Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
       
the Online NewsHour The Web site of the NewsHour with Jim Lehrer
E-mail This Page   Print This Page  
the Online NewsHour EXTRANews for Students AND Teacher Resources MAIN: ONLINE NEWSHOUR
7 - 12 grade level
SEARCH
ALL OR STUDENT VOICES LESSON PLANS VIDEO GO
Main: NewsHour ExtraU.S.WorldScienceHealthArts/MediaStudent VoicesTeacher Center
Student Voice
Posted: February 19, 2009
WORLD

Student Documents Plight of the Uninsured

Chelsea, Age 17
Supreme Court Building
Chelsea, from Arlington, Texas, looks at the problems of uninsured Americans through the personal account of one woman who lost her health insurance.
Why this Student Spoke Out
As of 2005, 55 million Americans are living without health insurance which often results in higher medical bills and poor medical treatment.

In America, medical treatment for those with health insurance is generally very good. However, what about those without insurance?

I had the pleasure of interviewing Michelle Struck, 36, who is suffering from several medical conditions that require treatment. Some of these medical conditions are: Type 2 Diabetes, high blood pressure, and Hashimoto's, an auto-immune disorder that attacks the thyroid. She suffers on a day-to-day basis with keeping her blood sugars in check and monitoring her Hashimoto's.

When she had insurance, she was taken care of. She had the medications she needed and her doctor watched out for her. "My doctor took care of me," she says, "all of my means were taken into account and I was very happy with the service." She describes her life as relatively good during her time with insurance.

Differences in treatment

In December 2006, Michelle was admitted to the hospital for the first time with extremely high blood sugar. "I was scared, but I knew that I was going to be taken care of." She was admitted within three hours of waiting and was given a private room. "It was really pleasant," she says, "It was a positive stay. All of the staff made sure that I had what was needed." Within a week's time, she was released.

2007 was a rough year for Michelle. She was laid off in March and that is when she lost her insurance. February of 2008, Michelle went into the hospital again for high blood sugar. She had to wait six hours before being admitted into a semi-private room. She describes the treatment of the nursing staff as horrible. "[A nurse] told me that I needed to find a job because I was running up high medical bills. I was devastated."

'No bedside manner'

Soon after this incident, because of her health conditions, she had to resort to JPS Health Care, a non-profit organization that helps those without insurance. However, the wait for treatment was long. When she finally saw a doctor, she was treated much the same as in the other facility. "It took almost six months before I was given an appointment to see my doctor." She explained that she was only allowed to speak with the doctor about three of her conditions in no more than fifteen minutes. "There was no bed side manner. I felt as if I had done something wrong by wanting my medical conditions taken care of."

The necessary medications were expensive, but the doctor quickly informed her that he didn't care about that because it wasn't his problem. Once, she was yelled at for making a phone call to the complaints department. "I felt degraded. Doctors are supposed to care about how you feel."

A change is needed

 

A friend of Michelle's, Jennifer Graham, 36, who accompanied her on doctor visits said, "Given the choice of JPS doctors and private practice doctors, I would prefer Michelle go to a doctor in private practice."

JPS has recently received negative press concerning their treatment of patients. According to Pegasus News Wire, more than 15 percent of those that go into the JPS emergency room leave without seeing a doctor. Many state the long wait as the reason for leaving.

In 2005, more than 46.6 million adults and 8.3 million children were uninsured according to Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. More and more people go about their lives without receiving the proper medical treatment that they require due to lack of insurance. Let us hope that 2009 will bring better odds for the uninsured.

 


A bit about this Author

Chelsea is from Arlington, Texas.


Related Coverage

Extra: News for Students
Children's Health is Political Battleground
Massachusetts Tries to Insure All Residents
Who Pays for Health Care?

The Online NewsHour
Number of Newly Uninsured Americans Rises Along With Jobless Rate
Economic Crisis May Take Toll on Health Services in Developing Nations
Obama Signs Child Health Care Bill


Speak Out
Publish your student editorial, personal stories and poems on Extra and reach a global audience!
NewsHour Extra is looking for smart, insightful, creative teens like you to share your opinions on current events and how the news has affected your life.
Even if you haven't written before, but have a great idea for a story, let us know! We can work with you to publish it on our site.
Tips and Story Ideas
Submit Student Voice or leave a comment
Your name
Your city & state
Your e-mail address
Your story idea, essay or poem
NewsHour Extra will not use contact information for any purpose other than our own records. We do not share information with any other organization.

SUBMIT

Student Voice
Evan and Kamaria
Debating Financial Aid for Illegal Immigrants
American schools and financial aid should be only for legal citizens of the United States. There should be no exceptions to this.
Evan, Houston, Texas
Send us your essay, personal story or poem
SUBMIT

Daily Video Clip
All Student Voices
The Online NewsHour
FRIDAY'S PROGRAM
Editor's Note
Shaky Economy
Financial Crisis in Dubai
News Wrap
Holiday Shopping
Hard Knocks
Shields and Brooks
Austin City Limits
The Online NewsHour, an hour-long daily news broadcast
Check your Local Listings