|
 |
|
July 16, 2008
In this entry: quotes, warm up questions, discussion questions, resources
VIDEO SUMMARY:
 This video addresses the controversy over a New Yorker magazine cover intended as a satire of the rumors spread about presumptive Democratic presidential nominee Sen. Barack Obama and his wife.
The cartoon shows the Obamas in the Oval Office with an American flag burning in the fireplace and a picture of Osama bin Laden hanging on the mantel. Obama is dressed in traditional Muslim garb, and his wife is carrying a rifle.
Both the Obama and McCain campaigns released statements opposing the cover. The magazine insists the drawing was meant to lampoon the outlandish accusations Obama is faced with.
In this video , a professor of sociology and the editor of Rolling Stone discuss the issue.
QUOTES:
“If people don’t get the joke or misinterpret it that wildly, then you’ve got a problem. It doesn’t mean, though, that that’s the role of the artist or the journalist to try to pull back or not take risks.” -Eric Bates, Rolling Stone Magazine “It shouldn’t be a shame that anybody is considered to be Muslim to begin with…and now he’s got to say he’s not really a Muslim, when, in fact, that’s horrible to even have to say he’s not.” -Michael Eric Dyson, Georgetown University
“I went to see Chris Rock on Saturday night here in Atlanta, and he made a statement in his comedy. He said, look, when you’re the big person, when you’re the rich person, poor people can say stuff about you, but it’s downright wrong and brutal for rich people to beat up on poor people. He said people who are larger can lampoon people who are skinnier, but not the opposite.” -Michael Eric Dyson, Georgetown University
WARM-UP QUESTIONS:
What is satire? What are some examples of satire that you either watch or read? What makes a joke, especially a political joke, effective or funny to you? Was there a time you’ve seen a satire, on a television show or in a cartoon, that was offensive to you?
DISCUSSION QUESTIONS:
What is your initial response to the cover? Did the cartoonist go too far? Why or why not? Do you “get” the joke or find it offensive?
What are some of the potential unintended consequences of a satirical cartoon like the one in the New Yorker?
Should artists or journalists be sensitive to the different ways the audience might interpret their work? Why or why not?
RESOURCES:
Transcript of this report
Online NewsHour’s Vote 2008 coverage
Use the comment function to add more resources…
|
|
|
Stay in touch with
Brian and teachers
using this site
Your e-mail address goes directly to Brian McLaughlin, Director of the Teacher Center. He'll use it to e-mail you directly about the project and won't share, sell or distribute it in any way.
» Hide this text Recently Added:
This is a list of links to sites recommended by our editors and by teachers. We're using Delicious to keep track of these links because it allows us to select and share sites that fit with NewsHour Extra's mission of finding and celebrating quality current events resources. Our Delicious bookmark list is named "NewsHour TeacherCenter", You will be able to click on the provided list of tags to find just the resources for your topic of interest.
For an excellent 2-minute tutorial on using Delicious, click here.
» Hide this text Share your teaching experiences: What works, what didn't, what's needed?
Click on Share Your Teaching Experiences to add your voice to our Teacher to Teacher comment section. No comment is too short or too long. You are among friends - we can learn from and support each other! » Hide this text
  |
 |
|
| |
July 23, 2008
Moral Hazard: Do Government Bailouts Encourage Risky Behavior?
July 22, 2008
Unfriendly Skies: Airlines and Passengers Suffering from Effects of Rising Gas Prices
July 17, 2008
High Gas Prices Fueling Hard Times for U.S. Fishing Industry
July 3, 2008
When a Coffee is Not Just Coffee: Starbucks Tries to Get It's Mojo Back
June 25, 2008
Gas Price Politics: McCain and Obama Offer Differing Energy Plans
June 23, 2008
Farmers, U.S. Food Supply in Trouble After Massive Flooding
June 12, 2008
Former U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan Explains Food Crisis from African Perspective
June 6, 2008
Temporary Visas for Mexican Workers Provide Migrant Labor for U.S. Farms
May 29, 2008
Modern China Confronts Environmental Crisis
May 20, 2008
Alternative Fuels and Rising Prices: Is Ethanol the Problem or the Solution?
May 13, 2008
Meet the Greenovators: Eco-minded Entrepreneurs Spark Rust Belt Renewal
May 7, 2008
Big Tankers, Big Business, Big Battle
May 6, 2008
Tragedy in Kentucky Derby Raises Questions
May 5, 2008
U.S. Farm Subsidies and Foreign Food Aid: Malawi, a Case Study
May 1, 2008
Gas Tax Summer Holiday: Political Gimmick or Good Policy?
April 24, 2008
Rising Price of Rice - Silent Tsunami?
April 23, 2008
NAFTA - Friend or Foe?
April 17, 2008
Confronting the Real Costs of Women's Low Wages
April 10, 2008
$4 Gas in Our Future? Oil Prices and Alternative Energy
March 14, 2008
Honey, I Shrunk My Footprint! The Economics of Carbon Offsets
March 6, 2008
Falling dollar: understanding the impact
|
| |
July 24, 2008
Head of D.C. Schools Faces Criticism for Tough Decisions
July 23, 2008
Moral Hazard: Do Government Bailouts Encourage Risky Behavior?
July 16, 2008
Satirical Obama New Yorker Cover Leaves Many Offended
July 14, 2008
Alexander Hamilton's House Takes Short Hike to New Home
July 7, 2008
Final Salute: How Military Families Are Told of the Death of a Loved One
July 1, 2008
More Conservative Supreme Court Shapes Rules on Guns, Death Penalty, Treatment of Terror Suspects
June 30, 2008
The War in Iraq and Why the Democrats Couldn't End It
June 27, 2008
Supreme Court Overturns Gun Ban in Second Amendment Case
June 25, 2008
Gas Price Politics: McCain and Obama Offer Differing Energy Plans
June 23, 2008
Farmers, U.S. Food Supply in Trouble After Massive Flooding
June 20, 2008
New Orleans Struggles with Possibly Toxic Landfills From Hurricane Katrina
June 19, 2008
Low Test Scores Mean Big Changes in D.C. Schools
June 18, 2008
What's Marriage Got to Do With It? California Allows Same-Sex Marriage
June 17, 2008
Change We Can Log Onto: How the Internet has Reshaped Presidential Campaigns
June 16, 2008
When Will U.S. Troops Leave Iraq?
June 13, 2008
How Other Countries View the U.S. Presidential Election
June 9, 2008
Red, Blue or Purple? Virginia is a Battleground State for Obama and McCain
June 6, 2008
Temporary Visas for Mexican Workers Provide Migrant Labor for U.S. Farms
June 5, 2008
Obama's Nomination: History in the Making
June 4, 2008
2008 Democratic Primaries: an Epic Political Journey
June 2, 2008
Internet Thriving Inside the Great(Fire)Wall of China
May 27, 2008
Young and in Love... With Politics - the Youth Vote's Impact on the 2008 Election
May 22, 2008
Iraq Veterans Speak Out Against Conduct of the War
May 21, 2008
Lobbyists and Election Campaigns: What's the Fuss?
May 20, 2008
Alternative Fuels and Rising Prices: Is Ethanol the Problem or the Solution?
May 16, 2008
Same-Sex Marriage Debate: Civil Right or Civic Wrong?
May 15, 2008
Polar Bears Threatened By Warming Planet
May 14, 2008
Humanitarian Crisis Challenges Myanmar's Isolation
May 9, 2008
Media Coverage of Race in the Election: More Than Skin Deep?
May 8, 2008
Freedom to Marry: The Loving Case that Overturned Anti-Miscegenation Laws
May 7, 2008
Big Tankers, Big Business, Big Battle
May 5, 2008
U.S. Farm Subsidies and Foreign Food Aid: Malawi, a Case Study
May 2, 2008
New Military Policy Aims to Remove Stigma of Mental Health Care
May 1, 2008
Gas Tax Summer Holiday: Political Gimmick or Good Policy?
April 30, 2008
Threatened Iraqi U.S. Interpreters: Risky Search for Safe Haven
April 29, 2008
When is Wright Wrong: a Question for Obama
April 25, 2008
Retired Generals on TV: Useful Analysis or Pentagon Propaganda?
April 23, 2008
NAFTA - Friend or Foe?
April 22, 2008
Democratic Party Super Delegates: Free to Ignore You and Me?
April 21, 2008
Carter's Hamas Visit Challenges U.S. Israel Policy: Peace Mission (Impossible?)
April 18, 2008
Clinton Obama Debate and Campaign Analysis: What Influences You?
April 15, 2008
Electoral Crisis in Zimbabwe - Nobody Claims Democracy is Easy
March 13, 2008
Teacher Cliff Notes for YouTube Election Videos!
|
| |
August 1, 2008
New Science Museum Has Penguins with Attitude and Walls Made of Blue Jeans
July 28, 2008
Art Casts New Light on Suburbia
July 18, 2008
What Makes China China? One Man's Quest to Understand the Middle Kingdom
July 16, 2008
Satirical Obama New Yorker Cover Leaves Many Offended
July 14, 2008
Alexander Hamilton's House Takes Short Hike to New Home
July 7, 2008
Final Salute: How Military Families Are Told of the Death of a Loved One
July 4, 2008
Afghanistan's Culture and History Revealed by Hidden Treasures
June 3, 2008
Dominican-American English Professor Junot Diaz wins Pulitzer for 'Oscar Wao'
May 28, 2008
Chinua Achebe on the Literary Legacy of "Things Fall Apart"
May 12, 2008
Israeli and Palestinian Poets: Lending Poetic Justice to Opposing Views
April 28, 2008
Pittsburgh Poet: Claiming Personal Place
April 11, 2008
Grief's Poetic Form, the Elegy
|
| |
August 1, 2008
New Science Museum Has Penguins with Attitude and Walls Made of Blue Jeans
July 9, 2008
High Oil Prices Give Energy Saving Technology a Boost
June 20, 2008
New Orleans Struggles with Possibly Toxic Landfills From Hurricane Katrina
May 30, 2008
Mind Over Matter: Monkeys Brain Activity Used to Control Robotic Arm
May 23, 2008
Birth of a Supernova - Proof that Science is Exciting
May 20, 2008
Alternative Fuels and Rising Prices: Is Ethanol the Problem or the Solution?
May 15, 2008
Polar Bears Threatened By Warming Planet
May 13, 2008
Meet the Greenovators: Eco-minded Entrepreneurs Spark Rust Belt Renewal
May 6, 2008
Tragedy in Kentucky Derby Raises Questions
March 28, 2008
Water, Water Everywhere, But Is It Safe To Drink?
|
| |
July 31, 2008
Attack Ad Also a Lie? A Discussion on the Truthiness of a McCain Television Ad
July 29, 2008
Summer Camp Aims to Ease Burden Felt by Children of Deployed Soldiers
July 28, 2008
Does the Press Love Obama? Critics Exam Coverage of Obama and McCain
July 23, 2008
Moral Hazard: Do Government Bailouts Encourage Risky Behavior?
July 22, 2008
Unfriendly Skies: Airlines and Passengers Suffering from Effects of Rising Gas Prices
July 21, 2008
U.S. Doctors Develop Treatment Program for Young Malawi AIDS Patients
July 18, 2008
What Makes China China? One Man's Quest to Understand the Middle Kingdom
July 16, 2008
Satirical Obama New Yorker Cover Leaves Many Offended
July 14, 2008
Alexander Hamilton's House Takes Short Hike to New Home
July 7, 2008
Final Salute: How Military Families Are Told of the Death of a Loved One
July 4, 2008
Afghanistan's Culture and History Revealed by Hidden Treasures
July 3, 2008
When a Coffee is Not Just Coffee: Starbucks Tries to Get It's Mojo Back
July 1, 2008
More Conservative Supreme Court Shapes Rules on Guns, Death Penalty, Treatment of Terror Suspects
June 30, 2008
The War in Iraq and Why the Democrats Couldn't End It
June 27, 2008
Supreme Court Overturns Gun Ban in Second Amendment Case
June 25, 2008
Gas Price Politics: McCain and Obama Offer Differing Energy Plans
June 20, 2008
New Orleans Struggles with Possibly Toxic Landfills From Hurricane Katrina
June 18, 2008
What's Marriage Got to Do With It? California Allows Same-Sex Marriage
June 16, 2008
When Will U.S. Troops Leave Iraq?
June 13, 2008
How Other Countries View the U.S. Presidential Election
June 12, 2008
Former U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan Explains Food Crisis from African Perspective
June 9, 2008
Red, Blue or Purple? Virginia is a Battleground State for Obama and McCain
June 6, 2008
Temporary Visas for Mexican Workers Provide Migrant Labor for U.S. Farms
June 5, 2008
Obama's Nomination: History in the Making
June 4, 2008
2008 Democratic Primaries: an Epic Political Journey
June 3, 2008
Dominican-American English Professor Junot Diaz wins Pulitzer for 'Oscar Wao'
June 2, 2008
Internet Thriving Inside the Great(Fire)Wall of China
May 28, 2008
Chinua Achebe on the Literary Legacy of "Things Fall Apart"
May 27, 2008
Young and in Love... With Politics - the Youth Vote's Impact on the 2008 Election
May 22, 2008
Iraq Veterans Speak Out Against Conduct of the War
May 21, 2008
Lobbyists and Election Campaigns: What's the Fuss?
May 20, 2008
Alternative Fuels and Rising Prices: Is Ethanol the Problem or the Solution?
May 19, 2008
MySpace-related Suicide Highlights Cyber-Bullying
May 16, 2008
Same-Sex Marriage Debate: Civil Right or Civic Wrong?
May 14, 2008
Humanitarian Crisis Challenges Myanmar's Isolation
May 13, 2008
Meet the Greenovators: Eco-minded Entrepreneurs Spark Rust Belt Renewal
May 12, 2008
Israeli and Palestinian Poets: Lending Poetic Justice to Opposing Views
May 9, 2008
Media Coverage of Race in the Election: More Than Skin Deep?
May 8, 2008
Freedom to Marry: The Loving Case that Overturned Anti-Miscegenation Laws
May 7, 2008
Big Tankers, Big Business, Big Battle
May 6, 2008
Tragedy in Kentucky Derby Raises Questions
May 5, 2008
U.S. Farm Subsidies and Foreign Food Aid: Malawi, a Case Study
May 2, 2008
New Military Policy Aims to Remove Stigma of Mental Health Care
May 1, 2008
Gas Tax Summer Holiday: Political Gimmick or Good Policy?
April 30, 2008
Threatened Iraqi U.S. Interpreters: Risky Search for Safe Haven
April 29, 2008
When is Wright Wrong: a Question for Obama
April 25, 2008
Retired Generals on TV: Useful Analysis or Pentagon Propaganda?
April 24, 2008
Rising Price of Rice - Silent Tsunami?
April 21, 2008
Carter's Hamas Visit Challenges U.S. Israel Policy: Peace Mission (Impossible?)
April 18, 2008
Clinton Obama Debate and Campaign Analysis: What Influences You?
April 17, 2008
Confronting the Real Costs of Women's Low Wages
April 16, 2008
Pope Quiz: Who is Benedict XVI?
April 15, 2008
Electoral Crisis in Zimbabwe - Nobody Claims Democracy is Easy
April 14, 2008
Iraq War Movies: What's (Not) Happening?
April 9, 2008
Roger Mudd on Network News: Just a Shadow of its Former Glory
April 8, 2008
Laying the Ground for a Frank Discussion of Undocumented Students
April 7, 2008
Martin Luther King Jr. Classroom Inspiration for Any Season
April 3, 2008
On the Ground in Afghanistan: What Would You Do?
March 28, 2008
Water, Water Everywhere, But Is It Safe To Drink?
March 26, 2008
Kenya Crisis Illustrates Challenges in Nation Building
March 20, 2008
Five Years in Iraq: Facing Our War
|
| |
August 1, 2008
New Science Museum Has Penguins with Attitude and Walls Made of Blue Jeans
July 29, 2008
Summer Camp Aims to Ease Burden Felt by Children of Deployed Soldiers
July 28, 2008
Does the Press Love Obama? Critics Exam Coverage of Obama and McCain
July 23, 2008
Moral Hazard: Do Government Bailouts Encourage Risky Behavior?
July 22, 2008
Unfriendly Skies: Airlines and Passengers Suffering from Effects of Rising Gas Prices
July 16, 2008
Satirical Obama New Yorker Cover Leaves Many Offended
July 14, 2008
Alexander Hamilton's House Takes Short Hike to New Home
July 7, 2008
Final Salute: How Military Families Are Told of the Death of a Loved One
July 3, 2008
When a Coffee is Not Just Coffee: Starbucks Tries to Get It's Mojo Back
July 1, 2008
More Conservative Supreme Court Shapes Rules on Guns, Death Penalty, Treatment of Terror Suspects
June 30, 2008
The War in Iraq and Why the Democrats Couldn't End It
June 27, 2008
Supreme Court Overturns Gun Ban in Second Amendment Case
June 25, 2008
Gas Price Politics: McCain and Obama Offer Differing Energy Plans
June 24, 2008
U.S.-Funded Network Broadcasts News to the Arab World, but is Anyone Listening?
June 23, 2008
Farmers, U.S. Food Supply in Trouble After Massive Flooding
June 20, 2008
New Orleans Struggles with Possibly Toxic Landfills From Hurricane Katrina
June 19, 2008
Low Test Scores Mean Big Changes in D.C. Schools
June 18, 2008
What's Marriage Got to Do With It? California Allows Same-Sex Marriage
June 17, 2008
Change We Can Log Onto: How the Internet has Reshaped Presidential Campaigns
June 16, 2008
When Will U.S. Troops Leave Iraq?
June 13, 2008
How Other Countries View the U.S. Presidential Election
June 5, 2008
Obama's Nomination: History in the Making
May 9, 2008
Media Coverage of Race in the Election: More Than Skin Deep?
|
| |
July 18, 2008
What Makes China China? One Man's Quest to Understand the Middle Kingdom
July 16, 2008
Satirical Obama New Yorker Cover Leaves Many Offended
July 14, 2008
Alexander Hamilton's House Takes Short Hike to New Home
July 7, 2008
Final Salute: How Military Families Are Told of the Death of a Loved One
July 3, 2008
When a Coffee is Not Just Coffee: Starbucks Tries to Get It's Mojo Back
June 30, 2008
The War in Iraq and Why the Democrats Couldn't End It
June 23, 2008
Farmers, U.S. Food Supply in Trouble After Massive Flooding
June 18, 2008
What's Marriage Got to Do With It? California Allows Same-Sex Marriage
June 16, 2008
When Will U.S. Troops Leave Iraq?
June 13, 2008
How Other Countries View the U.S. Presidential Election
June 12, 2008
Former U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan Explains Food Crisis from African Perspective
May 29, 2008
Modern China Confronts Environmental Crisis
May 28, 2008
Chinua Achebe on the Literary Legacy of "Things Fall Apart"
May 23, 2008
Birth of a Supernova - Proof that Science is Exciting
May 9, 2008
Media Coverage of Race in the Election: More Than Skin Deep?
April 18, 2008
Clinton Obama Debate and Campaign Analysis: What Influences You?
April 17, 2008
Confronting the Real Costs of Women's Low Wages
April 16, 2008
Pope Quiz: Who is Benedict XVI?
April 14, 2008
Iraq War Movies: What's (Not) Happening?
April 11, 2008
Grief's Poetic Form, the Elegy
April 10, 2008
$4 Gas in Our Future? Oil Prices and Alternative Energy
April 9, 2008
Roger Mudd on Network News: Just a Shadow of its Former Glory
April 8, 2008
Laying the Ground for a Frank Discussion of Undocumented Students
April 7, 2008
Martin Luther King Jr. Classroom Inspiration for Any Season
April 4, 2008
John Merrow: Case Studies of School Reform
April 3, 2008
On the Ground in Afghanistan: What Would You Do?
March 13, 2008
Teacher Cliff Notes for YouTube Election Videos!
March 10, 2008
April is Poetry Month - Unleash Our Poetry Series on Your Class!
March 6, 2008
Falling dollar: understanding the impact
March 4, 2008
Keeping Eyes on the Prize
(1)
February 28, 2008
Disputin' Putin? Russia's Tightly Controlled Presidential Election
January 11, 2008
Web Resources - It Takes a Village
(1)
January 9, 2008
If a picture is worth 1000, how many words is a video worth?
(2)
|
| |
July 18, 2008
What Makes China China? One Man's Quest to Understand the Middle Kingdom
July 4, 2008
Afghanistan's Culture and History Revealed by Hidden Treasures
June 30, 2008
The War in Iraq and Why the Democrats Couldn't End It
June 24, 2008
U.S.-Funded Network Broadcasts News to the Arab World, but is Anyone Listening?
June 16, 2008
When Will U.S. Troops Leave Iraq?
June 13, 2008
How Other Countries View the U.S. Presidential Election
June 12, 2008
Former U.N. Secretary-General Kofi Annan Explains Food Crisis from African Perspective
June 6, 2008
Temporary Visas for Mexican Workers Provide Migrant Labor for U.S. Farms
June 3, 2008
Dominican-American English Professor Junot Diaz wins Pulitzer for 'Oscar Wao'
June 2, 2008
Internet Thriving Inside the Great(Fire)Wall of China
May 29, 2008
Modern China Confronts Environmental Crisis
May 14, 2008
Humanitarian Crisis Challenges Myanmar's Isolation
|
|
|
|
|
 |
Video Picks are a way to sample the various internet video sites that may contain content relevant for teachers. We welcome comments and suggestions. » Hide this text
This is a collection of blogs by teachers or relevant to teaching. We welcome any suggestions or submissions.
» Hide this text |
Comments