Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

Program
Support
From:
ABOUT US  |  LOCAL TV LISTINGS    E-MAIL   PRINT      
PBS NewsHour
TopicsVideoRecent ProgramsTeacher ResourcesThe Rundown: news blogSubscribe rss | podcast


REGION: North America
TOPIC: Politics
Online NewsHour
FORUM
Posted: October 16, 2007

Authors Debate Israeli Lobby's Role

Forum Introduction
Condoleezza Rice and Ehud Olmert Abraham Foxman, Director of the Anti-Defamation League and author of "The Deadliest Lies" and John Mearsheimer, a professor at the University of Chicago and co-author of "The Israel Lobby and U.S. Foreign Policy" answered your questions on the influence of the Israeli lobby in the United States.
QUESTIONS
What if the Palestinian Authority renounced claims on Jerusalem?
Why is any criticism of Israel a criticism of the Jewish people?
Isn't it the fault of the American system if the Israel lobby has too much influence?
Would the US have voted differently in the United Nations if not for Israel?
Do the views of the Jewish leaders reflect that of the Jewish people?
Why should the US pay $3 billion a year to Israel it has a high standard of living?
Hector Smith of Santa Ana, Calif., asks:
Israel has a higher standard of living than many industrial countries, such as Spain and Ireland, yet it receives $3 billion from the U.S. Where is this money going and why should the American taxpayer support this?
ANSWERS
Abraham Foxman responds:
Abraham Foxman responds:

It is true that the Israeli economy has taken off in the last decade, mostly because of its advanced high tech sector. This was not always true and for decades Israel's economy was under stress as a new nation integrating people from all over the world while having to defend itself from hostile neighbors. In those days, U.S. economic assistance was critical for Israel.

Today, Israel no longer receives U.S. economic assistance. This, indeed, is recognition of the advances in the Israeli economy. Military assistance is another matter and reflects several particular factors that apply to Israel, its situations in the Middle East, and its relationship with the United States.

From its independence in 1948, Israel has been in a unique circumstance as a state whose neighbors denied Israel's right to exist and who took steps, military and otherwise, to try to end its existence. Unfortunately, that situation has not completely changed. Countries like Iran and groups like Hamas and Hezbollah are openly committed to Israel's destruction.

As a result, there is a tremendous burden on Israel to maintain a military that will deter its oil-rich neighbors from achieving their goal. U.S. aid to Israel recognizes that unique situation that our ally has been in and has worked with Israel to ensure it maintains a strategic military edge to deter its enemies.

John Mearsheimer responds:
John Mearsheimer responds:

It is hard to say how Israel uses the foreign aid that we give it both because money is fungible and because Israel does not have to account for how it uses our economic aid. Israel is a relatively wealthy country - indeed, it has the 29th highest per capita GNP in the world - and there is no good reason why the American taxpayer should be giving every Israeli the equivalent of $500 per year, especially when Israel continues to pursue policies (e.g. settlement building) that are at odds with official U.S. policy and which hurt American interests around the globe.


CURRENT NEWSHOUR HEADLINES







The PBS NewsHour is Funded in part by: The John S. and James L. Knight Foundation Additional Foundation and Corporate Sponsors
Program
Support
From:
Copyright © 1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.