 |
|
|
|
Tell us what you think.
Selected submissions will be posted here, so check back regularly.
Find out about the recent passage of an important bill that has reformed South Carolina parole board practices. Read an update from Joanna Katz >>
04/23/2009
Lorraine A. Corso
My daughter was a victim of molestation & rape during my marriage to my 2nd Ex-husband.
He never got charged and has been living his life free.
My daughter is still traumatized and so am I.
What do we do when we can't get a Justice system to do it's job?
The most I have been able to do is to have my story in print in newspapers and the internet.
I don't see why criminals need rights-they rape, murder, torture, rob innocent people of so much!!!!!
You are amazing Joanna! I hope you read this and somehow get in touch with me.
Lorraine
12/27/05
Heather L. Harris
Charleston, SC
We went to the same high school. You were one of the very few "cool" kids who were nice to me.(Yes, this is my most powerful memory of you in high school-you were nice to me in front of other jerks/kids who practically spit upon my nerdiness.) When your assault occurred in 1988, I did hear the abridged version. I was traveling amongst college in FL,moms in Chas.,and my father(stranger)in Alabama. Sometimes,I went to the club that you were leaving that night in '88.(the next summer, I DJ-ed at the same location.I did not know what happened to you and your friend, nor that the hell occured within yards of where I thought nothing of staggering about at 5am inthe parking lot.)
9/9/05
Kerri O'Kane
Los Angeles California
This is a very brilliant and necessary film. It is egregious to think that in today's day and age women are still treated like 2nd or 3rd class citizens. If rape and crime against men happened as often as it happens to women then paroling these less-than-human scums wouldn't even be an issue. I, too, have made a feature documentary about a semi-famous punk rock singer named Mia Zapata who was raped and murdered while walking home one night in Seattle. A year after starting the film, DNA caught the individual in Florida who was a known predator of women. I went to the sentencing of this "man" who tortured and strangled this young woman. The laws exist that he could get no more than 25 years without "proven" pre-meditation. Well, my producer and I put together a 10 minute piece about Mia Zapata and her band, The Gits and the impact her loss had on the community. The judge gives the guy and extra 10 years--36.6 years to be exact. This was last year. Present day brings us to the appeals courts and a "NEW SENTENCING" for this rapist/murder and now there is a new hearing to decide whether Mia's life was worth sentencing this "poor man" an extra 10 years. We will show our 10 minute piece again and we will encourage other surviving victims to come forward. Your film helps to bring community and a needed awareness to outdated and unfair laws that protect these heinous criminals and, like your film describes, sentences the victims. God has blessed you.
5/6/05
I think this is a real shame that this family that surley misses their daughter has to send this petition out every year. The parole system should change to every five years not every year.
1/28/05
Dawn Ridge
Yemassee, SC
My Hair Goddess!!
I am sorry to say that I did not know about your film until I stumbled across it online. I am living in Yemassee now, and ironically am a Correctional Officer for SCDC. I do keep in touch with Linda T. and would love to see your film. I know how long and hard a journey this has been for you, but I am proud to know you and see that you completed the film. I am desparately trying to move back into the area, but there aren't that many Victim Advocate's positions available right now. I do hope you read this and email me.
Miss seeing you,
Dawn
11/24/04
Palm Harbor Florida
I have known Joanna for a long time and have not been able to reach her since those horrible days. Knowing what she went through and knowing how far she has come along, makes me feel very proud that I know her. Joanna, if you read this please know, that my thoughts and prays have always been with you. And I am so sorry that we have lost touch, and am so sorry I wasn't there on time to protect you. I would have. You've always been a hero to me.
11/2/04
Jami Tatlock
Fredericton, New Brunswick
I am a student at a Canadian university and as a topic of discussion in my criminology class, we watched "Sentencing The Victim". I couldn't believe Joanna's amazing story of courage. You could hear a pin drop in the classroom. It's amazing how she went through such a horrific experience and yet is strong enough to continue fighting against crimes of rape and sexual assault. Joanna is an incredible person to be able to share her story with the whole nation and not be collapsing into tears. The only part where she got emotional was where she was talking about how it would hurt her mother. I would never be able to be as strong as she is. Joanna's story affected me deeply, as it did our entire class, and I will be remembering it for a very long time.
10/29/04
Glenn Bruder
Minneapolis, MN
A few nights ago while channel surfing before going to bed I stumbled across your documentary. That night I went to bed much later than I planned; I was transfixed as Joanna described her horrific experience. I was also singularly impressed by Joanna's determination and resolve. Every victim's story is different but Joanna is strikingly articulate and heroic. I cannot adequately express my admiration for her.
I was also struck by the supportive character of those around Joanna. Here mother and father should be role models for any parent whose child is unfortunate enough to suffer a similar tragedy. Today attorneys, rightly or wrongly, are blamed for many of society's ills. However, the prosecutor in this case steadfastly supported Joanna and her family and met the ideals to which all attorneys should aspire.
As a criminal defense attorney I am obligated to zealously defend my clients. This does not require gratuitously inflicting additional pain on victims after the defendants guilt has been established. The continuing cycle of parole hearings in this case could have been avoided if South Carolina adopted a determinate sentencing scheme currently employed in many states and in the federal justice system. In that type of sentencing arrangement both the defendant and victim know exactly how long he/she will serve at the time of sentencing.
10/25/04
Leo Stawicki
Greenwich, CT
Hello brave one.
I am just checking in to let you know you are in my prayers. May every day bring you a wave of warmth and love from all that is around you.
It is quite remarkable to consider all the bad done to you, in contrast with all the good you have done for so many others.
Your inner strength can not be measured.
So fortunate are those who know you. May the up coming holiday season find you and your family at peace with yourselves.
Your Friend and supporter,
Leo.
10/15/04
Jonestown Texas
I know exactly what the victum is going thru, and I admire her for her fortitude. The criminal "justice" system needs a complete over haul. This is not the ONLY system that needs it. The CIVIL COURTS need one also. Both of these entities are costing we tax payers money in more ways than one. These FRIVILOUS law suits are like the plague.There are jail trained lawyers that stalk innocent victums to extracate your money or property from you. If you are from out-of-state, these suits are hard to fight. When traveling, BEWARE to whom you befriend. I fell into that slot, and this LEGAL PREDATOR is trying to separate me from my life's savings. Even as I draw Social Security, I have managed to save, but not for long. RW
10/15/04
Michelle
I too was glued to the TV when I found this program after surfing for something to watch. I have a good friend who was drugged & raped but 2 men. I took her to the hospital & witnessed the devastating affect this had on her. She did come forward & press charges.
It has been about 5-6 years now. 1 of the men is about to go back to jail (He was let out from his 18-24 year sentence briefly on a technicality). The other is awaiting trial on her rape & the rape of several other women. Her courage has inspired me greatly. But, I have also witnessed firsthand how my friend has suffered over the years. Waiting to go to trial, the trial itself, living in a small town, etc... When the 1st man was let out of prison, I was outraged!! Here he was, walking the streets again. He got a job, vacationed and was free!! I listened to my friend sob for 50 minutes on the phone that day. I couldn't even understand her at times. She has been living in a virtual prison during the pre-trial and trial years. Her life was/is under a microscope - lawyers have even tried to subpoena her therapists records - these people disgust me as much as the 2 men. I couldn't have been happier to hear that his appeal was rejected and he is going back to prison to serve his sentence - his brief fling with freedom snatched away. I tell my friend all the time how proud I am of her and how proud she should be of herself. She has more strength than she ever knew and probably saved more women from these 2 men. When the 2nd man finally goes to trial & is sentenced, I hope she can finally find peace & happiness in her life. She can stop feeling like she is always looking over her shoulder in fear.
I am thankful for women like Joanna Katz & my friend. They are heroes. I'd like to give Joanna a HUGE hug... and thank her.
10/15/04
Leo Stawicki
Greenwich, CT
Joanna,
You,dear lady, are indeed an inspiration.....as are your family and friends...So much courage, so much spirit....The film was made in such a way, as to bring the viewer deeper into the horror of the story, and your incredible survival, than could be attained through any "news story".
I must ask ,however, ...You went along with the plea bargains which did not inclued the kidnapping charges, to avoid (understandably) reliving the nightmare over and over.......But, is that not what happened anyway?..With all the parole hearings you had to endure?
With all due respect....I was curious as to whether you (in hindsight) wish you had gone through the trials...which would have brought longer sentences (even life) to the monsters you faced?
You are such a strong, beautiful woman, and I hope you can remain so, in the years to come.
GOD BLESS
Leo.
10/15/04
Phil Gardiner
Stamford, CT
How does one reconcile his/her life with God? How do we find the courage to face the horrorific? When all seems lost, what compels us to go on? What is awakened in these moments and how can we awaken them more often, perhaps with less "agitation"?
Joanna- I do not KNOW you but I feel that you're a beautiful human being with all the strength of spirit and clarity of purpose of a spiritual warrior. Through the telling of your story you provide some answers to these questions for those who are suffering and in need of comfort as well as those of us who are sensitive to and aware of sexual abuse/violence and the impact it has on our lives and the lives of those we love. As an artist/actor of sorts myself, I can't help but notice the world from the perspective of an observer. Your observations are compelling and rise above the ordinary in a way that not only captures our attention but moves our hearts. God Bless You. And God Bless Liz for her vision and role in allowing your soul a little breathing room. And God Bless all the other souls who have shared will continue to share the healing journey with you.
Peace and good things Joanna,
Phil
PS Your handling of the Judicial Board is a lesson for all of us who deal with resentments and frustration on a daily basis. Congratulations on the changes your work has accomplished.
9/14/04
Lola
Los Angeles CA
First, thank you Joanna Katz from the bottom of my heart and soul. I was mermerized by your story, by the great documentary, and by your courage. God Bless.
My thoughts on the justice system: I think a great way of healing both the victim and the perpertrator, is for them work together in some way. Have rape victims talk to rapists. Have it be part of their daily lives in prison. Make videos of victims willing to share their story. The few programs I have seen regarding this type of 'therapy' seems to help heal both parties. Of course, the victim comes first and is the most egreged; and must be given the most respect and care. I have seen a few such programs on film, and in the ones where the victims of rapists, or the relatives/friends of murdered, tell their story, it does seem to affect and open up some of the perpetrators. I think it's the seeing the actual victims (whether 'their' victims or not) and being exposed to the reality of how what they did affects their victims lives so wholly and thoroughly, that seems to bring out their humanity. Even seeing the depth of the rage such an attack would bring could be healing for both. Of course, not all perps are going to be open/sane/wise enough, etc. to be able to benefit from such a program, but I've seen miracles occur. And probably few victims would opt to do this type of work. I can't imagine any victim ever wanting to face their perps in any setting. No one should have to do what I am suggesting, it's just that the few programs I've seen about it over time have seemed to be so dramatically healing for both sides, I just wish it could be incorporated more into our judicial system.
I absolutely believe that Joanna (and her parents) are the excpetion to the rule that: most women never even tell. If it happens when they are children they are even more unlikely to tell (that's another story). There is so much shame, and fear of judgement. That is why it's so important that Joanna, and any others able to, talk out loud and long about their stories. But coming forward doesn't always have to mean pressing charges, bringing a case. You can find support and just 'come out' that way, if you don't choose to go the 'justice' system route. But victims need to come out to heal themselves, regardless. Holding it inside it festers, whether one is in denial about that or not, it doesn't go away of it's own accord, unfortunately. Thank you for sharing your story. You are helping to heal more people than you know. Lola
9/7/04
Mike Spence
Lancaster, Ca
Just finished watching this amazing documentary. All I can say is that I hang my head in shame to call myself an American. Is there no chivalry left? We let maggots like this rape and torture women and children and what do we do? We put them up in an air conditioned room with three hots a day so they can lift weights and catch up on their television shows. Then we let them back into their hunting grounds after serving only half their sentence! All the while putting the poor victims through hell on earth. We used to hang creeps like these.I won't expound on what I would do with them.
8/27/04
David Varner
Phillipsburg NJ
I just viewed this remarkable video last night. I cried for the victim, I loathed the parole board attempts to be empathetic, and I rejoiced at Joanna's advocacy work.
Bravo!
8/11/04
Tracy Kennedy
North Carolina
I am writing to say that I had the honor to not just view this incredible film but also meet and spend time with Joanna. I have been working with victims/survivors for over 12 years and have never met such a strong and grounded person in my career. Joanna is a true example of how a survivor can be driven to make change without having the crime control her entire life. Her boundaries are defined and healthy. Joanna has worked very hard to change laws and struggled to create a healthy life for herself. I am forever changed by my time spent with Joanna. Joanna, you are an inspiration to anyone that views this film and those few that meet you. Thank you for showing me what one person's drive can achieve with the right support. You are "My hero!" Tracy K.
8/11/04
Wayne Uber
Chapel Hill, NC
I viewed the film for the first time last week at a (NCVAN) conference for victims. Unfortunately I was not able to speak with Joanna Katz after she spoke to us. This was not due to lack of effort on her part. More than a few of us were simply frozen by the feelings the film left us with. If a person could watch a film such as "Sentencing the Victim" without feeling something very deeply, they'd have to be dead. Joanna's story is graphic, emotional and heart wrenching.
Ms. Katz has turned her victimization into something positive. She's reminded others about what other things we all have to be thankful for. Victims of violent crime endure many long term injuries but she is living proof that the predators do not always extinguish what is good about us if we don't let them.
The things that made her a beautiful person before she became a victim are just as relevant and wonderful as they are now. Ms. Katz has demonstrated her strength and character by focusing efforts on constructive ways and means that will not only help her with the problems she has faced in the criminal justice system, but will benefit others that will endure many of the same problems that she has experienced.
It is my hope that future airings of the film will result in more awareness of the issues that affect many other victims of violent crime. Our legislators and state officials need to be reminded on occassion that they are working with real persons and that attention needs to be given to individuals (each and every victim) and that this is more just a job or a process to maintain.
Everyone should request that their local legislators view this film.
8/9/04
Ashley Evans
Smithfield, North Carolina
I was extremely fortunate to see this riviting documentary at the North Carolina Victim Assistance Network Conference held 8-4-04 thru 8-6-04 in Greenville North Carolina. I am a Victim Advocate for the Division of Community Corrections in North Carolina. I am so lucky to have personnally met Ms. Katz, and I am truly inspired by Ms. Katz as are my coworkers within my division.
I have worked as a probation/parole officer since 1989, and in 2000, I was given the opportunity to work as the victim advocate in my judicial district. I have always felt that the victim's of crime are not given the opportunity to have their voices heard.The "system" is not geared to handle the concerns and needs of the victim. Every citizen in the United States should have to spend a month attending superior court sessions, district Court sessions, and probation violation hearings so as to ascertain what does occur within our judical system. You will be very surprised at what you will see and hear.We need to educate ourselves about OUR Judicial system and if we have ideas, inspirations, that can help lead to the neceessary changes in OUR systems, it is up to US to do something about it instead of sitting down and hoping someone else with some GUTS will do what we need to do ourselves. If Ms. Katz's story has made any impact on your life let it be one of action and involvement in our communities to further the RIGHTS OF CRIME VICTIMS.
I will keep you and your family in my prayers. God Bless.
8/9/04
Melissa Reed
Asheville, North Carolina
I am a Victim Advocate with The NC Dept. of Corrections and today I had the awesome privelage of viewing this film and meeting Joanna Katz in person. Can you imagine viewing this amazing video and being awestruck by it and then realizing that the very woman who inspired it is stepping up to the podium to speak. Talk about one of the most important days in my career! My life is forever changed. I truly believed I was 100% committed to my victims before today, but now I know that I am 110% devoted to them and to the protection of their rights. I am still in awe of Joanna and her story...all I can say is thank God for you Joanna - your strength, your courage, your hope, your passion - thank God for you....
8/4/04
Jenny Miller
Tacoma Washington
I am sorry to inform: one of the women who responded to your film here on Talkback, couldn't take anymore:
Rape victim ends her struggle
Beaufort Gazette, SC
Jul 19, 2004
http://www.beaufortgazette.com/local_news/story/3697053p-3303438c.html
Here is her post here on Talkback:
3/3/04
jacquelyn cooper moore
hilton head island, south
Joanna Katz has the spirit of a warrior, the face of an angel, eyes that have seen evil, and a mind that will never escape.
This is the most moving film I have ever seen.
I see in this film the God's honest truth. I only hope society will open thier eyes and face the reality of the injustice of the "justice system".
As a 63 year old victim, I face endless appeals and trials. The appeals will never end until either the sexual predator or I die.
Which ever comes first.
Love to everyone connected to this project and a huge hug for Joanna's parents.
Sincerely,
Jacque Moore
http://www.pbs.org/independentlens/sentencingthevictim/talkback3.html
6/25/04
jr
Even though it's been a while since we saw your program, your story of courage remains with me and my friends. During dinner with one of my "support" groups of friends last week, we were discussing your program. Someone had noticed that it was around the anniversary date of your terrible night of horror. My only niece was born last week, and I said that with every bad memory in someone's life comes a good day of memories for someone else. I thought about your family support group and hope you still have your parents with you in good health. I lost my father two years ago and can't imagine what you would go through after having them as your rock for so many years.
I may be mistaken, but I believe I noticed on your police statement that your birthday was right after your attack. I cannot fathom having a happy occasion such as that continually clouded by the horrible memories that must precede that week. Even though you are probably sick of this show and attention by now, we hope that you or a spokesperson might add a comment to the show's website or comment field to let people know how you and your family are doing. We'd also like to know the parole status update of the animals who victimized you. I hope your film continues to gain more national attention and, therefore, spreads even more encouragement to victims. I wish you, your parents and Julie peace and happiness, and thank you again for sharing your story and courage.
5/26/04
KD
Canada
Joanna,
Wow. One word, brave! My husband and I watched the film and were in complete silence during its entirety. We were so moved by your horrific story. I went straight to my computer to find out more information. I just wanted to say that you are so strong and you should be so proud for what you've done for yourself and for so many other women. Your strength and courage and will resonate with me always.
5/13/04
Maria
Orlando, FL
I stayed late last night watching your film on Joanna Katz and I cried with her. Joanna, you are everybody's daughter: Young, beautiful full of life. What happened to you and your friend is something that should not happen in a great country like ours. This is every woman's and every parent's nightmare.
Joanna you are a great human being and you are to be commended for doing this film.
It is very sad, that there are human beings like the perpetrators on this earth.
May God bless you Joanna.
5/13/04
john h. born
clermont fla.
DEAR MISS KATZ, YOUR STORY 'TRADGEDEY' TOUCHED ME DEEPLY. MY DEAR GIRLFRIEND WAS MURDERED WHEN SHE WAS ONLY 17. ALTHOUGH IT WAS 44 YRS. AGO, IT STILL IS A HEAVEY BURDEN TO CARRY. YOU'VE HELPED ME. THANK YOU FOR YOUR WORK,AND COURAGE, AND INSPERATION! I'M RETIRED WITH FREEDOM TO DO ANYTHING ANYPLACE. IF YOU EVER HAVE NEED OF A FREE BODYGAURD, I'M AT YOUR BECKON CALL!!! SINCERELY JOHN H. BORN ecadjuster@earthlink.net
5/13/04
Juli Lewis
20 years ago I awakened to find a man in my bedroom and on top of me. I grabbed the gun from under my pillow and shot him. Unfortunatley, he did not die, and I had to survive a trial, phone calls from jail and him arriving at my door step when he was released. Again, my gun became my best friend. I was lucky. very, very lucky but even though I was never raped, I still live in fear. I can not forget that night. I can close my eyes and see the scenes unfolding. I am so lucky I did not live through the hell these woman lived through but I can understand it.
I have fear - just from an ordeal that had no physcial contact. I can not imagine living through that hell.
I still sleep with my gun at my bedside - and a gun in my car - and one in my office. I keep to myself and try to be so aware of who is around me. It is so hard to shake the past.
5/7/04
Coatesville, PA
The film on Joanna and Julie was a revelation to me. I was a victim of
rape 29 years ago. There isn't a week that doesn't go by that I don't
think about it. It has changed me forever. It took me 15 years just to
get into therapy for it. I never reported it. Never even spoke of it to
anyone for 15 years! I thought it was my fault. I had ZERO self-esteem
for years afterward. To see what Joanna has endured changed me the night
I saw the film. I felt she was giving voice to my silence. Thank you,
Joanna, for doing something for me that I am not strong enough to do for
myself.
5/3/04
J.Z.
Manitoba, Canada
Joanna,
I commend you, thank you and may God bless you for your courage and strength, as well as your parents.
Your story has awakened me on so many levels; how strong one woman can be and has to be to survive. It has also sounded off alarms on how the justice system works in North America. It is most likely that the same sentences would have been given here in Canada - max out dates and all. As for The Parole Board, how extremely unreal?? I wonder if they read any of the cases -I was apalled to hear this was to be "theruptic" for you AND asking why the sentences were the way they were -
You have triumphed against ALL the odds -continue to conquer!! It is truly an honour to have you out there.
All the very best.
5/3/04
lj bainbridge
i'am a disabled police officer (injured in the line of duty). i worked major crimes for years and there are so many victims to violent crimes (besides the victims themselves) i still have nightmares. i applaud joanna and her family for standing tall after this horrendous crime. i'm also glad the pendulum is swinging towards the victims where it should have been in the first place. Great job!
5/3/04
Lorraine
Fresno. Ca.
Never, never, never have I gone straight from the television to the copmputer. There is nothing more that I can add or say that hasn't already been mentioned. Nevertheless, I feel compelled to add my voice and name to the growing list of those who stand in awe of this wonderful example of someone who is to be held in the highest regard. Please know that you have made a positive impact on many many lives, and through this film will continue to help and heal. We are blessed that you have undertaken this task. I am greatful. Thank you, Lorraine
4/27/04
Marcia H.
Clarkston, WA
Hello,
I watched this documentary last night and was moved beyond words-so much so I had to look for this website to respond as I could not stop thinking about Ms. Katz and her friend Julie.
What a truly brave and unselfish thing Joanna has done by allowing her real life nightmare to be told in hopes that others will not have to experience the same horrors. Not only the horror of the attack but the horror of the repeated trips to the parole board hearings. The victim gets victimized over and over again while the criminals get 3 squares a day with free medical care, a roof, etc. Doesn't make a lot of sense.....
I just want to add that I am in awe of Joanna's strength. She is an inspiration to all women and I pray that she and her amazing parents find some sort of peace in their lives-Julie also.
I truly believe that if more people like Joanna, Julie and Liz came forward, that more lawmakers would be "forced" to do something more to help the victim. We as a nation should not allow women or any vulnerable population to be offended against and then subject them repeatedly to re-offence just because "that is the way the law is written." Sounds like it is based on convenience to me, the convenience of the parole board. I say, change the law!!!!!! Make the laws more victim friendly. They are in place to protect the innocent, correct?
4/20/04
Kathleen M. Dreyer
I actually saw this film several weeks ago but have not stopped thinking about Joanna. Joanna, you are a truly incredible and courageous woman. Thank you for sharing your story and allowing others to be inspired by you. I think about you and your parents often. I pray that everyday you and family find love, joy and peace.
Thank you
K. Dreyer
4/12/04
M Crane
Dear Joanna,
You are the most incredible woman ever! Your inspiration goes beyond mere words. Your strength, grace and courage all exceed any point of reference. The telling of your experience shook me very deeply. So much so, I had to write someone somewhere to express myself, and I don't really do that kind of thing. I'm at a complete loss as to how these men could be as void of empathy as to have done what they did to you. And for that matter, I'm at loss as to the reaction from some of the members of the parole board as well! You are light in the midst of all that darkness, and speaking as a man, you are a beautiful as well. I wish for you all the happiness and peace that life has to offer within us all.
Thank you so very much for being you.
4/6/04
J. Durfee
Buffalo, NY
My heart broke as I watched this PBS documentary. Joanna's ordeal is
every woman's nightmare. As much as anything, her anguish when she looked
at herself in the mirror for the first time after her rescue, and realized
that her mother would see her this way, was what did me in. This is
exactly how I too would feel, I have no doubt of it. I feel humbled in
the knowledge that she has had such wonderful parents to support her these
past 15 years, and question whether I could possibly be so devoted should
anything so dreadful happen to my daughter. It is the fear that this
might happen to a child of mine that is almost worse than the fear it
might ever happen to me. I would like to know if Joanna Katz is really
doing well in life now; can she cope, can she be happy, can she ever
really put such an event behind her. Some years ago a teenage niece of
mine was raped -- my sister never speaks of it, I have never been
officially told of the incident, and I have no idea how my niece is doing.
My heart bleeds for women who have been violated in this way. Is there really any punishment for men who do this? Do we really ever believe they can be rehabilitated and should be put back in society. God help us all. Joanna Katz, you are a hero to all, I hope you are doing well.
4/5/04
James.L
toronto ont
I just seen Joanna,s program and i am disgusted that these scum of the
earth only recieved the sentences they did.
The lawmakers of that state should hang thier heads low in disgust for
not having a harsher penalty in place for these crimes.From what i saw and
heard on this program the sentence should life with no perole.
I would just like to tell joanna that ive never seen a more stronger
person in my life,u show women of rape that it is ok to come forward and
speek out,you are a (HERO).Your are also a beutiful person in side and
out,u will always be in our prayers.
4/5/04
Dawn Campbell
Hamilton, Ontario
Thank you Joanna Katz and Liz Oakley.
I am literally at a loss for words. I cannot remember the last time I was
moved so emotionally.
I too am a victim of incest and sexual assault. I remember telling my
mother about the incest and all she said was that she knew. I felt numb.
She did nothing. I don't remember much as I was very young (6yrs and again
when I was 11), however clues surface through flashbacks and in dreams
when I sleep. I am never at peace! Sometimes its a struggle to wake up and
actually get out of bed and function.
There was one part of the film I found truly disturbing....when Joanna
shook the parole board members hands and the woman at the head of the
table said to Joanna "sorry for the circumstances that brought you
here...and I hope you get over it..." I thought I was going to be
physically sick. A crime of this nature is not something you "get over"
and thought it was a slap in Joanna's face.
Joanna thank you for your courage, honesty and class. Your parents are a
rarity and a gift.
Again thank you,
D.Campbell
4/5/04
Donald Campbell
After watching this documentary this evening. I was both outraged and
uplifted.
I was outraged at the thought that this beautiful young woman has been
put through this ordeal time and time again. The fact that one of these
mad animals is already out of prison is a black mark against the American
justice system. I am a Canadian and know that our justice system is as bad
or even worse, so I am not condemning the American justice system alone.
The other thing which enraged me was the very short cut near the end of
the film where the camera was still in the room at the end of the parole
hearing and the head of the board says something along the lines of "He
(Mr. Sullivan)isn't going to come in here and tell us how to run this
board." This is not a direct a direct quote. I believe that this is an
indication of why it is so hard to change any system, because of stiff
backed middle level bueaucrats with to much power.
Ms.Katz is the most amazing person I have ever seen.
I agree Mr.
Sullivan, hero is definitely not to strong a word. The strength she showed and continues to show is amazing. I only hope that sometime I get to hear her speak and shake her hand and tell her what a courageous person she is. Thank you Ms. Katz for what are doing for other women
4/5/04
John Mafnas
San Diego, CA
I was watching sports on television and was starting to fall asleep.
Before shutting it off, I started flipping channels. And that's when I ran
into -I say that because it hit me like a Mac truck- "Sentencing the
Victim," one of the most gripping, powerful and tragic stories I've ever
seen or heard.
Joanna, I hope you read this and realize that you are truly heroic, not
simply because you survived such a horendously, brutal attack by five
cowards, but because you give of yourself and provide hope and strength to
other victims by allowing your story to be told and by returning every
year and subjecting yourself to the emotional torture of reliving the
nightmare in order to keep these maggots from victimizing anyone else.
I will take inspiration from you and I will offer my prayers for you and
your terrific parents to find peace and happiness in every aspect of your
lives.
4/5/04
San Diego, CA
This country needs Joanna Katz to stand up for victims. When I reported
my rape at age 13 no one believed me. And to this day it never been
reported and I have to live with it. Change is slow but it is so
important that laws and people's ideas about abuse and abusers change.
Never give up Joanna! You have many supporters!
4/5/04
Melissa Bykowski
Ferndale, Michigan
Joanna, you have assisted others by what I would term as being a Teacher,
in brining us in to your world, so we can work to bring about change in
our legal system. Thank you.
4/5/04
Margaret
Buffalo, NY
It's the middle of the night and I have just finished watching your
documentary. It was awesome. Joanna your courage is speaks volumes to
all of us who have been victims of rape. I too believe that this
documentary should be shown during prime time. It sends a message that
our generation and our justice system should see and hear. Joanna, I will
pray for you and Julie and God Bless Liz Oakley for bringing such a moving
piece to film.
4/5/04
c williams
poway, ca
I sit here tonite and read of the many who "just happened to be surfing
the channels"...and I join their league. This was an incredible
experience...nearly as moving as "The Passion of The Christ". As the
story was told I found pictures of what the torture might have been
like...and yet..I am sure not even close to the actual experience. The
Bible says that Jesus was not even recognizable after his
torture...Joanna's emotional "body" would not be recognizable either.
The anger I have towards the vermin that did this horrible thing is
almost as much as the "judicial review parole board" that continued the
rape through the proceeding they forced her to endure just to keep some
type of peace of mind. And that peace was minimal at best. And her dear
parents? The Attorney?...what about the rape they endured by the forcing
of their emotions, mental strength and physical wellness to be drained
while thier pius conclusion come to a point?
I was truly sickened when one of the panel and a woman no less, tri
ed to trivialize this horrifying event by deciding it could be
"theraputic"?...How can reliving the torture every 6 months help?...And
what about the last "presiding" board member, ALSO a woman...becoming
indignant when the attorney tried to relay the frustration of YEARS of
doing the "motions" to protect themselves?...I would LOVE to have HER NAME
so that she could receive her due backlash for being so crass and
insensitive!!! To "rant and rave about OUR PROCESS"...WHAT ARROGANCE!!...
What must be done to remove such idiots from positions of authority?
Then again...the "questioning" of Joanna in regards to "why" any of these
animals were allowed to "bargain" their pleas? I don't remember the film
saying Joanna attended law school!!
I am disgusted and yet... so thankful to see such courage and hope to
come from someone who has had so much ripped away.
Many blessings to you, Joanna and you your loving,
strong parents....I
wish I could have had a mother like yours.
Lord bless...keep fighting the good
fight!!
4/5/04
Vancouver, Canada
I echo every word of admiration voiced here for Joanna and her steadfast
parents, for Julie, PAR, the DA, sensitive police officers and not least
for Liz Oakley: heroes all. And I echo every word of condemnation directed
at the five pieces of slime who attacked these women, and at the smug SC
parole board ? I'd love to have 10 minutes to speak to that particularly
ignorant and self-righteous chairwoman.
Renowned psychiatrist Dr. Viktor E. Frankl in Man's Search for Meaning
and his other books says meaning is unique, transmitted to our
consciousness by our personal conscience. As the guy who coined the term
"existential," Frankl says we are each responsible for fulfilling the
meaning of our lives, and "the answer to the question, What is the meaning
of life?, can only be given out of one's whole being ? one's life is
itself the answer to the question of its meaning..." He says the meaning
of life may be found in creating a work or doing a deed, in encountering
someone, in experiencing something, or in the
way in which we stand up to suffering. And he says repeatedly that meaning
must be found by each of us; it cannot be given to us by anyone else.
I'd say Joanna and her parents know the meaning of life, and that
learning of their courage and principles and strength and endurance is of
assistance to many of us in our own quests. I say the same to all writers
here who have also survived brutality in word or deed yet feel they're not
as strong as Joanna: to me, you are.
Some say that with insight comes compassion. That's not a concept I can
grasp when it comes to people who to me embody evil. I'd include certain
lawmakers and parole board members in that category: They do great harm by their pious indifference.
To Rory, writing here: with respect, castration wouldn't do a thing to
protect women. As the documentary noted, this was a crime of power, using
sex as the instrument. Castration might in fact only add to these slugs'
sociopathic need to exercise "power." I'm liberal generally, but not in
all things: I'd vote for the death penalty for rapists.
As an aside, may I say that I am often appalled by some Americans' views.
It's wonderful to be reminded that many of you are much closer to my idea
of good, caring people. I also thank PBS for giving us this forum.
4/5/04
Toronto, Ontario Canada
To Joanna Katz and her family,
You shared your horrific story with such honesty and bravery. I thank you
for this, and all the amazing work you are doing to change the system. I
wonder about the 'three strikes and you are out' system? I recently heard
a young man was sentened to life in prison for stealing a bicycle. His
other two crimes were of a nonviolent nature. How is it he gets life,
while you have to attend all these parole hearings for the most violent
crime? I just do not understand the system. I hope you receive continued
support, you and your family will be in my prayers.
4/5/04
Lucy Harrison
Vancouver, BC Canada
I saw this documentary last night on a PBS station and sat there riveted
by this story. All I thought about during the whole film was what courage
it takes to go on living, with the effects of PTSD - and the journey, that
many who have not been through trauma, would not understand. There is so
much that is so difficult to express to people in regards to the journey
recovering from something like this - or other trauma takes (which was
eluded to in stories like Joanna being curled up under her desk for three
days). Even so, no one can really know the horror and pain one has to
face and the courage it takes to deal with it. No film can truly get
inside the mind and heart of a person - but this film came pretty damn
close! Hats of to Liz and Joanna for their commitment and hard work in
creating a film that has such a powerful impact in educating people not
only about state law, crime, rape, but more importantly the journey
victims have to face if they want to recover and heal.
I have read many of the
comments here on this message board and I whole-heartedly agree with most
of everything spoken. So I will just say this: having never been through
a nightmare like this, I cannot possibly know what Joanna's journey has
been like in her healing process, but I do know that my own, recovering
from major depression, anxiety, and PTSD has been brutal. And anyone
knows who has been through something like this - knows the courage it
takes to keep on living, but I mean -really living and making one's life
worthwhile and giving back, and making something positive come out of
something so heinous. I have the deepest compassion for you Joanna, and
the most incredible admiration for you to go on screen and be so
vulnerable and let people into your life in the name of healing, and
helping others, and working on creating change for those who cannot speak
up or have the energy to fight.
Words cannot express how moved I was watching this film, and the awe I
felt in watching you put yourself out there like that. I
am just starting theatre again, after many many years - and hope to find
it therapeutic - I think it's fantastic you have found a creative outlet
for yourself, I think art is a crucial piece in facilitating healing and
in allowing one to feel fully alive. Your story, your honesty, your
courage, your vulnerability, and your incredible strength Joanna made me
feel like I can get to that light at the end of the tunnel too. I will
never forget you - and this film. Prayer is so important, and you
reminded me once again the importance of praying and listening - as you
did - and clearly still do. Making sense out of this kind of brutality in
human beings I have always found impossible, but your story helped me to
see how to make more sense out of my own life and showed me once again,
that we are all connected on some level - those of us on the path of
healing. I wish you and your amazing family many blessings. Happy
Passover and Happy Easter.
4/5/04
Raymond P. Clark
Canton, MI
For Joanna:
The good news is that there are women like you in this world and I am
thankful for that. My heart has ached for you while watching the program
depicting your situtation. I truly believe in prayer and my wife and I
both will bring you before the Lord in our prayers. You are truly the
epitomy of strength, courage, integrity and honor. We ask the Lord to
continue standing by you and to uphold your faith. I am your parent's age
and I have often pondered whether I would have the ability to endure harm
that might come to my own children. For your involvment to maintain the
continued effort involving changes in the judicail system, I thank you. A
person like yourself gives great inspiration to others.
3/31/04
Andy Hamers
Redlands, CA
Like so many viewers who've submitted their comments, I, unfortunately tuned into this program when it was already more than half over. So it wasn't until near the end of the story that I realized this ordeal has been going on for more than FIFTEEN YEARS!
I can only conclude that Joanna Katz represents the very best definition of a SURVIVOR! She has been blessed with an awsome ability to share her experience in a way that can help other victims to avoid the enormous pain, suffering and frustration she has had to endure. I hope the knowledge of this fact will bring Ms, Katz some measure of comfort and peace. She certainly deserves it.
Great credit should also be given to Liz Oakley for her efforts and talent in putting this compelling story on film.
And for those of you who spent your words villifying the perpetrators and challenging a system that allows for the POSSIBILITY of redemption, I hope you will eventually realize that this is not a story about the bad guys but about a GOOD PERSON who, instead of wasting all her engergy on feelings of vengeance and hatred, has given her spirit to helping others. How much more rewarding this must be!
3/31/04
I have decided that Joanna is my hero. I have listened to a missionary speak to woman about sexual abuse. I personally have never experienced it. This missionary encouraged all of us woman to pray regularly that God would send angels to minister to woman who are being abused. It struck me when Joanna mentioned angels attending to her. This missionary specifically prayed for God to encouraged us to continue to pray this way. Listening to Joanna talk about this has given me an even stronger desire to pray for her and the many woman she represents. To thank woman like Joanna who have faught so hard to keep these men behind bars, so they will not do this again. Thank you Joanna.
3/31/04
Kerri O'Kane
Los Angeles, California
Last night I flew in from Seattle, Washington after attending a hearing about a brutal rape and murder of rising punk singer, Mia Zapata. The crime occurred in 1993 and remained unsolved until last year thanks to a swab of saliva and advanced DNA technology. I've been doing a documentary about Mia and her band for over two years. It was a miracle that they caught the "man" who did this after nearly a decade. It took a lot of media attention and persistance by Mia's friends. Thank you for your story and having the strength to tell it and keep the fight. It is not an easy place to be in life but in order to stop these heinous crimes against women - which I believe are hate crimes - people need to come forward and be heard. Unfortunately for Mia Zapata, because numerous other people did not come forward until the trial, this predator slipped through the cracks of the law and was found last year fishing off the Florida Keys enjoying his life with a rap sheet of crimes against women for over fifteen years.
We have to keep up the fight together. If these crimes happened to men the way they happen to women, I'm sure the boys would fraternize to protect those in THEIR club, I'm going to do everything I can to protect those in mine. Thanks Liz and thank you Joanna--thanks for making a difference.
Sincerely,
Kerri O'Kane
Knockout Productions
3/31/04
Los Angeles, CA
I was falling asleep last night and happened upon PBS and Liz Oakley's documentary. I stayed up through the end, and couldn't sleep for a bit afterwards. I was too appalled, disturbed, angered, and flabbergasted. Who in the world wrote the laws of the criminal justice system, and why are the laws not actively revised? How is it that even after one of the perpetrators flipped Joanna's father the bird in court, he qualifies for parole? What in the world are the minimum requirements for parole consideration anyway, and are these animals being considered for parole just because it's a legal formality or because they meet these minimum requirements? (If it's the former, the governor of South Carolina needs to get his head out of the sand.) Who determines whether the animals are fit to re-enter society? I find it extremely disturbing and infuriating that these animals even qualify for parole so frequently!
I have had a very tiny exposure to law, and not even criminal law. I can only imagine how impossible it is to change the system from within. There are countless mindless civil servants out there who blindly follow the law, who blindly do their jobs and tell victims to just get over it. And there are countless lawyers out there who are not passionate about seeking justice. I am at least glad that Joanna found someone like Jack Sinclaire, who was able to advocate for her passionately.
Joanna, you are so brave and so strong to change the system after the horror you have been through. You are forcing people to re-examine their attitude towards victims, their attitude of "just let it go," and "just get over it." It is SOOO necessary. I support you unconditionally, and I will be telling your story to as many people as possible, as often as possible. Hopefully in such a way I will be helping you change the system.
I was also very moved by your relationship with your parents, and by your concern for your parents. Even after all that happened to you, it was heartbreaking to know that you broke down in front of your mother because you were worried about SHE was feeling. That just speaks volumes about your character and compassion. Please know that your courage and determination and passion have inspired me to help you in your cause.
3/30/04
R. S.
Cincinnati, OH
I saw this documentary two nights ago and can't get it off my mind. I think about Joanna and wish I could tell her how much her courage has moved me and her story brought me to tears. It is unbelievable the insensitive jerks sitting on SC's parole board, and especially that woman who glibly said it's "therapeutic" for Joanna to keep re-appearing at every parole hearing!
WHAT IS WRONG WITH THE LAW, ALSO??? WHY ARE RAPISTS EVEN CONSIDERED FOR PAROLE??! THE LAWS HAVE GOT TO CHANGE! Anyone who rapes MUST receive a severe sentence, and NO, absolutely NO parole. Why is the "justice system" not firm on this issue? Incredible!
Those low-life scumbags sitting in prison, may they max out their entire 35-year sentences. Can't the law change where these pigs' "rights" to these bizarre parole hearings be nullified? These creeps HAVE NO RIGHTS. A sentence is a sentence. Parole for rape? Never!
Joanna, you are a hero. God bless you. I will never forget you.
3/29/04
N. F.
St. Louis Missouri
I thouhgt that "Sentencing the Victim" was an incredibly moving documentary, and I found it incredibly hard to watch. I watched it alone, and almost with a sense that I was doing something wrong in watching it, I am the product of a rape, and I now know what my other has gone through. I have always felt like my mother resented having me, and I obviously have no relationship with whomever my father may be. I think that this helped me peer behind instead of through the looking glass; through the hard protective covering that my other has put on. I ache for all women tht have bee placed in this type of situation, where they have no choice, they must give up something that is impossible to get back, their self respect; they can get it back, yes, but they have to get it back from themselves, and it is much harder to get back than a stolen piece of jewelry. I applaud Ms. Katz for her bravery, her courage, and her daring, and even her valor. She was a woman who was trampled, beaten, raped, psychologically abused, and completly downtrodden, yet she raised herself up enough to become a rape advocate. Good for you!
3/29/04
Carl W. Yates III
St. Louis, MO
I, too, like a poster below had a chance changing of the channels Sunday evening, 3/28/04. What a wonderful film. I am a lawyer practicing municipal law for the City of St. Louis, Missouri and while not versed in criminal law and/or probation or parole procedure have the greatest respect for Ms. Katz, what she went through and what she has done in making this film. This film should be standard viewing at all colleges and law schools in several disciplines. To Ms. Katz, keep on..keeping on. You have more courage than anyone I have ever seen. Any your parents....with a 4 year old daughter who is still to face life's many challenges, I only hope I can be as good a parent to her as your parents are to you. All three of you are an inspiration....each a gift from God to the other.
3/29/04
Todd Robinson
Malibu Calfornia
As a filmmaker myself I was deeply moved and impressed by this powerful work. Little, if any money is to be made in documentary filmmaking. Films such as this are fueled by love and passion. Clearly Liz Oakley has this fire in her belly not to mention a deep calling to justice. I am so glad that she and Joanna put this film out into the world.
To Joanna what can you say except that she embodies an incredible sense of courage and survival. Beyond that she continues to sacrifice on behalf of people she will probably never know. I was touched and inspired by her story, her fearlessness and vulnerability. Her legacy is the example she sets for others who might not have her strength but through her willingness to share her experience in such a public way, will help them find that which they did not know they possessed.
In the meantime, if there is a Hell, I hope the five animals that perpetrated this heinous crime spend eternity roasting slowly on a spit and that the bureaucrats on the parole board are forced to go to their separate hearings regularly.
Best of luck Joanne and keep up outstanding work Liz.
Sincere regards,
Todd Robinson
3/29/04
Everett
Des Moines, IA
Joanna,
I recently watched your story on the local PBS station.
First, I am deeply sorry that you and your friend had to, and still have to go through the trauma. It has never happened to me, or anyone I know, and I pray to God it never does.
Second, you are a hero to me. You are nothing less than inspirational, admirable, and courageous. I wish nothing but the very best of good, because after what you went through, you deserve it. I extend the same to your friend.
Third, it is only my personal opinion, not only should they never granted parole, but their sentences were way too light-at least life for all of them. Again, my personal opinion.
God bless, and be safe.
Everett
3/29/04
S L May
I just saw your story and as a woman, I wish to say thank you for your courage and stamina! I hope that more people that saw it will have as much guts (I dought it) as you to stand up within the system and say to them, "Whatever happened to you do the crime, you do the time"? When I was a child it was that way! Now it's "You're going against my rights"!What about the survivors rights? You should be through counsling and on with your life! But, the pansys that feel we're "too hard" on our prisoners!They're Wrong! I say Back to hard labor for them! You have AWESOME parents! And the lawyer needs to start going to advocate speaking times in the capitol of your state! He could speak to congress! Or get on the governors advisory council if you have one there! It is wearing and it's ok to be human and not super human, because you think it's what's expected! When you're at your burn out moment go to a meeting or a crisis center! It will get your fight back! Spoken from an advocate! And eat ice cream! God Bless You, S.L. May
3/29/04
I am 39 a victim of molestation with no justice from the age of 18 mo. - and to be honest till today my expiriance took over my life I have social anxiety ptsd and ddmp alphabets to decribe me so what joann did is great she is much stronger then i ever could be and GOD bless her mom and dad for the stegth they give maybe if i had that i would be better off now so every one of you out there who stand up and say enoughis enough gives those of us who can't strength to say if SHE CAN DO THAT after all the hell she has been through just imagin what i could do and yes joann your expiriance was much worse then mine i grew up in a unsafe world not able to trust even my own family so when i went through my expiriances as a child then again as an adualt it was just the same stuff diff. day you lived in a safe loveing world so those creeps took from you the ability to ever feel safe again and for that i cry the Lord has blessed you with a strong soal and i'm glad he has because maybe with your help and others like you more victoms will stand up and say ENOUGH IS ENOUGH mothers stop being quiet fathers stop being afraid and victoms stop hidding its NOT YOUR FAULT we can stop them we have that rite and the courts need to open there eyes and change some laws to help the victoms feel safe to come forward without fear or judgment
3/29/04
Russell Elliott
Mexico Mo.
WOW !!
I can't begin to say how truely sorry I was to see such a strong HERO as you are Joanna go through such a punishing ordeal. You have so much strength and also your family was put through such a horriffic state and come out of this so strong. All of you are HEROS !!
This film touched me in a way I have not been touched before. I too have a daughter and seeing what horror you have and are going through , just pulls at my heart. God bless you Joanna,and also your parents. You have two of the greatest people to lean on, and your courage is second to none. Good luck in your life and hopefully someday this mess with the system will finally work itself out, Lord knows it has put you through a living nightmare and you have prevailed strong!
God bless you Joanna
3/29/04
I came upon your documentary while channel surfing during the NCAA basketball tournament. For this program to keep the attention of this life long basketball fan and athlete and to inspire this e-mail speaks volumes about the power of its message. I am a lawyer and substitute judge. Whatever the future holds for me in my career, it is my belief and hope that your message will assist me in making my court a more just forum for those who must come there. Thank you.
3/29/04
George Lytle
Fort Worth Texas
Joanna,
What a wonderful women you are. I pray I would find a women in my life half as bright, strong, courageous and fantastic as you.
Your mother and father are first-rate.
If your thinking of leaving your home state like you said, Texas needs more people like you and your parents.
All the best,
George
3/22/04
J. Robertson
Pensacola Beach, FL
Riveting! Heart wrenching! Inspirational! I'm sure that's what Roger Ebert would say if he saw this unforgettable story. Forget that "Lord of the Rings" hullabaloo, this is the best film I've seen in a long time. I, like so many of your viewers who commented, happened upon this show very late at night and had missed almost the first half hour. Since I live alone and start my workday at 5:45, the last thing I wanted to hear about before bedtime was the subject of rape. I even changed the channel a couple of times to avoid the show but was drawn back by the empathy I felt for this very courageous woman. I sat riveted, mesmerized and deeply saddened by her story and then disgusted and revolted by our "justice" system. I didn't see if this film first appeared in '03 or '04, but I do know this documentary should win any awards they have to offer. I can't begin to imagine the physical pain and terror Joanna endured that horrible day. But the psychological everyday pain she must have felt for the last 15 years each time she walked into a room of people, even if familiar, and knew every eye was on her and every whisper was about her would be too much for me to bear. That she is able to find the courage to speak in front of groups and the Justice Dept. and to stand up to those ignorant parole boards is absolutely amazing to me. In this day when overpaid, ego-inflated athletes and actors are regarded as role models, in many cases much to our dismay, it is truly uplifting to see an actual hero. I've told several of my friends about this show and have been scanning our tv guide in hopes that this will appear again on PBS or better yet on the bigger networks where so much crap inundates the airwaves. I missed parts of the show only because I was too weak to watch someone's pain (ok, my fault!) but I missed the beginning because this was not advertised and hidden away at such an odd timeslot. Also, a friend who did see the show swears that our station cut the ending early. I only hope PBS or somebody will show this again and this time in prime time and have it advertised so many more people can see these injustices and try to help. As I was reading the viewer comments on this site, I noticed that so many of them just happened to catch this show very late at night or during the early am. C'mon networks, show a little courage and give your viewers something very well worth watching at a decent time. We can do without Antiques Roadshow at least one night! Liz, please continue your great work in film or in a column. Your wit in the Filmmaker Q&A cracked me up. Joanna, you are an inspiration and as much as you'd probably like to keep your personal life to yourself, I'm hoping to see a sequel or read about your life after the documentary. I hope you have been able to develop relationships that have comforted you. I'm rooting for you and will keep you in my thoughts and prayers. If you need to "just get away" come on down to P'cola and the sugary whitest beaches around. May God bless you and your family.
3/22/04
Joan mclaughlin
Upper Darby,Pa
I understand Joanna feelings.I was raped at 17.My problem is that they lost my rapist.He was in graterford prison.That is where the trail stops.Someone from CID helped me last year.We found he isn't dead and his paperwork shows him being incarcerated.But that is where it ends.The records in all 50 states were checked and he is now where to be found.How can our penal system lose an inmate?The worse part is that nobody cares.I was told to get over it and learn to live my life.Well,I live 1/4 mi.from where it happened.I am handicapped and can't afford to move.I now spend most of time hibernating in my apartment.My nerves are shot and counseling is useless.He is out there and NOBODY CARES.I am hoping Joanna sees this and might have some ideas for me.(Or anyone else)Also as a victim,I was lied to by the police,my lawyer and my parents.Just because I was 17 doesn't mean I didn't have rights.That was in 1974.I am told there is nothing I can do.Someone PLEASE HELP ME!!!!!
3/22/04
Delaware
What strikes me is that there were 2 women raped, yet it seems like only one sentence was given. Why couldn't the state charge them with 2 rapes and then sentence the 5 animals to serve their time back to back? At least then if they really only serve half of their sentence then they would be in jail for 30 years at minimum. I can't comprehend why the prosecutor would take it easy on them.
I plan on finding a way to communicate to the SC parole board and express my outrage at the condecending way that victims are treated. "We'll let you have your say, but...we've already decided" is what they told Joanna everytime. So why does she have to come? Oh that's right, it's theraputic for her.
That woman on the parole board is a perfect example of a small person who thinks they have a position of power and therefore deserve respect. The end of the film showed her trying to talk to Joanna as she was going around shaking the board members hands. Joanna ignored her and kept going. Do you think that woman will ever figure out why?
Joanna and Julie are forced to have this scar forever. I wish them peace and am thankful for the people around them who have loved them and tried to help them go on with their lives. The fact that someone who is so victimized has to still fight for justice should be a wake--up call for all of us.
3/22/04
Southampton, PA
Joanne Katz gave a powerful presentation of the life of the victim of sexual assult. I was assaulted in 1976 at knife point by someone I had dated. I did not report it because I knew what hell the victims of rape were put through. What shocked me the most was how people who I had previously thought of as friends acted. It was as if I was the cause of the assualt. Some of these friends stay away permenantly. In my case, as Joanna's, my mother was a strong guiding influence. I married shortly after that and the understanding of my husband, when I would intermittenly panic in bed, was truely a gift from God.
I wish I had had Joanna's courage to see the cause of all of my pain put in jail. Joanna's story has prompted me to want to get more involved in victim's rights issues. Thank you Joanna for helping me find voice for my pain and turn it into something constructive.
I know the problem I had with re-establishing relationships with men after this event. I wish you had commented on how this attack has impacted relationships with others besides your parents (even though this is none of anyone's business).
May God bless your work in support of victims and continue to heal the hole in your heart that gets riped open every time you need to reappear before the parole board.
3/22/04
Harold E. Klein
Philadelphia, PA
Joanna's is a powerful testament to the horror of rape and the heroism of this remarkable woman and her family. I am sure that anyone seeing this film will have the same reactions. And that is what troubles me. The PBS venue for this important program is something akin to "Preaching to the choir." I would hope that this work is required viewing by every law enforcement agency, the personnel of every court system and social welfware organization at all levels of government (not that some of them don't also watch PBS at midnight on a Sunday evening).
3/22/04
Jennifer M.
Charleston, SC
I am a recent friend of Joanna through mutual friends. I saw this story several weeks ago on TV, but I must say that I am still haunted by it. I cannot imagine being the victim of such a horrific crime. I always knew Joanna had spunk, but I definately have much more respect and admiration for her now after seeing what she's been through. It is insane to me that victims are questioned and made to feel like they've done something wrong when they come forward with their stories. I applaud Joanna's strength and determination in changing the voice and rights of the victim.
Joanna, know your friends are here for you. We love you very much and are very proud of you!
3/19/04
Ellington CT
While watching this film and seeing what Joanna and her family went go through day by day, it sickened me to observe a room full of "judicial employees" telling Joanna these animals were "rejected". Year after year these people would act as if they were doing Joanna a favor. What a waste of taxpayer dollars and a waste of precious time for this wonderful family. These animals should never be let back into society.
3/19/04
Jen
CT
I was also channel surfing and came upon this powerful documentary - Joanna Katz' story immediately drew me in and I realized this was a very powerful story.
One of the things I am left feeling is discouragement at how women are still not free on the streets. No matter the location or time of day or neighborhood, we can be abducted, raped, mugged, etc. And these incidents leave lifetime scars. It saddens and angers me that women still have to be fearful despite many of the gains we have made in other areas.
I applaud Joanna's strength, Liz' determination, and Joanna's family for being so incredibly supportive. I pray that your life Joanna will be as fulfilling as it can be. Your life and story have had profound effects on so many, and I wish for you the strength to become fully whole.
Thank you for showing the degrees to which the soul can heal and the spirit can shine.
3/17/04
Laurinda Satryb
Manchester CT
I was deeply touched by Ms. Katz spirituality and the tremendous amount of strength it must have taken for her just to keep on living, little own, sharing her story with the world and baring her very soul and all the pain she had suffered though. I accidently came across Ms. Katz' film while "surfing" though the TV channels and immediately was drawn to her inner strength and resolve to tell her story. I appauld, admire and respect her as a survivor, a daughter an advocate and an example for victims of violent crimes everywhere.
3/17/04
Vivian Cronk
Northampton, MA
I was so stunned and shocked at what you endured. You discovered your internal power within a traumatic setting. I reach out to you and your family.
It was hard to watch you repeatedly present yourself - for what seemed like a waste of time - in front of the parole board. I am happy that you perservered, in spite of it all, and maintained your dignity throughout. Your human rights campaign will never be forgotten.
All the best for a fulfilled life - as it was intended.
Vivian
3/17/04
Dimmie
My husband and I were spellbound by the complexity of this documentary. It was a testament to the courage of not just one brave young woman, but to the family as a whole. Her concern for her parents, having to know what happened to her and having to support her through the ordeal was only surpassed by their concern and support for Joanna.
I was proud of Joanna for her honesty and courage as a woman. She has more guts than any punk with a gun.
Our system is a mess with the criminals rights more of a priority than the victims. The last arrogant statement by the chairman of the parole board was most telling! She should be removed!
3/17/04
Elizabeth Love
Arlington, VA
Like so many others, I came upon this film late one night; and I was riveted by it, and by the bravery and gallantry shown by Joanna Katz. One thing which was mentioned in the film, but on which no one seems to have commented, was the sensitivity of the police force in Charleston. God bless them and whoever trained them - too many women have been immediately victimized again upon reporting a rape or assault by the stupidity of the police in handling their cases.
One other point: many people have raved here about the length of time it takes to bring a case to court. We can cure that problem, but how many of us will remember our outrage when the legislature moves to raise taxes to support our judicial system? Ask any police officer or lawyer in a DA's office how many cases he or she is handling at one time, or any victim's advocate in those states which fund them the same question. So long as we are all willing to pay exorbitant amounts to attend sporting events but unwilling to pay the price necessary for an effecient, properly trained justice system (including properly trained parole boards), such problems will continue. Luckily for the rest of us, there are courageous and outspoken advocates such as Ms. Katz; but they cannot change everything which needs changing, and they cetainly can't do it alone. We all need to get involved - not only in advocating for change; but , unfortunately, in figuring out how to pay for some of those changes. God bless you, Ms. Katz, for your bravery and your dedication. And God bless the DA's office and the police in Charleston for their dedication not simply to seeing justice done, but also to making every effort not to further brutalize the victim in the process.
3/17/04
Kandi Hochmeister
Pensacola, Florida
Joanna,
You are a brave,strong,beautiful woman!! You have the power!! God has obviously given you the power. Blessings and Peace be upon you and your sweet parents. Always remember that yes it is an important thing that you have done. (facing our lovely judicial system) but your attackers TRUE punishment will come someday soon!!
3/17/04
Brian Vaughn
One day in this country (hopefully) the powers that be are going to finally understand that people such as these need to be locked up for good. I was absolutely heartbroken seeing this beautiful woman with her soul torn apart. I hope that somehow, some way, Joanna and Julie can find peace of mind from this awful ordeal.
3/17/04
Marie
GA.
Joanne, is a very strong and brave survivor. She gives courage and hope to other survivors who need a strong voice like Joanne to speak out for our rights as victims to such horrible crimes as sexual assault and incest. I am a survivor of incest/sexual assault. I supressed my abuse for many year. I am just now getting the help I need by going to see a therapist and going to a support group. It is not fair that we as survivors can't get a peaceful nights sleep because of what we have gone through while the perpetrators rest with no problem. The laws do need to be made stiffer aginst the perpetrators. They should get life in prison without parole or the death chair. They took away our freedom. That only seems fair that their freedom get taken away.
Joanne thanks so much for sharing your story. I wish you continued healing.
God Bless you,
Marie
3/17/04
Molly
Woodstock, GA
Joanna,
Thank you for telling your story and for fighting for justice. I stayed up all night thinking about you and Julie, thinking about how we all think it won't happen to me. The courage and determination you have is almost sureal. It seems from the moment this horrific incident started you have been thinking of everyone but yourself. You thougt of protecting Julie, your family, other victums and now your battle for society as a hole.
I see God in your eyes, in your strength and your love. You are the kind of person he calls us to be. I am truly inspired by your story, your personal war on the evil of the world. I know that a part of you died that night, but a part of you was born that could come into the world no other way. I thank you for keeping that part of you alive and for sharing it with the rest of us.
3/17/04
DAVE WATERS
OMAHA, NE
Jonna Katz is a very special person...someone who endured what she did and has the empathy to feel worse for the people who don't have the support that she does, truly does understand victims of such a violent crime.
I applaud her parents for being such pillars of strength and helping her through this unpresendented set of circumstances, she is blessed to have them.
It is so true that she represents a best-case scenario in the aftermath of such a horrific experience.
My heart goes out to all of the victims who don't have the strength that she shows. How lonely and empty they must feel. But because of people like Joanna...they can have hope.
3/12/04
Linda
Lincoln, NE
It never occurred to me how a victim continues to be a victim of our system, beyond the trial and conviction. How can the healing start?
I was captivated by Joanna's courage. She musters the ability to protect herself, society (cites this as as necessary example of tough time for the crime) and speak before the board of pardons to keep these monsters behind bars. She is so inspiring with her courage in recounting the event.
Joanna, you have made a positive impact on so many people. We the viewers are outraged at what you have had to endure. May the support and respect you have inspired in so many people continue to give you comfort.
3/12/04
Janet England
Omaha, NE
My husband is a DA and I called him in the middle of the night to tell him about this convincing, moving story. I have encouraged him to get this video and show it to all of his prosecuting attorneys, judges and especially, parole boards. I have long felt that victim's rights are sorely ignored; many times the concern and care for the perpetrator is of more importance than the concern, care and convenience of the victims. Joanna Katz is a beautiful person...listening to her recount her unspeakable ordeal was mesmerizing as much as it was disturbing. I wish her peace in her life....she certainly deserves it.
P.S. I bought the video!!
3/12/04
Edward Cook
Huntingburg, IN
There are two basic problems with parole of these criminals: The word parole derives from a French concept of releasing a prisoner who gives their word of honor to not break the law again. Problem one is that these criminals have already abdicated their word of honor as human beings. By their previous deeds, it no longer exists. Secondly, if parole is a condition of good behavior, this too is an oxymoron. Ten or Twenty years of relatively good behavior in prison cannot take precedence over the extremely inhuman behavior that preceded it.
The outrage is not that Joanna Katz was forced to attend 5 separate parole hearings but that these terrorists were and are even being considered for parole. I don't think the, mostly, men who pass our criminal justice penalty laws have the intelligence or imagination to foresee such violence and terrorism and to pass laws that would keep the perpetrators in prison for the appropriate time. In this case the punishment did not come close to fitting the crime which I believe should have been attempted murder and terrorism in addition to the others. An overhaul of our criminal justice system is long overdue.
None of this negates the strength, character and spirit of Joanna Katz who is an inspiration to us all.
3/12/04
Jodi F.
San Francisco, CA
It is with tremendous admiration that I acknowledge Joanna Katz and Liz Oakley for documenting Joanna's experience and for giving us a face, a life to hold up as true testament to human courage within a fatally flawed system. I am deeply moved and inspired, Joanna. Thank you for embodying strength, vulnerability and beauty as so few can. May you know great joy and may you experience blessings in your life far surpassing the blessings you have bestowed to all of us.
3/12/04
Gary Rathbun
I recently saw the program on PBS detailing the nightmare Joanna Katz and her family been forced into. It was a horrifying tale of brutality and viciousness - a disturbing account of the true evil in some people that allows them inflict their evil upon others. At the same time, it was a story of the true bravery and will on the part of Ms Katz and her mother and father.
I fail to understand how the bureaucrats running the parole board could justify tormenting this woman and her family with all the ill-timed parole hearings for the animals that brutalized these people. The bottom line is that this family is being continually d by the system that is supposed to protect them.
To Ms Katz and her folks, I salute your courage and wish you to know that people care about you and truly wish you well.
3/9/04
phil bowden
london, AR
Last weekend, in the middle of the night, I was perusing channels, searching for something interesting, and I came upon this documentary. I must say, I was quite moved.
I personally have never been the victim of a violent crime or known anyone who has, but should that calamity one day befall me, I can only hope that I handle it with the same strength, grace, and dignity as Ms. Katz.
I marvelled at her steadfast determination to help change a justice system which is under-funded and plainly sees victims as mere numbers. It is because of extraordinary people like Ms. Katz and the dilegence of Liz Oakley, who should herself be highly commended, that victims now have a face and can no longer be ignored.
This work actually moved me to tears. Both of these women are truly a credit to the human race.
3/9/04
Angela
It's been 2wks since I sat rivited to my tv as I was supposed to be going to sleep. I haven't been able to get the images of Joanna reliving her ordeal out of my minds eye. And to see her family so unjudging and supportive and unafraid to stand by her...truly wonderful to know mankind does have good as well.
I was appalled by the brutality and violence committed onto Joanna and her friend..I felt at one point in the show that had it been me, I would've chosen to die..but the more i watched, the more I saw how many things are wrong and how many times the victim is brutalized, first by the perps but then by the system!!
I thought at one point that the Parole Board was sooo insensitive because a man was heading it up, but when I heard the woman head say to Joanna, " I hope this is something you can get over"..words escape me to describe how horrified I was.
When legislation is made and passed in favor of WOMENS well being, rights and point of view, rather than man's attempt to sweep things under the carpet that doesn't effect them, perhaps then we will see justice for all the victims. Until then, there are more victims than male law makers so speak out! The only ones judging you are those too afraid to realize they have as much liklihood of the same thing happening to them, only they wouldn't be strong enough to survive. You pass many more of us in your daily activities who will support, listen, love and fight with and for you!!!
Joanna, you gave me a look into something no one should experience, something my worst nightmares couldn't conjure. But more importantly, you've raised my awareness of just how common this is and how troubled the system is for those out there. YOu are a fighter and my reference of WOMAN!!!!!!!
Live your life with that zest and happiness NO ONE can touch-
3/9/04
Liz Cook
Plainville, MA
I had fallen asleep on the floor with the TV on, and this documentary woke me out of a sound sleep. Like the previous commenters, I was very puzzled by refusal of the parole board to combine the 5 cases so that Joanna could make a single trip. I was equally interested to see that they did this after the release of the program. There was so much that moved me, inspired me and horrified me...I think that Joanna, her family, PAR, the victim's advocate and the DA are heroic. An honest, brutal show that will forever change my view of who truly is sentenced in a violent crime. Thank you.
3/9/04
Cindi Burck Alsobrook
Neptune Beach, Florida
I commend Liz on such a poetic job on such an almost impossible topic. Mostly, I want to thank Joanna and her family for making me more aware of victims' rights (or lack of), legal difficulties in the system regarding rape because it certainly does benefit the criminals, and for making me more acutely cautious of my surroundings in an effort to prevent anything similar from happening to me or my girlfriends. No words of thanks will ever do. I'm a strong minded person, but I'm not sure I could do what Joanna has done for the cause.
3/9/04
Jerry
Boston
This is quite possibly the most incredible story you have ever told on your station. You must be able to see that by the reactions in the other emails. I have never been so moved, and this is the first email that I have written as a result of a program.
Why is it burried late at night? Please consider running this again and in prime time
3/9/04
Robert Hudspeth Jr.
Dallas, TX
I am so grateful to PBS for showing Liz Oakley's moving and educational documentary! I never write comments in to any shows, companies, etc. but I was compelled while watching "Sentencing The Victim", to copy down information about the filmakers. I wanted to 'tattoo' that information on my brain so that next time I had the opportunity to get in front of the computer, now ten days later, it would stick with me and I could in turn tell SOMEONE of the large impact it had on me. I hope that Joanna Katz continues to speak for victims' rights because I was captivated by every word she said on screen. She could be like a female John Walsh. I hope that didn't sound cheesy, I meant it with the utmost respect to both parties. I plan to learn more and offer help where I can. Thank you so much!
3/9/04
Charles McDonald
Kansas City. MO
Joanna Katz,
You are my hero! I am thankful to God that you have been blessed with the extraordinary courage to enable you to endure an prevail over this tragic event.
There is nothing left to say, your deeds, past, present, and future, are making the statement.
Post this if you like, include my name if you like. I am pround to go on record as supporting such a brave person.
Charles McDonald
3/9/04
Jim Baldwin
El Prado, NM
In light of your film it is obvious that the criminal justice system should take a role in protecting the rights of victims. Because it does not, it makes the answer to Joanna's question a difficult one. I would think it would depend on the individual and the circumstance. One could hardly blame victims for not coming forward, but I wonder if their reluctance would stem from issues other than the fear that judicial proceedings would "victimize them again." Joanna, I was mesmerized by this documentary, and I thank for for having the courage to undertake such an ambitious project. You are an articulate spokesperson and the importance of what you are doing for victims and future victims cannot be understated. What a brilliant accomplishment to come out of a terrible experience. Keep it up and thank you so much.
3/9/04
Terry Corbin
Quebec , Canada
I see joanna as a row model for the women of rape and I admire her courage and force to continue to go to all those hearings . Of the men who raped her they don't deserve to be let out of prison . keep up your good work joanna .
3/9/04
Rob Kondrk
Syracuse, New York
Joanna,
You are a true Angel sent from God - Your strength is supernatural - Your decisions during your terrible ordeal were far above Genius - you are a role-model - "beautiful before and after, inside and out, and will be for eternity" - your parents are very strong, wise, and I will never forget the deep love that they have for you, and you for them - you are an inspiration and messenger to all who have been, and you hold the key - March Onward, as I know you will, and free Your Beautiful Heart & Soul Forever - "God Bless You Always" -
|
|
|
