|
|
 | |
 |  |
| TOXIC FALLOUT | |
 April 16, 2002  | |
|
Ray Suarez reports from lower Manhattan
on environmental concerns provoked by the collapse of the World Trade Center.
|
|
| |||||||||||||||||||
| Residents near WTC return home | ||||||||||||||||||||
| PAT MOORE: As you can see, the dust has gotten into every nook and cranny, nothing was spared. RAY SUAREZ: The women want to know what's in that dust, and if and when it will be safe enough to move back into their homes, where they've lived more than 20 years.
RAY SUAREZ: Whitman's agency monitored air quality throughout the New York area, and the EPA cleaned the streets and public buildings of lower equipped trucks that remove Manhattan with specially equipped trucks that remove hazardous materials. The declaration that this was a disaster area triggered a federal response plan. The Federal Emergency Management Agency, FEMA, became the lead agency, divvying up responsibility for lower Manhattan.
|  | |||||||||||||||||||
| Outdoor air vs. indoor air | ||||||||||||||||||||
|
RAY SUAREZ: But the EPA's Whitman says her agency did the best it could -- given the plan it had to work with.
RAY SUAREZ: Many residents found the whole business confusing and frustrating.
|  | |||||||||||||||||||
| Mixed messages about air quality | ||||||||||||||||||||
|
And in March, twin task forces, formed by the EPA and New York Mayor Michael Bloomberg, came up with a plan for the city's Department of Environmental Protection to remove debris from rooftops and facades with EPA's guidance. But the obligation to clean up inside buildings in lower Manhattan was left in the hands of landlords, and a majority of New Yorkers are renters. Some tenants decided to do their own private testing, including bond analyst Sharon McGarvey and her investment manager husband Paul Martin who live in nearby Battery Park City with their two children. When we visited with them last September, they were in temporary quarters, and McGarvey wasn't sure her old neighborhood was a safe place to breathe.
RAY SUAREZ: When we met them again, the couple said the government never provided the information they needed to make an informed decision about their future. SHARON McGARVEY: By withholding information, they decided how much risk we would take -- not us. And that was clearly wrong.
RAY SUAREZ: Their own tests, done in March, showed low levels of asbestos, so McGarvey, Martin and their two children have decided to move further uptown. Jane Kenny, the EPA Administrator for region two, which includes New York City, concedes that there has been some confusion.
RAY SUAREZ: The EPA ombudsman, Robert Martin, and Hugh Kaufman, his chief investigator, have held two hearings so far at Congressman Nadler's request. The ombudsman's office ensures that the EPA is doing its job, and works to resolve disputes. They heard criticism from residents...
RAY SUAREZ: ...And charged that their own agency did not tell the truth. SPOKESMAN: The administrator of the EPA's statement to the public after the World Trade Center catastrophe was a lie. RAY SUAREZ: Hugh Kaufman says local and federal mishandling of contamination from the terrorist attacks will bring a second set of victims.
|  | |||||||||||||||||||
| New clean up challenges since 9/11 | ||||||||||||||||||||
|
RAY SUAREZ: EPA Administrator Whitman insists that 9/11 presented many new challenges, which will be met before people suffer any harm.
The problem you have in things like asbestos and fine particulate matter is the length of the exposure. It's not so much one hit; it's if you live with it over time. And I believe that with the kind of effort that's being undertaken now to cleanup the window sills, to clean the roofs, to find the money from FEMA if we can do it, or however we find the dollars to help with the indoor cleanup, that that will take away a lot of that concern because while you may feel uncomfortable for a bit -- short-term breathing -- it's the long-term health impact that we're really concerned about. If we get at it soon, as we are now, that should alleviate much of that concern. RAY SUAREZ: But isn't there a long-term presence if there's not a coordinated... CHRISTINE TODD WHITMAN: If they don't do a right cleanup. RAY SUAREZ:...Thorough, professional abatement? CHRISTINE TODD WHITMAN: If they don't do a right cleanup, yes.
|  | |||||||||||||||||||
 |
   
|
|
| Support the kind of journalism done by the NewsHour...Become a member of your local PBS station. | ||
| ||
| PBS Online Privacy Policy Copyright ©1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved. | ||
| ||
RAY
SUAREZ: Mary Perillo and Pat Moore are neighbors in an apartment building just
300 feet from where the Trade Center Towers once stood. Perillo and Moore had
to buy moon suits and respirators just to enter their apartment building, and
six months after 9/11, their apartments are still covered in a thick layer of
gritty dust. 
PAT
MOORE: If you look out of my windows you'll see 16 acres of what was the World
Trade Center complex. And look how much work has been done out there. And you
look 300 feet away across the street into our little building that we've lived
in for almost 25 years, and nothing's been done. It looks exactly the way it looked
six months ago. 
RAY
SUAREZ: An estimated 20,000 people lived in the neighborhood within half a mile
of the World Trade Center before the terrorist attack. When the Towers collapsed,
they brought down with them materials like asbestos, fibrous glass, and other
potential cancer- causing toxins. The toxic materials in tens of thousands of
fluorescent light bulbs and computer screens covered lower Manhattan in a cloud.
From the outset, local residents have wanted to know how dangerous their neighborhood
really is, and who's responsible for cleaning it up. Just two days after the attacks,
EPA Administrator Christine Todd Whitman reassured New Yorkers about the air.
CHRISTINE
TODD WHITMAN: Well, if there's any good news out of all this it's that everything
we've tested for, which includes asbestos, lead, and VOC's, have been below any
level of concern for the general public health. 
Environmental
tasks were split into three: The EPA focused on outdoor air, the Occupational
Safety and Health Administration, OSHA, was in charge at ground zero, and the
New York City departments of health and environmental protection were charge of
indoor air in office buildings, homes, and public places. Congressman Jerrold
Nadler's district includes the World Trade Center site and surrounding neighborhoods.
He says putting outdoor and indoor air in different categories made no sense.
REP.
JERROLD NADLER: Outdoor air becomes indoor air not only the minute you open a
window, the minute that the force of that cloud broke open the windows, which
they did in many places, and when that cloud, or dust from that cloud got into
ventilation shafts and air conditioning inlets. What we need now is a systematic
use of EPA people and people contracted by EPA to go into every apartment, every
small business that hasn't been inspected, and test systematically thousands and
thousands of apartments and workplaces and remediate where necessary. 
CHRISTINE
TODD WHITMAN: We don't regulate indoor air. But there were a number of businesses
that came to us and said, you know, "Is it safe to go back in?" Or they
wanted to go in and get things. We provided them with the suits, the protective
gear to wear, for them to go into the buildings. We were there with them, or they
would tell us what they wanted, and where, and we would go in and get things for
them. And then subsequent to that, they were advised... again, the city as being
the primary responder here was the one that worked with people more directly than
we did as far as the indoor, but we did all the outdoor air sampling. 
MARY
PERILLO: And what there was, was systematic run around; not quite disinformation,
but the lack of information. "Call the EPA," And they'd say, "call
the DEP," call the DEP and they'd say, "call the Department of Health,"
they'd say, "call the EPA." Six months I did that circle with these
guys. And they left us in a situation to fend for ourselves in a dangerous situations,
dressed like amateur tier 2 OSHA workers, doing stuff that really civilians should
not be doing. 
RAY
SUAREZ: Five months after the attacks, New York City's Department of Health and
the federal government's Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, or
ATSDR, released preliminary results of one of the few tests inside buildings in
lower Manhattan. There is no level of regular asbestos exposure considered "safe,"
but in samples, ATSDR found asbestos contamination -- at low levels -- in more
than 16 percent of indoor spaces, and more than 40 percent of outdoor spaces.
At the same time, over 40 percent of homes and over 60 percent of outdoor spaces
contained fibrous glass, widely considered to be cancer- causing when broken into
small, inhalable fibers. 
SHARON
McGARVEY: (September 2001) I'm just really scared. I mean, it's a serious health
hazard. I need to know that it's safe, it's safe for my kids to be there; that
ten years from now, they're not going to have cancer because of this. That's what
I need to know. 
PAUL
MARTIN: It should have been us... up to us to figure out the scenarios, right?
Give us the data. We're all intelligent people; let us decide how we want to react
to that. But the fact was, there was no data and we were forced to come up with
it on our own. 
JANE
KENNY: I think the confusion is so justifiable, and I think people want answers,
and we always want answers from science. But I'd like to use the example of just
medical... the medical profession, if we've had an ailing relative or had been
sick ourselves, and sometimes people say, "Go get another opinion."
And you might get a totally contradictory opinion from a second or third doctor.
And then you have to use your own judgment. 
RESIDENT:
The general issue is the discrepancy between the official and unofficial accounts,
or a phase of assessments of the air and dust quality down there, they kept telling
us that everything was fine. But also, there are other unofficial levels that
have indicated that they are clearly very different than that. 
HUGH
KAUFMAN, Chief Investigator for EPA Ombudsman: The first set of victims are the
people who were killed when the attack happened. The second set of victims are
the people who are exposed to the chemicals: To lead, to mercury, to cadmium,
dioxin, benzene, asbestos, all these chemicals that have spread throughout lower
Manhattan and have landed in their apartments, in their schools, in the office
buildings -- and these Americans who are also suffering from the attack have been
abandoned by the government. And that's not right. It's our job at EPA not to
count the dead bodies ten or twenty years down the line, not to operate on people
to get rid of cancer. It's our job to prevent cancer. And we fell down on the
job.
RAY
SUAREZ: It's not yet clear that the indoor cleanup attempts will be coordinated
so that already clean areas don't become recontaminated. But city contractors
will begin the decontamination of outdoor roofs and facades within weeks.