Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

   
the Online NewsHour
E-mail This Page Print This Page
the Online NewsHourFUNDED IN PART BYPacific LifeChevronCorporation for Public Broadcasting2
BROWSE BY
REGION
TOPIC
RECENT PROGRAMSLOCAL TV LISTINGSSUBSCRIPTIONSNEWS FOR STUDENTSSEARCH


REGION: Asia-Pacific
TOPIC: Terrorism
Online NewsHour
TRANSCRIPT
Originally Aired: July 11, 2006
Update

Blasts on Indian Commuter Trains Kill More Than 140

Eight bombs blasted commuter trains in India Tuesday, killing more than 140 people in a well-coordinated terrorist attack. A reporter provides an update.
scene of one of India's commuter rail bombing
 
audioRealAudioDownload  videoStreaming Video

MARGARET WARNER: It was the height of the bustling rush hour in India's financial center, Mumbai, when multiple bombs tore through the city's commuter rail network. Stunned survivors and bystanders watched rescue workers struggling in the pouring monsoon rain to reach the dead and wounded.

SHIVRAJ PATIL, Home Minister, India: They are in the process of collecting the information about the passengers, and casualties, and all of those things.

MARGARET WARNER: As workers cleared their way through debris, the death toll mounted to well over 130 by midnight. Authorities said all the bombs appear to have been planted in the first-class carriages of the trains.

Mumbai is not only a financial hub, but India's largest port city, a metropolis of more than 16 million. The prime minister's spokesman denounced the attacks as clear acts of terror.

SANJAYA BARU, Spokesman, Indian Prime Minister: We will work to defeat the evil designs of terrorists and will not allow them to succeed. I urge the people to remain calm, not to believe rumors, and carry on their activities.

MARGARET WARNER: India's home minister, Shivraj Patil, acknowledged the government had some intelligence an attack was coming, but not specific enough to stop it.

As night fell, police carried out raids across India, and other major cities were put on high alert.

There was no immediate claim of responsibility. The attacks bore the hallmarks of radical Islamic groups and also of Pakistani-backed Kashmiri separatists. But Pakistani President Pervez Musharraf quickly condemned the attacks.

The Mumbai carnage followed a grenade attack earlier in the day in Srinagar, the largest city in Indian-controlled Kashmir.

Today's attacks were the deadliest in Mumbai since 1993, when the city was known as Bombay. A series of explosions killed more than 250 people that time; authorities blamed those attacks on criminal gangs.

Sifting through the attack details


MARGARET WARNER: Late this afternoon, I spoke by phone with Alex Perry, South Asia bureau chief for Time magazine. He's in New Delhi.

And, Alex, thank you for joining us. It's after 2:00 a.m. where you are right now. Is the rescue effort still under way or is it complete? What can you tell us about the death toll and whether it's continuing to rise?

ALEX PERRY, South Asia Bureau Chief, Time Magazine: The rescue effort is mostly completed by now, as there were -- the trains started running again a couple of hours ago, though they paused overnight.

Most of the carnage has been shifted off the tracks and bodies taken away. At the moment, we're looking at 147 dead and around about 400 injured.

People still expect that number to rise. Obviously, some of the injured are very seriously injured.

The trains were -- this was rush hour, 6:00, 6:30. The trains in Bombay at that time are incredibly packed, generally about three times to what is meant to be their capacity, so every train will be carrying about 4,000-4,500 people.

So I think we can expect the death toll to rise. But at the moment, the trains look at though they're going to be running again in the morning.

MARGARET WARNER: And is there any more detail on how these attacks were carried out? How closely spaced were the blasts? What kind of explosives were used?

ALEX PERRY: This is a precisely coordinated attack. There were seven blasts within somewhere between 11 and 20 minutes of each other, according to the different reports of when they came in.

But essentially almost going all at the same time, all on the same railway line. The western railway is a main artery going through Bombay. Something like 80 percent of India's commuters will take the railway to get to work, and 6.5 million people will use that one line.

So the idea, essentially, was to cripple India's financial capital, its transport network, and that's what happened. The railway lines shut down. People had to turn to the roads, and the roads were gridlocked.

Speculation on those responsible


MARGARET WARNER: What are Indian authorities telling you now about who they think was behind the attacks?

ALEX PERRY: Nobody's saying anything officially. India and Pakistan are having a peace process at the moment, and nobody wants to ruffle feathers.

Unofficially, off the record, security sources of mine (inaudible) are saying all fingers point to a loose alliance between a Pakistan militant group called the Lashkar-e-Taiba that fights in Kashmir and also has carried out bombing campaigns (inaudible) across the rest of India. And that group, working in alliance with a radical Indian Muslim group called SIMI, which was originally a student group.

That nexus is thought to be behind a series of blasts in India over the last few years. Bombay itself, actually, in 2003, there were nine explosions over a period of about nine months in which a few people died.

And in the last 12 months, we've had bomb attacks in Delhi that killed 60, bomb attacks in the Hindi holy city of Varanasi which killed around 20, and attacks in Bangalore and Hyderabad, the two I.T. centers.

MARGARET WARNER: So you're saying one group is involved in the Kashmir conflict but the other group is not? If not, what is their aim?

ALEX PERRY: Their aim is -- well, I mean, I have met one of these guys shortly before there was a large blast in Bombay in 2003. I met a senior leader in SIMI in Bombay.

He basically expressed rage. There was no point. There was no manifesto. He didn't want a change in policy. He didn't want any -- he didn't have any specific, say, a withdrawal from Kashmir. His whole point was to kill Hindus.

He basically saw himself as alienated and all Muslims as alienated in India by decades, if not centuries, of oppression and discrimination. He said that Muslims were excluded from the Indian boom, that therefore they always lived less healthy lives. They were ghettoized, and they were frequent victims of violence, of communal violence from Hindus.

So for him the whole point of what he was doing was (inaudible) it was an expression of rage. He wanted to kill.

MARGARET WARNER: And are either of these groups linked to al-Qaida in any way?

ALEX PERRY: Yes, the LeT has proven links to al-Qaida. There's been several senior members of al-Qaida arrested in Pakistan, who've been arrested from LeT safe houses. LeT and al-Qaida have been known to share training facilities, intelligence.

And they both have a connection through the Pakistani security services, the ISI, which to many people believe operates, you know, fairly independently of President Musharraf.

MARGARET WARNER: All right. Alex Perry, Time magazine, thank you so much.

ALEX PERRY: Sure.

Attack on India's financial hub


MARGARET WARNER: And since we talked to Alex Perry, authorities revised their count of the number of explosions to eight.

Now, some perspective on why Mumbai was targeted and the possible fallout from today's attacks. For that, we're joined by Anil Padmanabhan, New York bureau chief for India Today, India's largest weekly news magazine.

Thank you so much for joining us.

Why do you think Mumbai, the city of Mumbai, would be a target for terrorists? What American city would you compare it to?

ANIL PADMANABHAN, New York Bureau Chief, India Today: Typically, New York. It's India's commercial capital and also the business capital. It's a port, so there's a tremendous amount of investment in that city.

It's also the corporate headquarters for some of the biggest companies from India, Reliance and Tarders (ph), to mention two. It's the seat where Bollywood is located.

MARGARET WARNER: The film industry.

ANIL PADMANABHAN: In every which way of a commercial hub of the country, and hence a primary target for anybody looking to cripple India economically.

MARGARET WARNER: And when you mentioned Bollywood, you mean the film industry, the Indian film industry?

ANIL PADMANABHAN: Correct.

MARGARET WARNER: Now, how essential is rail transport to this city?

ANIL PADMANABHAN: Absolutely critical. It's like my colleague from the Times said; it's an artery that runs north to south in Mumbai. And it's critical to transporting people from across, right from the southern tip of Bombay right up to the northern suburbs. And it's like he mentioned, absolutely critical on a daily, five-day work week in the city.

Shock to a peaceful nation


MARGARET WARNER: Now, what are you hearing from your sources about who the likely perpetrators might be? Are they echoing what Alex Perry's sources talked about, about the nexus between a Kashmir-related group and then a kind of indigenous Muslim student-based group?

ANIL PADMANABHAN: Actually, like Alex said, they're very cautious in naming anyone, as opposed to what they would do in the past. And discussion is understandable from what the feedback and the kind of sequencing of the two incidents.

I presume you're aware of the strikes in Kashmir which were similar (inaudible) blasts. There is a strong reference being made to these extremist Pakistan-occupied Kashmir-based groups, like the Lashkar-e-Taiba, which have close links, established links with the al-Qaida. So there is a clear pointer being made in that direction.

MARGARET WARNER: Now, are Indian authorities concerned that al-Qaida is trying to or in the process of really establishing a beachhead in India?

ANIL PADMANABHAN: I'm not sure they'll be able to establish a beachhead in India, but they definitely have kind of beginning to ring India. Especially not much attention has been dwelled on the fact that Bangladesh has been identified even by the State Department as potential hub where al-Qaida has begun to operate from.

So, in a sense -- and already in Nepal you have a problem with the communist extremist groups. So, in a sense, India is being ringed by various extremist groups, including the al-Qaida.

MARGARET WARNER: Now, Alex Perry also mentioned that other group that was more indigenous, and that one leader he'd spoken to, the Muslim leader, and about his rage. How intense has the communal tension been between Muslims and Hindus in that part of India?

ANIL PADMANABHAN: In Maharashtra, actually, in this city, Bombay has probably got the best record, in terms of communal amity in the country. It's only in '93 that the city saw its first backlash against Muslims.

But otherwise the city has been a kind of leader in people living very comfortably with each other. So this city has not seen the tension, but there are other parts in the state which have been flashpoints, but these have been like far and few. They really haven't got the pattern and the systemic nature that India saw in the '80s.

MARGARET WARNER: India has certainly seen its share of political violence over the decades. Is an attack like today's shocking, do you think, to Indian society or political culture? Is it on a par with, I don't know, 9/11 or in London the subway bombings of last year?

ANIL PADMANABHAN: Definitely, it's a shock to the nation. India, as you know, has been a pacifist nation. On its own accord, it has never attacked any other country in the world.

And it also has a track record of non-violence, from the father of the nation, which is Mahatma Gandhi. So it's a nation which has generally existed peacefully with all its neighbors, in normal circumstances. And to get such a tragedy afflicting them and to a city, particularly like Mumbai, and also at a time when India is on such economic ascendancy, it comes as a double shock to the country and to the people at large.

MARGARET WARNER: Anil Padmanabhan, thank you, and our sympathies.

ANIL PADMANABHAN: Thank you for having me.

LATEST TERRORISM HEADLINES
Suicide Bombing in Pakistan Kills at Least 59
Twin Bombings in Algeria Kill 11, Injure 31
Suicide Bomber Kills 43 at Algerian Police School
  ASIA-PACIFIC: INDIA
India
  WORLD VIEW
WORLD VIEW



CURRENT NEWSHOUR HEADLINES
U.S. Defense Deal With Poland Stirs Angry Russian Rhetoric

Three Years After Katrina, No Easy Road to Recovery for New Orleans

Candidates Hit the Battlegrounds as McCain Visits N.M, Obama Tours Va.







ABOUT US | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS / FEEDS: 
POD|RSS
Funded, in part, by:Pacific LifeChevronCorporation for Public Broadcasting
            Support the kind of journalism done by the NewsHour...Become a member of your local PBS station.
PBS Online Privacy Policy

Copyright ©1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.