the Online NewsHour
E-mail This Page   Print This Page  
the Online NewsHour EXTRANews for Students AND Teacher Resources MAIN: ONLINE NEWSHOUR
7 - 12 grade level
SEARCH
ALL OR STUDENT VOICES LESSON PLANS VIDEO GO
Main: NewsHour ExtraU.S.WorldScienceEconomicsHealthArts and MediaStudent VoicesTeacher Center

Watch the full episode. See more PBS NewsHour.

Posted on August 8, 2011

Surrogacy Changes Lives, Raises Ethical Issues

This is the second of two reports about Indian women who are paid to bear children for infertile Western couples. Note to teachers: Some of the material in this video may not be suitable for all ages.

In India, parental surrogacy is often less complicated and expensive than having a surrogate in the United States. Even though the money may lift many women out of poverty, the practice also raises ethical concerns.

Dr. Nayna Patel of Akanksha Infertility Clinic has delivered 400 surrogate babies since 2004. According to reports, her clinic implants embryos in surrogates she recruits from the area and pays around $7,000 for a pregnancy carried to term. Biological parents come from across India and around the world.

Parents traveling to meet their newborns also come from all over the world.

Kirshner Ross-Vaden, 46, came from Colorado to pick up her baby girl named Serenity. She was born four weeks premature, but after a week in neonatal intensive care, she was ready to be discharged.

According to Vaden, the cost, $10,000 to $15,000 all told, is a fraction of what it is in the U.S. And, in America, she added, surrogacy contracts are not always airtight

"You can sign 100 documents. It doesn't matter. If that surrogate changes her mind, she can sue you for that child. And, oftentimes, she will win. And coming here to India, these women, they don't want my child. It's very cut and dry. They do not want my child. They want my money. And that is just fine with me," she said.

However, not everyone agrees.

According to Dr. Arthur Caplan, director of the University of Pennsylvania Center for Bioethics, the contracts are usually written to protect the wealthy people who are commissioning the baby.

"So that if the woman suffers an injury, if the woman has a health problem due to childbirth, if there's a long-term chronic condition, then what?" Caplan asked.

Dr. Nayna Patel said they do a lot of psychological counseling to the surrogate and the family before they recruit them. They explain to them the procedure of IVF, what all they will have to undergo.

"If she has had any complications during her previous pregnancy, we will ask her not to become a surrogate, because the same can repeat this time, to make it very sure and safe for her," she said.

According to reports, the moment their pregnancies are confirmed, surrogates are required to move into this home run by Dr. Patel. They're offered skills training in things like tailoring, but mostly it's a quiet, sedentary life.

The women who spend nine months in this surrogate hostel have all experienced childbirth with their own biological children. It's a prerequisite for becoming a surrogate. What very few of them have experienced with those previous pregnancies is any kind of prenatal care. And that's in sharp contrast to the pampering they get here, with meals provided and medical attention, should they need it, round the clock.

"You can sign 100 documents. It doesn't matter. If that surrogate changes her mind, she can sue you for that child. And, oftentimes, she will win. And coming here to India, these women, they don't want my child. It's very cut and dry. They do not want my child. They want my money. And that is just fine with me." - Kirshner Ross-Vaden.

"And the contracts are usually written, to be blunt, to protect the wealthy people who are commissioning the baby, so that if the woman suffers an injury, if the woman has a health problem due to childbirth, if there's a long-term chronic condition, then what?" -Dr. Arthur Caplan, Director, University of Pennsylvania Center for Bioethics.

"Am I living happily ever after now? I certainly hope so. I hope that I can get her home, and I hope that she is a happy, healthy little baby, and that -- that is what I will have, that she will remain such and grow up as such, a happy, healthy little girl." -Kirshner Ross-Vaden.

1. What is infertility?

2. What is surrogacy?

3. Do you know anyone who has had a baby through a surrogate mother?

1. What is the difference between surrogacy and adoption?

2. Why are couples traveling outside the U.S. to find surrogates?

3. How do you feel about surrogacy? Discuss.

Comments

Post a Comment:

This is a teacher community that thrives on your thoughts, suggestions and comments. We would love to have a free ranging discussion in this space about the resources and how we can all encourage young people to think about current events and the world around them.

So, dive in. Tell other teachers what you like about this video, what you wish was different and what you hope to accomplish.

Especially helpful? Come back after using the video and let us know how it worked!

To ensure a productive and civil discourse, we pre-moderate comments, so it might take a little time for your comment to appear.

Thanks for waiting.

Name: (required, pseudonym ok)
E-mail address: (required, will not be published)
Comment:
 

 
Welcome
Video Packages
Compiled from over 30 years of NewsHour archives, video packages provide historical context to topical issues.
Black Monday

NewsHour Coverage of Financial Turmoil

A selection of NewsHour coverage of past turmoil in financial markets.

Oil

Oil Prices: a Brief History

Four decades of NewsHour coverage on the price of oil.

NewsHour Coverage of Immigration Issues

As an increasing number of people enter the U.S. illegally, the United States has struggled to address the immigration issue.

Bridge

Examining the State of U.S. Infrastructure

Ray Suarez examines the state of bridges, ports, airports and roads across the U.S. in Blueprint America, a collaboration with WNET New York.

More resources: Blueprint America

Hurricane photo

A Look Back: Hurricane Katrina

NewsHour reports from the days immediately following the hurricane, detailing the storm\'s damage, broken levees, evacuations and the relief efforts.

Mao watch

NewsHour Coverage of Modern China

This video package focuses on modern Chinese history and how some of the biggest developments from the country have influenced the world.

Mars lander

NASA Celebrates Fifty Years

NASA was established on July 29, 1958. Watch recent NewsHour interviews with NASA scientists and reports on NASA research.

Radovan Karadzic

NewsHour Coverage of Radovan Karadzic

A collection of NewsHour coverage of former Bosnian Serb leader Radovan Karadzic, who was captured in July 2008 on war crimes charges.

Benazir Bhutto

NewsHour Interviews with Pakistani Leader Benazir Bhutto

A series of interviews with assassinated Pakistani politician Benazir Bhutto, the first woman elected to lead a Muslim country.

 
FRIDAY
What's Next for the U.S. Drone Campaign?
News Wrap: Syria Is Said to Agree to Peace Summit
Oklahomans Help Each Other to Rebuild and Recover
New 'Development' for Delivering Entertainment
Political Wrap With Brooks and Marcus
A Look Inside the Making of U.S. Foreign Policy
An hour-long daily news broadcast.