Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
       
the Online NewsHour The Web site of the NewsHour with Jim Lehrer
E-mail This Page   Print This Page  
the Online NewsHour EXTRANews for Students AND Teacher Resources MAIN: ONLINE NEWSHOUR
7 - 12 grade level
SEARCH
ALL OR STUDENT VOICES LESSON PLANS VIDEO GO
Main: NewsHour ExtraU.S.WorldScienceHealthArts/MediaStudent VoicesTeacher Center
Student Voice
Posted: March 5, 2009
WORLD

Stimulus Bill Just Another Bogus Bailout

Chris, Age 17
Chris
Chris, of Matthews, N.C., argues that the stimulus package is a waste of taxpayer money, and will do little to help the nation's struggling economy.
Why this Student Spoke Out
President Barack Obama signed the $787 milllion stimulus package into law in February.

On Friday, February 13th the 111th Congress passed an economic “stimulus” package totaling more than $787 billion.  This package includes provisions that would give taxpayer money to struggling private businesses and industries.  Like previous bailouts, this will be a waste of money because the government cannot manage the economy. This, however, may be the worst attempt at solving economic woes in American history.  

A free market

A free market economy has made America a great nation and we are only hurting ourselves by destroying it. George Bush tried a similar bailout approach last year with the Emergency Economic Stabilization Act of 2008 and it certainly did not stop our downward economic spiral. A free market economy should regulate itself and people must learn to cope with its ups and downs.  

Democrats are hoping to create “necessary jobs” in the near future.  However, spending money on anti-smoking programs, contraceptives, and national lawn renovations will not create jobs. 

Consequences for Americans

Clearly, Congress is ignoring the opinion of its constituents. A recent NY Times- Bloomberg News poll found over 55% of Americans object to the original bank bailout. Adding $787 billion to the national debt will not successfully stimulate the economy. For example, the Congressional Budget Office conducted a study revealing the stimulus may only have a limited short-term positive effect, and that it could cause the Gross Domestic Product to actually decrease after 2014.  

What will bailing out banks and automakers do for the middle class? These companies have made terrible business decisions and now must suffer the consequences.  There may be some short term fallout, but new companies will take the place of old ones; that’s capitalism.  Giving executives taxpayer money as bonuses is wrong.  Why should an average American making $50,000 a year pay for the bonuses of someone making millions?  

Investing in infrastructure

Although I strongly feel the government should not interfere in private industry, I admit something must be done. My suggestion to government officials is to invest in infrastructure.  Not only will this create jobs, it will also improve our economy by facilitating transportation. America’s infrastructure is outdated and inefficient; a staggering 25% of bridges in the United States are obsolete. 

The problem is only a small portion of this stimulus actually goes to improving infrastructure.  Investing in infrastructure will put people back to work.  The nation needs to focus on fixing transportation and water systems rather than lining the pockets of corporate executives.


A bit about this Author

Chris, age 17, writes for the Warrior Witness at Weddington High School in Matthews, North Carolina.


Related Coverage

Extra: News for Students
President Obama Outlines Economic Plan in Address to Congress
Massive Spending Bill Aims to Create Jobs, Strengthen Economy
Obama Moves Quickly in First Days

The Online NewsHour
Orszag Outlines Policy Priorities in Budget Blueprint
Obama Signs Stimulus Bill in Colorado Ceremony
Congress Passes Sweeping Economic Stimulus Bill


Speak Out
Publish your student editorial, personal stories and poems on Extra and reach a global audience!
NewsHour Extra is looking for smart, insightful, creative teens like you to share your opinions on current events and how the news has affected your life.
Even if you haven't written before, but have a great idea for a story, let us know! We can work with you to publish it on our site.
Tips and Story Ideas
Submit Student Voice or leave a comment
Your name
Your city & state
Your e-mail address
Your story idea, essay or poem
NewsHour Extra will not use contact information for any purpose other than our own records. We do not share information with any other organization.

SUBMIT

Student Voice
Classroom; AFP/Getty Images
What Young People Need to Know About H1N1
After H1N1-related school closures in the last flu season, local schools have lowered the severity of their response and are focusing on preventative action that does not interrupt education.
Brandon, Federal Way, Washington
Send us your essay, personal story or poem
SUBMIT

Daily Video Clip
All Student Voices
The PBS NewsHour
ARRAY'S PROGRAM
Afghan Deployments
Newsmaker Interview: Adm. Mike Mullen
News Wrap
Patchwork Nation: Philadelphia
Copenhagen Climate Summit
Newsmaker Interview: EPA Chief Lisa Jackson
Reinventing the Metropolitan Opera
The PBS NewsHour, an hour-long daily news broadcast
Check your Local Listings