Student VoicesBack to student voices archive September 30, 2013
Is Healthcare A Right?
On October 1, the healthcare exchanges in the Affordable Care Act, also known as Obamacare, up to the general public for enrollment. The imminent implementation of the program has reignited the debate over whether the act is a government overreach, or whether it doesn’t go far enough. At the heart of the issue is the question of whether Americans believe that healthcare is a right or a privilege.
As a part of a larger debate over healthcare, NewsHour Extra asked high school students Megan and Sam to write about whether they thought healthcare was a human right or not. In addition, students from around the country wrote in with their opinions on the topic to the Do Now social media conversation hosted by KQED, the PBS affiliate in San Francisco. Some of their responses are included at the bottom.
Healthcare is not in the Constitution
By Megan Gallagher
The provision of health care is not mentioned in our Constitution or the Bill of Rights. Our Founding Fathers rightfully focused on life, liberty and justice.
Health care is a service for Americans and it is something that most Americans need. The basic question is really, “should the Government be in the position of saying that all Americans must sign up for some type of health care coverage?” And, if that premise is accepted, should government be in the business of then providing every citizen with coverage, whether they want it or not?”
Conservatives believe in personal responsibility, limited government, free markets, individual liberty, traditional American values and a strong national defense. They believe the role of government should be to provide people the freedom necessary to pursue their own goals. Conservative policies generally emphasize empowerment of the individual to solve problems. Their view on healthcare is no different. We have come to a time in our country where the American public is becoming far too reliant on the government to take care of more than their basic needs such as food, housing, and healthcare. This mantra of “let the government take care of me” is not what this country stands for and not the direction it needs to be heading in. It breeds a culture of dependency. In the news for the past year, President Obama has been persistently pursuing legislation, the Affordable Care Act, also known as “Obamacare” which will bring drastic changes to the existing healthcare system, hospitals, and many private practices around the nation.
The government already provides healthcare for the poor and the elderly through large and costly programs such as Medicaid and Medicare and this is paid for by taxpayers. If the government were to mandate universal healthcare coverage, the additional cost to the taxpayers will be huge and a drag on the economy, even though those taxpayers are not receiving any benefits from it.
Statistics show that 83.7 percent of all Americans have healthcare. This shows that although there are certainly segments of the population without coverage, the vast majority do have healthcare coverage. With statistics such as these, it shows that many people, for generations have afforded their own healthcare by their own means, not because it was a right, but because it is a privilege of where we live to be able to take care of one’s self by our own means.
Megan Gallagher is an 18 year old senior at T.C. Williams High School and also writes for the school newspaper, Theogony.
Healthcare is a human right
By Sam Hanoura
The effect that time has had on our still fairly young country is quite amazing. As the world has slowly progressed over the past few centuries, the United States has been playing catch-up with the already established nations while at the same time barreling through the industrial and technological revolutions. This of course means that along the way it can be expected that things can change in importance and relevance. For example, in the time of the founding fathers and powdered wigs, healthcare was comprised of apothecary prescriptions, amputations, and death. In the 21st century however, it can provide a longer and fuller life.
Now, when the founding fathers were drafting the constitution, the idea of someone two hundred years later not being able to pay for their chemo treatments most likely did not cross their minds. Regardless, it doesn’t matter who said or wrote what when; healthcare is a human right. The fact that this is even a discussion in policy making is absurd, further identifying lawmakers’ detachment from their sick and dying constituents.
The opposition to healthcare is more or less condemning the lower economic classes to a life of illness, campaigning to stretch the unruly rat race of the free market to the lives of millions of uninsured Americans. In comparison, free market health insurance today is slower, but just as lethal as the market for fire insurance in post-colonial America, where if someone did not have fire insurance on their home they were regarded as less of a priority. The concept is laughable now, but by what moral compass in today’s world is it right to unflinchingly run to the rescue of someone in a burning home and then deny that same person savior from an internal threat?
Those who oppose the Affordable Care Act make the argument that a majority of Americans are already covered by medical insurance. To that it must be noted that the key word in said act is “affordable.” The American people struggle on a daily basis to make ends meet, worrying about groceries, bills, and car payments. For better or for worse, that is capitalism, and as a country the United States has stayed true to its ideals. Nevertheless, the competition of the game of life should never have to be a game of life and death.
Sam Hanoura is a 17 year old senior at T.C. Williams High School and writes for the school newspaper, Theogony.
Throughout the week, students have been tweeting in their answers to this week’s Do Now conversation, answering the question, “Is health care a basic human right?” Here is a collection of their answers.
— Serina Wright (@Serina_Wright) September 25, 2013
— Amelia Beville (@BevilleAmelia) September 25, 2013
— Gray (@AHA_fewafeg) September 25, 2013
— Clea M (@clmrsdn) September 25, 2013
— Macey Rawson (@Macey2016) September 26, 2013
— Nikki Jamshidbaigi (@WenchBagel801) September 25, 2013
— Dana Briggs (@Dana_B1116) September 26, 2013
— Chelsea Amos (@AmosSchool) September 26, 2013
Do Now is a weekly social media conversation hosted by San Francisco PBS affiliate KQED. Check their page every Friday for the latest topic, then join in!
Tooltip of related stories
Tooltip of more video block
Submit Your Student Voice
Tooltip of related content
Tooltip of RSS content 3
Women’s March draws support from around the globe
Hundreds of thousands of protesters converged on Washington, D.C. for the Women’s March on Washington the day after President Donald Trump’s inauguration.protestWomen's March on Washingtonwomen's rights
Tweets from classes on Inauguration Day
High school students traveled from across the U.S. to attend President Donald Trump’s inauguration on…Donald TrumpGovernment & CivicsinaugurationSocial Studies
Donald Trump sworn in as 45th president
At noon on Friday, Donald Trump was sworn into office by Chief Justice John Roberts on the steps of the United States Capitol Building.Donald TrumpGovernment & CivicsInauguration DayU.S. presidency
How to watch Inauguration Day 2017 with your students
On Friday, Donald Trump will be sworn in as the 45th president of the United States. Find out where to watch the events with your class. Continue readingGovernment & CivicsinaugurationPresidency
Education nominee Betsy DeVos faces questions on school choice
The confirmation hearing for President-elect Donald Trump’s nominee for education secretary, Betsy DeVos, saw many questions about her support of school choice and charters. Continue readingBetsy DeVosDonald Trumpeducation