see such gentle concern for the boys that was expressed by the bosses responsible for them. I was struck when one boss said, 'I have taught them carefully, not with force.' and when the second one expressed his dismay at a child having to work.
So often we are conditioned to expect a very fatalistic attitude from people in such circumstances. I did not see that in the film. The hopes that Basilio and Bernardino expressed for their futures belied that. Even the boss who talked about his own shortened life span and who knew he would not leave the mine spoke with pride about Potosi's history and for being able to endure personally.
I can't imagine what it was like for the filmakers to remain detatched enough not to interfere except for the occasions when they felt serious injury or death were imminent. I understand the need for such objectivity while filming but I am glad to know that afterwards they have been able to give the Vargas family some life changing help even as they use this film to raise awareness so more people can make such efforts too. They are doing the right thing. In my eyes, they'd loose credibility if they merely went to film premiers and collected awards once the film was complete. How could you share a family's home and life so intimately and then walk away?
5/24/06
*Watching the film, I was upset with the mother for not being able to provide for her children, but I am sure she does the best she can. I was also upset that the government does not have any program to keep these childrens from having to enter the mines. Children should contribute, but that contribution should limit to chores around the house, not putting their lives at risk to keep the family alive. Children in this country are so spoiled and unappreciative of their parents' effort. This film should be shown in all schools.
*I think Kief and Richard are just being humans. I applaud their effort, and inspired to help out myself, and to reach everyone I know to help out as well.
*The government has an obligation to ensure that every child has a chance for basic education. Through education, children will grow up to be productive adults, and be able to give back more through having a higher tax basis through higher earnings. I would much rather see my tax dollars going toward social structures such as education, than 90% of our government progams.
5/24/06
JC
It broke my heart to watch this story. This story immediately made me appreciate the life that I have, as well as, understand how truly fortunate I am.
Some days, I wake up tired, but I can't imagine how it would feel after working a full day, non stop, like Bassillio Vargas. I have a better concept for life, after watching this special.
I wish Bassillio Vargas, and his family, the best of luck. I think that it would be tremendous if I, as well as other people touched by this story, could email Bassillio directly and tell him how much he has inspired us.
I believe that God used Kief Davidson Richard Ladkani as an insturment/angel to help and aid the vargas family, as well as shed light on an untold truth that exist in this world today. I would love to do work with Kief Davidson Richard Ladkani. God Bless him.
Bassillio Varags is a modern day warrior. He's a true warrior. To over come such adversity, I know that nothing can stop him. The sky isn't the limit, for him.
5/24/06
Ally Kyllo
beaverton oregon
I was moved by this production.
After watching this episode, I had to find out how it ended for the Vargas Family.
14 is way too young to have to be the major breadwinner and attend school.
Basilio didn't have much of a childhood, which is very sad.
5/24/06
Dominic Greco
SLC, Utah
I just watched The Devil's Miner. I am amazed at the raw portrayal of life that these film makers share. It touched my heart deeply.
Forgive me but I felt an equal ballance of beauty and suffering in this film.
The hardships of life are many, and in America we enjoy things that these children will never know, but at the same time they stand on the mountain and play ball together. They are not ruled by fancy posessions, nor are they distracted by anything more than basic survival.
The men seemed so simple and caring, especially the way the boss looked out for the boy. To teach him the dangers of the mine, and prepare him as good as he could.
This touched me the way they were caring without coddling. Caring but not in a phony way as I so often see here in our own land. The kind of neurotic over attention to children that seems fueled more by fear than actual compassion. Where the miners teach the boys, but also let them be.
I know I'll be scorned for this, but these children work their lives in the mines and I can not imagine how hard that would be, but would they be better off being bratty American kids who pillage the planet with over consumption?
My point is that I probably don't have anything to offer these children, no solution for a better life. But I would like to find a way to donate masks so that they could breathe better.
5/24/06
calgary, alberta canada
Thank you for viewing this program. I cried throughout the whole program and my family and I have our eyes open to this heartbreaking problem not only in Bolvia but throughout the global. God Bless the filmmakers!!
5/24/06
Rehmah
Chicago, IL.
I cant stop thinking about them, I cant get their beautiful, terrible faces out of my mind, and I cant stop crying.
I have known children in terrible conditions. Bondage, sweatshops, brick kilns. However, this movie really showed me Basilio's life as an orphaned elder son, a brother and mentor to his siblings, a dreamer, a miner, a student who wants to be a professor. But he knows that his only escape from the mine is through working in the mine. I wish I could change that right away.
5/24/06
yanny
Your film was an eye opener. Bailio had me in tears. I think responsibilities and financial contributions vary from culture to culture. I feel when a child reaches working age, here in US between 15-16 yrs of age, he or she should contribute for the ammenities that he or she chooses to have. Such as cell phone, entertainment, and car insurance when of driving age and having a car of their own. They should be eased into taking financial responsibilties to encourage independence so they will be somewhat prepared when they go out on their own. However children in poverish countries do not have this luxury of working for life's pleasure. They work to survive.
Continuing to help the Vargas family and the laborers is a wonderful thing. Your hearts are in the right place. My heart aches for the children involved and the laborers. I appreciate the update. Knowing that Basilio and his siblings are in school, it is a joyous thing. God bless you both and all those that have a hand in this great work.
I think the government should see to it that every child gets an education. There should be a well organized system and resource for the children in need to be able to attend school. Children everywhere are the future. Education should be top priority of legislation.
5/24/06
Wilmette, Illinois
I just watched the Devil's miner on pbs and I was very touched by it. I felt very sad for the young boys. It made me cry. I was hoping for a happy ending. That they would stop working in the mines and go to school full time. It made me realize how good my life is and how lucky I am. Thank you for this powerful film.
Thank you for making us aware of this problem. I will do my share and help.
5/24/06
beimar iriarte
gurnee, IL
I have just finished watching The Devils Miner on PBS. Thank you very much to the filmakers Kief Davidson and Richard Ladkani for bringing this story to the world. I am a Bolivian expatriate living in the US, busy worrying about upkeeping my front lawn and getting my pool ready for the summer. I am glad that films like yours re-calibrate my life against such realities. It is not that I never knew or saw that kind of poverty growing up in Bolivia, it is just that Basilio's story touched me in the heart. I was impressed by his eloquence, I could just see that boy's intelligence blossoming if he had a normal childhood. It struck me how warm, close knitted, and cared of each other that family was. I was touched by the longing of Bernardino for his older brother, how much he missed and worried when Basilio was at the mines working. How he was looking forward to spending time together during Carnaval. With interest and cultures in general, I was struck by the story of the Tio. But what else can one expect logically: poverty, lack of education, ignorance, fear, supertition. Yes, I would like to help.
5/24/06
LuzCarmen Avendano
I just finished watching this interesting documentary, and I found it very appealing. I am 17yr. old hispanic girl, and I know what it is like to work and try to help a single mother raise your siblings on her own. This story not only shows the dangers of cild labor, but the lengths at which Basilio struggles to survive and keep the family together.
5/24/06
DAVE
Thank you PBS for showing this film!
On some days i think i have it 'bad' ...wow it really put it all in perspective..........and i donated to CARE...who could watch that show and not donate to some needy organization and still honestly sleep at night !
It really touched my heart and more 'reality' shows like this are needed to help wake 1/2 of the planet to the dire poverty of the other half that 2k years after Christ, still have virtually nothing..........wow
5/24/06
Renee Gori
I don't think the age of 10 is a age to ask a child to assist financially, but then again we are talking about different cultures and this often plays into effect. I believe that a child's responsiblity to his family is to continue with furthering education of their own selves. It is parents responsibility to ensure this happens. I think a child can help out in the home, but I don't think that it is right to ask a child to become the bread winner.
I think that for the filmakers it would be hard to complete a story such as this and not get involved. Did they step over a line of objectivity? Probably, but who can blame them. Many artist/filmakers to many things for there work, we are human and it would be hard to think that the filmmakers would have taken extra steps to help out the children of Bolivia or for the matter the family they were completing their film on, Basilio and Bernardino.
I think that the government has a obligation to see that a child receives an education to the upmost of its ability. Use any and all resources to make it happen. Prolonging assists for further educational needs is repeating the phase of these children having to work in the mines and not receiving a decent education to further their dreams, their futures.
5/24/06
E. Murphy
Kansas city, Kansas
I found the film on The Devil's Miner so very moving. I must admit it brought tears to my eyes and sadness in my heart for these children. It was obvious and brought out in the film that these children are very intellegent children with wonderful dreams for there future. Both the children and there mother are very hard working and are extremely GOOD people. There inocence put shame on us as a country for our outspokeness and selfish ways and our take it for granit attitude. I understand why these children have to work, but believe they must have a childhood and should not have to work. It brings child labor form the depression to current times for our generation to understand.
I feel the filmmakers should be commended for there example of doing the right thing. Had i been in there position I too would do the same. As for the government, I blame the government of Bolivia for this tragedy. For the price of silver these days and the export of it, surley the profits that are being made should be negotiated to include the mines, and the miners not only in salery but safty standards and health benifits for these people. I must say in these times when everyone is ready to comdem the United States at least our people working with the Government have comdemned and abolished these practices, and our children can be children and relalize there dreams.
5/24/06
Doug Jones
Atlanta, GA
Wow, what a compelling and heart breaking piece. To see that any human has to live the life of a miner, let alone a miner in those conditions is terrible to watch. To see that any human has to do that on a daily basis, let alone a child is unforgettable. I would really like to be able to pay for Basillio's education so he could grow up to work in an industry and make alot of money for his family. This child has more heart, determination and will than I have and many adults. Its amazing what the human can get through. What a necessary piece for the world to see. A true hero and this piece is his message to the world. Thanks. I hope the makers of this documentary compensated Basilio and his family well.
5/24/06
Rey
West Columbia, SC
Thanks guys for a very powerful documentary. Very well done. Thanks also for helping the brothers and their mother and sister. I was glad to know that they dont' work in the mines anymore and because of you, the family and other families will have a great future.
5/24/06
Jerry Ragan
wow!! The film just blew me away. What great dignity it showed in the midst of terrible poverty. I have more than enough. I'm long overdue in sharing my over abundance with the Vargas families of the world. Thanks for a new vision.
5/24/06
toledo, ohio
The Devils Miner is eloquent in its straightforwardness. The filmmakers' deftness in presenting a story without playing on your heartstrings is remarkable. I wish I could say the same about your story on Chavez Ravine.
Braulio's persona shines brighter than the darkness that surrounds him.
The filmmakers' "use of the first person" . . . added authenticity and realism.
5/24/06
Janet Sawyer
Walterboro, SC
What a heart-wrenching show! What wonderful children they are with goals in mind for their life. Their desperate poverty has not torn their family apart; the mother is so caring and the children so loving. The families in the US should be so lucky to have the kind of love that sustains these children and mother.
Was glad to read the update that all the children are in school and the boys no longer will be miners.
One concern: Does the excessive ingestion of cocoa leaves have adverse effects later in life?
Answers to your questions:
1. Child labor helped build this country and probably all countries. I think the US has gone overboard in not allowing children to work sooner; they would appreciate an education if that were the case. Twelve year olds and up are able to perform many tasks which can develop their self-esteem and confidence. But dangerous jobs are certainly out!
2. The filmmakers responded quite correctly. How could anyone be that personally involved and not feel compassion and want to do something?
Doing the right thing is never wrong.
You may get in trouble for it but that's the price of goodness.
3. The government already funds education in this country ... poorly.
In a perfect world, college would funded also. It's money well invested to produce an educated populace.
5/24/06
Tia Thomas
What a sobering film this was! Extreme poverty exists all around the globe but it is especially difficult when you feel it almost "first hand" through a film such as this one. In the absence of a father, a little boy's courage and love for his family forces him to become a man working in unforgivable conditions. In our comfy U.S. world, most of us have no clue what it means to work just to "survive." A ten year old child (Basilio started when he was 10)should never be subjected to these conditions. A 10 year old child should never live in fear of the devil taking his life and eating his soul nor be preoccupied with bleeding lungs and never growing up. All very easy for me to say as I am unable to comprehend that child's reality. I was particularly impressed with Basilio's maturity and sense of self. While his pain and suffering where evident, he also had great fortitude and the love for his family was obvious. It was nice to see he could also find his smile often. He wants to be a teacher when he grows up. He will be a great one!
I loved your film. I cried a lot. Thanks for reaching out and keeping me in check... P.S. - Please continue to do what you can for these children.
5/24/06
Leslie Cox
Smyrna, Tennessee
As filmmakers, Davidson and Ladkani couldn't POSSIBLY be "stepping over the line" in choosing to help their fellow human beings. Why should a filmmaker's objectives somehow forbid helping anyone, anywhere? The depth and quality of this documentary only proved that the hearts of its makers were--and are, definitely where they should be. There are countless places and people on this earth who are in grave need of truth-telling about their plights, and the Vargas boys, their family and fellow miners are no exception.
5/24/06
Amanda
Killeen, Texas
I enjoyed watching this documentary. It inspired me to not worry about my petty problems of whether or not to trade in my car, and what to do about my work and college. I have so much and yet in my eyes, I tend to see it as so little. I'm sadden to say that it took watching this film for me to realize that there are far more people in the world doing without in their lives. I should stop worrying about petty things and ask God to show me ways to help families like his. I am 23 years old and I have had no trouble in my life like this young man has had. He is such an inspiration. I wish him and his family all the best. I would like to tell him thank you for making me realize how selfish I really am, and making me aware of it so that I may change my ways.
5/24/06
Richard Stebor
Holiday, FL
I was deeply moved by the story of how the Vargas family struggled to survive and the young boys having to go into the mines. My jaw dropped open in disbelief as I watched Basilio explain all the dangers and hardships that were part of living on that desolate mountain.
Being touched personally, I'm so glad to hear the family has been helped to have a better life. It makes my day!
|
|
|
