Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
       
the Online NewsHour The Web site of the NewsHour with Jim Lehrer
E-mail This Page   Print This Page  
the Online NewsHour EXTRANews for Students AND Teacher Resources MAIN: ONLINE NEWSHOUR
7 - 12 grade level
SEARCH
ALL OR STUDENT VOICES LESSON PLANS VIDEO GO
Main: NewsHour ExtraU.S.WorldScienceHealthArts/MediaStudent VoicesTeacher Center

Electoral College Turns Presidential Election into State-to-State Combat

Posted: October 14, 2008 PRINTER FRIENDLY VERSION: PDF
While voters might think they're voting for Barack Obama or John McCain on Election Day, they're not. They're voting for a member of the Electoral College — a uniquely American institution responsible for George W. Bush's win in 2000 despite his losing the popular vote to Al Gore, and the reason the campaigns have spent over $25 million on ads in Ohio and nothing in Utah.
NewsHour/NPR Electroal Map
Because of the Electoral College, the outcome in each state is important for the presidential election. States are considered "red" if they lean Republican, "blue" for Democratic, or "toss-up" if the state could vote either way.

Created in 1787 to balance power between small and large states, the Electoral College has had a profound effect on presidential elections, leading candidates to focus on so-called battleground states instead of winning over the most total voters. 

When voters cast their ballots, they're actually selecting electors set up by each state who are pledged to one of the candidates selected in primaries or other contests.

In total, there are 538 Electoral College members: states are allotted a vote for each of their two senators, each House representative (depends on population), plus three votes for the District of Columbia. The electors never gather together – instead meeting in their respective state capitals on the "first Monday after the second Wednesday in December" to symbolically carry out the vote.

The most important number on Election Day is 270 --  the number of electoral votes needed to gain a majority and become president.

The popular vote is not important on the national level, but it is at the state level. In nearly every state, the candidate who gets the most votes wins all of that state’s electors. (Maine and Nebraska use a tiered system and sometimes split their votes.)

Swing States, Battleground States

John McCain in Ohio

Republican John McCain has campaigned hard in Ohio, which is one of the battleground states where candidates spend most of their time and money.
Each campaign divides the electoral map into states firmly Republican (“red”), firmly Democrat (“blue”), and swing states. These swings states can be further divided into “leaning” or “battleground” states, which are just too close to call.

This year, some of the hottest battleground states are Nevada, Indiana, Ohio, Virginia, North Carolina, and Florida. This list of states is updated day to day as states can easily shift from leaning to battleground and back again.

Both major party campaigns spend almost all of their time and money on battleground states.

 

Historical Reasoning

Constitutional Convention

The Electoral College idea came from the Constitutional Convention and was designed to balance power between large and small states.
The idea of the Electoral College was formed during the Constitutional Convention in 1787. The delegates to the convention worried how to balance the power between the smaller states and larger states and between the state governments and the federal government. (Although we often forget it, the United States is still a union of states who all want to be adequately represented.)

Early on, each member of the Electoral College would cast two votes for president. The runner-up would win the vice presidency. In the case of a tie, the vote was sent to the Congress.

Things quickly got complicated in the election of 1796 when the president and vice president came from separate parties and platforms, and in 1800 when it was tie but both candidates were hated by their parties.

The 12th Amendment -- passed in 1804 -- added that the Electoral College must vote for one president and one vice president.

Critics

Map of Wyoming

Wyoming voters technically count "more" than votes in more populous states.
Critics of the system still argue that the system can privilege the voters of swing states as candidates will campaign harder for their votes.

The system is weighted to benefit smaller states. For example, Wyoming, the least-populated state, gets 3 votes, giving it one Electoral College vote per 172,000 people, while California, the largest state, has 55 votes, making it one vote per 655,000 people.

Other critics say that they system is inherently undemocratic as it is possible for a candidate to win the popular vote and still lose the election as happened in 1876, 1888, and 2000.

While many proposed constitutional amendments have been written to adopt a direct popular vote instead of the indirect Electoral College system, none have successfully made it through both houses of Congress.

--Compiled by Lizzy Berryman for NewsHour Extra
Resources

Daily Video Clip

In the News
Hungry in America: New Food Insecurity Numbers Are A Wake Up Call
Hungry in America: New Food Insecurity Numbers Are A Wake Up Call


Afghan President Hamid Karzai Begins Second Term



President Obama Visits Asia

Student Voice
Evan and Kamaria
Debating Financial Aid for Illegal Immigrants
American schools and financial aid should be only for legal citizens of the United States. There should be no exceptions to this.
Evan, Houston, Texas
Send us your essay, personal story or poem
SUBMIT

Related Coverage

Extra: News for Students
Financial Crisis Tests Notions of the President's Role in the Economy
Vice Presidential Candidates Hold Their Own in Closely Watched Debate
Obama, McCain Push Different Visions for Schools, Teachers and Students

The Online NewsHour
Political, Economic Scene in New Mexico Set to Affect Election
Market Meltdown, Tone on Campaign Trail Top the Week's News
McCain, Obama Respond to Economic Crisis, Attacks

SUGGESTIONS / COMMENTS
Do you have an opinion about this article? Or do you have a personal experience related to this article that you'd like to share with our readers? Submit your comments!
The Online NewsHour
WEDNESDAY'S PROGRAM
Climate Change
News Wrap
Military Options
Making Sen$e
Toyota Recall
The Online NewsHour, an hour-long daily news broadcast
Check your Local Listings