Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

Program
Support
From:
ABOUT US  |  LOCAL TV LISTINGS    E-MAIL   PRINT      
PBS NewsHour
TopicsVideoRecent ProgramsTeacher ResourcesThe Rundown: news blogSubscribe rss | podcast


REGION: North America
TOPIC: Science & Technology
Online NewsHour
FORUM
Posted: July 16, 2009

Cyber Attacks on Governments

Forum Introduction
Blank South Korean ministry Web pages; AFP/Getty On the Fourth of July, cyber attacks started targeting computers at the White House, the Pentagon and other major U.S. government agencies. The New York Stock Exchange and the South Korean government were also targets. Who and what are behind the attacks? Two experts take your questions.
QUESTIONS
How can the average person protect his or her computer or Web site from being infected and used in similar cyber attacks?
What software vulnerabilities were exploited in the attacks? How has the software company responded?
I visited a foreign Web site and was greeted with a message saying I was under a malware attack. What should I have done?
When another nation launches a cyber attack on the United States government, why is it never discussed as an act of war?
How did malicious code get planted on so many computers? Did all the infected computers have to be turned on to be hijacked?
Can computers or servers be programmed to ignore repeated contacts from the same IP address to lower the risk of such attacks?
Do you foresee average Internet users benefitting from Internet2 community research?
Government security aside, is it sensible to expose one's personal financial to the Internet through online banking and brokerage?
Can adaptive software in routers be used to cope with cyber attacks?
The Online NewsHour asks:
Several viewers wanted to know the details about the computer operating system or types of computers that contributed to the distribution of the recent attacks. What vulnerabilities were exploited and how have the involved companies responded?
ANSWERS
Randy Sabett responds:
Randy Sabett responds:

The type of computer or computer operating system is less relevant than the nature of this particular type of attack. Let's recall the telephone analogy of where hundreds or thousands of bogus calls at the same time would prevent the one legitimate call from getting through. In that case there are no exploits of a vulnerability in the telephone system. Instead, the system is behaving as designed.

The same is true here with the DDOS attack - the Web is designed to allow requests to flow from a source (requesting) computer to a destination (responding) computer. When you have tens of thousands of source/requesting computers in a botnet all sending requests at the same time to a destination/responding computer (i.e., an attack target), that destination/responding computer gets overwhelmed. In this case, the system is also behaving as designed.

These DDOS attacks were not based on a flaw in any software. I would say that this isn't even a flaw in the general design of the system, other than perhaps not having security against such an attack automatically built into the protocol. Even a protocol-based response might not be appropriate, though. Think, for example, of when concert or other event tickets go on sale. The Web sites of the ticket sellers would legitimately get flooded. A protocol that automatically reacted to such a situation as an attack would result in a false positive with potentially very unintended consequences (e.g., people not getting through to buy tickets).

In conversations with colleagues, some have said the design of systems that provide Web site functionality could have helped prevent the problem. For example, an agency that uses an outsourced Web services provider that distributes content across multiple (possibly regional) servers would be less susceptible to such an attack than an agency that has kept everything in-house and centrally located. For those that have centrally located servers, they would need to take some of the steps outlined below (in the response to Mr. or Ms. Summers) , but the centralized nature of their systems would still make them susceptible to a renewed attack.

Going back to my previous response, the main 'vulnerability' here was a human one, not a technical one. Visiting untrustworthy Web sites or opening untrusted files, in combination with not having appropriate security software running, can cause people to infect their computers. This can then lead to the problems that have been experienced.

Rod Beckstrom responds:
Rod Beckstrom responds:

A summary of the technical details for the Windows operating system vulnerability exploited in the recent distributed denial-of-service attacks involving Web sites in Korea and U.S. is provided here.

Next Question and Answer

ONLINE NEWSHOUR LINKS

May 29, 2009
Digital Threats Mark New Front in Nation's Security


May 29, 2009
Obama Looks to Beef Up Security Against Digital Threats


May 21, 2009
In-depth coverage: Domestic Security




NEWSHOUR EXTRA LINKS

April 10, 2009
Cyber Crime and Spying Threaten National Security




CURRENT NEWSHOUR HEADLINES







The PBS NewsHour is Funded in part by: The John S. and James L. Knight Foundation Additional Foundation and Corporate Sponsors
Program
Support
From:
Copyright © 1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.