Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS


The Independent Vote

By Professor Paul Watanabe of University of Massachusetts -- Boston

In one way or another, Massachusetts has managed on numerous occasions to play an important role in the quadrennial quest for the nation's highest office. The Bay State, in recent years, has supplied some serious contenders for the Democratic presidential nomination. In 1980, Senator Edward Kennedy challenged incumbent Jimmy Carter for the nomination. Eight years later, Governor Michael Dukakis became the Democratic standard-bearer, and former Senator Paul Tsongas ran a spirited and courageous campaign for the 1992 nomination.

For a period of time, it appeared that in 2000 Massachusetts would once again field a contender for the Democratic nomination. The state's junior United States Senator John Kerry openly flirted with the idea of seeking the nomination. He eventually backed off in the face of what seemed at the time to be an inevitable march by Gore to become his party's standard-bearer.

Until recently, the Massachusetts primary carried some clout because of its position early in the nomination season. With the stampede toward front-loading, however, Massachusetts voters on March 7th will have lots of company. On that date alone, especially with the addition of the California primary, about 50 percent of the Democratic and 40 percent of the Republican delegates needed to capture the presidential nominations will be up for grabs.

With the first in the nation New Hampshire presidential primary next door, the candidate onslaught and the accompanying media barrage falls on Massachusetts like a mid-winter blizzard. Consequently, Massachusetts citizens are in an excellent position early on to scrutinize the candidates from both parties. In 2000, voters might be particularly attentive. For only the second time since 1952, Massachusetts primary voters in both parties will have clearly open choices. That is both ballots will be devoid of anyone who is either an incumbent candidate or a Massachusetts favorite son.

One wild card element in the Massachusetts presidential primary election is the state's uncommonly large number of voters (just short of 50% of total registered voters) who are not affiliated with any political party. These unenrolled voters can vote in either party's primary election and can be a decisive factor in the final outcomes. Republicans represent a mere13% of registered voters.

On the Republican side, Massachusetts GOP leaders are doing everything possible to keep the George W. Bush juggernaut steaming ahead. The state's Republican brass headed by Governor Paul Cellucci, who chairs the Bush effort in Massachusetts, hopes to deliver in a big way for the Texas governor. Cellucci indicated openly that he covets a high position in a Bush administration. Among the other strengths that he can exploit, George W. does have some indirect ties to Massachusetts - his father was born here and he attended Philips Andover Academy and Harvard Business School. John McCain's impressive victory in New Hampshire has in Massachusetts as elsewhere changed things dramatically. McCain clearly has the ability to topple Bush in Massachusetts especially if a large number of unenrolled voters participate in the Republican. The appeal of McCain's candidacy is also created with motivating a sizeable group of Democrats to change their registration to Republican or unenrolled as a precursor to their voting in the Republican primary.

The fact that 2000 will be a rather quiet year for contests in Massachusetts might affect the level of contributions by Bay Staters to presidential candidates. The ballot in Massachusetts will be devoid of any contests for statewide constitutional offices, and the Senate race will be the lone statewide matchup. This could mean that with a greater pool of campaign cash to go around and with a thriving state economy Massachusetts residents might be particularly generous in donating to presidential aspirants. Indeed, candidates have already dipped deeply into the pockets of Massachusetts contributors.

As far as the Democrats are concerned, the theory goes that for well or ill much of Gore's fate rests with his attachment to President Clinton. Clinton has always been able to generate remarkable sums of money from Massachusetts supporters. His impressive fundraising machine has been cranked up for the Veep. On the other hand, Clinton's radioactivity could prove to be a liability. Certainly, if Massachusetts Democratic primary voters with their special embrace of Clinton show the effects of Clinton fatigue, then Gore is definitely in trouble elsewhere and the nomination could go slip sliding away. The door could be opened for Bill Bradley as long as Celtic mad Massachusetts voters can forgive him for being a mainstay of the hated New York Knicks.

The commonwealth's senior U.S. senator, Ted Kennedy, no longer has the White House on his mind, but he is gearing himself up for a re-election run in 2000. Plymouth County District Attorney Michael J. Sullivan is the only individual to emerge as a possible Republican challenger. Kennedy is so confident of victory that he is already talking about running again in 2006. If he were able to win in 2000 and 2006 and serve out his term, Kennedy would have held onto his Senate seat for half a century. In 1994, Kennedy faced his toughest re-election challenge ever. Republican nominee Mitt Romney was smart and very well-financed. Kennedy, however, summoned all of his considerable political skills and resources to defeat the political novice. Romney is now engaged in another daunting task - trying to guide the Salt Lake Winter Olympics effort after a period of scandal, misconduct, and mismanagement.

With less than a year before the 2000 congressional elections, not a single member of the Massachusetts Congressional delegation, all Democrats, faces any declared Republican opposition. Indeed, at this time it appears that the greatest potential, although unlikely, threat to any of the Democratic incumbents might be a primary challenge by another Democrat.


Regional Coverage
Issues

Speeches and Debates
Calendar
Extra Election Coverage
   

    REGIONS | TOPICS | RECENT PROGRAMS | ABOUT US | FEEDBACK |SUBSCRIPTIONS / FEEDS:
POD|RSS
SEARCH
Funded, in part, by:ChevronIntelBNSF RailwayWells FargoToyotaMonsantoCorporation for Public Broadcasting
            Support the kind of journalism done by the NewsHour...Become a member of your local PBS station.
PBS Online Privacy Policy

Copyright ©1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.