Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

a NewsHour with Jim Lehrer Transcript
Online NewsHour Online Focus
GOVERNOR MARC RACICOT

November 27, 2000
The Challenge

Republican Governor and Bush adviser Marc Racicot of Montana discusses the Democratic challenge to the certified Florida election results.


realaudio

 
NewsHour Links

Online Special: Election 2000

Nov. 24, 2000:
Shields and Gigot discuss the political landscape in Florida.

Nov. 22, 2000:
Legal Experts discuss the Florida Supreme Court ruling

Nov. 22, 2000:
A cardiologist discusses Sec. Cheney's heart attack

Nov. 22, 2000:
Shields & Gigot assess the political ramifications of the Florida Supreme Court decision.

Nov. 21, 2000:
Editorial writers from across the country discuss Florida.

Nov. 21, 2000:
The future of Ralph Nader and the Green Party.

Nov. 20, 2000:
The Florida Supreme Court hearing.

Nov. 20, 2000:
Journalists Brooks, Broder and Oliphant discuss Florida

Nov. 17, 2000:
The Florida Supreme Court halts the vote certification.

Nov. 16, 2000:
Four senators discuss this year's election.

Nov. 15, 2000:
Foreign nations and markets react to the U.S. election deadlock.

Nov. 15, 2000:
Cultural scholars assess the election deadlock.

Nov. 14, 2000:
Newspaper columnists discuss the election.

Nov. 14, 2000:
Four former Senators evaluate prospects for bipartisanship

Nov. 13, 2000:
Newly elected Congressmen discuss today's political landscape.

Browse the NewsHour coverage of Politics & Campaigns.

 

 

Especially for Students: The ongoing legal battles of election 2000.

MARGARET WARNER: Joining us from Tallahassee is one of Governor Bush's advisers, Montana Governor Marc Racicot. Thanks for joining us, governor.
Racicot and WarnerYou just heard Senator Lieberman say that if the 10,000 votes in Miami-Dade that were spit out by the machine and registered no votes, if they aren't counted that a cloud will be over the next president. Do you think that's true?

GOV. MARC RACICOT: I don't think that's true at all. To tell you the truth, I find it very disappointing. I think it's very unfortunate and it's inaccurate to reflect that there are 10,000 ballots in Miami-Dade County that weren't counted. There simply were no votes that were cast for the president in that particular election, and as a consequence of that, they can't in fact count. So this is a real disappointment for the Gore- Lieberman campaign to reflect to the American people that what ought to occur is that every ballot ought to be counted -- as a matter of fact particularly so when they have fought so hard to keep out thousands of absentee ballots in Seminole County and more than 200 votes that were cast, they've tried to have excluded in Nassau County. So the notion that they want every vote to count is just simply not the case. What Senator Lieberman is trying to reflect, I think, is just simply not what I understand, what I saw with my own eyes through three-and-a-half days to be the accurate situation as we've described it from here.

MARGARET WARNER: Just so I understand, you and Governor Bush believe, in other words, that all the votes were counted?

GOV. MARC RACICOT: Well, they clearly were counted. These are ballots that do not have one of the punches for president poked out of the ballot. So, there may be a mark or a scratch on the ballot from which the Gore-Lieberman campaign alleges you ought to try and discern whether or not that's a pause mark or that somebody intended to vote. And these are people they don't know -- they've never spoken with -- they have no connection to. How in the name of God could you ever claim to be able to do that with a reasonable certainty, which is required by Florida law?

Counting ballots

MARGARET WARNER: Now, they would say that these same ballots they're talking about have never been hand-counted at all and that many of the -- they're more than marks, that they are punched through perhaps and that these are the kinds of votes that were counted in other counties such as Broward or Palm Beach. I don't want to mention the word chad, but I guess I have to. These are ones where it was punched through but maybe it was hanging or whatever. You're saying that those shouldn't be counted anyway.

Gov. RacicotGOV. MARC RACICOT: No. I think what you heard Senator Lieberman say is that there are 10,000 ballots that have never been counted even once. I believe that's a direct quote. And the fact of the matter is they were counted and then they were recounted. And, as a consequence of that, you just simply cannot truthfully make that allegation.

MARGARET WARNER: Let me go back to his larger point which had to do with whether there are doubts about whoever wins. I noticed in the Washington Post/ABC News poll today which did say that 60 percent of Americans now thought it was time for Gore to concede, nonetheless only about a quarter said they were very confident that the Florida count was accurate. Does that trouble you or Governor Bush at all? Do you think there's any danger that, in fact, there could be a kind of cloud over him?

GOV. MARC RACICOT: Well, we know, of course, what the facts of the situation are. And we know that this was a very difficult election as was reflected last night by Governor Bush, but we also know that the American people expect that the law will be observed. It's been very unfortunate that the Florida Supreme Court decided that they would rewrite the law and change the rules, not only in the middle of the stream but after the game was completed. They know that there have been ample opportunities for the votes to be counted, recounted and in some instances three and four times, and I believe that the American people understand plainly that even though there have been challenges associated with this election, clearly when Governor Bush has been certified with the highest number of votes in the state of Florida, thereby achieving the highest number of electoral votes in this country, that he will set about to gain, I think, the opportunity for them to invest their confidence in him as he serves them ably into the future. So, no, I don't think that that's going to be a challenge or a difficulty for him as he assumes the presidency.

MARGARET WARNER: Let me ask you about one other thing Senator Lieberman said. He noted, of course, that Governor Bush has an appeal in the courts also at the U.S. Supreme Court. He said given that, he thought it was both premature and unrealistic for Governor Bush last night to have essentially -- I don't want to put words in his mouth, I don't remember his exact words -- but to declare himself as having won the presidency. How do you react to that?

A difficult contest

Gov. RacicotGOV. MARC RACICOT: Well, I think what Governor Bush did last evening, and I believe the American people understand this precisely, is to reflect to the American people that it's been a difficult contest, that it has been healthy, that the American people expect some finality, that we need to draw to a close, and there are some very grave and very serious responsibilities here that the next president has to assume. And he was declared the victor on election night. He had the most number of votes at least. He had the most number of votes after the recount. He had the most number of votes after the first certification and again after the last certification, and now it's time to move on. He has to face these responsibilities of forming a government. So that's what he was trying to reflect even though it's been difficult, we have to bring about those processes that will allow for us to serve the American people as they have a right to expect.

MARGARET WARNER: Last week before the Florida Supreme Court, Governor Bush's lawyer, Michael Carvin, began by saying, look, the time to be contesting, challenging, any of these results are after certification, during the contest phase. Is the Bush camp now suggesting that nonetheless, it is inappropriate or unseemly for Vice President Gore to be challenging these three counties or several counties during this contest phase?

GOV. MARC RACICOT: Well, the reality is everything that the vice president has requested in reference to this particular situation has been granted. He has received the opportunity to count and to recount and count again and in some instances again. And the fact of the matter is we know many more facts and circumstances now than we knew when those particular arguments were made. And as a result of that what the vice president is seeking is an opportunity to repeat the same arguments that he presented over a week ago. We know what the evidence is now, and there's no reason to continue on with long, lengthy, difficult, complex legal battles that will achieve no more finality than what we already have.

MARGARET WARNER: The issues before the U.S. Supreme Court on the governor's appeal on Friday aren't directly on point on the issues that now Vice President Gore is raising in these challenges. What do you expect the U.S. Supreme Court to really settle here?

GOV. MARC RACICOT: Well, we expect the United States Supreme Court to vindicate the principles of law that were embodied as a part of Florida law prior to the time, enacted by the legislature, prior to the time that the Florida Supreme Court chose to legislatively, assume a legislative function not properly reserved to that branch of government, and to declare that to be inappropriate and in violation of the Constitution in federal law. That's what we expect the United States Supreme Court will do when they consider this particular case.

Margaret WarnerMARGARET WARNER: But I mean, do you expect that somehow that will put an end to the challenges? I mean, in other words, do you think it will end this thing?

GOV. MARC RACICOT: Well, that will depend upon what the United States Supreme Court says precisely. It's our expectation that that principle I just articulated is what, in fact, the court will do. But whether or not we can predict with any degree of certainty exactly what will happen I think is a matter of great speculation.

MARGARET WARNER: All right, well Governor Marc Racicot, thanks for being with us.

GOV. MARC RACICOT: Thank you.

 

 
 

 


    REGIONS | TOPICS | RECENT PROGRAMS | ABOUT US | FEEDBACK |SUBSCRIPTIONS / FEEDS:
POD|RSS
SEARCH
Funded, in part, by:ChevronIntelBNSF RailwayWells FargoToyotaMonsantoCorporation for Public Broadcasting
            Support the kind of journalism done by the NewsHour...Become a member of your local PBS station.
PBS Online Privacy Policy

Copyright ©1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.