Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS

a NewsHour with Jim Lehrer Transcript
Online NewsHour
THE NEIGHBORHOOD
 

November 15, 1999
 


Essayist Richard Rodriguez of the Pacific News Service takes a look at what was lost when a new baseball stadium was built.

RICHARD RODRIGUEZ: The noise you hear around me is the sound of nostalgia-- nostalgia being created in concrete, and at the cost of millions of dollars. San Francisco, like other American cities, is building a baseball park to resemble the ones we tore down a generation ago, a park of intimate scale.

SPORTSCASTER: A side-arm pitch to Charlie Neil. Eddie Mathews grabs the hopper
and really wizens up to first...

RICHARD RODRIGUEZ: You would be fooled, however, if you expect truly to find an earlier America within the state-of-the-art nostalgia of Baltimore's Camden Yards, or Denver's Coors Field, or San Francisco's Pac Bell Park. No, if you want to consider a more intimate America, I would recommend, instead, this wonderful book: Chavez ravine, 1949, "A Los Angeles Story."

Just over 50 years ago, around this time of year, a skinny 18- year-old named Don Normark trudged up the side of a hill, intending to take a photograph of downtown Los Angeles. What Normark found, to his astonishment, just over the hillside, was a Mexican village-- grazing goats, Indian grandmothers, roses falling from tin roofs-- all within earshot of the Pasadena Freeway. The kid hung around for a year, taking these pictures. Normark had come to California from a Scandinavian immigrant town in Washington state. He recognized immediately his own Swedish family in these Mexican elders.

The three neighborhoods that comprised Chavez ravine in the 1930's and 1940's were populated mainly by Mexicans. But there were some African- American families. And on one hillside, in shanties, lived single white men. "Los Viejitos," the Mexicans would call them affectionately, "little old men." "We had only one streetlight," a resident remembers now, five decades later. One streetlight on her block. "That was where everybody would party Friday and Saturday. We used to connect the wire to a big jukebox," she says. "We had Glenn Miller, Artie Shaw..."

When the war came, the young men of Chavez Ravine went off. Most joined the Marines. The village's life continued-- children and grandparents, summer and winter, and shrines in front of each house marked Catholic feast days, the alternating seasons of joy and grief. By the late 1940's, city housing officials were describing these neighborhoods as "blighted." On July 24, 1950, a letter went out, informing residents that their houses would be torn down for low-income housing. Urban planners in those years were very much influenced by Northern European modernism, especially the Bauhaus Movement. Perhaps their hope was that if you put poor people in clean, rectangular spaces, draw straight lines around them, you can alter their messy lives. Richard Neutra, the gifted Austrian modernist, drew up plans for Chavez Ravine, 24 thirteen-story towers and 163 two- story buildings. Happily none of them got built. Neutra's very beautiful glass and concrete houses belonged on the other side of L.A.

Growing up in the 50's in California, I grew accustomed to hearing New York sportscasters go on and on about the day the Dodgers left Brooklyn. On this other side of the country, there was another story to tell. Call it the story of when the Dodgers came to L.A. By the mid-1950s, Los Angeles wanted to entice Walter O'Malley and his Dodgers out West. And Chavez Ravine was dust or mud, depending on the season. So Los Angeles turned what had been a rose garden or someone else's front porch or a hillside's wooden steps into this: Dodger Stadium, with acres of parking. Don Normark's photographs are too gentle to shout in protest these many years later. What these photos remind us is that there was once, right in the center of our great American cities, not a brand-new, old-looking ballpark with a corporate logo, but neighborhoods where each door was a proper name and every face carried a nickname: Chuy, Hoyo, La Pocha, Neta, Punky, Topo, Vucho. I'm Richard Rodriguez.


The PBS NewsHour is Funded in part by: The John S. and James L. Knight Foundation Additional Foundation and Corporate Sponsors
Program
Support
From:
Copyright © 1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.