 |
|
|
|
Tell us what you think.
Selected submissions will be posted here, so check back regularly.
3/3/04
Eliud Martinez, Jr.
Mercedes, Texas
I think you are an amazing person. You had alot of courage to tell your story and even more during your ordeal. I thank God you and your friend came out of it alive. Even though you will always have this in your mind. The "animals" who did this should have received life without parole. Being a father of three teenage daughters, I could not imagine what I would do.
God Bless you and your family.
Eliud Martinez, Jr.
Mercedes, Texas
3/3/04
Annette Drefs
Elkhorn, WI
I sat down on the couch to talk to my husband for a minute and he had just put on Joanna's story. I was instantly "sucked in". I could not go to bed until it was over. Joanna, you are an amazing person. Your strength is truly an inspiration to others who have been raped. I am a mother of 2 daughters and watching your parents, I kept thinking about the pain they must feel and how strong and supportive they were and continue to be. I could never imagine going through what you went through. What really amazed me was the parole process. I kept thinking I was missing something because I couldn't understand how the board could seem so uncaring. I never knew that a person would have to go through that over and over again. It made me realize how little one really knows about the justice system until they are thrown into it by circumstances beyond their control. I will keep you and your family in my prayers. Keep up your fight. I will definitely recommend this story to my friends. If more people are touched by your story it then increases the chances of changes happening in our justice system. I just can't understand why a person who is sentenced to 30 years doesn't have to pay 30 years?
3/3/04
SouthWest Ohio
I work as a prison guard in the state of Ohio. We are trained from day one to not consider the inmates offense in how we treat him in his day to day life inside prison. This policy is in place for a good reason. The prison staff is not the judge and jury, and we should not determine any kind of sentence. The inmates sentence is to be THERE, not on the street, not in a halfway house, THERE!
Having said that, I would like to thank Joanna Katz for putting the pourpose back in my job. After ten years any work gets boring, has lost it's pace, become a grind. While the job may be a grind, I feel a new pourpse, and I will never ever look at any inmate the same again.
3/3/04
Walker
Oklahoma City,OK
Thank you Joannna for telling your story. It was insightful for me as I will be going through the prole board process soon myself. I agree that the process is for the most part a joke. You are intoduced to an array of people in the system that say "we are sorry thats the way its and our hand are tied"
The show has givin me the inspriation to pick up the fight again.
My 4 year old daughter was raped by a 50 year old. He got 6 years prision 10 years probation. She is 8 now and he will be out in no time. They "the DA's wouldn't even consult me about his time or what I wanted to do. Just do a plea bargin and thats it next case after 3 years of us preparing.
Sorry to vent but I bet you here a lot of that.
I hope they are getting what they deserve in prision.
3/3/04
W. Shannon Linning
Greenville,SC
What a powerful,poignant trip. I am just so glad I was invited in by Ms. Oakley, and Joanna Katz overwhelmed me with both her strength and vulnerability.
3/3/04
Charis Cox
Savanna IL
Joana you are an amazing woman. You have so much strength and determination. I watched your program last night as I tried to go to sleep. I cried throughout the entire program. I just could not believe the horrific situation you were faced with, and continue to face everyday. I am so proud of you. As I write this today the tears stream down my face. All I want to do is give you a great big hug and tell you what a wonderful person you are. I was very moved by your story. Thank you for sharing it with me.
3/3/04
Superb film. What can we do to help Joanna's cause? I want to help.
3/3/04
Phyllistine Travis
New York, NY
Bravo, Bravo, Bravo.
Thank you PBS for airing this. Thank you Liz Oakley for producing this. Thank you Joanna Katz for sharing your story. Thanks to the Katz' for supporting Joanna unconditionally.
I was getting ready to watch "Law and Order: SVU" and was flipping channels and saw the introduction to your program and watched the whole documentary.
I have been volunteering as a rape crisis/domestic advocate for five years and as soon as the documentary was over, I contacted my agency to tell them about the documentary and how I would recommend for the agency in general and in training new volunteer advocates specifically.
People who do this work know, unfortunately, the many ways the survivor can be revictimized. I hope this documentary can inform many more people of the how many things in the legal system, medical systems, institutions and attitudes can be and are revictimizing so many Joannas that are not seen.
Thanks again to all involved for airing this piece.
3/3/04
Kelli C. Trinoskey
columbus, ohio
'Sentancing the Victim' is a brave, and profound story of the horror of not only violent crime, but our tentative justice system and the intense burden placed on victims like Joanne. Her bravery throughout the crime and the multiple parole hearings sends a loud message to criminals and to the judicial system : there are brave and relentless women, lawyers, and families who will not allow them to continue to victimize them.
This film moved me, angered me and motivated me to get involved in this issue.
Thank you.
3/3/04
Wow. This was a powerful program. My PBS station cut off the end of the program, so I don't know how it ended. Did Joanna decide to stop going to the parole meetings? Did anyone else hear the woman at the parole hearing let in the film tell Joanna she hoped she could "get over it"?! I could not believe she said that. These people need sensitivity training and need to watch this film.
3/3/04
Deborah Newton
Pocatello ID
I thought this was a wonderfully done documentary. I was raped when I was 8 years old. I, like so many, didn't tell anyone. Who would have believed me back in the early 60's. I did try to suffocate myself but luckily didn't complete the act. I finally told my mother when I was 24 and just shy of having my daughter.
I was wondering how this trauma effected Joanna and her relationship with men. How is her friend Julie? Did she finally seek help? Does Julie and Joanna still talk?
I agree that the system doesn't respect victims rights as well as it does the criminals rights. I know that in the long run the best thing for Joanna will be to move to a completely different state so that there isn't a chance of running into any of her attackers. She should not have to live in fear of turning a corner and running into one of them. One or more of them just might be of the mind set to want to confront her for them being in jail. Here again the victim is the one who has to always adjust their lives to be able to cope. I know the saying "forgive and forget" and "put the past behind" but those are just words. Facing reality is just not that easy!
I was puzzled by the way the Parole Commission acted towards the victim. Wouldn't it have made more sense to listen to comments/statements from the victim and prosecuter prior to the hearing? What if they had released one of the attackers on parole then heard something from victim that would question of change their belief that the attacker should be paroled.
I am proud of Joanna for being such a strong person.
3/3/04
Mike Stroman
Greenville, S.C.
God will have a special place in Heaven for heroes such as Joanna (and friend) and a very special place in Hell for the 5 "animals" that scarred her and the other girl for LIFE !
I accidentally turned to this program in progress and will recommend it to every "power to be" in the S.C. justice and parole system to alter our laws to correctly punish the CORRECT persons in such crimes - these prisoners should have NO RIGHTS !Unfortunately, Joanna is a "best case" scenario and she should be and is a role model for others to come forward NOW !
Thanks to Liz and PBS for a superior program.In regard to Joanna and your terific Mom and Dad; stay the course of your actions and keep your faith in humanity - we are all behind you !
3/3/04
Marsha
I just have a short comment to make...Joanna Katz is a role model and hero!! I am very offended that victims have less rights than offenders, so it seems. I would like to start seeing more info on how we can all help people like Joanna by changing laws pertaining to this subject.
3/3/04
Randy Rogers
Marquette, MI
It is hallowed ground that Joanna and her family tred. I have nothing but pure admiration for her.
For a man with two daughters and four sisters it was a painful program to watch. I admit to thoughts crossing my mind that were anything but forgiving for those who must certainly be evil incarnate - or so we force ourselves to believe lest we lose all faith.
Randy
3/3/04
Edward Farrar
This film was an incredible tribute to the strength and character of Joanna Katz. As a father and a physician, I was incredibly touched. Thank you for your willingness to tell the story and know that you are awesome.
3/3/04
Arlene Feldman
Houston, Texas
The film was done so well, my heart certainly goes out to Ms. Katz her strength and courage is nothing more than amazing to me what the human spirit can overcome. Her parents were wonderful, I was very moved by the film and enlightened, I had no idea the laws were so un-just and basically re-traumatizing to the victim. If there is anyway for one to get involved in changing these laws please let me know. Thank you for a wonderful film, which was for me quite moving, painful, and at the same time so inspiring.
3/3/04
David Miller
Oklahoma City, Oklahoma
I think the film also shows an area of the criminal justice system that needs attention, the minimum/maximum length of incarceration.
If the perpetrator has committed a violent crime such as this and is sentenced to 30 years, then that person should remain in prison for the full duration of his / her sentence. This was an extremely violent and heinous crime.
Persons commiting these crimes know what they are doing and should removed from society at large.
3/3/04
Ruth Barrios
Edmonton ,Alberta Canada
Dear Joana,your TV documentary impacted me to the point I am writting to you. I have never written to anyone but I need to tell you that I am praying for you so you keep your spirit high. I pray for you to have the same courage you have demostrated until now to keep on carrying the light of the victims. May the Lord bless you with a rich spiritual life and may you have peace in the spirit. Blessing to your wonderful parents.
3/3/04
Michael Murphy
Traverse City,Mi.
I was so moved by the story I had tears in my eyes for most of the show. The rest of the time I was justifably angry at the indifferent parole board. It shouldn't matter if they are overburdened with a large caseload, it's their JOB to listen. I was especially appalled at the parole board member that thought she was off camera and said "she wasn't going to allow (Joanna Katz' attorney) to rant and rave". That lady has no compassion for the victim and is exactly what is wrong with the parole boards in this country. They say they "understand", but in reality they have no clue. I must say however, thay Joanna Katz is without a doubt the most courageous individual I've encountered in a long time. I also feel the sentence did not fit the crime. When 30 years means you serve 15 this becomes a slap on the wrist--these animals should have gotten life.
3/3/04
Columbia, SC
As I watched this film, I could not imagine what these two women actually went through that horrible night. I am the same age as Joanna and cannot count the many nights I have walked to my car with a girlfriend after a night on the town. Especially when I was only 19! It made me wonder what saved me from something like this, how could this have happened to someone so young and vital, and how could the State of South Carolina sentence her to a life of rememberance??? HOW??? As a resident of SC, I had no idea that this is how the parole system works. Call me niave, but I didn't have a clue. This film has opened my eyes and made me realize that I should be more aware and that I need to have a voice. We all need to take a stand! I commend Liz Oakley on the story she has told and cannot express to Joanna Katz enough on the impression her nightmare has made. I do not think I could ever be as strong as she was that night and still is today. What an amazing person she is............
3/3/04
Charlotte, NC
I watched Ms Katz's story last night. I must have caught it close to the beginning. I came in where she and Julie are abducted. I really wanted to change the channel. I knew if I listened to her ordeal that I'd never get to sleep. And I didn't.
But there was something in Joanna's spirit. Her courage in telling the story and in what she did during and since the attacks - I couldn't stop watching it.
Ms Oakley captured it well. Today I can still hear Joanna say about fighting the parole process - Who's a better candidate than me to fight it. When so often we all want someone else to step forward.
It's the same attitude she had when she walked away from one of her assailants. The same attitude when she refused medical treatment to help find Julie.
It's 2004, and still we hear about sexual assaults at our universities, in our military.
We need Joanna Katz's story. Thank you to Liz Oakley and to Joanna for telling it. It was a gift to hear and it has inspired me.
As my Aunt Beth from Mt. Pleasant, SC would say - she's a real sparkbuster that Joanna.
Thank You.
3/3/04
Rose M Gagnon
Sherwood Park, AB, Canada
I just wanted to say how much I admire Joanna Katz for her courage and strength. No woman should have to go through an ordeal like that.
1. The criminal justice system should be reformed so that witnesses should not have to appear time and time again, to keep someone deservedly behind bars. There must be a better way (ie video of statement)
2. Yes, I agree. Joanna Katz's story is a very, excellent story. I was struck by her courage in the face of a hopeless situation.
3. It is important for self-healing as well, to come forward. Every woman has a right to stand with a fist and declare I am worthy of better than this.
3/3/04
Paul Cohagan
Yukon, Oklahoma
Joanna Katz's courage to move forward, and work towards victoms rights, is a gift from God. The men that raped her will face God someday, and Does it make a difference who they are? People like these guys exsist everywhere, and as long as this kind of hate stirs in their souls, rape will only get worse? As bad as this crime was, without hearing from the rapist's, the whole story will never be told. To think they had absoutly no reguard for human life, and capable of doing this horrible crime, makes me wonder? Bless the Katz family, and everyone envolved in her story. I pray her work makes a difference. I know it got my attention.
3/3/04
Joanna - I can't stop thinking about you after having seen the presentation last night. Nor can I begin to imagine your trauma, or your hurt, nor the pain to relive the experience for this production. Please know this. It is through you that we have had the privilege to know your parents, their beauty and their unbelievable courage through this calamity. We now know about the parole system, the harassing legal process that victims endure, and of course, we are changed forever by you. We are all more human because of you and your legacy goes out in ways you may never even imagine, to touch even the beasts among us. I salute you, brave woman!
3/3/04
Harold Murray
Little Rock, AR
I was drawn into Joanna's story last night as I watched this film. I've heard news stories of rape, but never have I understood what a victim endures until listening to Joanna speak.
The grave injustice in our 'justice' system is that she and other victims have to relive their relentless pain at each parole hearing.
If Joanna gets to read this, I'd like her to know that I'm proud of her for speaking out. You have not allowed your attackers to win! You are in my prayers.
3/3/04
Roanoke,VA
In response to the first question why do the prisoners get rights? What htese men did to Joanna and what men like them do to woman everyday should automatically surrender their rights. Joanna's rights where surrender when the gun was stuck in her ribs.
As someone who experience a rape that was very similar to Joanna's and Jill(?) after seeing what she went thru I'M GLAD DIDN'T TELL ANYONE. I'm glad that I pretended that nothing happened that I was just robbed - That was so much easier than what Joanna went thru.
If Joanna gets to see this - Thank you for speaking out and doing what I would never have the courage to do. I hope that you do make a differance in how victims are treated - I don't think you will - the parole board wasn't even listening - but if you do then woman like me won't be afraid to tell the truth.
3/3/04
San Antonio, Texas
I found myself captivated by Joanna's story. She is a remarkable woman with a remarkable family that have stood by her and supported her through this horrific experience. There are not many people who would be strong enough to survive what she has and endure what she does or insightful enough to see so clearly how fortunate she is with her family and support system to help her work through this. God Bless You Joanna and thank you for sharing your story and making a difference in so many people's lives.
3/3/04
Gwen B. Hammond
Hollywood, SC
Powerful!
3/3/04
Donna
Charleston, WV
Joann, I was truely moved by your story. I am a registered nurse who works with rape victims of all ages on a daily basis. I truely could never imagine all the emotions and healing a rape victim must go through. It would be nice to have this to use as a training tool for nurses who work with rape victims. I plan to watch this again. I truely could not move from the tv once the movie started. Your strength is amazing. Your family and support system are wonderful. Your attorney, truely caring. I am also a paralegal, and feel clients of attorneys don't often get the time they deserve. You did. Continue to grow in your strength and your quest of concuring your experience.
3/3/04
Mrs. Terrell Marchetti
Racine, Wisconsin
I happened upon this film while getting ready to go to bed. I couldn't stop watching it and had to see it through to the end. Joanna is such a strong woman and I don't know if I would have had the strength to do what she has done. Her parents are such an awesome support system and I'm sure that keeps her going. It was discouraging to see how the parole board treated her. Only one woman on the parole board showed any emotion and it was minimal. I wonder if parole boards are coached into not getting personal with the victims. How else could you not be affected by such a horrific series of events? Stiffer penalties do need to be enforced and Joanna is just the person to accomplish that. I think this will be a lifelong journey for her and I hope she can make a difference in the justice system as she has in other victims' lives. Thank you, Joanna, for being a part of this film and I wish you peace and happiness.
3/3/04
Harold Kay
Easley, S.C.
This was a VERY powerful story. I am ashamed that it happened in the state that I live in. I am so proud that Joanna Katz lives in my state though.
If there is any justice in this world, this should cause some changes to be made in S.C.as far as victims of violent crime and the parole hearings of the perpetrators. This film should be shown to our Legislature, bar association, judges, anyone who is involved in the criminal justice system in this state. Because right now it is a travesty for a young woman like Joanna to have to relive the horror of that night time after time after time.
Kudos to Liz Oakley for a story well told and the guts to tell it.
3/3/04
Steve Glover
Arlington, VA
I couldn't sleep the morning of March 3rd, and was just flipping through the channels on the TV at 4 am. Soon, I saw one of the most powerful humans I have ever seen telling a story that spanned the entire range of my emotions - from horror, shock, outrage to sorrow, longing to faith, hope, and love. The strength of the Joanna and her parents was inspirational and makes one think of all that is good in mankind. Nobody should ever have to go through what Joanna did...either the obduction or the continuing aftermath. I don't know what the future holds for all involved, but I hope that for Joanna it will involved continued activism for the victim's rights. Nothing will change what has happened to Joanna, but, maybe with her actions, one other person won't have to fall into the same trap. God Bless You, Joanna. God Bless your family and those who have supported you through the long ordeal that is the aftermath of that horrific night.
Thank You. Thank You all for bringing me that shocking look at the way our Criminal Justice system treats those who are the victim...Hey, South Carolina, I would think that VTC technology would at least save Joanna and her family the drive to Columbia from Charleston...
Joanna, don't give up and don't quit. That is when they will have won.
Steve Glover
3/3/04
Portland, OR
Thank you for your excellent film. My heart goes out to Joanna Katz for all she has suffered, and continues to suffer. Your story is a real eye opener for me.
I have a sister who was raped as a young teenager. My parents, for whatever reasons, decided not to go to the police. I was very young at the time and was not told what was happening. All I knew was that something bad had happened and that my sister was different. I think my parents tried to forget about it and encouraged my sister to do likewise.
I think now that this was the wrong thing to do. I can see how my sister has paid the price with mental health problems and the inability to share in any kind of a lasting relationship with people in general. She was fragile to begin with, I think, and the rape just made things worse.
We are all grown into middle age now. Our parents are dead. My sister and I have a strained relationship which we have not, so far, been able to repair. But I think I understand some things about her a little better after having watched your film. Thank you.
3/3/04
William Davis
Redwood City, Ca.
I must say that this story was beyond a doubt very disturbing to me. The mear fact that the criminal justice system and the people that protect the criminals have the laws in their favor is unreal. I felt so vacant I really felt for Joanna, just the idea that she has to endure this crime and injustice year after year is sickening. To relive a horrible event in your life every year, is that justice?
I happened on the segment by accident and could not move away or change the channel. Joanna is a very strong person and I can not say enough for her courage. I would love to see a law put into the books that protects victims like Joanna and other victims of violent crimes. I would support any law that protected the rights of the victims and not that of the criminal.
Victims do not deserve to live in the shadows. They deserve the right to be left alone and given the opportunity to heal. The confort of knowing that the person or persons that committed the crime against them will not be allowed to repeat such crimes against anyone. They should not be allowed to contiue such crime past the point of the trial. They were put in prison to be penalize for their crime/s. Let them serve the time the were given. Theres no time off for good behavior. If they were good to beggin with there would not have been a crime, there would not have been a victim. Joanna and other victims of violent crimes would not be victims.
We say that we are civilized but how can we really believe that when we victimize the victim. As I watched on I was waiting for the point at which time the parole board would just say that there was no need for Joanna to appear for the hearings anymore. That she could get on with her life and not worry about early parole. Never happened and I was just shocked, actually I was mad.
I am sorry that these victims have to endure our lack of caring. Because we all need to get involved, we need to truly make the criminals responsible for their crimes and not place the burden on the victim.
sincerly,
Will Davis
3/3/04
Konrad Solomon
Honolulu, HI
This would be an outstanding program with a powerful message, EVEN IF its production values were only half as high as they are! This was some of the best use of the power of broadcast TV in recent memory. At the very least, Liz Oakley, Joanna Katz and her att'y Mr. Sinclair deserve public gratitude for reminding those on the business end of our criminal justice system that "the cure should not be worse than the ailment." It's clear that Joanna Katz is a very strong person; what others can learn from her story is that securing and maintaining justice can be so difficult as to be prohibitive of justice. Common decency demands that we aid victims in their journey to justice, as well as to healing. Don't punish victims! Lawmakers and would-be servants of justice, take note.
3/3/04
Lance T. Alameda
Sausalito, CA
Hello,
If it is at all possible, please convey to Ms. Katz that she is an amazing person and a true hero. Although she may already know this, it is important for me to say that I wished that I had one, one hundredth of her strength and resolve.
The documentary, SENTENCING THE VICTIM, was both powerful and profound. I am weaping even as I write this. I wish it was within my power to wipe her pain and the pain of other victims of abuse from this world, but I know that is impossible. I wish her to know though that her story of courage has touched me, and that I will do all that I can to raise my children and all children that I can influence to understand the evil that can occur if one has no compassion or regard for their fellow humans.
I hope that my emotion after viewing a story such as this is not conveying me as naive, but I hope that we can all make a difference in this world. I hope that I can make a difference as Ms. Joanna Katz has been able to do.
Joanna, I wish peace and happiness for you and your family. You are all a shining example of what we should all aspire to be.
Warmest regards,
Lance T. Alameda
3/3/04
Jerry Stein
Novato, CA.
I was riveted to the screen for the entire length of this documentary. It was so intense to hear and see the transformations occur as Joanna tells her stories at different times to everyone. She began her account exhibiting the appropriate emotional context one would need to have in order to relive this horrible experience. As the film unfolds we see the secondary toll being taken due to the ignorance and short-sightedness of the parole board. Joanna moves from enthusiasm to emotinal lethargy based on exhaustion and frustration concerning the seemingly callous and routine statements at the hearings. The next transformation occurs when she realizes the reality of her dillema and settles in with the strength she exhibited in the beginning and channels that to help others. She is to be applauded for her ability to withstand the horror of several "Rapes", one at the hands of the perpertrators and the other at the mercy of the system.
From a personal experience I was involved in a situation in which I felt some of the frustration she may have felt. I was brutally atacked and stabbed twice by someone I never knew nor had any words with. He was on a drug called PCP and actually had a record of doing this same thing prior to me. The city of San Francisco determined that because I was a drug addict at the time it was not necessary to prosecute this individual beyond a slap on the wrist.
My rights were completly eroded at the moment of my admission to having a substance abuse problem. The first stab was from behind and punctured my lung. The next was after I spun around to see who or what was atacking me and received the second stab on my jaw bone. It was actually a blessing that the blade hit that spot, just a 16th of an inch lower, would have cut right into my throat.
I went to court several times to try to put this person away as long as possible so that it would be more difficult for him to victimize someone else. The city plea bargained with him and the end result was that attempted murder which is what it was, became "aggravated" assault. He served no time but I still do, in my dreams and waking life as well.
3/3/04
San Francisco, California
Joanna's story needs to be heard. When I was 14, I was the victim of molestation and the daughter of the perpetrator was my best friend at the time. Three years after the abuse, I was summoned to the local police station for questioning and soon after was sent to testify against my friend (Annette's) father. Only then did I learn that not only was I not alone, but his daughter was the victim of repeated rape and forced fellatio by her father. I don't even know if her father is in jail or not but late in 2003, his daughter, Annette, took her own life. It grieves me to know that if only Annette would have had the support and understanding (or maybe even presense) of a loving network of people to listen she may still be with us today. Sadly, she was the victim and got the death penalty. Thank you for your bravery, Joanna. Thank you for living. Keep talking and listening and being heard.
Love and Strength
3/3/04
My heartfelt thanks to Joanna Katz, who has had the courage to be a voice for the many victims of rape. How fortunate we live in an age, finally, where the rape victim is treated as a victim. At least, it appears so on the surface.
But have we become such a politically correct society that finding a way to "recognize the rights of both victims and prisoners" should even be asked? The prisoners gave up their rights when they attacked their victims, and they eventually get to go free. The victim will never be free.
Yes, there's a much better chance of the criminals being convicted in our present day than, for instance, in the 1960's when I was gang raped. And for most victims of rape, I believe counseling and group therapy would be the best avenue for dealing with their trauma. For others of us, it's been buried right under the surface for so long that we'll go to our graves with it. Hopefully, fewer victims will take the latter route.
Thanks again, Joanna. My daughter's generation, and all that follow will reap the rewards of your bravery.
3/3/04
Anchorage, Alaska
An incredibly haunting story that we should all be thankful to Liz Oakley and Joanna Katz and Joanna's parents and attorney for. I am left wondering if parole board members' terms are too long so that they unwittingly become hardened to victims' cases and on-going grief and become a part of a poor parole process instead of useful in their knowledge and influence to bring about obviously needed court changes?
3/3/04
Jack Eames
I would like to comment on the courage of Joanna. I cannot imagine the absolute hell this girl went through during the rape. Then to have to relive the entire experience as many times as she had to every time she appeared before those parole boards.
I agree with the statement above. I watched the film this evening and I beleive Joanna is truly a hero and I applaud her.
I am glad the movie has changed the parole custom in her state.
Good luck Joanna.
3/3/04
Margaret Auth
Victims rights and survivors of sexual crimes can have no stronger advocate than Joanna Katz. This amazing woman's story opened my eyes to the injustice of having the victims come before the parole boards again and again to relive the horror of their stories. We are still woefully negligient in balancing the hardships imposed on the victims with the rights of the convicted. I hope that state legislators watch this and attempt to change laws in their own states to make sure that the victims are not revictimized by the criminal justice system and that perpetrators of violent crime have to serve the majority of their sentences before any chance for parole.
3/3/04
Walter Kendall Jr
Columbia, South Carolina
I woke up to this young ladies story being broadcast on PBS and the more I watched it, the more of this womans hurt and pain I felt. I am going through some difficult times in my life and it made me feel very ashamed of my self that I can let certain things bother me that seem so small in comparison to what Joanna and Julie went through. My heart and prayers go out to these two beautiful ladies as well as the countless other victims that have to deal with this terrible ordeal on a daily basis.
3/3/04
Maggie Kazel
Duluth, Minnesota
For my daughter, for everyone's children, this documentary needs to be in every high school. Every single high school, now, today ... yesterday would be best.
THANK YOU from every cell in my body. Really. The story, the way it was filmed and told, so eloquent, honest, incredibly gripping ... all the time deeply straightforward and providing dignity and compassion to the victim. I so appreciate this documentary. The hidden amount of sexual violence in our culture that is tolerated on a daily, hourly basis is reprehensible. Joanna, Liz, Joanna's parents, her attorney, her advocate ... THANK YOU ALL SO MUCH. You have shared deeply, you have shared well, you are changing lives and systems for the better. SAY AMEN SOMEBODY!!!
3/3/04
holly loewen
canada
Joanne, thank you for having the courage to share your story. Our daughter had a very similar brutal rape happen to her at the age of l5 and she suppressed it until she was 19. It reared its ugly head right after she was rear ended by a truck at a stop light. Came from out of nowhere like another brutal blow until she couldn't suppress it any longer. Her cry for help was and attempt on her own life. We went through a hell of our own but nothing I'm sure of what out daughter had been through alone...time has healed some things however the scars go deep and she won't convict these men..she is afraid of the whole ordeal. The brain is only as amazing as it wants to be , sometimes pushing a huge trauma down can only protect you for a time until something wakens inside and you have to deal with it all over again. I appreciate your parents and their undying love Joanne. Our prayer is that our daughter feels the same in knowing that we love her as much!!1We are afraid there is more ..more that we don't see that will surface in her future. No closure.. She has chrones. Her body cries out even if she can't. Our hearts ache most of the time for her. we embrace the good times...their are also good times in spite of this tragety..Thanks again Joanne for your courage for keeping these offenders off the streets. You have protected so many women!!!Respectfully Holly.
3/3/04
Carol Richter
Vale, OR
I was myself the victim of rape, accompanied by a gun and severe beating - a 13-hour seige during which time I was raped violently 8 times. That was in 1994. Local law enforcement failed me utterly and treated me like a criminal - even to this day. Nearly ten years later, I have never been able to receive any support from family or friends. I have a deep desire to be held and be allowed to cry. I am still enraged against the system that was supposed to support me - and bobbled everything, even refusing to do a rape examination! The local physician did not examination my head injuries (I was beaten with the stock of a rifle). The neglect and indifference is inexcusable! I am a very strong person and have held it together, but no one should have to be that "strong." No one wants to hear about it. I applaud this show which has allowed me to reflect on the incident and all the attendant circumstances both before and especially after. I want so much to use this experience to help others and I haven't even found a way to do that. It has cost me dearly - shame in the community, alienation from my children, suspicion from others, and terrible accusation from my parents. If I can do anything to help prevent this suffering on another's part, I want to do so. My deepest thanks to this courageous young woman - and to her incomparably supportive parents. Seeing and hearing this story has been wonderfully healing to me.
3/3/04
Genie
Nampa, Idaho
I was raped but did not have the courage that Joanna possesses. And my experience was not as severe as hers was. I salute her for her courage, stamina, and obvious faith in God. I hope that she can have eventual victory over what she has suffered and is continuing to suffer in her struggle with the obsticles in our judicial system. I also salute her parents and her lawyer!!! May God bless all four of them!
3/3/04
Charleston SC
What an outstanding documentary. The strength that Joanne possesses after what she has been though truly inspires me. While I watch, many parts of the story were too horrible to completely comprehend. The crimes against Joanne and Julie were hideous!
However, I find what has infuriated me and makes me type this - is the parole board. To think that this team of people have been put together to make such decisions, quit honestly frighten me. I was socked! Beyond doubt it seems that the board has no interest in the victums comments. It is clear the board members have no insight on human feelings. The lady member - seem to be giving Joanne well wishes, comments that "she hope that someday you will get over it". (What) Get over it. I believe it was the same lady that commented that she would think that the hearings would seem to be "Therapeutically" Is she out of her mind. Does she still have a job after this has been shown?
I wonder-if her daughter, granddaughter, or she ever sat in front of a parole board, what Would be her minimum expectation? Would she then understand the importance of being heard? Her comments were dim-witted and seemed to be unqualified. Joanne tolerance is what I found amazing.
Qualities of a parole board member should be of one showing: compassion, empathy, understanding, Patient and to do so with sincerity. Based on this documentary none of these traits slightly appear.
Please let me know what I can do to help, how we can make this change.
3/3/04
David sansing
Ethelsville Alabama
First i must say ,Ms. Katz is a remarkable woman.It amazes me the strength it took for her to carry through all she endured.I wish her luck and peace on her quest to get justice ,not just for herself,but for all who suffered ,such tradgedies.
I can also understand her frustration as most who do come foward as victoms .Our justice system seems to neglect the victoms as they worry more about the the perpetrators' damn rights .Laws need to be changed and stengthened as well.Stronger penalties and less paroles for convicted fellons of rape and murderers as well.Too many times ,they are let out and only to commit again.Why should the victoms have to be put through all that emotion again so soon and for so long when they are trying to get on with their lives and regain their whole being.
It really took me back that those parole board idiots were so cold and like robots just trying to get the hearing over with.Like they had no feelings or remorse for those who suffered the ordeal they have had to live with.They just said the same thing over and over like routine and passed her by.Ask anyone of them,how they'd feel if it was them or someone the loved.and then be treated like "NO BIG DEAL"
And to the one woman that had a fuss because their laws was question,well dear you'd better be glad it was not me you responded to like that.It is your job to be able to contain criminals,but more so to protect the victoms.SO do your DAMN job you were elected to do.we as people can change the laws if everyone was to put the pressure on to get them changed.Do you want your daugther to be the next victom????
3/3/04
DANNY CASTILLO
HOUSTON,TEXAS
dear joanna, thank you,for going and helping all those that need your courage. those of us that know not what you have gone thru,and reaching out to those who have,and can see in your eyes,that there is life after rape.please belive when i say that you are truliy my hero,i know that your sprit is strong,and your love of life will carry your message.to those that need to hear it,i was watching your story on pbs and you have touch my soul.the world is a better place to have such a fighter ,for life as you have shown,in this film.may happiness,be with you may god bless you all the days of your life and may one day,our system of justice,be for the victims.
THANK YOU
DANNY CASTILLO
3/3/04
This was a great revelation, I hope, to those who think a victim "should be over that." I was raped on March 21, 1974 by a man who was sentenced to 10 years and, given 'good time' was probably out of prison before I quit panicking and having to leave stores (the rape happened in a store I managed). Two things not mentioned in the video: 1) the victims address ia a part of the public record (the information is in the video, just not emphasized--the parole board notifies her of hearings--theirs are public meeting subject to open records) and 2) modern rape victims must worry about AIDs as well as all the other veneral diseases and the possibility of pregnancy. Also, rape is an presence in your live that you control but that never goes away. Victims receive a life sentence. Even when I do not think about it, I get nervous and have nightmares in the end of March--still.
3/3/04
ryan toshner
oshkosh, wi
i started watching this pbs show and right from the get go i felt very apalled at what man is capable of doing. everyone should watch this film. numerous times i broke down and cried while watching this film. i felt the utmost sympathy for joanna her friend and all their family and friends. i think that joanna has more balls than any human being to go through with this documentery and tell what she went through. my props go out for her to do this and i think, or may i say i hope , that everyone that sees this film will think twice about what the effects are for men and women alike to go through sexual assaults. thank you again for bringing this piece of film to the public. and i hope the best for everyone involved in this incident, and i hope when and if the other four get out they screw up somehow and get put behind bars for the rest of the lives,how they should of been in the first place.
3/3/04
Peter Ferguson, ACSW
Ann Arbor, Michigan
Powerful, very disturbing, heartbreaking and yet I feel certain that Ms. Katz's heroic courage is destined to bring about great changes in the judicial processes that often are antithetical to the healing of those who require the most gentle consideration. Is it important for victims to come forward? Watch this film before you answer that question. Thank you Ms. Katz, Ms. Oakley and PBS. I would be honored to stand in support behind Joanna at the next parole hearing, and it would beautiful if there were 10,000 others in attendance.
3/3/04
A girl
Ortonville
The film was so hard to watch. I cannot believe that over the years the system has not been changed! Adjusting the system to hold hearings for perpetrators of gang rape on the same date at the same time seems to be the least that can be done for Joanna, and other victims. I cannot understand why the board would make any decision before hearing the victims' statements. Are the statements not of any value???
I believe that Joanna is the exception to the rule when it comes to her strength and conviction. I was raped when I was fifteen by the most popular guy at my school. NO way could I have told anyone! I did not admit it to myself until I was laying on a hospital bed 4 years later, after delivering my first child, and my doctor told me that I had tore in an unusual place. I said, "Oh, well that's the same place I tore when I was raped." My doctor was like "well that's not in your chart, why didn't you tell me?". I felt like a total idiot, and those were my very first moments of motherhood.
Maybe after watching the torment experienced by rape victims in this film, people will begin to understand why women don't say anything...and maybe us rape victims might begin to grasp that we could. Personally, the thought of reporting my rape had never occurred to me as a possibility. Now, I don't know...maybe, one day, I will.
3/3/04
Bradley Ladwig
Madison, WI
This was one of the most moving documentaries I have ever seen. It was hearwrenching to listen to Joanna tell her story and disturbing to understand how the victim is further victimized through our judicial system. Joanna and her parents' strength is a true testament to the heros they really are. Thank you for bring the reality of rape victims to the public. And if you are out there Joanna, God bless you, from the bottom of my heart.
3/3/04
Carter J. Doering
Milwaukee,Wisconsin
Ms. Oakley and Katz, your film has just been shown on our PBS station here in Milwaukee and I must commend you both on the work. I have only words of compassion for what Joanna, Julie and her family have gone through. I am speechless at the horrific crime posed on her and Julie. Your film and story have touch me so. They say that the director of Lord of the Rings worked 7 years on his film as you did but I can't imagine the end roads taken by you two cannot in some way compare.
Please relay this message to your beloved parents. I will not soon forget the experiance you have given us, a glimps at personal courage in adversity as well as a judicial system that somehow forgets the Victim. God Bless and Keep you Safe.
Carter Doering
3/3/04
William E.
Inola Oklahoma
Of the many flaws I have noticed over the years with the legal system, one of the largest is what is termed as "criminal rights". In this particular case I see no reason why the criminal should have any rights what so ever.
Liz Oakley did a very complete and decisive documentary on Joann Katz's very traumatic and life changing experience without compromising the nominal threshold between too much and too little content. After 3 years of psychology in high school I am no expert and claim not to be, but as I have just watched this program I feel that Joanna Katz has grown into a stronger person from this experience although the cost of that growth has come at a price no person should ever have to endure. In the late 90's my cousin was molested at a very young age, and the boy who did this was not an adult at that time, the case was then dismissed pending 2 years of probation and register as a sex offender.
To this day nearly 10 years later that punishment does not seem adequate for the crime committed.
Earlier in my life I suffered the loss of a close friend who committed suicide after her father raped her, he was sentenced to 5 years since she was unable to testify as she had died 8 months earlier. He nearly didn't serve any time at all because there was originally a lack of evidence. He was released 1998.
Again I blame the legal system for not issuing a sentence that reflected the crime. I totally agree that victims of violent crimes including rape do not come forward because of their fear to re-live the experience, as cold as this may sound, those people need to realize their silence can and often does make them responsible for another innocent person becoming a victim.
As for having parole hearings for violent sex offenders, the state and local governments shouldn't even waste tax dollars on them. Given evidence beyond a reasonable doubt sexual predators and rapists should be sentenced to an indefinite prison term until that term is served and a complete and comprehensive psychiatric evaluation pending any possibility of coming before a parole board.
It is not a matter of how violent or traumatic the crime is for the victim that concerns the legal system, it's a matter of cost effectiveness. The reason these criminals serve half of their terms is because the state finds reasons to release them because they do not care to carry the financial obligations of keeping the criminals they put away behind bars.
I personally believe that these criminals should not be forced to sit in their jail cells receiving education, 3 meals per day and do nothing constructive while the tax payers, and often the very tax dollars of their victims paying for it.
3/3/04
Penny P. Moreau
New Orleans, LA
I am a parent of a murdered child, a son who initially just disappeared and was considered a missing person. It was not until almost 9 years after he was murdered when one of the two killers confessed that we finally found out what happened to our son Tim. The killers dug a grave on one night and strangled our son to death 2 nights later. After we learned what happened to our son, whose body has never been found, it took another 2 years to obtain some justice: one killer is serving 10 years, the other 12. From our own personal experience and the experiences of others whom we've come to know, I believe the most important reform which can happen to protect both prisoners and victims of violent crime is for Congress this year to pass the Crime Victims' Rights amendment to the U. S. Constitution (S. J. Res. 1 in the Senate and H J R 48 in the House). Victims/survivors need "standing" in the criminal justice system. Our voices need to be heard.
Joanna, how can we thank you enough for being so committed to surviving yourself and reaching out to others? You are just a wonderful young woman and I love your parents for all their love and support. I also want to thank Ms. Oakley for helping you tell your story to a wider audience.
It is so very important for victims/survivors to stand up for themselves in the criminal justice system. Joanna was and is a prime example of the courage it takes to do this. The title of the program is so true - the victim is truly sentenced in our criminal justice system and is often re-victimized over and over again by the system. Only as we victims/survivors let out voices be heard will any real change come.
Thank everyone involved for this powerful presentation.
3/3/04
Louisiana
Several women about my age were raped in Baton Rouge, the same time I was there at the university. It was really scary for me at the time, to be there with the serial rapist and killer on the loose. I especially identified with the last victim, thinking as I read a description of her and a bit about her life that it could just as easily have been me. Seeing this film and hearing Joanna's story was inspiring to me, and somehow it gives me courage, even though I have not been a rape victim myself. Thanks.
3/3/04
Michelle Melter
Pewaukee , WI.
Joanna, I'm the mother of 2 beautiful little red headed girls, My oldest that was a victim of sexual abuse. Not by a stranger but by a family member. Recently finding out that my youngest was also abused is tearing me up inside. I feel that I've been very strong but finding this out is reliving the whole tramatic situation over again. I have a very hard time with the judicial system I feel they think the criminal is the victim. It disturbed me tonite to hear that woman at the parole hearing tell you she hopes you get over it . She did not seem sincere at all. I would like to talk to her after she was gang raped or her child was molested and she would probably change her tune.
Seeing you tonite reminded me of myself, first of all I have to tell you I'm a hairstylist also and have no problem with talking to people. You have inspired me to do more for victims. I always told my husband I feel the need to help people since this, I'm just not sure where to start. If you have any suggestions on how I can help victims please contact me. Thank You for having a voice I'm so very proud of you for standing up and being a strong courages woman!
Sincerly,
Michelle
3/3/04
Merwin Abbott
Parrottsville, TN
Dear Joanna,
I have watched the entire documentary of your experience. You are a beautiful flower who has been tragically stepped on .. and tho damaged .. sprung back toward the light. Providence has annointed you to carry this cross. Walk tall. Today you may inspire thousands .. tomorrow millions.
Your parents are such a blessing. Their warmth and support comes though the story so well.
Your lawyer is sincere and dedicated to a strong sense of integrity.
The parole board get paid to "punch the clock". It seems that some creative thinking would help to streamline and redirect the justice system.
Joanna, you are a survivor (to live after all). It is my hope that your life will be "filled" with joy and blessings .. and many GOOD FRIENDS.
and SHALOM - Peace.
Blessings,
---Merwin.
3/3/04
Diane Brus
Michigan
After watching Sentancing the Victim I was left with many thoughts. My first thought is what a brave woman!!! I applaud Joanna and her parents. The courage that she showed on camera was remarkable yet, you could still see her pain. I have always known that our judicial system stinks when you are the victime. But to see Joanna and her family return time and time again, it seems that something could have been done. They seemed more concerned with giving the criminal his "chance" to speak and to have her travel all that way. The criminal lost that chance when he (they) violated her being! God bless you Joanna Katz, and hold your head high!!
3/3/04
victor
NY NY
I watched the Johana Katz story. Seems the fat lady on the parole board was more concerned with her next pizza than the rights of the victim . What is the deal down south? Those parole board members looked like a bunch of lazy, uncaring, on the clock employees.
That broadcast by PBS has encouraged me to become active with Victims Rights Groups and have the Legislators enact laws to make victims have more rights, criminals less.
3/3/04
Sonja
Jersey City, NJ
Thank you for making this film.
3/3/04
Amazing! This is how I would describe Joanna and her parents! God bless you for appearing in this film and trying to demonstrate the reality of what happens to the victim after a rape. Many victims feel that "forgetting" is the best way to go in order to deal with the consequences of rape. The problem with "forgetting" is that these rapist will continue to rape. I personally know the route taking of "forgetting". Many of us prefer to keep quiet for fear of being victimized this time by the system.
I can't express my admiration for your courage. This was an eye-opening film. Congratulations to both you and Liz. Please keep strong and do attend those parole hearings. We need survivors like you!
3/3/04
Long Island, NY
I just finished viewing Sentencing the Victim. I must say I could not leave the room once I started watching. JoAnne's courage is admirable and I think it's awesome to know she is championing victims' rights. What a powerful testimony! The film quality was also good. I was concerned to read after the film was over that one of the perpetrators have been released. It must be so difficult when you have worked so diligently. But your drive is an encouragement for us all to keep believing and keep working!
3/3/04
Trent DePonte
Maryville, TN
I found myself having difficulty getting through this program, and am not sure that I could have - except for the courage that Joanne showed - not only in telling her story, but in pressing forward in her continuing efforts to ensure both her, and other victim's rights. I do not know from where Joanne draws her courage, but I found myself needing to draw on her's numerous times. Thank you both for telling this story in such a powerful way, and thank you for making a difference. ~Peace~
3/3/04
Tina
It is so very disturbing to me that such violent criminals such as rapists and pedophiles get such rediculously short sentences. How in the world can we allow this to continue day after day, year after year? We hear these stories and see the flaws in our justice system but there never seems to be a big enough change. If a person (or persons) is as violent and cruel as these men were then they should never ever ever be free to do it again. And the victims should not ever have to endure the unnecessary process of re living this horror every year in front of calous and jaded people like the ones that are appointed to our parole boards. I was just plain mad watching the blank and bored looks on their faces. I hope that Joanna and Julie both have a life full of happiness and peace. And I hope that our system changes soon.
3/3/04
Somerset, NJ
I am a victim of Sexual Assault also. I am amazed with the strength Joanna has. You are truly an inspiration to all survivors of violence. I found the justice system very frustrating when I went to trial. I hated reliving everything & it made me very anxious going to talk about it. I hated waiting for the trial to begin & then waiting & waitiing for a decision to be made, as I just wanted to put it behind me & move on with my life. I don't think anyone will really understand this unless you go through it. It's a very screwy justice system & it's true a lot of people don't take their cases to trial for that reason. It's true the victim always has a longer life sentence than the perpetrator. I always fear running into the man that convicted the crime as he was released after 15 months. Something has to be done. Victims shouldn't have to suffer like this.
3/3/04
Jorge Pastor
Staten Island, NY
It is easy to see where Joanna Katz received the strength and the wherewithall that allowed her to endure to this day. Her lifelong experience was been shaped by the parents that she experienced. I wonder what kind of experiences would generate five individuals to commit such a crime, for they too are a product of their environment. How sad to think that parole boards are not as responsive to the emotional needs of the victims. None of us are safe as long as these predators are released into society to re-experience a permissive society.
3/3/04
Claudia Matney King
Tulsa, OK
Liz...This documentary was outstanding. I applaud you and Joanna for stepping out and taking on this incredible challenge. We all need to continue to fight for Victim's Rights. Your mom and I are sorority sisters.
In answer to question # 1...yes I do believe that the criminal justice system can be reformed.
Question # 2...Yes, I don't believe that very many victim's coulld do what Joanna has been able to do.
Question # 3...If victims don't step forward, the perps will continue to commit their crimes over and over again, and hopefully the judicial system will be changed over time.
3/3/04
jacquelyn cooper moore
hilton head island, south
Joanna Katz has the spirit of a warrior, the face of an angel, eyes that have seen evil, and a mind that will never escape.
This is the most moving film I have ever seen.
I see in this film the God's honest truth. I only hope society will open thier eyes and face the reality of the injustice of the "justice system".
As a 63 year old victim, I face endless appeals and trials. The appeals will never end until either the sexual predator or I die.
Which ever comes first.
Love to everyone connected to this project and a huge hug for Joanna's parents.
Sincerely,
Jacque Moore
3/3/04
Tom O'Dwyer
Thank God for Joanna. America is always changing and this film WILL have a dramatic effect on Parole Boards all around the country.
And if you read this Joanna, and you need someone to stand with you, count on me.
3/3/04
Kevin Looby
Joanna,
Your story was so moving I can hardly see straight. The tears I shed through the pallid light of your story cannot ever begin to match the rivers bled by your soul. While I do not know how to attack the roots of the problem that spawned your ordeal, you mentioned the pain endured by battered women, and I have decided at least to make the commitment to support a battered women's refuge in my area. God bless you for you your sprit, strength, and the soulful wisdom to tell your story. I hope it makes a difference in others as much as I believe it hass in me.
God bless your parents for supporting you in such a wonderful way. They truely must be anchors in your life :)
- Kevin.
3/3/04
I admire Ms. Katz' incredible courage and wish I could shake her hand. I caught the tail end of the program and came here to the website to read more as I found this story incredibly upsetting but wanted to know more. I came upon the date of June/1988 and became more upset because this was the same month and year that I was raped by a boy who I knew with the assistance of his friend. I told no one and have often wondered how my life would differ if I had. Ms. Katz attack was, I am sure; a million times more horrible than mine as I was not physically beaten, but pinned down for a matter of excrutiating minutes. I applaud her and hate that she has to be victimized again and again and again. I cannot handle hearing so many defend the rights of criminal rather than those of the victim. This program meant a great deal to me. I would be tempted to tell my story if I thought it would help others but even now after so many years I cannot talk about it.
3/3/04
Prentiss Hallman
Columbia, SC
I am still in a state of amazement after viewing Joanna Katz' story only moments ago. I am in awe of her presence, resilance, and her ability to share her story.
The Documentary was beautifully made to portray the real story and the pain and struggle that follows -forever. I want to commend Joanna's parents for their strength and advocacy. One would think this might be the obvious reaction for a survivor's family, but unfortunatly it is far from reality.
I intern for USC's office for sexual health and violence prevention with the opportunity to work with and learn from some very special advocates in the fight against rape. Despite the fact that I have viewed several films on the issue of rape this is the most telling, empowering and educational concerning the injustice surrounding our justice system. Congratulations on the victory concerning the combining of parole dates. Unfortunatly it takes shining a light on such injustices via the media instead of simply through the survivor's experience alone. Thank you! Wonderful job!
3/3/04
MARC RUNDBAKEN
MANORVILLE NEW YORK
MY HEART BLEEDS FOR THESE 2 YOUNG WOMEN. THERE CAN BE NO AMOUNT OF JAILTIME THAT WOULD COME CLOSE TO COMPANSATING THEM FOR THE PAIN THAT THEY WILL CARRY FOREVER. JUST KNOW, THAT THERE IS A SPECIAL PLACE IN HEAVEN FOR THEM AND THEIR FAMILIES, AND ETERNITY IN HELL FOR THEIR TRANSGRESSORS.
KEEP UP THE GOOD FIGHT!
3/3/04
Jerse City, NJ
Joanna,
I have two daugters 10 and 11. If there was ever someone that I would model them after It would be you. Your strength is a thing of beauty. I as a parent can only hope that I have the endurance and class that your parents have. They are a blessing and now my role models.
"What a women". All the best.
3/3/04
John D. Armstrong Sr.
Columbia, South Carolina
The state of South Carolina needs to drasticaly revamp their parole board system. Why can't the offer video teleconferencing for the victums? Why subject the victum to this ordeal of traveling to Columbia to testify? They should not.
3/3/04
Ellen Bunnell
Bradford, PA
Thank you, Joanna, for doing what many young women cannot do. Thank you for your openness, for your vulnerability and for your tenacity. May your life be a triumphal shout to all who see how a survivor lives!
3/3/04
RW
Miami, Florida
Thank God for Joanna Katz. What a Good Woman.
3/3/04
Stacy Perry
Charleston, SC
Thank you for your courage and your candor. I turned the program on tonight as a sort of background noise, and became entranced. Joanna, you are such a presence. I am impressed beyond words by your strength of character and wisdom. You have been sent by God. You have used your life in an amazing way. You have touched and inspired.
Now is the time to call upon Senator Graham to doing something meaningful in Congress for South Carolinians and the country as a whole. Reform this ridiculous system, I beg you.
3/3/04
Rene Hoagland
New York, NY
I think PBS is racist for showing the race of the supposed offenders. The prison industry is modern slavery and they are victims of economic apartheid.
3/3/04
Christopher Villani
Montclair, NJ
Excuse me, but did we even see a moment in this film in defense of the accused? For the record, the answer is no, apart from nine seconds of mugshots of three black guys two minutes before the end. What we get from this film is the prosecution's case stated, restated and gracelessly drilled into our heads until we simply must come to the conclusion that one side is so right the other side is not worthy of representation. That is not the way the criminal justice system is supposed to work. This film is partisan, one-sided and ultimately harmful to the idea that people accused of a crime are innocent until proven guilty.
The lack of objectivity in this film invalidates its relevance.
3/3/04
Ella Rue Buckheister
Mt.Pleasant, S.C.
It is incomprensible that victims of horrific crimes have to be saddled with the responsibility of keeping the perpertrator(s) in prison.
We also must protest the release of the murderer of our daughter,Kathy Buckheister Sanderlin each and every year.
Joanna has to go before the parole two or three times every year. We applaud Joanna for her dedication to make things better for future victims.
We feel that Joanna Katz is forever a victim (as we also are)and the system offers no relief for victims.
2/26/04
Tom Cubbage
Bartlesville, OK
I have seen a preview of this documentary film and it is awesome. Liz Oakley has a great storytelling style and it brings you right into the pain and anguish of Joanna Katz's experience ... both of the the rape and the many parole hearings that followed. This is a powerful story of a problem that few people realize is going on all over the country. The story does not end when a convisted criminal goes to jail; in fact, that is when a brand new ... and often very painful ... experience and story begins. Everyone needs to see and understand this story. It illustrates how out of control the criminal just system can get when the rights of a victim are not balanced with all the other humane considerations involved. Here the parole officials seem coldly indifferent to the victim; it is as if they are going through the motions because they have to, when it is obvious that a more empathetic approach would work so much better.
|
|
|
