Gabrielle Giffords (D): Right now we don't provide in-state tuition for undocumented immigrants. We know that the cost of education continues to go up and up and up. My priority is to make sure that folks who are here legally are able to receive the educational benefits first and foremost.

Randy Graf (R): We only have so many seats available for high school students. For every illegal alien that comes in and takes a seat, that's taking it from someone that should have the right to go to that school but may be not allowed to attend because there's only so much room.

Randy Graf (R): I understand that many states do allow that, but here in Arizona we do not. We are not comfortable with [that]. We should give preference obviously to the residents of our state who are U.S. citizens, who are here in this country legally. In-state tuition for those in the country illegally would do a disservice to students who live in other states who come to Arizona to study.

Gabrielle Giffords (D): We here in southern Arizona are disproportionately shouldering the effects of illegal immigration through our state. It's a national problem. The national government needs to get involved. We are disproportionately -- here in Arizona -- shouldering the burden.

Gabrielle Giffords (D): Because there was a buildup of the California-Mexico border, the U.S. Texas border. And the way that the roads are, the way the geography is, we have a disproportionate percentage of people who are crossing through our borders -- thousands and thousands every single day.

Randy Graf (R): The 8th district in Arizona has 80 miles of border with Mexico. Along our border, just in the state of Arizona last year, border patrol apprehended over 500,000 illegal aliens. And they admit that they only apprehend one in four. So that means as many as one-and-a-half million illegal aliens walk across the border into Arizona. They also suggest that 17 percent of those that they apprehend are previously convicted criminals here in the United States. By those numbers, that means ... close to 250,000 illegal aliens with previous criminal records -- rape, murder, child molestation -- are walking across our border into our neighborhoods, into our communities, and this is unacceptable.

Gabrielle Giffords (D): We had a statewide initiative a couple of years ago called Proposition 200 which did a couple of things: One, it required proof of citizenship for voting; another was it denied social services or emergency services to folks who could not prove that they were U.S. citizens, and it passed overwhelmingly. So many people in Arizona feel frustrated about the situation with illegal immigration and people are pretty vocal about it.

Randy Graf (R): Proposition 200 didn't change who was eligible; it simply said prove your eligibility, and it passed by a total of 56 percent to 44 percent. Arizonans approved of those simple measures dealing with our voting system, trying to prevent voter fraud, and trying to prevent welfare fraud. So it passed by 12 percentage points, pretty overwhelmingly. I believe the vast majority of Arizona citizens would feel the same way dealing with in-state tuition for illegal aliens.

Gabrielle Giffords (D): [In-state tuition for undocumented migrants] is not going to happen in our Arizona State Legislature. The appropriations chair this last week talked in a very strong way against illegal immigrants and referred to illegals as "wetbacks." We have an incredibly incredibly conservative Arizona House and Arizona Senate. In no time in the near future are we going to allow in-state tuition who are here and are not documented. It's not going to happen here in Arizona.