Tax Tips 2007 Q&A - Real Estate
Tax Tips Q&A
Read Kevin McCormally's answers to tax questions submitted by NBR's viewers.
Click on a tax topic to explore related questions and answers.
This feature is intended to provide general information and education and should not be considered as investment or tax advice. Each individual should consult his or her own tax, financial, or investment advisor.
Real Estate
QUESTION: CLAIMING LOSS ON SALE OF RESIDENCE
Busniss failure in 1994 caused me to sell personal home ($124,000) to pay creditors. I had little income until 2002. Never claimed loss on home sale to pay business debts on tax returns. Can I claim loss from 1994 on home sale today (or next year) against my taxes now?
--Bruce, Portland, Oregon
ANSWER
Sorry, but losses on the sale of a personal home are never deductible.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: NEW LEGISLATION FOR PURCHASES OF FORECLOSURES
I have heard that a bill is pending that will allow a $7,000 tax credit (to be taken over a two year period) for purchasing a foreclosed home. Can you tell me when this is to become effective (for homes purchased during what time period) and if it will also be applicable to investors purchasing homes as rental property. The home next door to me is in foreclosure and I would like to purchase it as a rental unit.
--Xavier, Detroit MI
ANSWER
Sorry, but things are really in flux around this legislation. The House and Senate and the White House are far apart and it is impossible to know what the final bill will look like, let along when it will be effective, if enacted. Things may become clearer in the next week or two.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: TAX CREDITS FOR REMODEL
I bought a house and have completely remodeled it (new electrical, exterior stucco, resurfaced hardwood floors, new windows, new interior and exterior doors, new plumbing, new everything in kitchen and bathroom...) Are there any tax credits that I can take advantage of? How does the home improvement tax deduction work?
--Mr Stoddard, West Jordan, UT
ANSWER
Some of your efforts may have earned a residential energy tax credit, which you claim on form 5696: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f5695.pdf
You'll find info on the program here: http://www.energystar.gov/index.cfm?c=products.pr_tax_credits
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: LOSSES ON RENTAL PROPERTY
I have a condo for which I get rent of $1400 but I pay $1900 for interest on intreast only loan. All losses are counted in SCH E. but i see $-3000 entry as passive loss in 1040 line 13 while using TAXCUT 2007 software. Is it correct? I have entry of -23000 on line 17 from sch E.
--Pravin Chhaya, Springfield, VA
ANSWER
Let me take a stab at what's going on, based on the information you provide. The law classifies rental real estate losses such as yours as passive losses, and such losses generally are not deductible until yo sell the property that is producing them (this is an anti tax shelter rule). But, the law also includes an exception to allow people who actively manage their properties to deduct up to $25,000 a year of otherwise nondeductible passive losses. And, that $25,000 allowance is gradually phased out as AGI rises from $100,000 to $150,000 (on a single or joint return). So, if your income is somewhere in the phaseout zone, your deduction would be reduced, but not necessarily to zero.
If this is what's going on, the other $20,000 of passive losses is "suspended" until you have passive income to offset, or until you sell the rental property.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: MODIFYING HOME FOR MEDICAL NEEDS
I am 70 - had to move to first floor in small townhouse which required a sink and handicapped commode installed (non existent before) unclear as to what is a medical expense - total bill to contractor was $4,000. IRS said it is a medical expense - but Info. shows somethng about capital gains?? - have not had an appraisal in 10 years - confused - Please advise.
--Fot Vernon, Indian Head, MD
ANSWER
Such improvements can qualify as medical expenses, but only to the extent that the improvement does not increase the value of the home. Thus, if installing the sink added $500 to the value of the home, just $3,500 would qualify as a medical expense. If you can argue that the improvements did not add to the value of the home -- that a future buyer might want to remove them and thus reduce what he/she is willing to pay -- then you could argue that the full $4,000 qualifies.
This is a "facts and circumstances" issue. I hope this helps.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: HOW CAN I BENEFIT FROM PAYING CHILD'S MORTGAGE?
I have been supporting a child who has been unemployed for several years, including paying for the mortgage and property taxes on the child's condo. In addition to claiming the child as a dependent, do I have any opportunity, tax-wise, to benefit from this situation?
--R. Martinez, Chicago, IL
ANSWER
If you get your name added to the mortgage (so you are liable for the debt) and to the deed of the condo (so you are a co-owner), then you could deduct the mortgage interest (assuming this would be your second, and not third or more home) and property taxes (regardless of how many homes you own).
The law allows you to deduct such expenses only if you are legally obligated to pay them.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: DEDUCTING MORTGAGE INTEREST WITH ONLY DISABILITY INCOME
My only source of income is Social Security Disability benefits for which I can't and don't file a tax return for. I am a home buyer and would like to know if there is any way I can file a tax claim for the interest I've paid?
--B. Leone, Ridgecrest, CA
ANSWER
Sorry, but you can only deduct interest if you file a tax return and itemize deductions. If you have no taxable income and do not file a return, you can't deduct your mortgage interest.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: TAX DUE ON FORGIVEN DEBT
Dear NBR
I am filing Chapter Thirteen Bankruptcy in California. I have a Rental Property being for-closed in Phoenix AZ. If the bank sells the house for less than what is owed will I owe tax on the forgiven debt? Or if the court takes the property and sells it for less is the same tax liability an issue?
--Anthony Britton
ANSWER
Sorry to hear about your financial problems. There are two exceptions to the general rule that forgiven debt is considered taxable income. One is if the debt is wiped out in a bankruptcy proceeding. I'm not sure if that applies to you since the actions are going on separately and in different states. The other waives the income issue if you are insolvent -- defined as your debts exceeding you assets.
You may want to read the document you'll find at: http://www.irs.gov/newsroom/article/0,,id=174034,00.html
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: CARRYING-OVER LOSSES ON RENTAL VACATION HOME
We have a rental vacation home and our annual expenses exceed the rental income. we know I can carry over the excess expenses to next year. Once I retire in a few years, our modified gross adjusted income will be less than $100,000, and we will be able to realize up to $25,000 of these expenses against the tax on our non passive income.
What happens to the carried over expenses if we stop renting the vacation home and change it to personnel use before I retire and our income is reduced to < $100k?
--Richmond VA
ANSWER
The carried-over passive loses can be used against nonpassive income only when you sell the property. Converting it to personal use will not trigger the deduction.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: RULES ON HOME MORTGAGE INTEREST DEDUCTIBILITY
I understand I cannot make a first mortgage on my free and clear single-family residence and get an interest deduction if I use the proceeds to purchase another single-family for an investment. Where do I find this in the IRS publications?
--Earl Stanfield, Santa Barbara CA
ANSWER
The law allows you to deduct mortgage interest on up to $1 million worth of "acquisition debt," which is basically defined as money borrowed to buy or improve a home that serves as security for the mortgage. If you were to pay off your mortgage and then take out a new mortgage secured by the same home, the debt would not qualify as acquisition indebtedness because the money would not be used to buy the home (any part of the new loan used to pay for capital improvements would, however, qualify and interest on that amount would be deductible as acquisition indebtedness). Now, up to $100,000 of debt on that "new mortgage" on the paid off house could qualify as "home equity" debt, the interest on which is deductible.
You'll find these rules in IRS Publication 936: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p936.pdf
But wait, there's more: If you borrow money to buy an investment property, interest on that loan may be deducted. If the house you buy is rented out, for example, interest on the mortgage is a rental expense deductible on Schedule E.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: DONATION OF HOUSE FOR FIRE DEPARTMENT TRAINING
I donated my house to the city fire department to practice their skills before the house was demolished. I was told I can write off the donations as part of the charitable contribution. But what should I base the contribution amount on? Is that the replacemnt value, insurable value or structure value? Is the Fire Dept. considered a public charity or private charity?
--KEN, Virginia Beach, VA
ANSWER
Oh, my, you've really raised a complicated issue...and one for which I'm afraid I can't find a definitive answer.
Back in 1973, a Tax Court case (TC Memo 1973-265) allowed a taxpayer to claim a charitable contribution deduction, over IRS objections, for allowing a fire department to turn down a house as a training exercise. And, the deduction was based on the fair market value of the house before its destruction. However, the IRS is fighting a similar deduction in court now, so it's clear the government position is still to oppose such a write-off. Some observers believe the homeowner actually gets a benefit from allowing the fire department to burn down the house, reducing costs of removing the property so he/she can rebuild, for example, or reducing the volume of materials that must be disposed of.
I believe some tax advisors would be willing to recommend such a deduction and be willing to fight the IRS if the return were audited; others would steer clear of the deduction. I'm afraid I can't weigh in one way or another on that point.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: WITHDRAWING MONEY FOR FIRST HOME PURCHASE
I am 35 yrs.old. If i withdraw money for downpyment of 1st.home will it be penalty free? If so, how & whereit is to be reported in tax return? I think it will taxed @ regular rate. Pl.confirm. Thanks.
--SAJIB GUHASARKAR, FLUSHING N.Y.
ANSWER
Are you talking about withdrawing funds from a traditional IRA? If so, then yes, there is an exception to the 10% early withdrawal penalty for up to $10,000 withdrawn to buy a first home. The money would still be taxed -- in your top tax bracket -- but no 10% penalty would apply.
If you have a Roth IRA, you can withdraw all of your contributions tax and penalty free at any time, and then up to $10,000 of earnings can also be withdrawn penalty free to purchase a first home.
If you're talking about a 401(k), there is NO exception to the 10% penalty for first time home purchasers.
If you qualify for the exception to the penalty, report it on form 8606: http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f8606.pdf
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: TAX-FREE PROFIT ON HOME SALE
I plan to move to another state as soon as I sell my present home. I have been here more than 5 years. If I purchase in the new location and move and later sell my present residence, do I loose the primary residence status on the sale of the current property?
--Tarviler, White Stone, VA
ANSWER
That depends on how long it takes you to sell. The provision that allows homeowners to claim up to $250,000 of home sale profit as tax-free ($500,000 if you file a joint return) requires that you own and live in the house for two of the five years leading up to the sale. So, if you're already owned and lived in it for five years, you'll be okay as long as you sell within three years of the time you move out.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: IRA WITHDRAWAL FOR HOME PURCHASE
I understand withdrawals from 401(k)before 55 for downpayment of 1st house is penalty free. How and where do I report such withdrawal to aviod penalty? Thanks.
--SAJIB GUHASARKAR, FLUSHING N.Y.
ANSWER
Sorry, but the exception to the 10% penalty that applies to up to $10,000 withdrawn from an IRA prior to age 59 1/2 for the purchase of a first home does NOT apply to premature withdrawals from a 401(k). Such 401(k) withdrawals are taxed and penalized. You figure the penalty on Form 5329. http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f5329.pdf
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: INHERITANCE OF FOREIGN REAL ESTATE
I inherited money from the sale of my parent's real estate in a foreign country. The money was transferred to my bank account in the US. Do I have to pay any tax on the cash I inherited ($45,000) and also how do I report that to IRS. What form I need to file to inform IRS about it?
--SH, Denver, Colorado
ANSWER
Inheritances are income-tax free and do not have to be reported to the IRS. In your case, though, it sounds like you inherited property and then sold it. If so, you should report the sale on a Schedule D, to accompany your Form 1040. Your basis in the property would be it value at the time of death of the previous owners. If the value rose between that time and the time you sold, you have a long-term capital gain; if it fell, you have a long-term capital loss to report.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: TAX DUE ON FATHER'S RESIDENCE?
20 some years ago my father bought a house in NJ (his primary residence). He put it in both of our names. He's now in a retirement home and the house was sold last year. The title company did a 1099 for both of us. It was his primary residence not mine. Am I obligated to pay tax on half of the capital gain?
--John Peirce, Pembroke Pines
ANSWER
If you were simply a nominal owner of the home--put on the deed for convenience sake, and never claimed deductions for mortgage interest, for example, and received none of the proceeds from the sale--then no, you're not liable for the taxes on the sale.
And, make sure your dad doesn't report any gain that is tax-free. Remember, if he owned and lived in the home for two of the five years leading up to the sale, up to $250,000 profit is tax-free. And, there's a special rule for the use test since he's in a nursing home. In that case, he only has to have lived in the home for one of five years leading up to the sale (and time he lives in the nursing home counts as time he lives in the house he owned).
See IRS Publication 523 for details. http://www.irs.gov/publications/p523/ar02.html#d0e2072
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: DEDUCTIONS FOR SELF-EMPLOYED REALTOR
I am a realtor (and am viewed as one who has his own business). Is there a place where I can find a list of all of the deductions for a realtor? Thanks.
--David, Tulsa, OK
ANSWER
A good place to start is IRS Publication 334, Tax Guide for Small Business http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p334.pdf
I'd also suggest you check the website of professional organizations for Realtors; you might find more specific help there. And, by all means ask your fellow real estate professional about the resources they use.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: SELLING LAND IN NEPAL
Sir, I am from Nepal. If I sell my long term hold realty or land. Do I have to pay property gain tax. If not what documents do I should submit? Is there any different tax for realty and realty-property? Meaning sell of land whereas house? Thanks for valuable time.
--Lama, Vacaville, CA
ANSWER
Generally, any resident of the U.S. is taxed on his or her worldwide income. The sale of raw land would produce a capital gain or loss. So would the sale of a home, but up to $250,000 of profit on the sale of a home is tax free ($500,000 if you file a joint return) if you have owned and lived in the house for at least two of the five years leading up to the sale.
Sorry, but I'm not conversant with any tax treaties between the U.S. and Nepal that may avoid double taxation, that is, being taxed in Nepal as well as the U.S. on your income. Wish I could be of more help.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: USING IRA FUNDS FOR HOME PURCHASE
Hello Folks. First of all I watch NBR daily on PBS and enjoy every minute.
Tonight I took in the new Tax series and the rebate info. I have a question. Last year I purchased a home and used ALL of my IRA money to make the down payment. Can you please tell me what the IRS requires as far as reporting this purchase with my IRA funds and what form #s are required and where I can get them? Will I owe penalties for doing this in addition to tax?
Thanks Much.
--S. Soares
ANSWER
I'm assuming you're talking about a traditional IRA, not a Roth IRA. I'll also assume that you have not made any nondeductible contributions to the account. In that case, the amount withdrawn from your IRA is taxable income, to be reported on lines 15a and 15b on the front of your Form 1040.
If you were under age 59 1/2 at the time of the withdrawal you may owe a 10% penalty, too. The penalty is waived on up to $10,000 withdrawn from an IRA for a first time home purchase..and first time is defined as a home purchased when you have not owned a home in the previous two years....even if you owned a place earlier than that. If you qualify for this exception, it will save you up to $1,000.
You figure the penalty, and report the exception to it, on Form 5329 -- http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/f5329.pdf
All the details are in IRS Publication 590 -- http://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p590.pdf
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors
QUESTION: CAPITAL GAINS ON LAND
I bought a land 18 months ago. The land was bought to build my primary residence because I am still renting and do not own a house anywhere. I started the paperwork with the Township for getting the approvals. As a part of the process, I did get some survey and engineering work done. During the course of process Township indicated that they want to preserve the area as Open Space for the public good. They offered me the market price which I accepted and I am in closing process. As soon as the deal will be closed I will be looking to buy a house for the family. I just need an information on the capital gain tax. If there is any legal way I can minimize my taxes on capital gain I will receive on my deal. Appreciate if you can provide me some input in this issue. Thanks.
--Khursheed Khan, West Orange, NJ
ANSWER
If any of the "engineering" work you had done counts as a capital improvement (it would if you had electricity or water installed, for example), add that cost to the cost of the land when figuring your basis. The higher your basis, the lower your capital gain. If you arranged to have the proceeds paid to you over more than one tax year (e.g., an installment sale), you could stretch the reporting of the gain out over more than one year, too.
Since you owned the land for more than 12 months, you can treat the profit as a long-term gain, taxable at a maximum rate of 15%. If you're otherwise in the 10% or 15% bracket, the rate on long-term gains realized this year is 0%.
--Kevin McCormally
Editorial Director
Kiplinger Washington Editors


