Student VoicesBack to student voices archive November 27, 2012
Lessons on Democracy from the Philippines
On Election Day American voters checked a box with the name “Barack Obama”, “Mitt Romney” or a third part candidate, but they were not casting a ballot directly for one of these candidates. Instead, voters chose “electors” in the Electoral College, who then selected the president and vice president.
Shaneil noticed some differences between the U.S.’s Electoral College system and how her native country of the Philippines selects its presidents. While happy about President Obama’s reelection, she questions the electoral system that put him in power.
A new beginning for the United States starts once again as president Obama wins re-election as our nation’s president for another four years. But, in choosing our president, are our voices heard? For over two centuries, we’ve been using the same process for electing the nation’s leader: the Electoral College.
The Electoral College awards a certain number of votes, or points, to a state based on the popular vote in that state. It is used to protect the smaller states from being overpowered by the larger states. However, is it really protecting anyone? In addition, is it a fair system? In my opinion, it is not a fair system for electing the president because it does not give us our own voice to vote for whom we want to be president and who we want to govern this country.
I was born in the Philippines, which is also a democratic country with three branches of government. However, it has a different system for electing its president. Under the American voting system, the president is voted into power through the Electoral College, while in the Philippines, the president is determined through popular votes. Easy and fast as it may seem, the U.S presidential election doesn’t really show the true choice or preference of each and every individual voter.
In the Philippines, the vice president is also chosen through a separate popular vote, which means that the president and vice president may be from different parties. The citizens in the Philippines have a voice and a say in who we want to lead and make our country better.
Secondly, the U.S has a two-party system, while the Philippines has a multi-party system. In a two-party system it is easier for voters to choose because they only have two choices, but people can get used to voting for a certain party without thinking about the issues.
The Philippines’ multiparty system can be quite chaotic because there’s a lot to choose from and the agenda the government wants to achieve is very divided. In addition, a multiparty system that chooses a president through popular votes takes a longer time to come up with a result. Another factor is that there is sometimes cheating in the form of vote buying. Even with the chaos of a popular vote in a multiparty system, the voices of each individual voter in the Philippines are still being heard and counted.
Looking back at this election, I am quite satisfied by the outcome, but as a democratic nation, I hope that someday American voters will have more say when it comes to choosing their leader – not just by state electoral college votes, but by the popular vote of the people.
Tooltip of related stories
Tooltip of more video block
Submit Your Student Voice
Tooltip of related content
Tooltip of RSS content 3
After weeks of secrecy, Senate health care bill to be released to public
After spending weeks drafting a bill to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act behind closed doors, Republican leaders in the Senate announced that they would release it to the rest of the Congress and the public on June 22, 2017. Continue readingAffordable Care ActCongressdean hellerhealthcarehouse of representativeslisa murkowskimitch mcconnellObamacarerand paulron johnsonSenateshelley moore capitoSusan Collins
Grounded airplanes and the unexpected consequences of climate change
An extreme heat wave is currently affecting the western and southwestern United States. Continue readingairplanesclimate changeGlobal Warmingheat wavesScience
Senate Democrats increase opposition as secret health care bill picks up steam
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) promised on June 20, 2017 that a draft of the effort by Senate Republicans to repeal and replace the Affordable Care Act would be available on June 22. So far, the bill has been drafted behind closed doors and Senate Democrats have demonstrated strong opposition, including a late-night talk-a-thon on the Senate floor on June 19. Continue readingAffordable Care ActAmerican Health Care Actbob corkerGovernment & Civicshealth careMike Pencemitch mcconnellObamacareSocial Studies
High schools and colleges crack down on students’ online activity
High schools and universities are beginning to pay close attention to what students post online, which can have serious consequences for students. Continue readingACLUcollegescyberbullyingFirst Amendmentfree speechschoolssocial mediaSocial Studies
Gerrymandering, or how drawing irregular lines can impact an election
Most states have some rules for redrawing district lines, but cases of gerrymandering in order to give one party an electoral advantage over the other remain widespread. Continue readingcivics & governmentElectionsgerrymanderingredistrictingSocial Studiesvoting