|
Over the weekend of November 13 - 15, 317 Michigan citizens traveled to Lansing
to discuss and debate the state’s problems and what to do about them. The participants
were a statistical microcosm of the state in age, education, employment (and unemployment)
and political persuasion. Participating in a “Deliberative Poll,” upon arrival,
the participants filled out a questionnaire to determine what preconceived notions
and opinions each held on a wide variety of issues directly related to Michigan’s
problems and possible solutions. By the People, a civic engagement initiative
launched by MacNeil/Lehrer Productions, organized the event, working in partnership
with the Center for Deliberative Democracy at Stanford University. The project
was supported by a grant from the W.K. Kellogg Foundation.
Over three days
and two nights, the participants, who had received background material in advance, debated the issues in small groups and in large conferences in which
panels of experts, with often opposing viewpoints, fielded their questions and
provided their insights. The topics included tax policy, funding for education
(particularly middle school, in which the state lags behind), reviewing prison
sentencing and incarceration rates to reduce the fiscal burden, reforming the
health care system for state employees, transportation, the “brain drain,” the
consequences of term limits on the legislature, public assistance, and the best
ways to redesign the state’s economy away from its reliance on automotive and
manufacturing and a toward high-tech, ecologically friendly economy.
On
the final day, the participants were polled again, and the results showed a dramatic
swing in attitudes and opinions in several major areas: · Respondents were
much more willing to support increases in the state income tax and sales tax to
eliminate cuts in education and some other social services. · Respondents
were persuaded that cutting both the Michigan Business Tax and reducing small
business taxes were among the best ways to attract and keep businesses, thereby
creating jobs. · Support for increased investment in a “green economy”,
agriculture, and tourism also went up significantly during the weekend, as did
support for a high-tech, knowledge-based economy. National issues such
as aid to education, immigration and transforming the economy to meet the 21st
Century challenges were also featured in the documentary. The weekend-long
Deliberative Poll is the focus of a MacNeil/Lehrer Productions documentary report
to be broadcast on Michigan PBS stations the evening January 18, and by other
PBS stations across the country in the weeks following. |