Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
       
the Online NewsHour The Web site of the NewsHour with Jim Lehrer
E-mail This Page   Print This Page  
the Online NewsHour EXTRANews for Students AND Teacher Resources MAIN: ONLINE NEWSHOUR
7 - 12 grade level
SEARCH
ALL OR STUDENT VOICES LESSON PLANS VIDEO GO
Main: NewsHour ExtraU.S.WorldScienceHealthArts/MediaStudent VoicesTeacher Center
Student Voice
Posted: October 13, 2008
WORLD

Criticism of Flip-Flops Not Valid

Miriam, Senior
Miriam
Miriam writes that no person is completely consistent in their stance on a particular issue and that candidates should not feel insecure when they change their minds on a topic.
Why this Student Spoke Out
The candidates running for president in the current and recent elections have had to carefully manage their media images.

November is drawing increasingly closer, bringing with it another presidential election. As election day approaches, the presidential candidates are anxious to avoid the mistakes of previous candidates.

One of the major complaints about former Democratic presidential nominee, Senator John Kerry, was about his tendency to change his mind on major issues. He was called a flip-flopper. People worried that he was changing his opinions on issues only to win votes.

While this was a valid worry- candidates should not let their desire to win the election interfere with their sense of right and wrong. Changing of opinions in general is not something that should necessarily be discouraged. Moral absolutism is a dangerous thing, and hardly works out in real life.

The myth of a flip-flopper

Many people are intensely devoted to their sense of right and wrong, of what should be and what should not be- at least in theory. Many people, probably even most people, see their opinions, morality and views on hot-topic issues as being part of who they are and of how they identify themselves. But how many people can actually hold up all of these morals when they are put to the test?

Of those who have decried gossiping, how many of them have not actually talked about others behind their backs? Of those who claim people should not judge each other, how many have not looked down at others for their sexuality, religion or political views?

People are always making exceptions in their beliefs and in their morals. Abortion is wrong, people say, except in cases of rape or incest- or unless the mother is their own grandchild, child or friend.

Killing others is wrong, but war and the death penalty are necessary to a well-functioning world. And of those who believe war is necessary, who talk about the worth and value of the military, what small fraction of them have actually served in the military, or seen their family members serve? President George W. Bush, after all, who is responsible for sending thousands of Americans into war in the Middle East, avoided seeing combat in the Vietnam War.

To change is human


This pattern of contradiction in beliefs can be seen in all people, Democrats along with Republicans, parents along with children, males and females. No one has any assurance of how they will behave when they are actually put to the test, and it is, as has been said many times before, easier to talk the talk than to walk the walk. Morals are messy and full of contradictions. Often times, they are based on feelings, not on logic or common sense.

It is easy to live a perfect life until one is confronted with the real world. People should be more understanding of those who screw up, who act contrary to what they say they believe and who change their minds and make mistakes. After all, it is impossible to be both human and perfect.

 


A bit about this Author

Miriam is a senior at Spring Brook High School in Silver Spring, Maryland. She is editor-in-chief for the Blueprint.


Related Coverage

Extra: News for Students
Markets Falter After Congress Fails to Agree on Rescue Plan
Vice Presidential Candidates Hold Their Own in Closely Watched Debate
Obama, McCain Push Different Visions for Schools, Teachers and Students

The Online NewsHour
McCain, Obama Respond to Economic Crisis, Attacks
Presidential Candidates Focus on Hotly Contested Swing States
In-Depth Coverage: Vote 2008


Speak Out
Publish your student editorial, personal stories and poems on Extra and reach a global audience!
NewsHour Extra is looking for smart, insightful, creative teens like you to share your opinions on current events and how the news has affected your life.
Even if you haven't written before, but have a great idea for a story, let us know! We can work with you to publish it on our site.
Tips and Story Ideas
Submit Student Voice or leave a comment
Your name
Your city & state
Your e-mail address
Your story idea, essay or poem
NewsHour Extra will not use contact information for any purpose other than our own records. We do not share information with any other organization.

SUBMIT

Student Voice
Classroom; AFP/Getty Images
What Young People Need to Know About H1N1
After H1N1-related school closures in the last flu season, local schools have lowered the severity of their response and are focusing on preventative action that does not interrupt education.
Brandon, Federal Way, Washington
Send us your essay, personal story or poem
SUBMIT

Daily Video Clip
All Student Voices
The PBS NewsHour
ARRAY'S PROGRAM
Bombings in Iraq
Congressional Support for Afghan Strategy
Britain's Role in Afghanistan
Help for Small Businesses
Patchwork Nation: Ann Arbor
The PBS NewsHour, an hour-long daily news broadcast
Check your Local Listings