ArticleDownload Worksheet September 24th, 2012
What is the American “Middle Class”?
This election cycle the candidates running for president are fighting for the support of middle class voters who have been hit hard by the economic recession. Both Mitt Romney and President Obama have said that a strong middle class is necessary for future growth in America. So what is the middle class that these candidates are fighting over? How is it defined, and how has it changed over the years?
Politicians on both sides of the aisle warn that the middle class in America is shrinking; a claim that they base on the increased wealth polarization in America. Every 10 years, the U.S. Census takes a detailed survey of the American population, asking questions about income, race, religion, etc. The Census data shows that since 1969, the share of total income in the United States controlled by the top 5 percent of households has increased from 16.6 percent to 21.7 percent, while the income controlled by the lowest 20 percent dropped from 4.1 percent to 3.6 percent.
Governor Romney proposes cutting taxes on all Americans, including the very wealthy, arguing that they will invest in business, creating more middle-class jobs. President Obama, on the other hand, wishes to increase taxes on the wealthiest Americans to pay down the national debt, and ensure that wealthier citizens are paying what he dubs, “their fair share.”
Who is middle class?
There is no strict definition of the term “middle class”, so it can often mean different things to different people. While both candidates promise to reduce taxes on middle-income Americans, Romney recently defined the middle class as “$200,000 to $250,000 and less;” a similar definition to President Obama’s, which simply names all middle class people as those making less than $250,000.
However, those numbers are very different from the median – or middle – household income in America, which the Census Bureau reported to be about $50,000 in 2011. The top 5 percent of American households had incomes of $186,000 or more, meaning that many of them would still qualify as “middle class” under the candidates’ definitions.
The Census splits the population into five different groups based on income, each comprising 20 percent of the population. If the middle 20 percent is truly the “middle class”, then middle class households make between $38,500 and $62,400 per year.
How is the middle class taxed?
Both the federal government in Washington and most states around the country levy income taxes on working people. The federal income tax is determined by your income, your marital status and whether you are the head of your household.
Incomes are grouped into 6 different brackets, with the lowest bracket, or those with incomes up to $8,700 per year, paying a 10 percent marginal tax rate (before deductions), and the highest bracket, or those with incomes over $388,351 per year, paying 35 percent.
However, according to the Urban Institute-Brookings Institution Tax Policy Center, a family of four in the exact middle of the income spectrum would expect to pay only 5.6 percent of its 2011 income in federal income taxes after deductions (for children, mortgage, giving to charity, etc.).
Governor Romney recently gained attention for a remark he made at a private fundraising dinner that referred to a statistic that 47 percent of Americans do not pay federal income tax. While it may seem that this statistic would include a large chunk of the “middle class”, it is largely low-income working families who receive tax deductions and credits that reduce their taxable income to zero. However, these working families are typically required to pay state income taxes and payroll taxes as well as many other non-income related taxes.
The elderly, the unemployed, the disabled and students, who often do receive government aid, are also included in that 47 percent.
–Compiled by Allison McCartney for NewsHour Extra
Submit Your Student Voice
Tooltip of RSS content 3
- Satire’s role in current events – Lesson Plan
This lesson asks students to think critically about their relationship to satire and explore the question of how it helps us interpret global events. Continue readingApril Fool's Daycomedycurrent eventsMedia Literacysatire
- How an Afghan dressmaker became a policy-maker
When Kamila Sidiqi was a teenager during Taliban rule in Afghanistan, she was not permitted to work, attend school or leave her house without a male chaperone. Today, she holds the powerful position of deputy chief of staff to Afghan President Ashraf Ghan Continue readingbusinessEconomicssocial studieswomen
- Yemen’s president flees country
The collapse of Yemen’s government has raised concerns about the possible effects of a power vacuum in the country and ripples throughout the world. Continue readingal-QaedahouthiIranISILsocial studiesWorldWorld & GeographyYemen
- Newly elected Afghan president visits U.S. to rebuild relations
Afghan President Ashraf Ghani’s first official visit to the U.S. underscored a changing relationship between the two countries and an increased focus on security. Continue readingAfghanistanAshraf GhaniObamasocial studiesWorldWorld & Geography
- Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia is main character of new play
A new play dives into the life of Antonin Scalia, the leader of the Supreme Court’s conservative wing and its longest-serving member. Continue readingAntonin Scalialawsocial studiesSupreme Court