 |
|
|
|
Tell us what you think >>
Selected submissions will be posted here, so check back regularly.
2/6/07
Santa Marta, Magdalena
Well done you guys! Very well done!
Answer for your questions:
1. I don't deserve the faculty to judge, but if I lived there in that place, I'd probably make a
living out of shooting.
2. Yes they do. But They've got a 'large pile of Colombian shit for them to eat' before they can
reach their goals. Many Colombians are not willing to make such "sacrifices", Thats probably the
same in every country.
3. Yes. It made me understand that all those thing they say about Colombia in international news and
American movies, may be exaggerated, but not all-out untrue. It taught me that the active Colombian
society is only a small heaven within the Colombian guerrilla hell. I'm a Colombian living in this
small heaven, with a high bandwidth connection to the Internet, that makes me a very lucky guy.
1/8/07
Serge
Mexico City
I traveled to Medellin in January 2006 and was deeply impressed by what I saw, namely a city that
intent on becoming a true "home" for its inhabitants. Taking the Metrocable I went up to barrios
that once were battlegrounds for narcos and other armed groups. Superficially everything looked
peaceful and almost beautiful given the incredible scenery surrounding the city of Medellin.
Watching La Sierra made me think that Colombian people have in their heart the power to
individually change their destiny and turn destructive forces into energy to build a better future
that all desire. From a foreigner's viewpoint, Medellin and Bogota seem to be on their way to escape
their spiral of violence. At the same time Mexico City sees increased corruption, soaring crime
rates and rife kidnappings. What has happened in La Sierra can repeat itself elsewhere!
Edison was clearly intelligent though misguided in his choices, especially when we consider them
from an American viewpoint. Some comments from his girlfriends were deeply touching and overall all
participants in the movie demonstrated a level of "raw" humanity that our modern Western lifestyle
is coldly uprooting. Congratulations to those who had the will power, patience and courage to shoot
this movie. Perhaps, just perhaps, it would be worth following the population of La Sierra and see
how the situation has improved or not?
From the bottom of my heart, I wish they will find peace and happiness one day.
12/19/06
Mao Mayoman Yang
St. Paul, Minnesota
Magnificant film that touched my heart and moved me to tears. How can people watch something like
this and not want to help in some way, I just don't know. Watching this film also remind me of other
bad situations happening around the world, such as dar fur and there's so many more. Thank you for
reminding me that I need to help and act one day...soon. More documentary films like this should be
made so the world can be taught about issues/world issues that they can help. How can people learn
of such things and not be moved? And why are we, as the world, not helping them in some way?
10/2/06
Kristofer McDonald
San Diego, California
I watched this documentery two days before my birthday. I couldn't stop thinking about it, even
throughout my birthday. I just turned 28 and I don't have any kids, but this really touched me. I've
been all over the world. Brazil, Spain, France, Japan, Norway, Turkey, Russia etc. And have seen
many things, but nothing like this. My cousin and I were watching "Family Guy" the other day and
they were mocking something simmilar to this, but I was not laughing because once you have seen it
you feel like you have become a part of it.
I'm going to be married next year and looking forward to having kids and I hope that they are able
to watch something like this and know exactly how fortunate they are. Life is rough in different
ways for individuals, but not like this. This is too much.
9/12/06
Michelle
St. Cloud MN
Absolutely riveting. I happened to catch it before going to bed last night, and I too have had the
video on my mind all day long. The irony of watching and being captivated by this war that these
KIDS lead on the eve of 9/11 really struck me. This will stick with me forever. My heart goes out to
all of the kids involved in that conflict and all conflicts around the world. I hope to have all of
my friends/family watch your documentary the next time it airs on our local PBS station!
9/11/06
Kristin Zimmer
San Diego, CA
This was brilliant. My boyfriend and I watched this before I went to work and thought about it all
day. I am 29 and pregnant and having my first child so my heart goes out to all of the children.
Wonderful and powerful video.
8/30/06
Elvia Flores Amirsehhi
Scottsdale, Arizona
When i seen this documentary i was very shocked too. With all the diseases out there it is shocking
to see something like this. I am from a Mexican,native american, Lebanese background and lived most
of my life in Mexico, so I can relate to most of the things that happend here because I've seen it
with my own eyes. Especially as a young woman. It is very sad and makes me think of another
documentry I saw not too long ago.
8/29/06
Diana
Chicago IL
Edison's character was not "intelligent" as was stated in "the film" section on this website. What
kind of intelligent person admits that they will most likely not survive for very long and then gets
six different very young girls pregnant? How can he not think about his future children and their
mothers? It seems very self serving. He talks about saving the community, how is fathering
illegitimate children helping strengthen the community. Please don't use the word intelligent to
describe someone like that.
My family is from Colombia and many still live there. I have seen and heard similar stories as this.
But I still disagree with anyone who would say that Edison is "intelligent".
Hopefully people living in the U.S. and similar countries, that are not aware of what is happening
in many places in the Americas and around the world will see this story and see how fortunate they
are to live in the U.S.A.
5/30/06
What we saw here were children in the middle of a "Civil War". Guerrilla has been fighting the
government for decades. Civilians, specially poor ones in rural areas and urban outskirts have had
to defend themselves. On top of that, education and employment opportunities are very few. Kids from
La Sierra have very few options. Without help, those
babies will most likely walk the same path of Edison, and perhaps die young. Thier grandpa does not
have the power to change that. They need help. Lets give them hope and jobs. Instead of taking jobs
to China and India, lets think about our hood.. all America: South, Central and North! Lets invest
there! Its in the US best social interest.
We can't compare that situation to the gangs in the US. Education and employment opportunities are
abundant here. Hope this is an eye opener for those who think gang life and violence is cool.
5/18/06
Great documentary! Those young kids are the byproduct of the inability of the law enforcement
agencies to protect their community.
If they didn't fight back, they would be forced to surrender their posessions, families and
neighborhood to the guerrilla, or even worse, forced to join it. The police could not protect them
against that.
Unfortunately when those kids take arms to protect themselves, they also become murderers, thugs,
and robers on the side. Very tough and sad situation without an easy way out.
Do they have the power to make choices about their future? Yes, but they need help. As they grow
older they will move out of that lifestyle. The real issue is how to break the cycle and stop the
younger ones from being forced to engage in that lifestyle. Do they have the power to change the
root causes? perhaps not, but who has that power?
5/3/06
El Cuco, Texas
To those of you who have never traveled outside the United States, welcome to reality. These kinds
of events happen all over the World, and not just in Colombia. As unimagable as it might seem, some
of these individuals, such as Edison are actually trying to esablish a better tomorrow. We Americans
are very fortunate to live in a country like ours, so thank a Veteran next time you see one. If you
found the film disturbing, all I can say is; the option was at your fingertips. To Scott Dalton &
Margarita Martinez, thank you y gracias. The story had to be told!!
5/2/06
Tito
Carteret, New Jersey
Yoooooo this documentry was the realest s*** i've ever seen if you think you gangsta you got s***
twisted because that was real life right there kids are giving their lives for their barrio man its
sad but true yoo PBS keep playing stuff like that to make people realize whatz going on outside of
thier cities and let them know wutz going on out in the real hoodz
5/2/06
San Diego, CA
Anyone who has lived in a southern border town should not be surprised by anything shown in this
documentary.
5/1/06
Derek
La Mesa, Ca
WoW!!!!!!!!!!!Talk about RIVETED!!!!! Some of "PBS'" best. Hard to believe this is -thee- REAL
world..........Environment,Environment, Environment!!!!!!!!!!!!!!10,000yr-old habits are hard to
break, Gotta go. Well made Doc.
5/1/06
Riz
This show caught my eye when I saw the word "gang". Im 20 years old and I live thousands of miles
away from Colombia. I never thought it'd be so much similar to here. Not the situation but how the
people there think. They think like us. In example, Edison was saying that this isnt a life he
wanted to lead. I see how they wanted to be a "thug" but as they became more deep into the gang/war
type of life, they knew it wasnt such a good life afterall. Many thoughts ran into my mind as I
watched this documentary. I cant believe it hit me so hard. How many lives can be affected by gang
violence. It's just sad that all of them realized what they were doing at the cost of anothers life.
What kind of world do we live in? With so much violence. And the girls there are 15 when they are
having babies. As if it were a proper age to have a child. I couldnt believe it was so common among
the girls...It makes me sad. I never really knew how good it is here in U.S.A. Everyone told me, but
I think I had to see it on my own. How we have such a good life and should be thankful we don't live
in a soceity with killings on every street.
5/1/06
Mersedeh Mehrtash
San Diego, CA
Absolutely remarkable! This film was one of the most gripping, honest and intense documentaries that
I have ever seen.
As for the nonsense criticism of this work; It is very easy to pass judgement, especially criticism,
from those who are far away from terror and war, tucked in their comfortable homes and living their
comfortable lives. However if anything this film puts us in the shoes of these children, even if for
only a brief moment and only then can we begin to understand the complexities of their lives, their
struggles, their souls and their waisted potential. For me this was incredibly eye opening, moving
and educational.
The children in this film are no different than any child anywhere in the world. If put in the same
situation, with the same choices and civil and economical shortcomings, all children would end up in
the exact same path. This is anarchy in a corrupt state. These children are not to blame, but rather
are victims in a circle that only promotes their deadly behaviors. The only cure is education.
Beautiful work!
5/1/06
Ernesto Carrero
boston MA
as a guy that grew up seing this on the everyday basis, was hard to remember, i just saw the last
part of it on pbs , ..that's what happened in a country were people dont have hopes and dont see
posibilities around them, drug money fuel this social cancer, if you do drugs you are killing people
, whether is in colombia peru or afganistan, getting high means get other humans killed. Medellin is
a great place were people is so beautyful and smart, but also have very ambicious unhonest people
that dont have any shame stealing resourses from education and social developement and others that
sell the dignity of colombia selling narcotics... that creates a living hell in the middle of
heaven.
Americans !! love your country ,. and dont do drugs
4/27/06
Holly
Buffalo, NY
A poster on this forum wrote that anyone who had sympathy for Edison were the "basis of evil." Is it
evil to feel compassion and sympathy for our fellow human beings? It is no question that what these
men (who are relly no older than boys) are committing horrendous crimes themselves, but does that
mean that the rest of the world should ignore the poverty and seemingly hopeless situation in which
they live? Columbia is not the United States and these young men are following the only paths they
know. The boys expressed dreams such as becoming a civil engineer, but this is impossible for them.
I am 16 and was greatly affected by this show. This was a heart renching documentary and one that
calls for greater actions from people to help better the lives of others. This situation in Columbia
(along with other horrible situations in the world) cannot be changed without much effort and the
realization that all people are created equal, and that human life is something to be valued!!
4/27/06
Sherri
Mesa AZ
When Edison talked about how wonderful it would be to help others as a doctor in a clinic, it struck
me how many people do not find a way out of their life circumstance to live up to their potential.
Toward the end when his father's story was told, the father had found a way to live a full,
productive life in a difficult place. That's what God does - gives hope to the hopeless.
Many, many interesting layers to the documentary. Thank you for bringing it to my living room and my
heart.
4/26/06
Turner Jones
Houston, TX
First of all, I am incensed that the announcer at the beginning of the show pretended that the
people who filmed this documentary were embedded with "front line troops". As if the thugs and
criminals who were filmed in this documentary were the same as US troops in Iraq or Afghanistan. I
can assure you that US troops do *not* use children in their fire fights to hold ammunition or
accompany them to gun battles or to serve as look outs. There is no comparison between what was/is
going on in the slums of Columbia and the danger that US troops work with in Iraq and Afghanistan. I
would like to see some of your film crew take an IED explosion up and close and personal.
Secondly, while I do not feel that Edison deserved to be summarily gunned down by the police, I
feel this man was personally responsible for the deaths of innocents and that he felt entitled to
flaunt the bounds of civility by fathering 8 children out of wedlock and of which he had no hope of
ever supporting. At the ripe old age of 22. To those posters on this forum that have found Edison to
be a sympathetic character, I say you have no moral compass and are the basis of evil. I am
disgusted that I ever watched the show.
4/26/06
pennsylvania
this was brilliant. i saw it at 4am on sunday morning before i went to work and thought about it all
day.came home to check the listing and it was on again at 11 pm. very good documentary. my heart
goes out to all of the people. how sad for edison and his children. thank you to his father. great
video.
4/26/06
Thanks for showing this film.
May be one day I got back to
Colombia and be able to make a differance or at least help some of the helpless childress that are
not to
blame for what is going on In Colombia. We don't know how good we have it in the United Sates of
America. We seem take this goodness for granted. Let's all pray for Colombia and to the end of this
war where children are paying the price.
4/26/06
Cincinnati, OH
Brilliant, Ugly, & Non-Stop. Surrealistic landscape just adds to the nightmare lives these kids
live. La Sierra is wonderful, in a tragic sort of way.
...people should show this to kids who jest about violence in a gang scenario. ...It may enlighten
them.
4/26/06
Adam Wilson
South Bend, IN
First of all, All of us that viewed this should take a few moments and pray for these people
EVERYDAY. Life goes on after the filming ends!
I was flipping through the channels at 4 am and came across La Sierra. It was a chance for me to
learn something new. And for all of you from Colombia, those of us that have some education are
aware that this documentary does not represent the entire country. Just like President Bush does not
respresent the views of all Americans...that being said...the film was riveting as I was unable to
change the channel and seek other programming. It reflects the world we live in more than it
reflects the life on a neighborhood in Colombia. We could go into any country on this planet and
film "documaentaries" that show one angle over another. I feel as a member of the human race that we
need to be made aware of the many, many horrors in this world. We all have a responsiblity to make
this a better place than when we were born into it!
4/25/06
Andrei
Somerville, MA
'La Sierra' is one of the most hard-hitting, no-nonsense & powerful documentaries I've seen in a
while.
4/25/06
Diane doty
Cincinati, Ohio
What a powerful film. It displays the harsh reality that some people deal with in their everyday
lives. Watching this amazing film last night reminded me that human struggle is real in the world,
sometimes sitting comfortably in middle-class America, some forget this. This film consumed my
thoughts while and after I watched it. The hopes, struggles, and difficulites of Edison, Cielo and
the others became my hopes and struggles as I watched, and that is the true gift of the film.
However, it is true that some do not have the choice other to struggle - it is the way that they
carry out this action that is the difference, for example Edison and his father.
The fight for your own existance is inconceivable, yet real. The experience of watching this
independent film was enlightening, inspirational and compelling.
4/25/06
Fernando Martinez
Missoula, MT
Caught me by surprise, being from Colombia, but living so far for so long. Well done work. Couple of
questions that should've been asked to put it in perspective of an internal conflict.
Who provides the money?
Who provides the drugs?
4/24/06
Juan Manuel
Costa Rica
An amazing film from a human struggle perspective, as it shows an isolated community creating its
own brutal and violent reality. Capturing such real events in film, with co-operation of the main
characters were both amazing and brave, and the effect was indeed penetrating, regardles of anyone's
nationality. I do belive that we needed aditional perspective to fully understand the film's events
and ultimate purpose to avoid the claim that the film is an inaccurate portrayal of social life in
Colombia. First, it is a poor and isolated barrio, up on the mountains where there is no police
force at all, this is not the case in most of Colombia, I believe. Second, how does Edson manage to
have so much relative wealth ? Drug money ? and thirdly, education in La Sierra is probably
non-existent as are most of the social services offered to most Colombians. In all, it seemed as the
gangs created an illusion of a war, and probably the gun shots heard at night to violently control
an isolated community that lacked any law enforcement. These pockets of un-patrolled areas exist all
over the world, including in cities like NY and Chicago, where similar documentaries can be filmed.
However, the human factor and honest dialog of the main characters, with the tragic and deathly
results are genuine and shares a true lesson to be learned by all. Great work !!!
4/24/06
Aaron
Montreal, Canada
Incredible film! It is rare that a documentary takes the viewer so deep into the reality that it
seeks to capture. The filmakers responsible for this movie, along with others who risk their lives
and livelihoods bringing such important stories to the masses, deserve much praise and respect for
their efforts. I was reminded of just how dangerous it must have been to make this film in the scene
when the Jesus tells the camera-person "Get down gringo! They're shooting at us!" Wow. In reading
about the civil war in Colombia (or any other struggle), it is so easy to forget about the human
beings affected by this kind of violence. Thank you to the filmmakers for bringing humanity back
into the picture. One Love.
4/24/06
Mayra
This was amazing!!! It was a real eye opener for me. After a "rough" night of partying last wk I
decided I would stay home the following night. I was flipping through channels and caught the
opening credits. I watched the entire doc w/out leaving my seat. It made me realize so many things
about myself as well and my choices in life. The "rough" nights & all. I haven't stopped thinking
about it since. I cried for Edison and the family he left behind.I felt like I really knew these
people...
Great Job!!!!
4/24/06
Erin
Buffalo, NY
It takes a powerful show to keep me from flipping channels all night. I don't know what captured me
more: the real-life conflict that exists in Colombia, or the way it was all presented. Whichever it
was, it kept me motionless the entire time it was on. When the end credits began rolling, I wondered
endlessly when I could purchase the episode on DVD or video, but unfortunately, that information
never came up. I will try to find out where I can get it, or when/if it will be on again. This story
was so enlightening that I became emotional during the presentation, sometimes talking right to the
screen. I will definitely keep my eyes open for more works by Dalton and Martinez; they are true
journalists with the talent to show us what is happening in faraway places during our easy, everyday
lives. It was shocking, to say the least, and extremely gratifying.
4/24/06
Canada
OMG... When i seen this documentary i was very shocked...It is so shocked seeing these girls at such
a young age become pregnant. I'm here and other girls my age are thinking how we are going to finish
school, and they are alredy having babies at such a young age.It is so sad that these young gilrs
have to bag on the street to survive. But it is reality.
4/24/06
David H Lee
Davenport, Iowa
This documentary is very profound and it shows the crude reality that thousands of people live in
other parts of the world. Here in the U.S. many times we take for granted what we have. God has
blessed this country and watching this documentary really made me think about what I have and how I
live, and how in other places the struggle for survival is so great and death can be just around the
corner, as sadly we found out following Edison.
I commend the brave authors for their great work and to all the viewers I say let's pay attention
and realize how easy we have it here.
4/24/06
Jan Hernandez
While I was saddened by this documentary, it was the conclusion that brought the ray of hope... the
way Edison's redeemed father has taken all his fatherless grandchildren under wing, to sow unity
amongst them and the light of Jesus Christ's love to each one, brought tears to my eyes.
Unfortunately Jairo was unable to help Edison before his early death, but I was so impressed with
the largeness of this man's heart to show Edison's children the way of peace, with God and with one
another. It is obviously his redemptive mission in this life, and an expression of his deep love not
only for Edison but for his community. One man touching eight young lives, as well as the lives of
their mothers, is an example we all should follow. One by one, we can make a difference, perhaps
even an eternal difference.
God's blessings on you and yours, Jairo, and on your community.
4/24/06
Dane
Leesburg, Virginia
I stumbled on to "La Sierra" by accident late at night and was quickly captivated. This is an
excellent, touching film. In many ways the young people of La Sierra are so much like the young
people here, and yet their lives are so different, made uncertain and fleeting by war and violence.
The film effected me in a way similar to "Les Miserables" but the fact that its reality and not
fiction makes it much more tragic and touching.
I also think it was excellent the way the story was captured without the padding of narration or any
self-insertion of the film makers.
Thank you Scott and Margarita for preserving the story of La Sierra and sharing it with us.
4/24/06
Rio Grande Valley of Texas
WOW ! I sat glued to this compelling film. Here along the border we are very sensitive to the
violence that is just south of us, and to what a different world we live in, here in 'El Norte'.
We are also keenly aware that we live in a place and time where our situation could change in a
heartbeat.
The WORLD should see this important documentary. Excellent Work !!!
4/24/06
Andrea Sheldon
Ohio
That documentary was AMAZING!! I seriously had no idea what truly is going on in Columbia. Those
young men and women are following the only paths they knew...they hard one but the right one to
them. I think they do have the power to make their own choices but they just need to put in the
right situations. Yes my eyes were open to the situation and it helped me gain a new perspective on
their situation.
4/24/06
Beverley
West Palm Beach, FLorida
God Bless Indie filmmakers. What an excellent study of human strife..how similar we all are. One can
look at the film "Bus 174", read about the child soldiers of Africa and can come to the same
conculsion.
We can look at our own Ghettos,'Hoods, Barrios or Favelas...It's all the same
ingredients...Proverty, ignorance, babies having babies and an early death being an everyday
normality.
Our Children have become numb.
Violence has become a vital form of existence.
Violence has become Normal
4/24/06
Nikki
While watching La Sierra, I was very disturbed to find out these type of things are still going on
in the world we live in. I was also very moved by it and will definately be perchasing the
documentary. I respect the filmcrew first for even thinking of bringing this film to life, it took a
lot of courage and hard work to put yourselfs in the story you were trying to capture.
Even though at times I was sadened by what I saw,I know knowledge is power, and now that so many of
us viewers have seen the hardships that these young adults and in many cases children are going
through, what can we do to help or at least bring awareness to others who have not had the privilage
of viewing this independent masterpiece.
4/24/06
Gainesville, FL
As a Latin American and avid student of Latin American history and politics, and especially of the
Colombian conflict, I have to say this is one of the best films I have seen made on the subject (and
believe me, I have watched many... six semesters' worth). The paramilitary path has become both a
necessity and a way of life. It IS the only way to get ahead, just like the corporate rat race may
be in many parts of the U.S., or tourism in Caribbean islands. What else would you do in a place
where there is no education, no jobs, almost no state presence (except for abusive police forces)
and constant attacks by guerrillas? I agree with the filmmakers that these men are largely products
of their environments. Although I know more than the average citizen about the Colombian situation,
films like these continue to drive home the urgency of the situation and the incredible, almost
surreal dimension of existence in which these people live every day.
4/24/06
Jodi shondel
fairfield,iowa
i came apon this film early this morning. and wow what can i say. cant believe things like that
really happen. I'm a 22yr old woman with 3 kids I could not imangne my kids growing up without me at
such a young age. my heart goes out to EVERYONE in this film.
4/24/06
Josh Bosley
Perry, Iowa
Simply amazing. A real eye opener and a must see. Leaves you speechless.
4/24/06
Noli Cabantug
Pomona, CA
I watched it Saturday night in L.A. and despite being drowsy, I went on to finish the film. I had
insomnia afterwards and the images kept on repeating in my brain. Such was the power of the film
that it was so disturbing. Scott and Margarita, your job has a lasting value, I hope you will be
discovered by Hollywood and this work will be shown again. I am a substitute teacher and sometimes,
dealing with stubborn fifth or six graders makes me exasperated. I found out I'm dealing with
non-issues after watching this film. I hope I can get this video to show to teachers whining always
about how bad some kids are.
Edison, Jesus and Cielo are in the whirlpool-they can hardly get away from it , so as with those
others in La Sierra. Some things could help change them, if ever there is a chance: 1. moving away
-change of environment, 2. government intervention, 3. religious experience.
Coming from a third world country and from a poor neighborhood - yes I agree that: gun symbolizes
power, and it is POWER-
it is almost everything to someone. A man with a gun has some seduction. And drug is a
pestilence.
La Sierra made me understand some parts of Columbia. It actually invites me to see the place myself.
4/24/06
Greg
Iowa
Once I get past the depression of watching this film, I know I will have a much deeper appreciation
for my peaceful life in the united states. However, right now, everything seems so insignificant,
knowing that things that like are happening on this earth as I type this.
4/24/06
LCPL Micah Hebert
Kaneohe Bay, Hawai'i
Very rare is the occasion when one encounters a medium which, through its banal candidness, makes
one question and re-think our paradigm as a society. Seeing this documentary with its unfiltered
reality made me re-evalute much of what I previously thought about Columbia and those fighters
(worldwide) who fight for any given reason or cause. Being one myself (active duty in the United
States Marine Corps) I felt this film touched me both as a soldier and especially as a fellow human
being. Kudos to both the producers and PBS for airing such a riveting tale which would otherwise
have gone unheard. My only complaint would be that it aired so late; unfortunate, since such a
cinematic gem desereves a much wider audience.
4/24/06
Akuma Kage
Corpus Christi, Tx
After watching this film i wept.The harsh realities of life in an area like La Sierra are enough to
ground the hope of anyone involved into dust and ash.To say that these young men are simply
murderers and thugs is one of the most closed minded ideas ive ever heard.No one can understand what
it means to live in La Sierra. To live a life where the only way out is death. When all you have is
your fist and your steel then you will use those tools to the best of your abilities. Anyone would
if they really took the time to think about it. High praise to the film makers for bringing this
modern tragedy to light. The wolrd needs to see these images. They need to see the human beings
behind the headlines. They have lives, families, homes. These are people who live in a poverty level
that most americans cant even imagine.I have lived on the streets. I have been homeless. I have been
hungry. I have stolen to survive. Now i am enlisted in the US Navy and my children have cloths on
their backs, food in the bellys, and security of home and heart. I have never taken the life of
another human being and i pray that i never have to but where is the difference in the story of the
young men in La Sierra and my own.
4/24/06
Ulises Urbina
Bakersfield California
If you see no evil, if you hear no evil and if you speak no evil does that mean that evil does not
exist. Certainly this film proves the existence of evil even if we rarely see, hear or speak of it.
Living in the USA has made me blind to what is going on in the world. I have been very fortunate in
not seeing the dark side of our human nature. Unfortunately the only way to address the problem of
evil is to see, hear and speak of it. Columbia is a beautiful country but even the most beautiful of
flowers have their thorns. This is a very powerful film that should be more accessible to all.
Thanks for the experience.
4/24/06
Bryan Everett
Baltimore, MD
Originally, I planned on watching "Saturday Night Live" as my study break tonight, but as usual it
was garbage from the instant it began. Prepared to turn the tube off and surf the web, I checked PBS
as my only alternative and, thankfully, I stumbled upon this powerful and engrossing film.
The overriding theme, to me, was naturally poverty and the decision-making process imposed on its
victims. This is true in every barrio and ghetto in every country.
I work with the underprivileged on a daily basis and understand the effects of curtailed access to
education, health care and employment. My conversations with the impoverished and criminally
entangled urban youth of Baltimore are strikingly parallel to what Edison, Jesus and Cielo were
saying: we want to do better, but we don't know how. In America, it's easy to say that opportunity
abounds - that it merely takes willpower to steel oneself against the temptation of the easy road to
emphemeral success in order to follow the more difficult path of education and an "honest day's
work". This is simply not the case. In a meritocracy, those with access to resources generally
succeed and those without generally fail. Naturally, success is relative and disparate, even for
Edison, Jesu and Cielo. Everyone wants to succeed, so we attempt to succeed with the resources that
are at hand. Edison was ambitious while Jesus and Cielo were more survivalist in their attempts.
4/24/06
Christina Bustos
Tempe Arizona
This was an amazing film. I am always concerned with the treatment of others, Latinos especially,
and this has just truly sparked my interest. As a Chicana I must say that I do not know much about
other Latin American countries besides Mexico and it is refreshing to know that there is information
out there. It is devestating to know the treatment of these innocent young women, and these children
growing up with out direction and fathers.
With the current legislation that is being proposed in the US, this is something that should be
shown over and over again. The reason? This film, although it does not talk about how the US is
involved shows us reasons why some people might choose to come to the United States, to get away
from the constant war, drugs, prostitution of young woman (not to mention their horrible treatment
by the paramilitary), and of course death.
Please share this with others. Most often we look at why people come to the United States and
because we are so money driven here people think that that's of course why all people come here.
I would like to suggest that people come here to get away from the constant fear of death, raising
children alone, and being sentenced to life long abuse (sexually, physically and mentally).
I would like to thank the film makers and I encourage you to keep going with what you do because it
was amazing.
4/24/06
sam
excellent piece of work.
it would be interesting to see if we could find stories here in the U.S that parallel community
struggles of every level.
4/24/06
Juan M Huezo
Houston, TX
As a Salvadorean national, coming from a civil war of 13 years and now working as a police officer
for the city of Houston, had forgotten (or ignored)the problems that we (people from poor
countries)had to endure and still going with out an end in sight. I came from work that day tired
and not to happy, I sat down and came across PBS and "La Sierra", my troubles and aches were so
miniscule compared to these "kids", my wife and I sat down and reflected to the film and the impact
of seeing the main character dead in just a few moments after he predicted it. Knowing that he will
not appear in the next film or commercial.. Awakening, Strong and Human..
Que viva Colombia, nuestros pueblos y sobre todo nuestra Gente......QEPD
4/24/06
Rachel
Wisconsin
Wow, I was so touched by this film. It is completely different to watch the real life situation in
Colombia as opposed to just reading the headlines. I began to understand why they turned to
violence... because it is their world, it is all they know. The film saddened me, and made me want
to learn more about the situation in Colombia. Thanks for making this film!
4/24/06
Marco Cardona
Atlanta, GA
Unfortunately all this documentary is real. Thanks for showing the shocking and violent city where I
was born. Is when ignorance, corruption and killers collide.
Colombia needs education and opportunities.
4/24/06
Julian Sal
Delray Beach Florida
Your wonderful Ducumentary aired two days after I arrived from Medellin.
I due admire your courage in taking the risks you took to film this story;however, after talking
extensively with the maid at my sisters house, she assures me that even in the poor neighborhoods
things are changing for the better; There is police patrols in areas where the authorities
previously feared entering. There is a lot of International investment going into the Country. As
one of the many investors, I hope That What ever happens in the next years, the wealth that is
entering the Country will trickle down to those in need.
Maybe through our actions, All of us will bring hope to those that dont have any.
4/24/06
J Cabrera
Long Island, NY
Wow, where do I begin. I caught the documentary about a third of the way through where the child was
holding the bullets for Edison. This was a most powerful and disturbing image to me as I have two
young children about the same age. My heart goes out to all of these people who have lived their
entire lives under these miserable conditions. I am aware that there are two sides to every story
and it appears that some are offended by the documentary but this was such a powerful, gripping, and
raw film about a way of life the majority of us could never fathom living that I couldn't stop
watching. I emigrated from Colombia over 40 years ago and couldn't help thinking what my life could
have been if I were presented with the same conditions as these young people. I grew up in a tough
NYC neighborhood, or so I thought until watching this, but have always been grateful for the
opportunities the U.S. has provided me. My only wish is to see the filmmakers go back in a year or
two to see if life has changed for the better since the precarious peace took place. Thank you for
bringing this film to your audience.
4/24/06
Maricela Dominguez
San Benito, TX
This documentary really touhed me. i just couldnt stop watching it. its amazing the kinds of things
they have to go through and how different their world is from ours. I just felt like i was there
with these young people sharing thier lives and even though i didn't feel half of the pain that they
did i can truly say that i did feel pain on how the story ended, because thier real people just like
me and young also. they just happen to live somewhere else. i was very impressed and i really admire
all the people who took part in this wonderful story.
4/21/06
WOW. I accidentely flipped to this channel at 1am this morning and saw this program. I cant beleive
how many other people saw it and were affected by it. What a wonderful documentary. Very sad but
VERY good.
4/21/06
Oh MY GOd. This film was EXCELLENT. It really saddens me to know how different things can be just an
ocean away. I was up till 1 in the morning watchng this because I was so intrigued. At first I
thoght what a shame that these young girls allow those thugs to cheat on them and impregnate them so
young. Then as I really listened to what they were daying I began to realize that they were not mere
thugs. They were young men who had grown up fighting for their lives and really knew no better. I
could tell they have dreams. I never expected Edison to die in the film. I cried like I actually
knew him. He sounded so intelligent. To Scott and Margarita: WONDERFUL JOB. I respect your
profession so much for things like this.
4/21/06
Angel Babilonia
Aguadilla , Puerto Rico
Waaooo well that story really toach me because i been thru that same situacion where i live we are
going thru the same here in Puerto Rico butt over there in colombia is real getto over here in
Puerto Rico the police is really big and strong not like over there butt i really love that story i
think the camara man did a Hell of a job ! Thank hope 2 see it again on tv.
4/21/06
Laura O.
Houston, TX
Excellent film! Props to the brave filmmakers for showing these beautiful people in Colombia. These
young people have dreams, just like young people in America and all over the world, but they have
little opportunities for advancement. It was sad to see that these lovely young ladies were so
trapped in their environment. It seems like they don't realize there is a whole world out here, much
bigger than La Sierra and they have the potential to be so successful. May God bless them and make
their lives more peaceful and prosperous!
4/21/06
oscar
I've never seen a documentary like this before so shocking so REAL, it's "D best".
4/21/06
Jaide
This is an excellent film! It is stunning the situations that they have to go through. I think that
as Edistoís father says it at the end, he sacrificed his life for peace and at least they stopped
fighting in that barrio. This is definitely a film to open our eyes to similar situations going on
in this world and an invitation to know more about other historical and similar events in the past
where young men and women had died dreaming of a better country; Mexico 1968, 1994-, Chile 1971,
Guatemala, El Salvador, Argentina only to mention Latin America. Congratulations on and hopefully
you can give us an update on Cielo and Edistoís family.
4/20/06
kay kay
houston, TX
I think they are following the only obvious path that has been laid out for them, although i do
think that if things were different in their country then yes they could have the choice to have a
better life, but like Edison states if he moves away he leaves behind his family and may by some
chance run into one of his enemies. i feel for those in La Sierra, if i had the chance to let my
kids see how good they have it. i cried when Edison died i can't imagine how those girls felt
because each one of them loved him their own way. i also admired what his father was also doing
trying to bring the kids together very loving.
4/20/06
david r medina
First of all your film was quite bold and daring, I thought the film was an excellent view of the
current plight of society in Colombia. The drug usage of the main characters didn't help their
ability to make proper choices, so I believe they were searching for answeres for happiness. I do
believe each person has a choice to do good or wrong. Oftentimes in a violent society fear is a
dominant opposition to civility. The film was an eyeopener to the situation in Medilin. Excellent
film.
4/20/06
Yady King
Oxford, OH
I was very anxious to see this documentary as I have not been back to my MedellÌn since 1995. I can
safely say that after watching it my heart aches for my land. This documentary reminded me of the
helplessness that my family that is still there, endures everyday. It made me question my own "luck"
to have been able to get out and come to this country and start a new life. It was so very
depressing to see so many young lives ruined by a violence that precedes them and that they've
inherited. I hope, as all Colombians do, that this documentary will inspire U.S. citizens to care
about the conflict in Colombia and to shed pre-conceived notions of its wonderful people.
Thank you so much for shining some light!
4/20/06
Fernando Martinez
Houston, TX
La Sierra is a spectacular documentary which opens your eyes to reality. One becomes personally
involved with the story's characters, only to find out they are shot killed in the end. I respect
and admire journalists who risk their life in order to tell the truth about war.
4/20/06
panama city florida
i have just watched the last probably 30 minutes of the la sierra.i have a lot of latin friends that
say it is like this in mexico also i am deeply moved by this program tonight i have no idea what it
is like to have a man with several different girlfriends and many children to have fought for our
lives i find it sad and i feel helpless as to what to do about this i imagine that in some forms it
is still going on like the rest of u have said it is a terrible tragedy to have young people like
myself to have been and still are struggling with things like this in many different countries i
hope that as the people read these little summaries will fall to ur knees and thank the good lord
for what u have and pray for all the families in the world such as our own fighting in iraq, for
peace and togetherness its is mad out there and i cant but help thinking what if that were me and my
husband fighting in wars with children around guns were too and i am terribly sorry to the families
of columbia for there losses. so tonight i hope everyone is thankful for the house they live in and
also for the nice and neat houses they may live in take alook at that poverty when u or myself think
that were broke so thank the good lord for that lets do something about it if we can
4/20/06
Saira
Honolulu, Hawaii
As a student in the US, I was shocked to see the difference in our lives. Some of the most shocking
moments came when the little boy was carrying the ammunitation, and the eight year old telling
matter-o-factly what happened. I also moved when they said, I expect to die young. I sincerely hope
as many people as possible are able to see this in order to appreciate one thing that they would die
for, peace.
4/20/06
Alejandro Munoz
Miami Florida
My fellow Americans you have just witnessed first hand what Colombianas have had to go through. I
was amazed when I first started to see the film. Accurate is not a word to describe it. Its better
like exactly like what it is like. I felt right back at home and memories started to come back. I
give tramendous respect to the filmaker for risking his life to show this documentary to show not
only the United States but the world what my people go through. Colombia to me and I believe to many
other Colombians is a very beautiful Counrty with many if not some of the most beautiful things life
has to ever offer. "Eternal Bliss" but be scared and be cautious that with eternal bliss comes great
suffering and tramendous danger.
Thank You PBS
4/20/06
francisco ramirez
houston, texas
These paramilitary fighters are taking the only opportunities available to them. The Colombian
government has always given economic support to paramilitary groups when the government feels that
it is to their advantage to do so. In a country like Colombia, where 40% of the workforce is
unemployed, getting money to fight as a paramilitary is a good alternative.
The real criminals are not these low level paramilitary fighters. The real criminals are the
Colombian government officials who support and defend the Colombian status quo, and the economic
order that condemns millions of Colombians to lifes of misery and despair.
The film LA SIERRA showed the choices that Colombian society offers to young, poor women: they can
become beggars or prostitutes.
By the way, the Colombian military has always been involved in creating these paramilitary groups.
Also, the United States government gives billions of dollars every year in aid to the Colombian
military.
4/20/06
Michael
Houston, Tx
That was a very good film!! It's sad the way it ended with Edison's death because he seemed like a
good man with a good heart just in the wrong environment to be living in. I can't imagine how all
those kids are going to grow up without their dad. All those teenagers involved in the paramilitary
fighting just wanted to have a better life for themselves and their family. I hope they are all
living better now. You guys should do a follow-up film to see how the people in LA SIERRA have been
doing especially those who were in this film. It would be great to see how they are doing!! You guys
did a great job on this film and i'm sure it's touching many people's heart..
4/20/06
Juan Carlos Ospina
Wilton California
I am from a wealthy Colombian family. In fact I used to live in Medellin and still have lots of
family living there today.
I was in a hotel room flipping through channels and this film caught my eye. I did not see the
beginning and frankly it took me a while to figure out what the movie was all about. I have to admit
that at first I was horrified that this young man, Edison, had several very young girls pregnant and
seamed to so cavalier about it all. Ironically my first concern was the poor image this presented of
the Colombia people and struggled to determine why someone would produce such a film. I have to say
though that after watching the remainder of the film I started to get a sense of what Edison was
striving for in his community. I truly think his desire was for the war to end. But sadly it is that
very war that gave him the power he relished.
Even though I had glimpses of the issues that these poor areas are forced to deal with, and thought
I understood at least some of the economic and political issues, after watching this film from
Edison's eyes I realize I know even less than what I thought
4/20/06
I have learnt so much about a place I didn't know existed.
It's sad to see fellow human being living like this. I supported Edison all the way, even his many
children.
4/20/06
Alejandro Garcia
Pearland Texas
La Sierra native
we can retreat back to spirit life or let ego command (the ego racist,the ego is nationalistic, the
ego is prejudicial, its happiness is determinant on stimulus from outside) crusade to put god back
in the people as the native from that part of the world lived
4/20/06
Guillermo Maya
Fresno, CA
After reading some of the comments that people posted lately, specially those written by Colombians,
I also think that people need to change the way they percive Colombia. I know for sure that not
every body living in Colombia is exposed to such atrocities, and there are good and successful
people there. People doing this documentals should try to show the other side of Colombia. I know
there must be one. There is enough negative propaganda about Colombia already. I do share this
sentiment expressed by Colombians, I feel the same way when people generalized and stereotype all
Mexicans the same way, not being true for all of us.
4/20/06
greenwood ar
this movie was really amazing i am 15 and in a spanish class and it really was intersting to me....i
really liked it i wish there were more movies about things like that and about young
people....thanks
4/20/06
diana
lady lake, florida
Like everyone else, i thoroughly enjoyed this documentary. I was born in Colombia and lived there
until I was 9 when I was adopted. I grew up in a very poor barrio like so many. I knew that a lot of
this was going on even when i live there. However, I never saw it firsthand, so to see it on tv, it
just opened my eyes to the danger and turmoil that my country faces. I feel like i can relate to
those young girls because I too could have been one of them. I want to go back to Colombia and visit
and see for myself how lucky i am to live in the United states where I dont have to experience such
horror and danger. Thank you so much for making this film. I hope that you will be able to make more
so that more people will see the dangers out there not just in Colombia, but all around the world.
Once again, thank you and please keep me posted if you make another film about Colombia. Hopefully,
it will be something more light and less depressing!
4/20/06
Amy Lukau
Phoenix, Arizona
I think this film captured what is really going on around the world; not just the war in Iraq or the
presumption that Iran will use iranium to build weapons of mass destruction.For me it is refreshing
to watch shows like Independent Lens because a times I think we as people let the media act as our
conscious in the respect that what we see on certain channels alters our view of the world.Watching
the film last night really tugged on my conscious and I am still thinking about it today, but I
can't help but parallel this situation to what has and is going on in certain parts of Africa.It is
also fascinating for me because I was reading national geographic and Colombia seemed to be in my
view on the road to recovery but this film showed a other side and I am grateful for that.
4/20/06
Justin Schwarz
Phoenix, AZ
The documentary was incredibly well done. I felt a gripping compassion as I walked along side
Edison,his friends and family. I was deeply moved by their attempt to make a life out of a living
hell.
This should be required viewing by every high student in America.
The haunting question that lingers even now is,"What can I do to reach out and help these people?"
"How can I make a positive impact in my world and the world around me?"
4/20/06
Brenda
Tennessee
I watched La Sierra last night and it really had an impact of me. I never knew what I was going to
see next. It was a good realization of what life is like outside of my country, especially for
people that are my age. I could not imagine going through the things that they had to go through.
Not only that, but it deeply saddened my heart to see that Edison was killed, just to hear all the
things he hoped and dreamed for and in an instant it was all gone. Thank you to the filmmakers for
such a powerful film!
4/20/06
Chente Rodriguez
San Antonio, Tx.
Wow! I live in awe of the experience others endure, and the hope some never lose, though much loss
surrounds them.
4/20/06
Serena
Tucson, AZ
I came home from work and turned on the tv and saw this, it caught my attention and eventually I was
glued to the tv. I thought it was a great documentary. It almost seemed like fiction. I was
thinking, "how could this be real?" At the end when it said that edison had been shot to death, my
jaw dropped because you know thats real. wow. Great video.
4/20/06
Fernando, Bueno
phoenix, Az
This video really did surprise me and showed me how much better we have it over here but what
happens to edison is messed up but thats the goverment for you
4/20/06
Madison, WI
I would like to start by stating that I am Colombian, and I believe that all sides of the stories
and stories of all layers should be told.
I lived in Medellin for about a year at the beginning of the decade and I was able to experience
first hand the violence and sadness of the most depressed social classes in the area.
Never the less I have to be quite critical about this documentary; the side that is being exposed is
the darkest and hence the most miserable of all societies in Colombia, creating quite a gruesome
image.
I believe these stories are not to be censored, but the initial cameo of a dead body full of flies
latter to be hugged an caressed by two people (that I supposed are their family) is a sinister way
to start a macabre documentary that might biased a lot of PBS viewers about a complete culture of
people.
I live in the United States and have been living here for a few years, and I believe is not
responsible to present such a dark and grisly image that can create such stereotype of Colombian
society, and sadly Colombian people
Focusing on the story of the girl that has to prostitute herself in order to provide for her baby,
and the significant emphasis done on the violence, weapons and corpses. Especially shocking to me,
the deplorable scene of the two young males using drugs while being arm to the teeth and talking
about how consumed they are on the conflict, is very deceiving of a complete culture.
4/20/06
Zetha B.
I invite you to watch this video:
Medellin turns from fear to hope at
http://www.medellin.gov.co/alcaldia/jsp/modulos/V_medellin/index.jsp?idPagina=847
4/20/06
Ma. Helena Arango
San Antonio, TX
I am originally from Medellin, Colombia. It is true that Colombia is a beautiful country, it is also
true that according to a survey we are the happiest country in the world (which I think is
irrelevant and stupid). As Colombian, I deeply love my country but I don't understand why are we so
irresponsible and keep denying a reality...The gap between rich and poor every day is getting
greater and greater, the poor don't have the opportunity to have a good education, you can see how
these girls get pregnant not realizing the enviroment in what their kids are goint to grow in. Is a
very complex problem but is worst to confirm that people who are able to do something about it don't
care. What do we do as Colombians, nothing. You go to any city in Colombia, any...and you'll find
children in the streets begging for food, elderly people living in the streets. And the conflict in
the fields is even worst because the farmers are between several armed groups that are even more
dangerous than this gangs.
We have been in a Civil war for more than 50 years and we are still in dialogues and no solution to
any of the conflicts. We are a democracy that's right but the injustice, indifference and corruption
are destroying our country. What are we doing for our children (they are our future), what are we
doing for our elderly (they are our experience)???
4/19/06
Dallas, TX
As a Colombian I feel the film was extremely informative and accurate. It is hard to capture the
complexity of the conflict Colombia lives but the ducumentary gives a very valid point of view in my
opinion.
4/19/06
deandra blizzard
englewood nj
i think that you should have this in libaries make it so we can have ina public schools so kids in
america see what it really like to live with basically nothing to see how fortune we are but no one
is goinf to but it t 450 a dvd come i wanted to share this with my class but was not able to get my
hands on it it was wonderful be thankful for what you have god forbid it to happen to anyone its sad
it made me cry iam so lucky to live in america let alone live where i have parents and people to
teach me to do better
4/19/06
Nate May
Huntington, WV
Jon Stewart's snickerings about FARC had been my only experience with the Colombian civil war prior
to seeing this film. Actually, I tuned in late to it, so the whole time I was watching I didn't even
know what country it was in. I was curious at the time, but not too concerned. I was most
preoccupied with these lives that were being exposed to me -- I was trying to come to terms with the
fact that I truly cannot imagine what it would be like to live in such violence and fear. This film
removed me from my comfort zone -- my daily mindset where my concerns are mostly of little
consequence. Seeing this is important because it reminds me that my life experience is not any kind
of universal experience, and I should be more humble in my judgment of others.
I was also impressed by the heroism of the filmmakers. Whereas for me even seeing this violence on
television is scary, these people chose to immerse themselves in it. They did it for people like me,
who are too wrapped up in their own comfortable lives. But I'm sure they also did it for themselves,
because I am sure an experience like that is both enlightening and humbling.
4/19/06
Katelynn Ann Sorrells
Anderson, South Carolina
La Sierra had a great impact on my emotions last night. I cannot imagine being cielo with that child
and my husband die. The whole story stirred up emotions. *I think that the boys were just young men
following the only obvious path to respect and prestige. * yes they have the power to make those
decisions because they are responsible for themselves. *well i never knew of the situation of
colombia but La Sierra certainly made me think about the life that i have and the life they have i
wish that things would be different for them i want them to be happy and free after all they are
people just like Americans treat them that way!
4/19/06
Carolina Torres
Sanford Florida
I would like to challenge you to portray all the good things about this country, the hard working
people, the creative minds, Colombia was declared by the UNESCO as the country with the happiest
people in the world, we have medical minds that have contributed so much to this world, we have
artist that are well know around the world, writers and poets that have made our life better.
I am a proud Colombia, I love my country and I want people not to be so ignorant about the reality
that is lived there, besides the confrontations and violence problems, and I want to express that it
is sickening to me every time someone finds out I am Colombian and they ask me if my father is a
drug dealer or if we are in the guerrillas, they dare to ask me if we have indoor pluming, and they
don't even know we are a democracy.
If your objective is really to educate the American population, you need to show the whole picture,
our country is not just exotic dancers, paramilitaries, and guerrillas. I do understand that the
gore and the violence are more appealing, but you are only portraying the negative part of a
wonderful country.
I hope one day I see in my TV all the amazing things about my country.
4/19/06
TY SCHILDWACHTER
SPRINGFIELD MISSOURI
Me and my wife watched La Sierra last night. Very interesting show. Very very sad though. It's hard
to believe that people in this world live like that at such a young age. We is the USA don't know
how good we have it. I'd have been very afraid for my life when making the film. Excellent work!
Those people down there don't really know any better though. The government is murderous, drug
dealing thugs so it's like anything goes. I'm sure if any one of those kids were put in a different
environment they would do great.
4/19/06
Dean De Negri
Stanford, California
The film La Sierra is life changing. I want to thank you for bringing existence in Columbia to
light, and to thank you for sharing the lives of Jesus Martinez, Cielo Munoz, and Edison Flores and
thier loves, dreams, and hopes. My wish is to embrace all Columbian's in the Unitied States, to
assist and make their dreams come true.
A. The young paramilitary fighter are just young men following the only obvious path to respect and
life. This is true. At Stanford, Game Theory would validate the young men decisions. "When the 'pie'
contracts, 'compete'. When the 'pie' expands, cooperate." The young men compete in the most hostile
of enviroments. They are actually victims of the enviroment. Violence and guns are the ultimate
competition. If you were to translpant them here in San Francisco and a safe enviroment, they would
still think and make decisions such that; they are going to die tomorrow.
B. Do the young men have power to make those choices? No. This is true because Columbia and thier
particuliar enviroment is a vortex of contracting opportunities, both in the past, present, and
unless they come to the United States, the future.
C. The film La Sierra enlightened me very much. Thank you. I embrace every Columbian "brother" and
"sister". I love them; they're the most deserving in the world.
4/19/06
Guillermo Maya
Fresno, CA
I just want to congratulate all the people who were involved in the making of such documental,
specially the directores and the cameraman who really put him/herself in such dangerous situation
for the only purpose of capturing this footage. I am really shocked. I am a Native Mexican, living
in US, and going to the university. This film really made me reevaluate the way see my life. Some
times, I said things like: "why life is so unfair with me", and I don't realize how much I have that
other people don't. I always had an idea of what was going on in Colombia (mostly trhough the
media), but I never imagined such crude reality.
I just can not undertand why we(humans) are they way we are. I wish there would be something I could
do about it, but I guess the only thing I can do is what I am doing right now: Educating myself.
Thank you very much
4/19/06
Phoenix, AZ
La Sierra shows a hidden side of Colombia, one that even me, as Colombian, was only aware through a
few lines every other week in a local newspaper. I had never seen any footage from inside these
"comunas" of Medellin and to be honest, it was very disturbing. You can't even see images like these
in Colombia simply because nobody, from inside the country, couldn't get in.
Being Medellin one of the most elitist, trend-setting and well-educated cities in Colombia, it is
just sad to discover this parallel reality with its own life and laws attached to the city. These
people are not murderers and thugs, but just victims of a society (a.k.a. government) that forgot
about them a long time ago, they just had to survive their own way. They didn't know any other
way.
Unfortunately, they didn't have the power to make any decisions about their lives, their decisions
were ruled by a society that took their own path four decades ago, and being La Sierra one of the
poorest neighborhoods in Medellin, their opportunities to get ahead in life were minimal.
I can't deny that watching this show was upsetting, not only after facing a reality I didn't even
witness while living there, but by wondering about how many viewers will take the wrong perception
of Colombia by generalizing images like these as if they were happening in the rest of the country,
which is not true.
4/19/06
Millie
Bronx, New York
It is an unimaginable sitaution what these people have to face in Columbia. They were very raw but
real issues that happen. I was not aware that these things happen in Columbia. I trully think The
tree main chachter are not murders or thugs, perhaphs they want respect. or Prestigae. Maybe they
follow in the paths of their parents. They don't know any better. I assume it must be horrible to
have to go through these streets and not know when you will get shot. I did not notice they had a
empathy for the children look at the lady laying dead in the ground the morning after. Edison seemed
to be very confused and why have so many young pregnant girls. Is there need for the Ego of having
so many woman. It is obivious he was a disturbed individual who trully cared only to kill and not
give a demn about what would be of all these children he would leave behind. It seems as this is the
only path but I am pretty sure they knew in the long run they would loss this battel. All the young
mothers seem to be so numbed and care free about life. It is tormanting tosee the only ones who are
inflictted and suffer obviously are the children, however it is clear they grow immune to this life
style. making them vulnarable to become the next gun man shooting in the air not knowing what they
trully believe in or what the cause really is.
4/19/06
Luis Vassallo
Phoenix, AZ
What is the root cause of all this? Drug money making a bad situation worse. Throw illegal money
into an area where people are struggling to survive, and you'll debase everyone. Life, morals,
values will be perverted.
The lack of context in your film is bound make uninformed people to get a very biased view of
Colombians. (Or confirm the wrong perceptions the media has already planted in their minds). You
could have filmed a similar situation in many countries, including developed ones and make viewers
conclude that they are witnessing a hopeless society.
Good effort, poor result.
4/19/06
Colorado Springs
Although disturbing to watch, I was compelled to try to understand something so different from my
own world.
I'm not that familiar with what goes on in Columbia, but that it is in a volatile state. There is
always hope, it's really sad that the life of war is all some of the young men ever knew.
4/19/06
Rosetta
i just watched the "independent lens" doc. i can't believe how it ended1 even though i don't know
these people my heart goes out to the young ladies who have or will have children by Edison! Also to
cielo, the young lady who's just trien to make it and have a better life for her and her baby. i
wish there was something i could do to help them. i will keep them in my prayers, i hope they will
be blessed with peace and happiness. please keep me updated on life in La Sierra. Thank you i really
enjoyed watching your documentary, i felt like i was right there. keep doing what you do, you're
great at it.
4/19/06
mesquites Texas
Hi that films is very touching and i really appreciates u guys , to really go in there and films
them that is really impresing. However Edison is really a brave Man all want for his community is
peace but he can do that and all his children what do u thinks there lives will be , i hope in
future they should not follow the footsteps o fthre fahter and all the mothers of those childrens
should steps up make sure that those children will be the most happiest thing and that country
should find something to do for there community and there children which eventually Edison did not
see them growing up i hope they will become something good in the lifes that Edison left behind. and
i know whenver those childrens are growing up and he will looks down on those Kids and hope
everything turns up for the kids....
Watching this show really help me and also enlightens because all they ever wanted is people to see
what they are going through and the Governments should really do something good in that community..
This films very sad because of Edison who all he wanted for his community to be safe and all the
kids should have somthing to call theirs when they grow up But i guess he never see the days .
PLEASE EVERY SHOULD MAKE PEACE WITH EACH OTHERS. MAY HIS SOUL REST IN PEACE AND ALL THE KIDS HE LEFT
BEHINDS.
4/19/06
This film present as if Colombia was all about a war.
The young kids that are on the film is the cause of poverty and not one to guide them. Sure they
talk about they want to change but they do not have the power to make a better choices. it is sad to
see these poor kids are the one that pay the price of this war. Because if you were to do a film of
the the upper middle class or the upper class in Colombia, you won't see they taken part of this
war. By the way Colombia is not all about war.
4/19/06
robert jones
west palm beach, florida
this documentary touched me so in many ways, as a young man the similar ways of me and edison were
identical until i went to prison to actually find myself and realize that i was fighting a losing
battle on the streets of w.p.b there is only a couple ways out of the streets of w.p.b and that is
in jail for 25 yrs to life or death in the streets or dying with aids. this story of life was as
real of a film that i had ever seen
4/19/06
Absolutely compelling, touching, and moving. It is the reality that is lived each and everyday in
the lower class neighborhoods in Colombia. Furthermore, the outskirts of major cities have also
being affected in the same degree. Overall, I think this film shows the reality that exits, and the
fact that Colombians want to change for the good and are in constant search for new and improved
horizon. Thank you for putting this film together.
4/19/06
delray beach fla
Oh my God! I coulnd't believe my eyes!
it has been 25 years since We moved the family in USA and I got disconnected from the every day
affairs of colombia, particularly Medellin, the city where I was born,growing up there I never heard
of anything like that.I watched with and incredible feeling of shame and sadness to see what is the
future of all those young girls.Is there a way to help them?.Can You show us the fans of PBS next
time the other side of colombia?I am going to cartagena next month on vacation with my daughter and
I like her to have better memories of a positive Colombia.
|
|
|
