Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

Program
Support
From:
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
ABOUT US  |  LOCAL TV LISTINGS    E-MAIL   PRINT      
PBS NewsHour
TopicsVideoRecent ProgramsTeacher ResourcesThe Rundown: news blogSubscribe rss | podcast


GEN NEXT: MAIN


THE DOCUMENTARY


THE DEMOGRAPHIC


AUDIO/VIDEO


SPEAK UP


ABOUT THIS PROJECT
The DEMOGRAPHIC
BACKGROUND REPORTS
GEN NEXT DIALOGUES
TIMELINE
MAJOR EVENTS
MEDIA
MUSIC
SPORTS
TECHNOLOGY















RELATED LINKS
Harvard Institute of Politics
Pew Hispanic Center
All Peoples Christian Center
IMMIGRATION Posted: September 13, 2006

Immigration and American Identity

As a young boy, Dan-el Padilla was abandoned by his father, shuffled through homeless shelters and always worried about his family's next meal. Now at 21, Dan-el is on his way to Oxford, after graduating at the top of his class from Princeton University with a degree in classics and a certificate in educational policy.

He sounds like the archetypical American success story. Once Dan-el leaves for Oxford, however, he may not be welcomed back.

Dan-el, who first came to the United States in 1989 at the age of 4, is an illegal immigrant. His family came from the Dominican Republic so his mother could receive temporary special medical attention; they decided not to go back.

While Dan-el no longer worries about where he will sleep or eat, he has found navigating through the United States immigration process to be a complicated and troublesome experience in its own right. The experience has profoundly shaped Dan-el's opinions about immigration -- an issue many of his peers care about as well.

Immigration rights demonstrators in Los Angeles 2006The topic of immigration can trigger strong and emotional responses from young people. Generation Next is coming of age at a time when a nascent war on terror is changing the way people feel about security, freedom and what opportunities America should grant.

A 2006 study by the Harvard Institute of Politics suggests that 31 percent of 18-25-year-old college students in the United States agree with the statement, "Recent immigration into this country has done more harm than good." Twenty-seven percent disagree with that statement, while 40 percent had no opinion.

The debate falls closest to home for those members of Generation Next who are immigrants themselves. There are nearly 5.2 million immigrants of various national and ethnic origins in the United States between the ages of 18 and 25, according to a 2005 tabulation by the Pew Hispanic Center. That's 12 percent of Generation Next.

Like Dan-el, nearly 2.5 million immigrants between 18 and 25 in the United States are undocumented, according to the Pew Hispanic Center. Of all the undocumented immigrants in this country, nearly one quarter belong to this generation.

Dan-el may be undocumented, but he identifies with the United States. He did, after all, grow up there -- albeit arduously.

Dan-el was raised in homeless shelters and shady apartment buildings in New York City. His one respite was school. He developed an interest in classic literature at an early age and saw a good education as his ticket out of the ghetto.

Dan-el worked particularly hard to overcome the language barrier he faced in the United States. His mother did not speak English, and he learned under trial by fire in poor public schools. It was a rough experience, Dan-el said.

"In a way, to be American has meant you check your cultural identity at the door," he said. "What's been particularly disheartening to me about the immigration debate and ancillary issues like language is that people say, 'Now that you're in America, you have to act American.'" It isn't necessary to explicitly request that immigrants learn English, Dan-el said, because the pressure to do so is already there.

In his opinion, people are unsympathetic toward immigrants because of the individualistic nature of the "American dream."

"People think, I succeeded on my own terms, and if people can't, there's something wrong with them, or they're to be blamed for the problems they've encountered," Dan-el said. "I think that's kind of perverse."

While he is skeptical of whether the reality of the American dream can match its rhetoric, Dan-el doesn't deny that it has applied to his life. "When I was younger," he said, "I would ask myself, 'Could I have done this anywhere else?'"

Ultimately, Dan-el would like to pursue a career in teaching in the United States. He would also like to help shape educational policy. Because he is not a legal resident of the United States, immigration law says that if Dan-el were to leave the country, he would not be able to return for 10 years.

He is excited to study at Oxford, however, and plans to leave this fall. He will apply for a waiver to re-enter the United States to visit his family in the summer. Dan-el says his lawyer is "cautiously optimistic" that the waiver will be granted.

He said he will always call the United States home.

Young man at immigration rally in D.C."There are many things that have been passed down to me about life in the Dominican Republic, but what I know and love is here," he said. "I can't imagine being away from that for too long -- I feel as American as anyone who was born here."

Like Dan-el, first generation American Kimberly Salem has always felt completely American. But the older she gets, she said, the more important it is for her to embrace her identity as a Palestinian American.

Kimberly, 24, grew up in Jacksonville, Fla., with a Caucasian mother and a Palestinian father. Her father immigrated with his family from Ramallah to the United States in the 1950s, when he was 7 years old.

Kimberly's childhood memories are filled with family. Every weekend she and her cousins would play outside, behind her uncle's deli. On Sundays, the whole family made the compulsory trip to church in the morning; in the evening, everyone congregated at her grandmother's house for supper.

Many people in Generation Next feel close to their families -- in fact, 65 percent of people between the ages of 18 and 25 see or talk to a parent every day, according to a 2006 study by the Pew Research Center. Kimberly, however, said she thinks that the tight bond her extended family shares is a function of their strong connection to their culture and homeland.

"It's just that mentality that it takes a village to raise a child," she said. "People in our culture, whether Christian or Muslim, are very strong in faith. Family and God are what you live your life by."

Kimberly is Christian. Her mother is Baptist, and her father is Greek Orthodox. She grew up attending two separate churches.

People aware of Kimberly's ethnicity often assume she is Muslim, but many people think she is Caucasian because of her blond hair, she said. Sometimes people will make derisive comments about Arab culture, unaware of her heritage.

"Sometimes you feel like everyone in the world thinks if you're Palestinian you're a terrorist," she said. "People lump everyone together with those few extremists."

As she has gotten older, Kimberly said, her Arab-American identity has become more meaningful to her. She now works in the Detroit area at the Arab American and Chaldean Council, a nonprofit organization that serves the Arab-American community. Chaldeans are a segment of the Iraqi Christian population. One of the programs that Kimberly helps run is the Cultural Tapestry Initiative, which teaches cultural tolerance and understanding to groups such as schools and businesses.

Familiarizing oneself with a culture clearly helps a person understand current events, Kimberly said; this is especially important to Kimberly since the conflicts are personal for her.

Immigration and American Identity"I've made an attempt to understand the full history, not just what happened two weeks ago," she said. "But you realize, I still have uncles in Ramallah, and there was a bomb in the market there."

While Kimberly has grown to appreciate her identity as an Arab American, finding a place in American culture can be difficult for some first-generation Americans.

Adrian Renteria, 21-year-old social worker from East Los Angeles, said he does not identify himself as American or Mexican.

"I guess people would take it as self-hatred, but it's not," he said. "I respect both sides."

Adrian's father came to the United States at age 17, after having worked in Mexico since he was 5 or 6. His mother is an American-born citizen of Mexican descent. When he visits his family in Mexico, Adrian said, people see him as an American.

"Here, they'd rather call me a Mexican because of my features," he said. Designations such as Chicano or Mexican-American are no better. "The whole hyphen -- that's kind of an insult," he said. "Like, what -- I'm not American?"

Growing up with a turbulent home life situated in gang-ridden neighborhoods did not help Adrian's ideas of what he could make of himself in the United States. Adrian was never in a gang, but just about everyone around him was. "That started at a very young age because I had cousins already gangbanging, and to me it was a normal thing," he said. "I looked up to a lot of these guys."

After shadowing gang members throughout his high school years, Adrian was shot in 2003. He spent some time in jail as a result of the incident.

Now Adrian is a mentoring coach for All Peoples Christian Center, a nonprofit social services organization in Los Angeles. He oversees about 60 students at John Adams Middle School, teaching them about things like proper nutrition, birth control and "just whatever I feel that they wouldn't learn on their own and they won't be taught at school," he said.

Along with mentoring, Adrian is focusing on rapping. Many of his relatives are musicians, and he grew up with fond memories of local mariachi bands, he said. That influenced his love for all types of music.

"I can relate to hip hop more [than to Mariachi music]," he added. "It's just a little more expressive I feel on my part."


-- By Stephanie Condon, Generation Next



Generation Next RSS Feed
FUNDED IN PART BYThe Pew Charitable TrustsThe Annie E. Casey FoundationCarnegie Corporation of New York
The PBS NewsHour is Funded in part by: The John S. and James L. Knight Foundation Additional Foundation and Corporate Sponsors
Program
Support
From:
[an error occurred while processing this directive]
Copyright © 1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.