Small Michigan museum holds massive collection of Edward Curtis’ Native American photography
In 1907, a Michigan librarian named Lulu Miller had a wild proposal. She wanted her library in Muskegon, then a bustling industrial port on the shores of Lake Michigan, to subscribe to a set of photos documenting North American Indian tribes living west of the Missouri River. She managed to convince the library board to pay $3,000 — roughly $80,000 today — to purchase 20 volumes from photographer Edward S. Curtis, who was largely unknown at the time. The small town library joined a handful of other subscribers, mostly wealthy and famous, including the King of England, President Teddy Roosevelt and Alexander Graham Bell.
In the years that followed, Edward S. Curtis became one of the most well-known photographers of his time, especially of North American Indians.
Now more than 100 years after librarian Lulu Miller’s gamble, these photogravures — the resulting images from a printing process that uses a metal plate and etching — have come out of their dusty volumes and are seeing the light of day. All 723 are displayed at the Muskegon Museum of Art, in what’s believed to be the largest ever exhibition of Edward S. Curtis’ work.
“Quite honestly, I never was entirely sure the exhibit could work,” said curator Ben Mitchell, citing the sheer size of the undertaking for a small museum. He’d wanted to mount an exhibition of 300 of the photos but museum director Judith Hayner was insistent: all or nothing. So Mitchell and a team cleared out four-fifths of the museum’s wall and floor space to accommodate the photos. But as the installation process got underway and the photos went up on the wall over the course of two weeks, Mitchell said, “I began to be very gratified. It worked. It really worked.”
Many of the images are iconic, some are controversial. There are portraits of tribal chiefs, sweeping landscapes and depictions of the daily lives of 80 North American tribes — the Nez Percé, the Navaho, the Piegan. What was intended to be a seven-year project took Edward Curtis 30 years to complete.
Mitchell said, “I think he began the project thinking they would all be gone, just be wiped out either physically through genocide but at the very least, forever changed, no longer have their rituals, their history, their language. Luckily, he was wrong.” For many of those 30 years, Curtis lived with the tribes he was photographing and controversially in some instances, paid his subjects to pose for him. He also made audio recordings of his work and took copious notes.
The exhibition tells both the story of the North American Indians he documented and also of the photographer himself. Curtis had pulled himself out of poverty in the late Victorian era.
“The people who were in charge were white men,” Mitchell said. “They firmly believed the world, the social and the human world, was a hierarchy, and white maleness was at the top, and in descending order were people of color from other places. We can’t condemn Curtis for [also having] that view.”
Larry Romanelli, the leader of the Little River Band of Ottawa Indians in Michigan, said Curtis captured a culture that would have otherwise gone unseen. “The thought was that Native Americans were going to be eliminated, and while that didn’t completely happen, we were diminished greatly,” Romanelli said. Native Americans now make up just 2 percent of the total U.S. population.
Early on in the planning stages, Mitchell involved elders from the Little River Indian tribe, the nearest Native American tribe in the Muskegon area. Even though their tribe was never photographed by Curtis, Mitchell wanted to assure the tribal leadership that critiques of the photographer’s representation of North American Indians would be included in the exhibition. He also asked them to perform a formal blessing at the public opening. Attendance is up 390 percent at the museum since the exhibition opened.
“In the end,” Mitchell said, “what could be more poignant for us to sense in this turbulent, troubled, fraught time than how important it is to learn from people who are not us.”
“Edward Curtis: The North American Indian” is on view through September 10th.