Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

Your Take »

What's the shelf life of CDs and packaged music?

For people who remember back when vinyl records, eight-track tapes and even reel-to-reel recordings were the best way to listen to music and audio, it's a strange new world we live in. In the '80s, compact discs replaced vinyl, and audio cassettes have become scarce. And now peer-to-peer file-sharing networks let people download music for free -- despite the best efforts of the music industry to snuff them out. Apple's iTunes store and various competitors offer legal music downloads, while Napster and Rhapsody offer unlimited listening via the Internet for a monthly fee. Plus, you can now listen to digital audio through satellite radio, or hear streaming music on millions of Internet radio channels online. So how long will we need CDs or physical packaged music? Are the days of Tower Records numbered? And what will we miss if packaged music dies?

6 comments so far, Add Yours

 

Well, we'll miss the artwork -- that ended with LPs. However, Times they are a changin' and things are functionally obsolete quickly For example, the DVR/TiVo, while incredible is very limiting -- when it comes to disk storage. Someone will figure out a better way to record,store and manage video soon -- I hope.

 

JO BURFORD said:

February 1, 2006 8:23 PM

I WILL MISS JUST A CASUAL BROWSE NOT INTENT ON BUYING A COMPACT DISC,ALSO I LIKE THE JEWEL CASES AND THE ARTWORK, MY ONLY GRIPE IS THE INFERNAL PLASTIC PACKAGING AROUND A COMPACT DISC, YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN. PLUS I STILL WILL USE MY ONKYO DUAL CASSETTE DECK, ONKYO RECEIVER AND MY SONY DISCMAN,THAT'S MY IDEA OF LISTENING TO MUSIC.

 

First of all vinyl isn't dead, but it has moved out of use for Joe Six-Pack. Ironically the internet has helped revive its fortunes and Eastern European pressing plants (particularly in the Czech Republic) have moved the quality of pressings forward.

The move to digial loses a collector element which takes the big volume buyer out of the market and having wall to wall music lessens our appreciation of it.

The internet gives specialists advantages over the likes of Tower Records as they can exploit a global 'niche', downloads won't kill Tower but poor management that fail to adapt and mine these niches for business will.

 

Constance said:

February 3, 2006 10:37 AM

This is what we will miss when the days of control musing was enjoyable. There is, however, a much grander consequence to this trend. Why would we encourage our youth, (the obvious primary target in terms of marketing), to put plugs in their ears and on their phones and on their pc's so that they not once take time from the bombardment of noice, as it is quite clear this direction will lead to public advertising on the wire, as well. How's about a little reminder of less noise more peace. Not to mention, at the least, the type of influence you are allowing your youth to be bombarded with; we have a moral and spiritual obligation to our youth by not encouraging or supporting the "plugging in" of our kids! The only commercial I have seen for these types of media was for iTunes on Ipods showing the kids all acting like robots and out of control and then at the end drained like unplugging a robot. Is this what we want our children to know? Or do we give a damn about the programming of our children to be robots. The dire consequences are no less than complete removal from this planet. I am saying a silent oath to do my part to remind others that we cannot allow this to go on. Hello, is there anybody out there?

 

Your rules:
Please comment on the subject of the blog post itself.

Sorry but this comment is on one posting. I never ever (hardly ever) post on a blog or even comment anywhere. However i read them constantly. Whether i agree or not i enjoy all.

GED 5:38 02 Feb 06 said it all, at least for former wall to wall listeners, in the 2nd paragraph, last sentence.

"having wall to wall music lessens our appreciation of it. "

Even before iPods, MP3's-yes there actually was a time like that- people used to listen with virtually the same "phones" plugged into cassette music devices(this was even before CDs'). But the music is always the same: Good. Maybe the quality is much better now. I spent 24/7 365 hooked up almost all my life from the early 60's(we actually had earphones for radios way back in the dark ages) until the late 90's. And while i still love music especially hard rock heavy metal, not much of the "oldies" thank you, I no longer have the desire i once had.
"having wall to wall music lessens our appreciation of it. "
I'm afraid that says it all. Hopefully it's only me and not a trend. That is the only meaningfull thing i will say. The rest is pointless but sadly i did write it. Thank you

 

Bruce Potter said:

February 5, 2006 2:12 PM

Based on the headline, I thought you were talking more to the question of how long CDs will last, stimulated by some guy recently claiming that a burned CD would not last (reliably) more than two years.

If that is true, then the shelf life would probably be less than two years?

Post a Comment

Ground rules for posting comments: No profanity or personal attacks. Please comment on the subject of the blog post itself. If you do not follow these rules, we will remove your post. Keep it civil, folks!

By This Author

  • @FakeAPStylebook Editors Explain Their Overnight Success on Twitter

    For anyone who has suffered through reading the entire AP Stylebook for a journalism class, there's a cathartic release when reading the dry wit of the @FakeAPStylebook feed on Twitter. It combines parody of the journalism usage bible with funny repartee and the absurd. That mix has brought amazing success to the people behind the feed: more than 40,000 followers...

  • Harold Evans Sees Bright Future for Print-on-Demand Newspapers

    Evans is the editor-at-large for The Week magazine. He has written numerous books, but his most recent is called "My Paper Chase," a fascinating memoir covering his early years as a cub reporter, copy editor and eventually editor and publisher over decades of distinguished work. He connects what happened in those early years to the changes wrought by technology and the Internet, and what he sees as he watches his wife, Tina Brown, co-found and manage The Daily Beast.

  • 4 Minute Roundup: Twitter's Real-Time Search Deals; Bloomberg Rising

    Here's the latest 4MR audio report from MediaShift. In this week's edition, I look at the deals Microsoft made recently with Twitter and Facebook to incorporate tweets and status updates into its Bing search engine. Google quickly announced a deal with Twitter too, but why should we care? Also, Bloomberg bought out BusinessWeek magazine, but the jewel might well be...

Stay Informed

Who We Are

MediaShift tracks how new media -- from weblogs to podcasts to citizen journalism -- are changing society and culture.