Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
Home
Resources for Students
Arts

Science
Math and Economics

World

U.S. History

Health / Fitness
Resources for Teachers & Educators

Click here for more current events lesson plans matched to national standards.

How to use this story in a classroom...

Online NewsHour: Legal and religious experts discuss the same-sex marriage debate. 07.31.03

A report on a lawsuit brought by gay couples in Mass. who are arguing for the right to legally marry.07.11.03

Legal experts discuss the impact of the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to strike down a Texas sodomy law. 06.26.03

Browse the NewsHour's coverage of law.

NewsHour Extra:
My Story: Bursting the Bubble: A student editor describes her effort to write about a club for gay students in the school paper. 03.05.03.

Outside Links:
Dignity USA

MarriageDebate.com

The U.S. Constitution

The Vatican

Sen. Bill Frist

Extra is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites

The Legal Debate Over Same-Sex Marriage
Posted: 08.13.03

Should gay couples have the right to legally marry in the United States? That is the question currently being debated in many political, religious and legal circles.

Printer-friendly versions: HTML / PDF

U.S. federal law currently prohibits states from issuing marriage licenses to same-sex couples. But, gay rights advocates argue that preventing people from getting married -- whether they are gay or straight -- amounts to discrimination and violates human rights.

The legal battle

Since the Supreme Court threw out a Texas law banning sex between gay couples in June, issues of gay rights, including the marriage, have been in the spotlight.

Reading and Discussion Questions

The decision declared a victory for gay and lesbian couples and convinced some it was a good time to push for legalized marriage.

While advocates say they are only seeking equal rights under the law, many people, citing deeply held religious beliefs, contend marriage should only be allowed between a man and woman.

The issue is attracting much attention in Massachusetts, where the state Supreme Court is weighing whether several same-sex couples can legally marry.

In one case, a lesbian couple together for 16 years and raising a daughter, sued the state for refusing them a marriage license.

Hillary and Julie Goodridge"We are not considered spouses. If Julie were to die, it is possible I would have to sell the house because I would have to pay tax on the inheritance, which most spouses would not have to do," explained one of the women.

Marriage licenses are granted by the states. None provides licenses to gay and lesbian couples, though Vermont allows "civil unions" that give gay couples the same state benefits as a married couple.

At the federal level, the government has said it is opposed to gay marriages. The 1996 Defense of Marriage Act, signed by President Clinton, defines marriage as "only a legal union between one man and one woman."

"No State, territory, or possession of the United States, or Indian tribe, shall be required to give effect to any public act, gay women marryingrecord, or judicial proceeding of any other State, territory, possession, or tribe respecting a relationship between persons of the same-sex that is treated as a marriage … or a right or claim arising from such relationship," the law reads.

If Massachusetts does legalize marriage, gay couples hope the Constitution's "Full Faith and Credit Clause" will cancel out the 1996 law.

"Full faith and credit shall be given in each state to the public acts, records, and judicial proceedings of every other state," the clause reads, in part, meaning that states are expected to uphold rights and privileges granted by a different state's law.

A cultural and religious issue

To many Americans, marriage represents a cultural and religious institution and not just a legal debate. President Bush, during a recent news conference, cited his religious beliefs in saying, "I believe a marriage is between a man and a woman."

The president also said his staff was looking for ways to legally classify the term "marriage" as the union between a man and woman only and Republican lawmakers are considering an amendment to the U.S. Constitution that would outlaw same-sex marriage.

"I very much feel that marriage is a sacrament, and that sacrament should extend and can extend to that legal entity of Bill Frista union between -- what is traditionally in our Western values has been defined as between -- a man and a woman," Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist, R-Tenn., said in June.

A document released by the Vatican soon after President Bush's statement called on Catholic lawmakers to oppose any effort to legalize gay marriage.

Advocates of gay marriage counter that religious doctrine should not influence the creation of law, pointing to the Constitution's ban on an established religion -- often referred to as separation of church and state.

"I think that that's very problematic for democratic countries like our own, which are founded upon the separation of church and Pope John Paul IIstate in which the legislators' highest duty is to uphold the Constitution," Marianne Duddy, executive director of Dignity/USA, said.

Lawmakers say they will await the outcome of the Massachusetts decision before moving forward with a case for a Constitutional amendment.

-- Kristina Nwazota, Online NewsHour

Daily Buzz



NewsHour
Students From Around the US Debate Gun Control
I think we've been witnessing violence for years, whether in reality through the media or through video games, and I don't think that's a first-hand effect.
Ellie, Student Reporting Labs

Debating The News
My Story
Editorial Page
Poetry


Click here to find out how your essay or poem could appear on NewsHour Extra.