Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

Program
Support
From:
ABOUT US  |  LOCAL TV LISTINGS    E-MAIL   PRINT      
PBS NewsHour
TopicsVideoRecent ProgramsTeacher ResourcesThe Rundown: news blogSubscribe rss | podcast
By The People
BY THE PEOPLE: MAIN
WHAT IS BY THE PEOPLE?
PAST PROJECTS
PARTNERS
RESOURCES
Hard Times, Hard Choices

A group of Michigan public television stations are pursuing ant array of community outreach projects building on the By the People "Hard Time, Hard Choices" documentary.  They are engaing local communities through additional discussions, as as broadcast and intercative Web elements.  Learn more about Michigan station activities here.

Enter your e-mail to receive the BTP newsletter
SUBMIT

Funded in part by
The W.K. Kellogg Foundation
Rockefeller Brothers Fund
Public Broadcasting Service
Current Project
Hard Times, Hard Choices:
Michigan Citizens Deliberate
Participants at BTP's citizen conversation

Over the weekend of November 13 - 15, 317 Michigan citizens traveled to Lansing to discuss and debate the state’s problems and what to do about them. The participants were a statistical microcosm of the state in age, education, employment (and unemployment) and political persuasion. Participating in a “Deliberative Poll,” upon arrival, the participants filled out a questionnaire to determine what preconceived notions and opinions each held on a wide variety of issues directly related to Michigan’s problems and possible solutions. By the People, a civic engagement initiative launched by MacNeil/Lehrer Productions, organized the event, working in partnership with the Center for Deliberative Democracy at Stanford University. The project was supported by a grant from the W.K. Kellogg Foundation.

Over three days and two nights, the participants, who had received background material in advance, debated the issues in small groups and in large conferences in which panels of experts, with often opposing viewpoints, fielded their questions and provided their insights. The topics included tax policy, funding for education (particularly middle school, in which the state lags behind), reviewing prison sentencing and incarceration rates to reduce the fiscal burden, reforming the health care system for state employees, transportation, the “brain drain,” the consequences of term limits on the legislature, public assistance, and the best ways to redesign the state’s economy away from its reliance on automotive and manufacturing and a toward high-tech, ecologically friendly economy.

On the final day, the participants were polled again, and the results showed a dramatic swing in attitudes and opinions in several major areas:

· Respondents were much more willing to support increases in the state income tax and sales tax to eliminate cuts in education and some other social services.

· Respondents were persuaded that cutting both the Michigan Business Tax and reducing small business taxes were among the best ways to attract and keep businesses, thereby creating jobs.

· Support for increased investment in a “green economy”, agriculture, and tourism also went up significantly during the weekend, as did support for a high-tech, knowledge-based economy.

National issues such as aid to education, immigration and transforming the economy to meet the 21st Century challenges were also featured in the documentary.

The weekend-long Deliberative Poll is the focus of a MacNeil/Lehrer Productions documentary report to be broadcast on Michigan PBS stations the evening January 18, and by other PBS stations across the country in the weeks following.

Bringing the views of 'ordinary' citizens to a national discussion on the important issues of the day

By the People Michigan Broadcast

Jim Lehrer leads the opening plenary session from the historic Capitol Building in Williamsburg, VAOn Monday evening, January 18, Michigan public television stations broadcast “Hard Times, Hard Choices,” a special report on a unique statewide citizens’ deliberation. Every state in the Union is going through economic belt tightening and budget cutbacks as the nation’s Great Recession stretches into 2010. One state hurting the most is Michigan, home to declining auto industry with its devastated manufacturing base. While Michigan’s problems are not unique, they are different in degree. By the People produced this documentary that gives voice to the citizens of Michigan who all too often have been overshadowed by a public discussion of Michigan’s challenges and opportunities which has been dominated by politicians, policymakers and pundits.

Michigan Citizens Deliberate

Citizens deliberateFor the first time ever, a scientific random sample of the people of Michigan gathered together to deliberate about the hard choices facing the state’s economic future. Results of Michigan’s first Deliberative Poll® show what the people of the state would think if they could all become more informed and discuss the issues in depth. Highly representative in both attitudes and demographics, a sample of 314 participants deliberated for a long weekend in Lansing, with both small group discussions and plenary sessions in which their questions were answered by competing experts. The resulting changes of opinion in the final survey offer some dramatic recommendations for both policymakers and the public.

 

Learn more about Michigan station activities here.

 

Copyright ©2010 MacNeil/Lehrer Productions.
The PBS NewsHour is Funded in part by: The John S. and James L. Knight Foundation Additional Foundation and Corporate Sponsors
Program
Support
From:
Copyright © 1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.