Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS

Media Watch
Online NewsHour Online Focus
BUSH DEFENDS "RATS" AD

September 12, 2000

An Online NewsHour Report

Texas Gov. George W. Bush manned his defenses on the campaign trail today, after being accused of including a subliminal message in an anti-Gore ad.

NewsHour Links

Online Special:
Media Watch

2000 Democratic Convention

2000 Republican Convention

Election 2000

Sept. 5, 2000:
The candidates on prescription drug benefits..

Sept. 4, 2000:
Debating the debates.

Sept.1, 2000:
Religion and politics.

Jan. 20, 2000:
The GOP tax debate

Jan. 12, 2000: Special interest ads

Dec. 15, 1999:
The GOP air war

Dec. 7, 1999:
The Democratic air war

Browse the NewsHour's coverage of the media

 

 

The ad, which has been airing on television stations across the country for two weeks, is critical of Vice President Al Gore's Medicare plan. But most troubling to the Gore campaign is a frame of the ad where the word "RATS" -- a fragment of the word "bureaucrats" -- appears in white capital letters larger than any other word in the commercial. Some Democrats called the image -- which appears for one 30th of a second -- a subliminal attempt to influence voters.

The word appears on-screen while the commercial tells viewers that, under Gore's plan, "bureaucrats decide" how their health care plans will operate.

The ad, sponsored by the Republican National Committee, is being pulled, although the campaign said it was scheduled to end its run tomorrow anyway. It has run 4,400 times in 33 cities, at a cost of $2.5 million.

The ad's creator calls the word's appearance a "visual drumbeat" meant to grab viewers' attention and not an intentional message. Bush's chief media consultant, Mark McKinnon, told The New York Times today he was not aware that the image appeared in the ad until asked about it by a reporter.

Gore's supporters said they found it hard to believe that the image was unintentional.

"I think it's a disappointing development," Gore told reporters. "I've never seen anything like it."

Gore's running mate, Connecticut Sen. Joe Lieberman, called the ad "very disappointing and strange."

But Bush says cries of conspiracy over the incident are unfounded.

"One frame out of 900 hardly, in my judgment, makes a conspiracy," Bush said today, on a campaign stop in Florida. "Conspiracy theories abound in American politics. I don't think we need to be subliminal about prescription drugs."

Bush said the use of subliminal messages in advertising is "not acceptable."

 


Program
Support
From:
Copyright © 1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.