Daily VideoOctober 2, 2015
Prophet Muhammad cartoon debate continues 10 years later
Prophet Muhammad — in Islam, the man believed to have been the last prophet of God to mankind and credited with establishing Islam in present-day Saudi Arabia
satire — the use of humor, irony, exaggeration or ridicule to expose and criticize people or ideas one disagrees with, particularly in the context of contemporary politics
Ten years ago, a Danish newspaper published controversial cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad, setting off a series of violent protests and debate throughout the world.
Images of the Prophet Muhammad are strictly forbidden in Islam and many Muslims were upset at the cartoons depicting Muhammad in offensive ways. The cartoons also brought into question what freedom of expression and freedom of religion mean to people living in a democratic society.
Freedom of speech supporters saw the cartoons as satirical and an important part of a debate over the role of religion in society.
Danish cartoonist Kurt Westergaard received numerous death threats when the cartoon first published and survived an assassination attempt five years ago. “I think it’s a cartoonist’s, a satirist’s job to criticize those in power,” Westergaard said.
In 2006, more than 200 people in Turkey died in protests after the cartoons were published. In Denmark, many Muslims protested in the streets.
Some free speech activists worry that news organizations in Europe are self-censoring by not printing images of the prophet out of fears of being attacked by extremists.
Imran Shah of the Islamic Society of Denmark said there are no winners and losers in the debate. “The simple thing is to respect each other and not to force people to accept to be dishonored, ridiculed and so on and so forth,” Shah said.
The debate over freedom of religion and freedom of speech will likely continue as thousands of refugees from primarily Muslim countries arrive in Europe.
Warm up questions
- What is freedom of speech?
- Who is the Prophet Muhammad?
- What is the job of a political cartoonist?
- What is satire?
Critical thinking questions
- Is freedom of expression important to sustain democracy?
- Should cartoonists be able to draw satirical depictions of the Prophet Muhammad, even if it upsets Muslims?
- Why is it important to find a balance between freedom of speech and freedom of religion?
- Some Muslims protesting magazines that publish cartoons of the Prophet Muhammad point to laws in some European countries forbidding anti-Semitic, anti-Jewish symbols and speech. Countries such as Germany, France and Austria, all places where the Holocaust had devastating effects, have laws against Nazi symbols and denying the Holocaust. Should free speech include pro-Nazi speech?
Tooltip of related stories
Tooltip of more video block
Submit Your Student Voice
Discuss key election highlights with your students, particularly the impact of the youth vote, with this PBS NewsHour lesson plan. Continue reading
Use this lesson to talk with your students about the mass shooting at the Borderline Bar and Grill in Thousand Oaks. Calif. Continue reading
If you were born in 2000, there’s a good chance you will be eligible to vote in the 2018 midterm elections. The PBS NewsHour Student Reporting Lab’s Mason Berger reports on how organizations in Florida are trying to mobilize young voters around issues like the cost of college and gun violence. Continue reading
Why do young people hold some of the lowest voter turnout levels in the U.S.? Is it really their fault? NewsHour’s teen reporters talk about the youth vote in America and why the 2018 elections could see young people voting in historic numbers. Continue reading
It is difficult to know how to react to any act of gun violence, but particularly a mass shooting or a hate crime. Use this NewsHour lesson to help you discuss the shooting at the Pittsburgh synagogue with your students in a safe way. Continue reading