Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS
The web site of The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer
Online NewsHour2004 CoveragePrimariesGeneral  Election
Vote 2004
Main Presidential CoverageCandidatesCampaign TrailNewsHour Analysis
General CoverageIssuesKey RacesStudents & Teachers
IssuesHealth Care
Candidate PositionsRecent DevelopmentHistory

President George W. BushPresident George W. Bush
A major feature in President Bush's approach to health care is expanding choices for patients and giving people more control over the type of health care coverage they receive.

"Loss of control to government and health plan bureaucrats threaten to keep patients from getting state-of-the-art care," says the Bush campaign Web site.

According to the site, people should be able to pick the doctors, facilities, and prescription drugs that suit them best. Also, the increase in options would create competition, and drive down raising health care costs.

President Bush also wants to expand coverage through supporting community health centers. These centers, many which are already in place, are centered in low-income urban and rural areas where affordable health care is hard to find.

One of the ways Mr. Bush plans on keeping health care affordable is by slowing the fast-growing medical liability insurance costs that doctors and hospitals often pass on to consumers. The president also advocates for national medical liability standards, saying it would save money that could be used to reduce health care costs. These measures include capping recoveries for non-economic damages and punitive damages, prohibiting old cases from being brought to court years after the incident, and limiting the amount plaintiffs can receive from doctors in compensation for losses when the plaintiffs have already received payments from insurers.

"We've got too many darn lawsuits, too many frivolous and junk lawsuits that are affecting people," Mr. Bush said in a speech in Little Rock, Ark. "We need medical liability reform to make sure that medicine is affordable and available."

Background Information

iconBush 2004: Making Health Care More Accessible and Affordable

iconThe White House: Healthcare

enator John KerrySenator John Kerry
Democratic contender Sen. John Kerry of Massachusetts believes in universal health care and expanding coverage to as many Americans as possible, especially children. He also calls for a loosely defined patient's bill of rights

"We need a strong patient's bill of rights and we need it now, and we will not rest until every single American has affordable health coverage that no bureaucrat can take away," Kerry has said.

Kerry has said he would work to cut family premiums by up to $1,000, savings he says will fuel the economy. He also calls for cutting down on paperwork and improving technology to eliminate the bureaucratic costs of health care, and awarding tax credits to small businesses and those who are 55 to 65 who have trouble buying coverage.

A major difference between Kerry and Bush is Kerry's endorsement of government power to negotiate prescription drug prices on the behalf of patients, especially those on Medicare. Mr. Kerry also supports speeding up the availability of generic drugs and allowing the reimportation of cheaper drugs from Canada and abroad to be sold in the United States.

Kerry also calls for the government to take a harder line when dealing with pharmaceutical and health insurance industries.

"What we're going to do is break this cycle and start putting the worker, the individual citizen, the people, in front of the campaign contributions," the senator said at a speech in Louisville, Ky.

Background Information

iconJohn Kerry 2004: Affordable Healthcare for All

iconVote by Issue Democratic Primary Quiz: John Kerry on the Issues

Recent Developments

DrugsDuring the 2000 election, much of the health care debate focused on reducing the skyrocketing costs of prescription drugs. Both then-Gov. George Bush and Vice President Al Gore campaigned on promises to offer seniors more access to cheaper drugs.

To achieve this, President Bush proposed and Congress passed a prescription drug discount card.

"Seniors are going to be able to save between 15 to 30 percent off the retail price of most brand drugs and more for generic drugs," President Bush said in a May 27 speech. "As well, there is going to be a $600 credit for poor seniors. This is the beginning of a reform package that will affect seniors' lives in a very positive way, by making sure our drugs are more affordable."

However, critics have pointed out that Canadian drugs are still cheaper than those purchased using the new Medicare cards. And while the new card law prohibits the government from negotiating prescription drug prices, federal benefit programs for seniors have also been able to make drugs available for cheaper than the new drug cards.

Cardholders are locked into using their cards for one year, while pharmaceutical companies can change the prices within the program at any time. And with more than 70 different cards to choose from in certain parts of the country with varying benefits, getting and using the cards has been called confusing.

"You'd think with all of the money the government is spending on advertising, more people would have the cards," pharmacist Isam Salah told The Detroit News. "But they're not too sure about it yet."

Related Report
Online NewsHour Health Spotlight
The latest news and information on medical research, health policy, and the healthcare system in the United States.
HistoryTop

President TrumanIn the late 1800s and early 1900s, as American industries began to develop so too did their employee medical programs. However, despite the efforts of social reformers, it wasn't until after World War II when President Harry Truman proposed a national health program plan that there was a serious attempt on the behalf of government to provide health care to the American public.

Truman's ideas were labeled an attempt to socialize medicine and made little headway in the face of opposition from the American Medical Association. The piecemeal system left in place meant health care options were limited to private insurance for those who could afford it and welfare options for the poor. Then, in 1965 President Lyndon Johnson signed Medicare and Medicaid, the largest government effort ever to guarantee some level of medical care in the United States.

While Medicare and Medicaid provided needed support for the poor and elderly, Americans across the board faced increasing medical costs, driven mainly by the increasing lifespan of Americans and the cost of new medical breakthroughs. In response, President Richard Nixon established federal support for health maintenance organizations (HMOs).

HMOs expanded quickly through the 1980s, making health care more of a corporate endeavor. HMOs have been criticized for being more interested in profit than patient care, but have also made health services available to more Americans by reducing costs. While the American public adjusted to changes brought by wide use of HMOs, those who could not afford coverage -- the poor and the elderly -- still relied on federal government programs such as Medicare and Medicaid.

The 21st century has higher health care costs and a push for the government to do something about them. Companies have had trouble keeping up with increasing premiums it must pay and the number of uninsured has continued to inch higher. Some studies have shown that as much as a third of American families, nearly 82 million people, lack coverage. Six states have already frozen enrollment in Medicaid.

With rising costs, more uninsured, people living longer, and an eventual Medicare budget crisis on the horizon, polls show more and more voters are demanding changes to the health care system. Whether President Bush wins reelection or John Kerry takes control of the White House, health care policies will likely be a major factor in the outcome of the 2004 presidential race and will weigh heavily on the president in the next four years.

-- By Chris Nammour, Online NewsHour

Also on PBS.org
Healthcare Crisis: Who's at Risk?
This program, first aired in 2000, outlined a series of possible problems in the U.S. healthcare and how those issues are impacting the lives of ordinary Americans.
By the People Election 2004
The Online NewsHour's Vote 2004 is a part of PBS' By the People: Election 2004
Your guide to PBS election news and resources

    REGIONS | TOPICS | RECENT PROGRAMS | ABOUT US | FEEDBACK |SUBSCRIPTIONS / FEEDS:
POD|RSS
SEARCH
Funded, in part, by:ChevronPacific LifeVestasCorporation for Public Broadcasting
            Support the kind of journalism done by the NewsHour...Become a member of your local PBS station.
PBS Online Privacy Policy

Copyright ©1996- MacNeil/Lehrer Productions. All Rights Reserved.