 |
|
|
|
Tell us what you think.
Selected submissions will be posted here, so check back regularly.
3/9/04
Jennifer L. Cuccia
Winter Park, Fla
Joanna, on 3/6/04 I watched your film. It was on at 5am. As a victim advocate certified by the state of Fla and Nationally, I was taken back by some of the things I heard. It is all to sad but true. Victims are always the one's put on trial.When working with victims of any crime I always state to them no matter what the out come of the court system, Justice Never Comes from OUR Justice System!
A victim
A Survivor
An ADVOCATE!
3/9/04
Sam A. Coats
Emory, Texas
Joanna,
I thank you'r Mom and Dad for instilling in you the heart, and determination that makes this Country great.
I hope you go on to Do even greater deeds to help our victems.
I would like to see a new law that states, "Anyone that does not believe in our peacefull society, can vote themselves out with any violet act against any other peace loving citizen." "They vote themselves out."
And then proceed to send them to an issolated Island (away from the USA to their death, and the victem can live without the fear of that criminal ever again.
Sam Coats
3/9/04
Patty
Thank you Liz Oakley for your commitment to produce this compelling and necessary documentary.
Mr. & Mrs. Katz, Thank you for your moral support, compassion and unconditional love provided to your daughter after this tragedy.
In response to the three questions:
(1) Absolutely, the criminal justice system needs to be reformed for victims. It was appalling to see the demeanor and actions of the parole board. They should be registered for a course in sensitivity training. Perhaps there should be a mandate to attend a rape trial as a spectator. This would certainly be a reality check for the board.
(2) I disagree as I do not believe she is the exception to the rule.
(3) Without a doubt,it is extremely important for all victims to come forward to report these horrific crimes. No one deserves this type of treatment and the attackers must be punished. For all those victims who have failed to report the incidents. You must seek professional help to work through the pain, to heal and recover. If you don't the remorse and pain will exhibit itself later in life affecting your families and relationships.
Joanna, I am a survivor and have walked in your shoes.
I was a victim of a gang rape in the late 60's. I was brutually beaten and suffered many injuries for resisting their advances Like you I wandered the streets until a delivery man stopped to assist me and transport me to the police station. Although it has been over 30 years the date and experience is forever embedded in your mind. I was in a trance reviewing this program for its entire duration. I was emotionally connected to you during this entire progam. I understand the pain, withdrawal and guilt you experienced after this incident. I admire you for your courage, stamina and strength to relive this nightmare. You are a beautiful person and I appreciate what you have done and your involvement to educate rape victims.
Joanna & Julie, You are in my thoughts and prayers.
Mr. & Mrs. Katz, I offer a prayer of thanksgivng that you are the parents and foundation of a beautiful daughter.
Liz and Joanna,
Every high school & college should have a mandatory review and showing of this tape.
3/9/04
Teressa C.
This film completely blew me away and I wanted to hug Ms Katz and thank her. There are no words I can muster to let her know how much this film is appreciated..and understood...by so many women across our country. I wanted to hug her for all she does..for all she's been through. Like many others, I also wanted to slap the woman at the parole board for her comments and lack of understanding. If there was a way to take away the title of "woman" from this creature on the parole board..I would advocate that. She is clueless and it is frightening that this group will release such blights on humanity as the group that victimized Ms. Katz. When will they treat the crime of rape as a serious felony? It deserves no less than a life sentence or at least no possibility of parole prior to the 30 yrs these bugs were sentenced to. Rape is murder of the mind and spirit as surely as a homocide. A living hell can be worse than a murder. Please..PBS...air this documentary often...you have no idea of the good it will do. It has motivated me to do something. Federal sentencing guidelines must be longer for the crime of rape all over our country.
3/9/04
Terry Callen
Gloucester City, NJ
I am sick to death of this country's "criminal justice system." It's all for the criminals, and there is no justice for victims.
The animals in this case should've gotten life with no parole. In another nation, they probably would've executed...or castrated.
Why do "condemned" murderers get years of appeals and numerous stays of execution..when their victims received no such amenities? Why do murderers get paroled when their victims can't get up and walk out of their graves - and the victims' families will never get their loved ones back?
Why is it necessary to keep making crime victims relive what happened to them?
3/9/04
Brian H. Clay, Sr.
Philadelphia, PA
Joanna,
I am truly appalled at the brutality & indignation you have had & still endure. From the bottom of my heart, I feel your grief, yet am compelled by your inner strength. What an incredible testament you are to the human race. I was ashamed to be a male after watching what these animals did to both you & Julie. Being a father of 2 children, one being a daughter, I found myself in your father's shoes. No parent should be put through what they have been. I am still aghast that the parole hearings are making you re-live the trauma. Good luck in your efforts to make the world aware of this awful experience. I will never forget your story.
BC
3/9/04
Susan
Dallas, TX
I caught your film at bedtime, but was riveted by your story and stayed up to watch it and just had to write.
You are an incredible woman, with incredible family and friends. I cannot get over that parole board and the way they treated you...especially when that woman said "I'm not going to sit here and let that man rant and rave about OUR PROCESS SYSTEM..." Since when is this HER SYSTEM? Who the hell is she to judge who can or cannot speak freely within our judicial system.
Unfortunately for the victim, she was appealing to the wrong group. I think every congressman should receive a copy of this video....that Joanna should continue to solicit on behalf of victims who are too scared, too ashamed, too weak to come forward and challenge our courts to protect and advocate ALL victims---and especially sexually assaulted victims---this is horrific.
Joanna, you inspire me and, I am sure, inspire every victim---you have found strength and courage and purpose, built from the ashes that pure evil burned away in your life. May God find a way to use me on behalf of victims of rape to change our legal system --- tell us what we can do --- I would do anything you asked of me!
Yes, I believe the criminal justice system can be reformed (or at least amended) to recognize rights of BOTH victim and prisoners.
Yes, I believe Joanna represents a best-case scenario -- an unique scenario, because she has decided to use her story to speak out on behalf of ALL victims, finding the strength and support to fight against this injustice in our court system.
Yes, it is important for victims to come forward. But for many who cannot or will not, there are woman, like Joanna, who can tell their stories, who WILL tell their stories, and who does have the courage to face and fight our "justice."
3/9/04
Brim Crow
Carrollton, Texas
What seemed to stick with me most while watching this splended documentary, was not the horrors the five thugs impressed upon Ms. Katz, but the absolute courage she showed during the assaults and in the years afterwards. If they could give a civilian the Medal of Honor, she would certainly deserve one. Bravo Ms Katz! Would that everyone (including myself) could show the courage and integrity you have shown!
Brim Crow
Carrollton, Texas
3/9/04
Suean Martin
Texas
The only word that comes to mind is "Angel". Joanna you are an Angel, God did not give you more than you could handle. I must say you have handled this so admirably. I am so very touched that words can not describe my feelings. I cry as I write this even though I am not a victim of rape. I truly felt you message.
Your parents are "top of the line" and the credit you gave them was very appropriate.
This year my New Years Resolutions included to volunteer and because of your story I will join the fight for victims rights.
Carry on Joanna...
3/9/04
Jack Sinclaire
Charleston, SC
Mr. Villani must have missed the fact that 4 of the 5 animals pled guilty. The remaining defendant went to trial, exercised every Constitutional right afforded the citizens of this country and was convicted by a jury of his peers.
3/9/04
Nicolette Andrews, M.D.
CT
Johanna:
Thank you for having the courage to come forward and help others not feel isolated in their quest to heal trauma.
It must have taken a lot of courage to do that. Thank you.
N
3/9/04
Jeff
Newport News, VA
Very sleepily, on my way to bed last night, I flicked the remote one last time through the channels, eyes half open, nodding off. Who was this woman on PBS, and why was she describing someone's brutal attack? Certainly I didn't need to hear this, not as I was preparing to retire. But something in this woman's delivery, an incredibly resilient and persistent determination, pushed me back into my chair. As I listened further, I was simply awestruck with the young lady's personal courage and inner strength. I watched the entire documentary, at once amazed and devasted, ecstatic at her persistence, openly crying for her soul. I lay awake on my pillow last night for two hours thinking about what I had just seen, and I feel compelled to tell someone, tell everyone, about this special lady, Joanna Katz, and her incredible strength of spirit. In this world, heroes and icons seem to evaporate like dust in the wind. After experiencing "Sentencing the Victim," I have a whole lot better idea of what it takes to be my hero. God Bless You, Joanna Katz.
3/9/04
Peter Maroney
Doylestown, PA
Dear Joanna:
Your courage and that of your Mother and Father is astonishing and incredibly inspiring. You have lifted the human race to a level that I scarcely believed possible. Thank you for your gift of hope.
Peter
3/9/04
jeff reiher
redford,michigan
i'm 24 years old and i normally wouldn't watch shows like this but something about joanna captured my attention from minute one. she was sitting their telling this horrible story with strength like i had never seen before. then i stared to pay close attention to what had all occured. the way the parol board is handling the situation is totally disgusting. there was one seen after joanna and mr.st.clair left the room and the head of the parol board was sitting their saying bad things about mr.st.clair as they left. disturbing to say the least. people in those positions are supposed to help and support people like joanna. and even though she knew what they were doing she still keeps it up. joanna you are truly amazing i wish you the best of luck.and even though you dont seem to be out for vengance just remember "what goes around comes around" in prison those a--holes have probably gotten what they deserve and even more. one more thing your movie should be seen on regular tv so every one can see the horrible story told by a strong beautiful person like i saw.
3/5/04
Veronica Swain
Columbia, SC
Joanna Katz will be the Keynote Speaker at Opening Ceremonies of the 17th Annual Victims' Rights Week conference held on Weds, April 28 at the Statehouse Grounds in Columbia, South Carolina. Victims' Rights Week is a three-day conference designed to gather together vicims and survivors, their families, and those who serve victims of crime to share resources, share stories of hope and healing, develop lasting partnerships, receive top-level training, and to honor those who have suffered criminal violence. All are welcome to attend. Log onto www.scvan.org or call 888-852-1900 for more information.
3/5/04
Dara Feinstein
Philadelphia
I watchd the documentary with my policeman husband asleep next to me, to afraid to move lest I miss some nugget of this unbelievable story. There were so many parts of it that made me angry, from the crime itself to the treatment Joanna has received over and over again from the parole board. As a mother to three little girls, the oldest who is four, with another baby on the way, I have discussed many times with my husband how can we prepare and protect our girls from crimes like this? The answer doesn't make me happy because no matter what we do, anything could happen at any time. I don't like that.
What impressed me the most was the relationship between Joanna and her family and I agreed with her that her incredible recovery has everything to do with the support she has received from them. She is lucky to have that and i'm relieved for her. Joanna is an amazing person, full of life and passion and I admire her struggle.
I'm sorry she has had to live through such a horrific experience but appreciate her drive to have something positive come from it, in terms of reform and victims rights. I think if a criminal is sentenced to 30 years, that person should serve 30 years without any possibility of parole. Joanna should not have to continue to live in fear that those animals will be set free every other year. How can she ever truly get on with her life or have the opportunity to put some of it behind her if she is forced to relive it again and again to keep these "men" ( and I use the term loosely) in jail? Isn't that what the original sentence was for?
Joanna, continue to live your life outloud. Thank you for your bravery.
3/5/04
Ashley
Anytown, USA
I admire and appreciate what you have done for those of us who were unable to speak for ourselves. I was mesmerized by your documentary. I am sure that the accolades fall far short in comparison to what you went through. Your strength is inspiring.
I, too, was appalled by the insensitivy displayed through the comments by the members of the parole board. I was especially stunned by the woman who hoped you would "get over it". There is no hope for understanding in the face of such ignorance.
3/5/04
susan
I wanted to thank you, Joanna Katz for sharing your horrific story and for your courage and strength. I remember coming forward after being sexually assulted, although it was not physically as brutal by any means, I remember all of the emotions that went through me. I remember being told that I was just a beautiful girl who happened to be victimized because of the way I look. I remember the insensitive judicial system who put me on a stand in front of people whose faces I never looked at. I remember my mother, who didn't talk to me for a year after all of it. I remember getting on my knees and begging God to touch my heart and give me strength to accept the things that I cannot change. It was a time in my life when I really got to know my self and my soul being. I learned that when all else fails in this world, I have my faith in God, knowing that I will again hold my head up and be somebody who is worth something.
I think that the comment that you made regarding what a person could say or do to help a person through the aftermath was very courageous and correct. You said just having someone that you love, like your parents there by your side was so comforting. Just being there quietly makes all of the difference in the world. I admire your parents greatly for the way that they nurtured you through the aftermath. It's as though they knew exactly what you needed. Because, there is no excuse in the world by any means, to justify what you experienced that evening. It's not something you could have prevented. It's not something that " shouldn't have happened" It's something real and by all means something you experienced. I am proud to say that you are an inspiration to so many of us who have been victimized and tried for someone else's crimes. Because I know, based on my experience alone, that it was God who gave me strength because I turned to him. I was able to face the facts and do what needed to be done to make sure that the man who shattered so many aspects of my life and my future, would never do this again, to me, my children or to anyone. Joanna, you will never be alone,not even during the points in your life where you are breathless and in despair. Again, I want to thank you for sharing your story. You have touched my heart. I needed to hear your story. You made an impact on my life.
3/5/04
John
Collingswood N.J.
I will be praying for this woman"s continued strength and healing as well as major reform on penalties that will throw away the key on people who try to destroy any human being in this way. I will never forget this story.
3/5/04
Rayann Moody
Burton, Michigan
Joanna,
I like so many others on this site, just happened to tune in on your program. What I saw and heard both astonished and infuriated me. I was in awe when I heard you speak of your attack. I also wanted to slap several members of the parole board, yet you held your head high with both a dignity and grace worthy of a saint. You are an incredible person, you make me very proud to be a woman. Thank you.
3/5/04
STEVE MCCARDLE
Columbia, South Carolina
JOANNA,
MAY GOD BLESS YOU & YOUR FAMILY FOR YOU HAVE BLESSED MY FAMILY. AS YOU KNOW IN 1/2000 I SUFFERED A BRUTAL ATTACK ON MY LIFE AS WELL. WITH YOUR HELP WE ARE DOING OUR BEST TO PUT A FACE ON THE VIOLENCE WHICH NOBODY SHOULD EVER HAVE TO ENDURE. HOW YOU MADE IT THROUGH 5 HOURS OF TERROR IS BEYOND ME. SINCE YOU MADE IT THROUGH SUCH A TRAGIC NIGHT YOU HAVE GIVEN BACK SO MUCH. YOUR ATTITUDE & YOUR ABILITY TO GIVE BACK AFTEER A NIGHT OF TERROR HAS IN TURN BLESSED MY FAMILY. THANK YOU SO MUCH.
3/5/04
James Bethany
Birmingham, Al
I watched in disgust and intense anger at what I saw was South Carolina's definition of justice. Those animals should not have even been offered parole for at least 20 years after their convictions.
Personally, I believe there is a lot of wisdom in the Bible that so surpasses our wisdom. The penalty for rape was and is death with the victim throwing the first stone!
Joanna don't let those worthless bums or those animals get you down. Fight the good fight. March on Columbia and Washington if you must!!! This abomination should be corrected. Where is the Justice for the victim???
3/5/04
Rory
Ontario, Canada
Perhaps it might help to bring a sense of finality to women if the law stated that a convicted rapist must be castrated before he is released from prison. They would hopefully pose no more threat to women. There could be a choice - castration and parole or life (until physical death) in prison.
3/5/04
Barry Fabius MD
Valley Forge, Pa
I am again ashamed to be a member of this species (when hearing such a crime perpetrated upon an innocent individual). The only thing that gives me hope is the existence of people like Joanna who pursue justice and rise above the rest of us who lack the strength,tenacity, and courage that she has.I hope that she and her parents realize what an amazing person she is.
3/5/04
Roberto
Denver, Colorado
Dear Ms. Katz:
A chance changing of channels during a commercial landed my tele on PBS and the program which you and Ms. Oakly produced was being broadcast. Immediately it was apparent that you have endured terrible ordeals and have survived. It was particularly embarrassing and even agitating to see what happens once the 'justice' system is involved.
That you have survived is remarkable. That you are still able to articulate feelings and emotions, is miraculous. That you can still smile, engage others and manage to live is beyond human understanding. Where many of us would have simply 'buried' these experiences in the darkest corners of our minds, you have shown the courage necessary to express to rapists and other violent offenders that they cannot take your spirit. You are truly an inspiration to anyone that has been faced with seemingly insurmountable odds that they can still determine the outcome.
Your story has left an indelible mark on my soul. Never again will the word rape fall upon my ears without seeing your face and hearing your words.
My wife was raped many years ago. She was a young woman and was raped on a college campus. The perpetrator slashed her with a knife to make his point then raped her. She has not shared her story with anyone other than me. When she first confided in me, I cried and told her that I was sorry for what had happened to her. After watching your story, I feel even closer to my soul mate as I understand how difficult it must have been for her to tell me about an experience, which transpired many years prior.
Thank you for having the courage and strength to relive what none of us can truly understand or imagine. You are a wonderful person and a beautiful spirit.
You will be in my prayers for the rest of my life. I hope that you find a way to forgive the fools who hurt you and that they find a way to ask the creator to do the same.
One day man will understand
Without woman we are damned
We cannot bring life
For that we need a partner or wife
The power of the female
Has for eons been suppressed
The decisions to war
Been made by the rest
Who is it that wants the world whole
Who is it that sha
res their heart and soul
Who is it that tells all true
I believe that person to be you
Woman is precious and life is short
Domestic abuse has been like a sport
Who can win when each is beat
Better we never take to our feet
Someday when jealousy is mute
When it no longer matters who is cute
When what is important is really understood
We'll all work together for our common good
You will be in my prayers for the rest of my life. I hope that you find a way to forgive the fools who hurt you and that they find a way to ask the creator to do the same.
3/5/04
John J. Zelenka
NY,NY
The weaker sex? She has more of what it takes than any of her attackers. We can only hope that if called upon to reach that inner strength that she found in herself, we find it too. I hope we haven't heard the last of her. She gave so much and in doing so she gave many a voice. Great person! Great family! Great show! IT WILL HELP!!!
3/4/04
Marc
Tulsa, Ok.
Like others, I happened onto your program. Astonished, appalled and offended by the parole "head chair" lady. Wanted to slap her. Joanna you are indescribable...will you marry me? Seriously, my heart and life was touched and influenced. Was sexually abused as a child... Just know you are an incredible hero to many and your film with Liz Oakley should be seen by all. God Bless you for your story and strength to tell it.
3/4/04
Greenville SC
I was totally blown away by this story when it aired on SC public TV last year, and even more deeply moved watching it on PBS.
It's so tragic that victims like Joanna are treated so poorly by our justice system. In fact, justice seems an illusion after watching this program.
Joanna is an inspiring, corageous person-- many others would be shattered or ruined or even dead after such an attack. That she is using her experience to make a difference is truly remarkable. Thanks to Independent Lens and PBS for sharing this story with a national audience. Now it's up to us-- viewers and citizens-- to advocate for reform. That's the least we can do for Joanna.
3/4/04
J.Q.
Houston, TX
Your film caught my eye at bedtime, yet I watched it all. It moved me and I could feel the pain, unable to sleep that night. I respect your courage Joanna for speaking up and doind what your doing.
I told my mother about your documentary, then she told me she was gang raped being only 12 yrs. old. Only a child. Yet she could do nothing about it. People need to come together nationwide and bring this issue out into the public eye, or it will never stop. It is time to refine our judicial system in Texas as well.
I would proudly join in on a public walk at the same time throughout the country, grabbing the medias attention. I would proudly join in a support group as well. Don't stop now, it has just begun!
3/4/04
Joelle Campbell
Avella Pa
I was rivited to this story the other night. It touched me in a way that was good. It made me realize the strength of some people. The parents of this girl are rare in a way that some can't fathom. God bless the mother that saw her daughter through this terrible ordeal. It made me cry when I saw the pain that you all were going through. I hope and pray that some day you find peace in this screwed up world. Hold your head up and smile..you are all survivors.
3/4/04
Mark
Columbia, MO
I happen to stumble upon Joanna story and was shocked as to what she has to go through because of these animals.
It's a crime to our society and to Joanna that we can let anyone of these guys out of prison. There should be no debate or hearing about this matter. What a special person Joanna is. Best of luck to her!
3/4/04
Bill Broadhurst
Akron, Ohio
For the entire 48 hours after I have viewed the film I am still almost constantly struck by the powerful impression Ms. Katz left on me. Her amazing courage and strength to not only come forward but to survive and fight back; her resolve to persist until change in the system occurs; her empathy to make sure that others avoid the "sentence". She uplifted me. My first impressions were of the tragedy that such a beautiful woman was so severely damaged that the world may never know her radiant presence ever again. But as the film developed, it was a joy to see her spirit triumph over the darkness.
3/4/04
Panama City, FL
It was just 2:15 this morning, I could not sleep. I turned to the TV Guide channel to see what was on that this hour. I didn't see anything so I just started flipping backwards. There was your face and you were talking about one of your attackers...it sucked me in. I watched the entire program, not even getting up to go the restroom.
I work in the legal field and regularly attend Victim Advocacy Coalitiion meetings to keep strong contacts which we utilize at my job. I cannot believe that after going through this horific experience that you had to endure 14 parole hearings in 6 years!!! I am appalled by what the people of that board had to say...especially the snide remark from the female lady, "...I wasn't just going to let him rant and rave..." Do you think that she or anyone could fathom what it must feel like to be hit in the head with a gun, beaten, raped, etc... and then have to sit there and go through this for the rest of their lives?!?!?!? I was so sad, angry, bitter, shocked! It really opened my eyes to a different side of the justice system.
You are incredibly brave and I have so much respect for you!!! You are truly an awesome person. And your parents are awesome as well! I am the mother of a 10 year old girl and so this definetly made an impact on the way I will view victims of violent crimes and the things I had no idea they had to endure. Who is really serving time here??
You keep doing what you are doing because IT IS MAKING A DIFFERENCE!!! God Bless You!
3/4/04
Barb
Charleston, SC
I have gotten to know Joanna in the past year through mutual friends. I would like to say that Joanna is a truly amazing lady.
As I watched her story I felt so much anger and outrage at what she and her family have had to go through at the parole hearings. It angered me by how insensitive many of the parole board members sounded. I feel they should be much more sympathetic toward the victims in their actions and language. Shame on them!!! I hope your battle ultimately brings about positive changes concerning how parole hearings are scheduled. No one should have to go through what you've faced year after year in Columbia, S.C.
God bless you for making this film and sharing your story.....
3/4/04
Christopher Le Blanc. Ph.D.
New Orleans, Louisiana
Joanna,
Your story is very powerful and tragic. As a 50 year old practicing psychologist, I thought I had been hardened by frequent stories regarding the pain that human beings can inflict on each other. I was not able to remain detached while watching your film. I was very moved and inspired by you and your family.
It is not often that the public is able to experience the clear extremes of good and evil that are presented in your film. Your goodness is made so real and pure because it is tested by the pure evil of those "men" who victimized you. Our daughters, mothers, sisters, etc., are all victims of these men because they represent the evil that will try to destroy what is good and caring in our lives.
Your fight against a bureaucracy that is more interested in preserving itself than what is moral is a righteous fight. A bureaucracy that does not support the good becomes part of and enables the evil. Please do not give up your fight. By helping yourself you help others. We need to believe you will overcome the evil you have experienced. We need to believe that good will triumph over evil. This is how you will be remembered, and all the good people in the world support you in every way. My thoughts are with you. Don't ever give up.
3/4/04
Marc
Marion Ohio
Thank you PBS for the quality and the honesty of your wonderful programs! Thank you Joanna Katz for your bravery in bringing these horrific crimes out of the darkness. Every woman who has been sexually molested, raped, or has had any sexual crime commited against her, needs to pickup the phone this instant and put a stop to this! Hundreds of thousands of you CAN change things if you band together all at once. Let the world know your tired of this and your not going to take it ANYMORE! Dont let even one more of these low-lifes take anymore of your respect or rights away from you again. I am outraged that these crimes do not carry a mandatory life sentence! Kudos to you Joanna, and to your loving family and all those who stand behind you! I wish you and your family the very best and god bless you Joanna.
3/4/04
James Perry
Portland, OR
Flipping through the channels late last night for some evening news, I happened across Joanna Katz's riveting account of her double ordeal as both a victim of a horrendous crime, and of the judicial system which failed so miserably to address the challenges she faced in the aftermath. I could not change the channel or leave the room or go to bed. This is a heartbreaking, enlightening and compelling story. I had a vague notion that victims of violent crimes could subsequently face problems in dealing with the justice system, but I now have a whole new appreciation for the enormity of the issue.
My thanks to JoAnna, her family, and the filmmakers for their courage in bringing this issue to light in such a powerful way. I feel changed and awakened for having viewed this film. Thanks also to PBS for airing it. I don't know where else I would have been exposed to such a controversial, unsettling and important production.
3/4/04
Alison Buck
San Francisco, California
Dear Joanne, thank you for the courage to tell your story and share you experience and emotions so publicly. I also felt completely taken in and compelled to sit and try to take in your pain and your incredible drive to move forward in your life. As a woman in todayís society I believe we have all been sexually victimized at some level in our lifetime, but the violent and brutal experience that you have gone though and your journey to open your heart is so incredibly powerful! You show me that as humans we CAN survive and move forward. I hope you are able to find peace and have joy and happiness in your life. God Bless
3/4/04
John Kingston
Ely, MN
Great documentary, we were so sad about the man's inhumanity to man parts, yet very uplifted by this victim and her family and friends' story of strength and courage to help us all; she is truly a hero.
I am generally a liberal progressive person, but cases like this and one in which a friend was raped ind murdered in her apartment stairwell by a felon on regular release to clean the Governor's mansion in Kentucky make me favor the death penalty. Suzie Schick was a wonderful, talented person who suffered horribly, but not annually at the hands of a parole board. The man who tormented and killed her was quickly adopted by a church who tried to get him off and were apparently not sympathetic to our innocent friend.
I am in favor of the death penalty in these cases. Certainly there should be a means to deny parole to such perpetrators forever. and to stop the regular punishment of the victims.
Take back the night, and the day.
Sincerely,
John
3/4/04
David H. Liddle
Boise, Idaho
Ms. JOanna Katz,
WOW!! Joanna, you have managed to display the best of humanity: fragility, hope, courage and the will to live.
I commend the film maker. Marvelous job. The film was riveting. Like others, I couldn't go to bed until I had watched the whole story.
I wish you the best Joanna.
Dave Liddle
3/4/04
Stacy Saldivar
San Antonio, Texas
I was very touched by Joanna's story and feel that she is a strong woman. She has and will continue to leave a mark on many people.
She is brave for revisiting the parole board repeatedly, that must be horrible. I was horrified at the comments of one of the Parole Board members who said "I hope one day you will get over this." I noticed such a disinterest in the parole board members. They seemed so disrespectful. You would think that they could stop fidgeting and look you in the eyes while you speak. It seems as if they have no compassion. I would be afraid to leave parole matters in the hands of people who seem so indifferent.
May God bless all who were involved in producing this film and may he watch over Joanna and Julie.
3/4/04
Tony B...
Hayward, CA
I cried for your pain, was strengthen by your resolve, and sicken by the treatment the parole board exhibited toward you and your advocates. Please thank your parents for setting a wonderful example for all.
3/4/04
Paula
Rapid River, MI
What can I say? Joanna you are an absolutely amazing person. Unable to sleep at 3am, I stumbled over the film. Little did I know, I would be entranced by it! May God bless you and your family - as well as your friend. It is unbelievable and sickening that such monsters exist out there. I was disgusted to see how the courts treated you as a victim. But please believe that these 5 beasts that did this to you, will have their "true" judgement day someday. I will keep you all in my prayers.
3/4/04
Jonathan Schancupp
New York, Ny
I watched the documentary and wanted to go thru the TV screen and helping her and protecting her from this horrible experience. The one thing that stayed with me was during one of the parole hearings someone said how though the men convicted of the crime would be doing anywhere from 30 to 35 years Ms. Katz would have a life sentence. I found the structure very interesting cutting back and forth to the story and the hearings. How it had affected the family. Her parents looked drained. How they all had changed. I wanted to know more about Ms. Katz. If she was involved in a relationship now. It bothered me to think that there are people out there like that and to have such disregard for human life. And when Ms. Katz told at one of the trials how one of the rapists had given her father the "bird" as she put it. It's almost like you don't know what to say in the comments because the act was so unspeakable. A woman had her life changed forever at the age of 19. So much ahead of her. She has make a remarkable recovery and I commend her for achieving all that she has since that time.
3/4/04
Jason Method
Orland CA
Last night I watched your film despite desperately needing to go to bed. However, I was compelled to watch because of Joanna's incredible strength, courage, and vulnerability. I cannot imagine what she went through and the fact that she has remained such a powerful presence through not only her ordeal, but the seemingly endless dealings with the parole officials has moved me in ways I never expected. She is a most incredible person, and she will be in my thoughts.
3/4/04
Roanoke, Va
Joanna,
I am amazed by your story. I watched, completely inspired, by your story. Throughout, I saw elements of regrets...of blame. I was so concerned...because of your STRENGTH, you both lived. Because of this, you have compelled others to be strong and to fight for victims rights.
Please, be proud, both, you and Julie. You survived. You are both amazing women. My prayers will be be with you. God Bless, IMT
3/4/04
Marsha Mace
Lawrence, KS
I am confused, please help me understand why these "waste of flesh" are sentenced to 30+ years but are released,NOT PAROLED-RELEASED, in 15-17 years.
God Speed to you Joanna and Julie!
3/4/04
Tim Parrish
Nashville, Tennessee
The first thing I did this morning was to send an e-mail to Jack Sinclaire. I will paraphrase what I wrote him.
I told Mr. Sinclaire that Joanna Katz is a living, breathing, genuine American hero. It is a miracle she is alive, and yet year after year she has to put up with the crap from the South Carolina Parole Board.
I watched the show in stunned disbelief, getting upset at times that this happened and continues to happen to people in this country. Then as the wheels of justice began to grind, the victim gets victimized again.
No one on earth deserves what happened to Joanna and Julie. It really put me off and angered me at how condescending the parole board members were to Jack Sinclaire, but then in most states, and that is the case in Tennessee, parole board members are political hacks and appointees being rewarded for supporting whoever the governor is. Some do not even have any background in criminal justice. The last person was the worst. The sugary-sweet way they tried to talk with and to Joanna and her parents made me want to throw up.
I am the father of two daughters in college and the brother of 5 sisters. I worry daily about my daughters and I wonder if I could be as strong as Mr. & Mrs. Katz in helping their incredible daughter through this ordeal.
From my perspective, Joanna was telling the viewers that we need to be very concerned about rape, its consequences and aftermath, and the type of follow-up that must be done with people who commit these crimes. I am a hard-ass; when you are a convicted felon you lose all rights and the last thing we need to be doing is figuring out how to take care of the criminals when it is the victim who we should be helping.
Joanna, Mr. & Mrs. Katz, Mr.Sinclaire, may God continue to bless each of you and watch over you. Thank you for sharing this powerful story.
tim parrish
3/4/04
Justin
Anchorage, Alaska
Well done, Liz... well done.
Joanna, you're a brave, bold, beautiful person. Don't ever think otherwise.
It is sad that criminals are given so much at the expense of victims trauma. This is a classic case why we need judges on benches who are willing to say these words: "... without the possibility of parole."
3/4/04
Pete Bowman
Utah
I accidentally scanned onto this program last night as it was about to start at 11 pm my time here in southwest Utah. It was one of the most riveting experiences of my life watching this terrible story. I just couldn't stop (to my spouses dismay). There are very few things that make a monumental impact on a person. Watching this was definitely one of them for me. Watching that parole board over and over again going through their mechanical and "by the book" procedure was horrifying.
Thanks for making me sad and angry and more aware of some of the entirely stupid processes that are in place in our lives.
3/4/04
Dear Joanna,
Thank you beyond words can say. You came forward for all who cannot do so. You have changed the system. You went forward with only a hope for change. But no guarantees. You are the best of us.
3/4/04
charlotte,nc
I am so proud of Ms. Katz for her bravery. I was the victim of an attempted rape in college and my mother said it was my fault because I was stupid enough to fall for a stranger's story. I didn't report it because no sex act occurred but it changed my life forever.
Ms. Katz took her power back and has made things better for all rape victims in South Carolina.I would bet the assailants had done this to other women and men before.
3/4/04
Sara Shallenberger
Galveston TX
This film was one of THE BEST I've seen on rape victims' rights. Being able to 'meet' Joanna over a period of years really went a long way to seeing the aftermath of this violent crime. It was so affirming to watch the program, as I survived as rape at age 19 as well. My rapist was a serial rapist who was caught, thank God, 1 month after my attack. I was able to ID the rapist in a line-up. Joanna's experience was so painful, and yet I suspect parts of it were all too typical. There are three points in particular about our systems mishandling of rape cases that stood out to me.
1. The length of time between arrest and trial. In my situation one year passed before the trial, as in Joanna's case. In my heart, a year going by stood for 1 year that justice wasn't metted out. Emotionally I struggled with this length of time because it only added to and fueled the anger I already had about the rape, and my rage exploded out to the court system that seemed to 'not be doing anything.' (In reality what I later found out was happening was that the case against this rapist was so damning that he was changing attorneys every few months to avoid a trial. Although a legal manuever, I felt betrayed by the system that would allow my attacker these rights and priviledges at the expense of handing out justice.
2. The length of sentence. Obviously this is a complicated factor, and I totally support every District Attorney out there who has to decide what charges he/she pragmatically they feel can stick. I loved my District Attorney in Sacramento, CA and think the world of him. However, one of the first thoughts that occured to me after the rape was that really life in prison or the death penalty really was the only sentence that I would ever feel fit the crime against me. I felt dead myself, like I had died. In your film a rape advocate said the same thing, that this type of crime takes something the can't be replaced. Almost 20 years after my attack, with a husband and two incredible daughters, I honestly tell my close friends that part of me won't be brought back to life from this rape. I believe in recovery from rape, but I also believe in a type of death that takes place for each survivor. If our justice system had this perspective, the sentencing would be stiffer!!
3. Our Justice System (as if it is a homogeneous entity) does NOT understand the consequences of rape. I think it shines in providing a rape crisis counselor in the hospital, and in providing an anti-pregnancy and anti-STD medication which was priceless to me. However, here are a few experiences I had with my case that point to a need for improvement.
A After being raped where the rapist ejaculated inside of me, I was not allowed the information if the rapist was a HIV carrier or not. I understand this was to protect his right to privacy, but this is what his right cost me: Repeat trips to a AIDS Clinic that were so terrifying every time I waited for results. The idea that this man could 'kill me' through passing on a disease, without even giving the right to his medical information seemed slanted in his favor.
b. The year delay before the trial cost me a huge amount. For me, it meant my anger continued growing instead of starting to slowly ebb a bit. To me, my attacker not being sentenced yet, felt like the law wasn't holding him accountable. In my mind and rage and complete desperation, I felt 'to hell with the sytem, if this guy isn't punished I'll be damned if I abide by it either." I don't know how common or uncommon my response was, but I acted out by beginning to shoplift compulsively which led to embezzeling at my place of work. I wish more people in the justice system had a window into the personal hell after a rape.
c. A few years after my case had been decided (through a plea bargain) I called the District Attorney to get any additional information I could. He said that my attacker was in prison, as sentenced, but that he was placing classified ads from prison for women companionship. What the hell is this? Human rights are indespensable, but the right to contine to harrass women and pervert sexuality is no right for a rapist.
I know this has been long, but there are just 2 more quick things I wanted to say.
In my case, the total years from all the charges (which included 33 individual victims) was 298 years. When I heard this news it felt right. Totally out of the realm of ever, ever being short of a life sentence. However, the plea bargain knocked the total to 80 years, and in CA a rapist only has to serve 50% of sentence before being eligible for parole. So really, only 40 years were 'in the bank'. Considering the attacker was only 27 at the time, there is the possibility of him getting out. Absurd. Regardless of the reality of having to compromise for a plea bargain, someone getting out for doing 298 years worth of damage just aint right.
OK, that's all of my rambling about the 'system', now to address those dealing with a sexual assault, I so agreed with Joanna about the amount of support after an attack is what can make or break a victims ability to recover. During the film I fell in love with Joanna's parents. I have loads of respect for her father who faced the crisis head on, was there for his daughter and didn't mince words when she needed to be defended to the parole board. For me, as much pain came from my family's lack of response as from the rape itself. I was basically left to self-destruct, even while living in their home the year after the assault. Of course I know they love me, but neither my mom or dad have mentioned the attack to me ever. I wish there was some avenue in which I could help others who find themselves totally on their own after an assault. I think women with already existing hardships have so many extra hurdles to overcome after a rape. For me it was a family who 'didn't notice anything', and eating disorder and chronic depression. But there must be sooo many others. Women who have been raped and who were molested as children, beaten as children, are pregnant, are new to the country , have a serious disease and on and on. I think the film did a good job at the end saying that each person responds differently. Some of us, myself for sure, come to a rape already wounded and then need to heal from multiple wounds. I guess I've spent a lot of years blaming myself for 'handling my rape so poorly', but really have seen the older I grow that coming into a traumatic experience already wounded and then with no support system after the event, does create a longer recovery period. I hope any others out there who feel like they've "botched up' their response to their attack are able to see what specifics about their life added extra burden to their recovery, and see that a long recovery isn't because you are 'stupid'.
Thank you so much for this film!!!!!!!! I have to think it will spur on more help for victims and a fairer perspective on justice for our legal system.
3/4/04
Melanie Hegge
New York, Ny
Step by step we make our way through the darkness - sometimes the only thing we can do is look for the light each of us can lift high for others to see. I needed to be reminded that I am not alone out here.
Thank you.
3/4/04
Sam Johnson
Henryetta,Ok.
My wife and I were drawn in to this so quickly. It has been on our minds all day. Our prayers are with you Joanna. You hang in there.
3/4/04
Eric Crist
Peoria, Arizona
I happened upon the program without realizing what it even was about...and I was immediately captivated by Joanna and her story. What an amazing person you are and it is just hard to believe the pain some people can endure and come out on the other end such a strong and wonderful person. Everyone hears about various horrendous crimes that are perpetrated daily in this great country of ours. But I never once sat back and really thought about what the victims have experienced...and will continue to experience for maybe the rest of thier lives. This story made me so angry at the perpetrators and, at the same time, sad for Joanna. I'm just shocked at the story and want Joanna to know that she is a beautiful, amazing woman and I applaud her accomplishments.
3/4/04
Brenda
Boston, MA
TRULY DISTURBING story about how evil a pack of men/animals can be. First, I would like to congratulate Joanna for having the presence of mind to reach deep down to escape such a brutal attack and saving her own life as well as her friend's life. Second, I would like to congratulate Joanna for having the strength to be a "witness" and tell this story to the courts, otherwise these animals may have simply walked. No one could even imagine the brutality of this experience, without experiencing it themselves. I am happy that Joanna has made such progress from such a devastating experience. This documentary was frightening, especially since I am a woman. Thankfully, I have never been physically assaulted. Honestly, after watching this film, I think if anyone ever pulled a gun on me, I would immediately run, even if that meant getting immediately shot. Joanna, I am sorry you had to be the random victim in this crime. May your assilants eventually get their just punishments.
3/4/04
Valerie Andrews
East Providence, RI
Like so many other viewers, I too was captivated by Joanna Katz and could not stop watching this film until the very end. Joanna's strength and perseverance are truly remarkable. The fact that her parents have never wavered in their support of her efforts is also inspirational.
This was one of the most thought-provoking pieces I've ever seen, and I'm so glad I happened to click on PBS in time to see most of the film.
Thank you for airing such a powerful film - I hope it will be shown again for all those that missed it the first time around.
3/4/04
M Strickland
Lexington, SC
Joanna Katz is such a courageous young woman to have come forward with her story and to have faced her perpetrators in court. For Joanna to endure additional torture in dealing with a parole board in order to keep these despicable criminals behind bars is an outrage. After what those animals did, they should be locked up for life with no chance of parole at the very least. Our justice system has a long way to go before there is truly justice for those who are victimized.
3/4/04
Dahlia Blue
Philadelphia, PA
Joanna,
This program was so difficult, yet so necessary and cathartic for me to watch.
I was raped in 1991 after coming home from campus. Because I had my headphones on, I could not hear him behind me. I was chocked until I was unconscious and I woke up in an alley suurounded by garbage, and I did not know the full extent of my assault until I was in the hospital and told of my injuries while still in a state of shock.
I was unable to identify my attacker. I live with that pain when I walk by someone and wonder, "Is that you? How many other women have you made suffer?".
However, I have tried to educate myself about healing and moving on.
I thought I was getting somewhere until I saw your story. You are an amazing inspiration to me, Joanna. You had instilled in me a willingness to fight for other women, who cannot speak, who cannot feel, who do not see any justice in their future.
I admire your courage, your determination to change these aribtrary sentences for sexual assault changed to long term sentences that can not be ratioed to time served. I appreciate your honesty, this raw, powerful honesty that keeps you going.
Thank you for sharing your story with us. I have felt very stigmatized, very angry, very sacred, very shut off in the 12 years since, but at long last, I know this experience has changed who I am since then I and should no longer be ashamed of that.
Sincerely,
Dahlia Blue
3/4/04
Clancy
Louisville, KY
Dear Ms. Katz,
Thank you for sharing. This brutal tragedy is eclipsed by your spirit & your honesty. Your vulnerability to the truth and sacrifice to the need fed Ms. Oakley's fire to enlighten for the rest of us what we otherwise would take for granted: that the criminal justice system is something we can count on. Joanna Katz, you are a beautiful child of God and I'm thankful for the life you are leading. God guide you and Ms. Oakley. God bless your parents. Keep the faith; the best is yet to come.
3/4/04
Katie Merkel
Milwaukee, WI
I, too, was touched by Joanna's story. I happended upon the documentary, as others did, and was frozen from the time I started watching through the end. As I read through everyone else's comments, I don't know what else I could add, except, Joanna, I find you so incredibly brave and beautiful and it would be an honor to be able to meet you and shake your hand someday (and your wonderful parents). You will all stay in my thoughts and prayers.
Katie
3/4/04
J.R. Freeman
In his commentary (above), Mr. Villani states his displeasure with the film and says that we "must come to the conclusion that one side is so right the other side is not worthy of representation." It obviously escapes him that, in fact, all 5 defendants WWERE duly represented--by a lawyer--THROUGHOUT THE TRIAL PROCESS--prior to being convicted and sentenced to prison terms.
He goes on to plead that this "is not the way the criminal justice system is supposed to work." Well, that is why this is a documentary and not a trial-by-video. It tells a story -- one side of a terrible story -- 15 years after legal process and "innocent until proven guilty" were given exercised to their full extent.
Mr. Villani's arguments are not without merit, in the appropriate setting. In this instance, though, I think he misses the mark...and the big picture.
3/4/04
Lara Goldsack
Charleston, SC
Joanna's story was a beautifully moving story. She has given many of us women a new voice. She will not be forgotten. Her strength and ability to move ahead, give me hope.
I too was raped here in Charleston in 1998. There are small similarites in our experiences. But the major difference in my case, is that my rapist got life without parole.
This gave me a sense of closure that Joanna and many other victims nationwide will never have and I am sorry for that. Watching Joanna's story last night, brought back many memories. I cried hard, but mostly I prayed for all of us who were strong enough to move on. And then I prayed for those that haven't found the power yet. Don't ever give up -- it is inside all of us.
3/4/04
Jen Haus
New York, New York
Joanna,
What a wonderfully brave woman you are. I was riveted to watch your courage and strength in the film. As a therapist, I know how vital it is for my patients to discuss their painful experiences, rather than burying them in silence. You are a perfect example of good mental health! Best of luck to you and know that many women are surviving because of your courage.
3/4/04
rainy day
portland, oregon
didn't want to watch it, couldn't turn it off, stayed up too late...the realities of our legal system are painful to behold. justice? for whom?
i can't imagine such violence. i was heartened to see such amazing and caring parents and the strength of joanna, who speaks for so many.
the parole board lady was unreal. her comments were a slap in the face. if she didn't want to listen to testimony, she could just say so. her commentary reveals a certain attitude that is pervasive. keep quiet. get over it. move along. next?
i hope she has retired. the system is tough enough without going up against that.
good luck, everyone.
3/4/04
Lori Leydorf
Madison, WI
Having worked in the criminal justice system for 13 years and recently having gotten involved in Restorative Justice practices, I can't say enough how important it is for survivor's to come forward. It is only through their experiences that all persons, including criminals, will learn what changes need to be made in regard to victim/survivor rights. I honestly believe a key component to lower recividism rates is for offenders to know the impact their crime has had on the survivor and the community as a whole. The world needs people like Joanna, her family, the police, her attorney and the victim/witness coordinater to make injustices known. Progress would not be made if their voices were not heard. Wisconsin is in the process of starting to allow survivors to be present for parole hearings. I am confident the Dept. of Corrections will make sure the victims involved do not have to endure anything close to what Joanna has had to. The SC process is absurd. The world-wide movement toward restorative justice is such a positive process - it is through these intitiatives that true healing is possible. Keep up the good work Joanna. You are a truly blessed person with a terrific family and support system. Kudos to all of you for your courage and committment to justice.
3/4/04
Michele Schoedler
Allentown, PA
Joanna,
I caught your story airing 3/2/04 at 10PM. I'm glad I checked the channels one more time before bed. I could not go to bed until your story was told. I think you are an incredible person. I said a prayer for you and and your family and all the other victims of similar crimes. I think all five should have been put away for life without parole. Our judicial system needs alot of changes. The part that outraged me the most was the parole board, especially the women. The uncaring and unthinking comments they made infuriated me. They cannot begin to put themselves in your shoes, nor did they try. I was beginning to believe they may have been on the criminals side. I wish I was there with you to speak my mind, but I did notice that no matter what you said it was as if you were talking to a brick wall. You are extremely brave. Ironically from this tragic ordeal, you now have special role (and gift) to help others. I praise you for all you work! You, your friend and your family will remain in my prayers along with all the other victims.
3/4/04
G. Nolan
Cape Cod MA
I was so impressed by the enormous courage , strength, and wit, that Joanna possesses that not only carried her through that hell, but brought her to where she is now. A strong successful woman fighting for the rights of survivors of violent crimes. We need more women like her to educate decision makers in our criminal justice system. It is not bias it is the truth and the truth must be heard !! God bless her for comming forward.
3/4/04
Bob White
Brooks, Alberta, Canada
WOW ! An incredible story about an incredible lady.
I find it so sad that we are controlled by a "Legal System" and not by a "Justice System"
In Canada we have a very similiar system, where the victims "Rights" groups have totally distorted the process, and the system indeed, "Sentences the victim" while accomodating the perpetrator(s) every whim and distortion of justice. Joanna, hang in there despite them, and reap the personal rewards of what you represent.
God, grant me the serenity, to accept the things I cannot change,
Courage to change the things I can,
And wisdom to know the difference
Thank you for your life
Bob
3/4/04
Joanna- I saw your film last night and was amazed at your strength- I am praying that your attackers remain behind bars, and that you find peace of mind-
Have fun with your acting-
Love,
Becky
3/4/04
Jim Gideon
Prescott,Az.
WOW!!!!!Joanne you blew me away with your courage and tenacity.I sat there and watched you explain what happened with such strength.Also your parents are so impressive with there thoughts and total LOVE for you.In this sense you are on top of the mountain.
I can not put on paper what hate I have for those five whatever they are---these actions only confirms my belief in California's "three strikes"law.At least it is a safety net that someday these type people will end up in a jail without a KEY!!!!! Love to you and your folks.Jim and Jocelyn Gideon
3/4/04
Christie Wilson
Brentwood, TN
I flipped by your story on PBS last night and your face and eyes drew me to continue to watch. I could not go to sleep until I found out what had happened. You and your family are very special people. As a mother of a 5 year old girl hearing about abductions and other violence on the news has me quite worried about her future. I have never been a victim and my heart goes out to all who must endure all the pain that goes along with the experience. I wasn't suprised by the parole board's stupidity and lack of caring but it hurt me more for you and your family to endure that as well. You are an inspiration and I admire your mom and dad. I hope I can be as great of a parent to my children as they must be to you. I would love to learn how I can help prevent such crimes. Thank you for your story.
3/4/04
Andy Cutler
Providence, RI
I had the opportunity to view the PBS special, Sentencing the Victim, last evening in the comfort of my own home in Providence, RI. It was at the end of a long day, and I had lots of things on my mind. I was immediately hooked into your story, and that of your friend, and immediately felt your pain as well as your family's pain. While I will never know what it must have been like for you to experience this insidious act, I can say without any hesitation that I was totally inspired by your story not only as a victim, but as a survivor, too.
It is my personal and professional belief that Sentencing the Victim was edited extremely well in that it was able to catch the most on camera -- your family's obvious love, respect and support for their child, your own personal strength, the network of people (who are in the system) who acted as your advocates and those on the parole board (who were quite dismissive and insincere as evidenced by their overtly bureaucratic behavior).
Maybe it was your story. Maybe it was the sparkle in your eye. Maybe it was the fact that you survived these atrocious acts. Maybe it was your courage. Maybe it was your family's gracious and intuitive support. Maybe it was the commitment by the advocates who not only heard your story but actually sympathized with your "victimhood." Maybe it was your collaboration with your co-producer (Liz) that enabled your story to be told in such a distinct manner. Maybe it was all of these things that gave me the incentive to contact you to tell you how moved I was by this movie.
It sounds like you have some really special people in your life who have told you how special you are, I just thought that you may want to hear it from a stranger, too!
As a thirty-seven year old male, I believe that this documentary should be aired in every high school so that both young women and men see not only the consequences and pain of such brutal acts, but also to let them know that there is help for those victims and their family's and life after suffering such an attack...and that life can productive, inspiring, and even happy. Additionally, if classrooms were open to viewing this kind of documentary, maybe there could finally be some "real" dialogue on the subject of rape, which could in turn serve to lessen its "taboo" labeling (even in this day and age).
Your parents would probably never think that their behavior was so special, and that they were just being your parents, but as you well know (and as you stated so eloquently time and time again in Sentencing the Victim), their extraordinary support came in the way that they were just there to support you--showing their true courage in how they treated you with a level of respect that is often missing in most child/parent relationships. They are in the truest sense of the word, your FRIENDS (not just parents)...a distinction that can not often be made between child and parent.
As I stated earlier, it was at the end of long day, in which I was thinking about my own business (own a public relations consultancy), and let me share with you that Sentencing the Victim got me out of my own small world, and allowed me(if only for 90 minutes) to see myself as part of a larger society...the society of human beings, with real emotion, feelings and empathy. Thank you for sharing this great gift with me (and millions of others).
3/4/04
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
Stunned. Appalled. Amazed.
My mind absolutely reeled at the description of what you and your friend endured.
Joanna,
Like so many other folks that saw your story last night, I have been profoundly touched by what you have survived -and continue to survive.
May God grant you grace and peace, and healing for your mind, body, and spirit.
3/4/04
Clarence Beveridge
Dothan, Al
I was captivated by Joanna's story telling and story. She did the right thing and the best thing.And, she is still doing it with the support of her parents.Total admiration for her!
What a human being!
The system needs to adjust to the victim.
3/4/04
Stephanie Holmburg
Dallas, TX
I was touched by this film in many ways:
1. The ferociousness of this crime disturbed and saddened me. In the absence of life-sentences without parole, these "animals", as Mr. Sinclair appropriately described them, should have been ineligible for parole for the length or their sentences. I'm absolutely horrified that in the state of South Carolina in 1988, the crime of kidnapping held more penalty than rape. I hope the sentencing guidelines have since been amended to reflect the brutality of this crime.
The parole board's unwillingness to listen to Joanna and Mr. Sinclair indicates to me their lack of understanding of the impact this crime had on Joanna (and Julie). Regardless of the number of cases they have to hear -- no victim should be patronized with insincere comments about how sorry they are for the circumstances that brought her there or that coming before the board should be therapuetic for Joanne. The parole board as a body should be the voice of the victim, and their sole responsibility is to HEAR the victim and make a decision that is just and RIGHT.
2. Joanna Katz's spirit moved me not only to watch this film in its entirety, but has also moved me to share her story with others. Hers is a story, a life, of pure resiliency and strength of character. She is not just a survivor, she is a woman who provides hope and inspiration to generations of women.
3. Diana and Sid Katz -- I only wish every child had the blessing of parents as loving, supportive and non-judgemental as they are. As the mother of an infant daughter, I found in them my heroes for parenting!
3/4/04
Cristina
Madison, WI
Last night my husband and I watched your powerful documentary. We were riveted by the amazing survivor story that unfolded in this film. We were amazed at the strength that Joanna has shown throughout her life to turn this horrific experience into a story to share with all of us. I found out my best friend also watched last night and we had a long conversation this morning about the different issues in the film.
I was appalled at the parole board's insensitive and condescending attitude toward Joanna and her family and in spite of that, you'll keep going to all those hearings. Joanna's resilience is a powerful message of the prevailing human spirit.
Thank you for making this documentary, it gave me a new perspective on violence toward women, recovery and victim's rights. I hope it has the same effect on other viewers and can be used as a tool to help others understand these issues.
This documentary is worth every penny I've given in support to my public television station. Thank you Independent Lens for your wonderful programs!
3/4/04
Tulsa, OK
The Purple and Silver Star at the least should be in order for this ordeal. As for the parole board, I'm sure that it would be unavoidable that they would come across as appearing insensitive. They, too are victims of an outdated, overloaded, overworked system. I would also like to thank Joanna Katz for her sheer courage. It is an inspiration to mankind everywhere.
3/4/04
ann
NYC
you are my hero.
3/4/04
Denny Breslin
San Diego
What a powerful, moving expression of Joanna's resolve to do the right thing, in spite of circumstances that would wear down anyone less gifted and less motivated. I stumbled across the story midway into it, but was captivated by the earlier testimony of Joanna telling her story in a very emotional, yet sure-footed way. The simple expression of her thoughts combined with a the thoughtfulness of someone with introspection made her story very compelling.
Thanks for your courage and your resolve Joanna, wish there were some way for other victims to know what you went through and how you are dealing with it, and the consequences. I accidentally stumbled across your story when I was not looking for it. Perhaps someone who needs to hear your story won't be so lucky. Thanks to PBS for airing it.
Denny
|
|
|
