Event honoring Nelson Mandela lacked usual security measures

BY Associated Press  December 14, 2013 at 2:06 PM EST


President Barack Obama delivers a speech during the memorial service for Nelson Mandela in Johannesburg on Dec. 10, 2013. Credit: Brendan Smialowski/AFP/Getty Images

WASHINGTON — In the hours before President Barack Obama arrived at a Johannesburg soccer stadium to honor Nelson Mandela, the White House staff was in the dark on critical details.

Where would the president and first lady Michelle Obama sit? When was Obama supposed to speak? Who else would be on stage during the speech?

The result was an array of confusion and security risks that typically would not be tolerated by the Secret Service in the United States. The situation showed just how the Secret Service often is at the mercy of foreign governments to make arrangements when the president is overseas.
There were metal detectors and X-ray machines at the stadium, but they were not used on the initial crowds streaming in for the ceremony, according to Associated Press reporters on scene.

Many people walked through with little or no screening. Inside the stadium there were few signs of the heavy security that routinely would accompany an event with Obama and other world leaders.

The VIP section was where Obama and dozens of other dignitaries sat, including former Presidents George W. Bush and Bill Clinton. This area was protected by a short pane of protective glass that covered only those in the first row of seats. Obama and his wife were several rows back.

Large crowds were allowed to gather in front of where Obama sat, with no visible security nearby.

When Obama made his way to the stage to deliver his speech, a South African sign-language interpreter stood an arm’s length away. This man later described himself as schizophrenic with violent tendencies, and he reportedly was accused of murder 10 years ago, according to the national eNCA TV news station in South Africa.

Secret Service officials say the South African government was responsible for the decision to place interpreter Thamsanqa Jantjie just inches from some of the most powerful people in the world during a four-hour memorial service.

“Program items such as stage participants or sign-language interpreters were the responsibility of the host organizing committee,” said Secret Service spokesman Edwin Donovan. “For the purposes of this memorial service, this would include vetting them for criminal history and other appropriate records checks.”

Brian Dube, a spokesman for South Africa’s Ministry of State Security, declined to answer questions Saturday about what security measures were in place at the soccer stadium and what sort of background checks and screening were performed on Jantjie. Dube said those issues are part of the investigation into the hiring and use of the interpreter.

Donovan said prearranged security procedures were in place Tuesday and agents were “in close proximity,” a standard security practice wherever the president is. He declined to discuss specific security details of Obama’s trip to South Africa.

The Secret Service is charged with keeping the president, vice president and their families safe. Presidential trips, whether across the country or around the world, are meticulously planned with every imaginable detail within the agency’s control managed and scheduled.

But once the president leaves the United States, the Secret Service isn’t always entirely in control.

Joe Hagin, a former deputy White House chief of staff for Bush, said that to some degree the Secret Service is at the mercy of a host government.

“There’s a lot of diplomacy involved in one of these trips,” said Hagin, now a partner at Command Consulting Group in Washington. “The White House is very demanding. But there’s a fine line in what you can demand and what you can’t.”

Hagin said some security issues are simply nonnegotiable, including allowing the president to ride in any vehicle that hasn’t been flown in by the Secret Service. The Secret Service also won’t allow the president to leave his security detail.

“You manage the risks. You can never fully mitigate them,” Hagin said.

It was apparent from Obama’s arrival in South Africa that security was not up to Secret Service standards.

Roads typically are shut down for the president’s motorcade. But the highway between the military base where Air Force One landed and the suburban Johannesburg hotel where he spent time before the memorial service was filled with morning rush hour traffic, forcing the motorcade at times to slow to a crawl.

If Secret Service officials aren’t satisfied with security protocols for a foreign trip, the agency can and has advised against going, said Joseph LaSorsa, a retired Secret Service agent.

Hagin said that was the case when President Ronald Reagan wanted to travel to Egypt for the funeral of Anwar Sadat, who was assassinated in Cairo in 1981.

“Reagan wanted to go and the Secret Service said no,” said Hagin, who also worked in the White House under Reagan.

When Pope John Paul II died in Rome in 2005, Hagin said, the decision to have Bush travel to the Vatican was “an easy one.”

LaSorsa, who is now a security consultant, said if anyone is to blame for allowing Jantjie on stage, it is the South African government staff member who selected him.

“I don’t really see this as a Secret Service issue. It just highlights the risk of international travel,” Hagin said.


Associated Press reporters Alicia A. Caldwell and Julie Pace wrote this report. Follow them on Twitter at @acaldwellap and @jpaceDC.

Associated Press writers Jon Gambrell, Alan Clendenning and Ray Faure in Johannesburg contributed to this report.


South African freedom fighter Nelson Mandela, who died Dec. 5, will be buried Dec. 15 on the grounds of his home in South Africa’s Eastern Cape Province.

Here’s how to watch the event online.