Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS

a NewsHour with Jim Lehrer Transcript
Online NewsHour
ESSAY:CELEBRATION
 

July 3, 2000
 


Essayist Richard Rodriguez of the Pacific News Service considers some recent celebrations that turned wild.

RICHARD RODRIGUEZ: We tell ourselves that we have seen enough of that afternoon in Central Park. We do not want to see those pictures again, but we are held by what the jostling camera reveals, and by the questions that the camera will not answer. Young woman after young woman is encircled, stripped, and fondled. Police officers are nearby, but nowhere to be seen. It is important to remind ourselves that this is the center of New York, of the golden city, not some mean street in a distant precinct. And it is bright afternoon, not some treacherous hour of dark. And it is, after all, a Sunday of celebration. A happy parade has just made its way down Fifth Avenue. A few days after the Central Park riots, on the other side of America, the Los Angeles Lakers won the NBA championship. Immediately after, outside the pavilion, a crowd, mostly young men, went on a rampage. Police cars were torched, stores looted.

Beware the celebration in America. Beware the final bell or the referee's upraised hands, the winning side's jubilant dance. Beware the cheering fans. In recent years, in large American cities and in college towns, the most violent riots have come after athletic victory. "We're number one!" Sometimes the face in the crowd belongs to the middle-class undergraduate. Other times, it's the high school dropout. In either case, when the car gets overturned, the kid is usually smiling. In his surreal, extraordinary book, "Among the Thugs," published ten years ago, Bill Buford describes the murderous football riots of Europe. In recent days, we have seen the mayhem again: Young men from various European nations fight mini-wars outside the soccer stadium. These battles among fans have almost nothing to do anymore with which team wins or loses. We are seeing something different in America, I think. We are seeing something counter- intuitive. We are seeing happy riots, fierce demonstrations of celebration.

We are accustomed, of course, to the more obvious narrative line. We remember the labor and racial riots of America, earlier decades, the mob angry because it had a grievance. But what to make of today's smiling crowd? Far from the arena, far from the parade, our politicians assure us the American economy is robust; American cities are glittering; America is winning in the competition of nations-- all of which is true enough, of course, but to speak only in superlatives is to miss the mundane point. Many Americans do not feel themselves winners-- or rather, they don't know exactly how to connect their plain lives with the story of spectacular American success. It's important to remember that this year's Puerto Rican Day parade in New York had been a wonderful event. There were high school bands and smiling parents. The mood was festive and optimistic. America, after all, is enjoying this Puerto Rican decade of Jennifer Lopez and Ricky Martin.

These dangerous men in Central Park, Puerto Rican or not-- who knows what their ethnicity?-- These young men will certainly never date Jennifer Lopez, nor will they come onto the stage to sing "La Vida Loca." These kids in Los Angeles will certainly never play basketball for the NBA or make commercials or millions of dollars in endorsements. In the haze of marijuana and the stench of beer, at the edge of a parade, there is a steroid thrust of power in the mob. They rule New York. They have just won the NBA title - the Super Bowl. They are winners. They're number one. But look, the woman is weeping. The men are smiling. I'm Richard Rodriguez.


The PBS NewsHour is Funded in part by: The John S. and James L. Knight Foundation Additional Foundation and Corporate Sponsors
Program
Support
From:
Copyright © 1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.