ANNOUNCER: From our studios in New York, Bill Moyers and David Brancaccio.
BRANCACCIO: Welcome to NOW. We begin tonight with money, the political conventions and some travel advice for Arnold Schwarzenegger. There's word that the California governor has gotten a long list of corporations to pay his way to the Republican convention, where he'll give a primetime address Tuesday night, just a block-and-a-half from here.
The governor's office says the 350,000 dollar budget for Schwarzenegger's trip will come from some oil companies, some pharmaceutical companies, a telephone company, a credit card firm and... see if you can discern a trend here: Fox Entertainment, NBC Universal, News Corp, Paramount, Time Warner, Disney and Viacom. The governor says he's doing it to save the taxpayers money, although the taxpayers will still foot the bill for the Schwarzenegger security detail.
Point number one: 350,000 dollars? Sacramento to New York's JFK on JetBlue is 470 dollars, roundtrip coach. I found a room in the Super 8 in Times Square smoking, of course for 162 plus tax. And if the governor gets hungry, there's a guy around the corner who makes a decent potato knish for two dollars.
Point number two: that's a long list of corporations from a governor who promised during his election campaign last fall that he would ignore special interests.
The private sector is picking up the tab for a lot of what goes on at the political conventions, both Republican and Democratic. This includes invitation-only social events power parties that have become a key component of a democracy that is too often pay to play. Bill Moyers has been looking into this issue with producer Brenda Breslauer.
MOYERS: They're ready and waiting in New York. All of the exclusive venues are booked, beginning with the famed 21 Club, "the city's ultimate experience," with fine wines galore and more deals over lunch than at a Fortune 500 board meeting. The celebrated Tavern on the Green is reserved; so are landmarks like the Metropolitan Museum of Art and the Central Park Boathouse and Rockefeller Center.
What are they getting ready for? Remember the Democratic convention last month in Boston? More than 200 private parties and events. Look closely. That's Howard Dean boogying to music at a party thrown by Johnson and Johnson, the drug company. And here's the Red Hot Chili Peppers flown in especially to play at a benefit gala hosted by the Creative Coalition and the recording industry. And the fellow conducting the orchestra, that's… you know who that is: Senator Ted Kennedy. The Washington wheeler dealer Vernon Jordan had a front row seat. Kennedy's party was paid for by not only by big labor the AFL-CIO but also big name companies like pharmaceutical giant Bristol Myers Squibb, defense contractor Raytheon and Bank of America.
So what's going on here?
ROSS: I think it's clear now that the actual convention proceedings are the sideshow. The real main events are the corporations and the politicians coming together in these excessive, lavish parties.
MOYERS: Private parties.
ROSS: Private parties. You don't get in without an invitation. And the invitations are traded back and forth like viable pieces of currency.
MOYERS: ABC News correspondent Brian Ross and his investigative team have been crashing these parties at convention after convention reporting on the money trail.
ROSS: What's really happening is this is a chance for the big money interests to show their appreciation and to make investments in the future for relationships with the people who are very powerful, the people who run the federal government.
MOYERS: And the ordinary delegates, the public, what happens?
ROSS: They're like extras in a movie. The delegates are there to fill the seats so they look like a lot's going on. But they're not invited to these parties.
We were at one party outside the big bash thrown for Senator Hillary Clinton and her husband, the former President. And I was downstairs. And several delegates from Iowa showed up.
And they'd heard about the party. And assumed that because they were delegates they, of course, would be able to attend. And they were turned away at the door as we were and most other people were. And just sort of stunned that they weren't allowed to go to that party. They thought that as delegates they would be able to. But, in fact, this convention more and more in Boston and here in New York is very much a private affair, invitation only.
MOYERS: Who were these "special interests" in Boston?
ROSS: Every major industry. The pharmaceutical industry, healthcare industry, the railroads, tobacco was there in a smaller role, the recording industry. Every group, every company that has a issue before Congress or before the government. Any industry that's regulated, they all want something.
MOYERS: An example?
ROSS: The Time Warner company spent, I don't know, whatever it cost, to put on a blowout fireworks display for Congresswoman Nancy Pelosi.
And they threw a small, private party for her unannounced. At this outdoor scene with the chairman of Time Warner, Richard Parsons right next to Congresswoman Pelosi. She had her staff and members of the Time Warner staff dodging in front of us so we couldn't see her face, and making every effort to stay away from our cameras. And this is a woman, Bill, who in Washington, you have a hard time keeping away from cameras.
ROSS: Congresswoman, can we speak with you for just a minute . . .
MOYERS: What was she afraid of?
ROSS: I think she didn't have a good answer to the question.
MOYERS: And the question was?
ROSS: Question was "Why are you here"? Why are you letting Time Warner spend several hundred thousand dollars to entertain you?
MOYERS: And what does AOL Time Warner possibly want from the United States Congress?
ROSS: Well Mr. Parsons is very, very candid and said, "We want to be able to know who to talk to, and who can talk to us."
MOYERS: About?
ROSS: Whatever comes up. And they right now have many, many issues, including a federal investigation by the Security Exchange Commission of some of their accounting practices. They have trouble in Washington. And this is how you get out of trouble.
MOYERS: The House Democratic Leader wasn't the only powerful politician who didn't want to talk to Brian Ross during the convention. It was hide and seek all week for Washington's elites. Brian Ross and his crew were ejected from more private parties than you could shake a stick at. And on the way out they found some strange bedfellows.
ROSS: At one point, we began to take a look at what are called these independent groups. It's a way around McCain/Feingold rules that allow the big-money contributors to continue to give large amounts to specially set up committees that claim they have nothing to do with the Democratic Party.
MOYERS: These are the 527s?
ROSS: Right. Loophole in the IRS tax code, 527. And what we discovered was that the five… the biggest of these 527 committees had set up shop right in the Four Seasons, which was the main hotel for the top Democratic money people.
And so, I took a little tourist camera and walked around, and met some of the big money people who said hello, and then wandered into the lounge of this group called ACT, one of these 527s.
VOICEOVER: This morning, the ACT hospitality lounge was full of Democratic donors, and there appears to be a close relationship between the people running ACT and the Democratic Finance Committee.
WOMAN: If I could just escort you outside.
ROSS: They may say they're independent. But clearly, they're not.
MOYERS: So, these 527 committees can only raise money because they proclaim to be independent…
ROSS: Independent.
MOYERS: …of a political party?
ROSS: Nothing to do with the Democratic Party.
But just the proximity alone told me more than I needed to know about this supposed independence.
MOYERS: You got your hands on one of the invitations to the Caribbean beach bash. Tell me about this.
ROSS: Well, this was Senator Breaux's invitation. It came like it was some treasure map. And, in fact, inside… I wasn't allowed inside. I was among the reporters kept outside. But we managed to get somebody inside. And it was quite a scene.
Senator Corzine of New Jersey showed up. And it was an amazing moment because I happened to have in my ear I could hear what was happening in the convention. And I saw Senator Corzine get out of his limousine with his entourage. And Senator Kennedy almost at that very moment was speaking about the excesses of Enron under the Bush Administration and the Democrats would never allow that kind of thing to happen.
KENNEDY: We wouldn't have had the excesses of Enron.
ROSS: And yet here is Senator Corzine arriving at this million dollar-plus party thrown by the biggest, most powerful corporations for one of his fellow members.
CORZINE: I was told there were TVs inside.
MOYERS: But were they watching? Let me make sure that I understand this. Senator Kennedy is speaking on the floor of the convention against special interests, against the power of corporations. And Senator Corzine, who is one of the powerful Democratic senators and chairman of the Senate Democratic Campaign Committee…
ROSS: That's right.
MOYERS: …raising money for Democratic senators around the country.
ROSS: That's right.
MOYERS: …is coming to a private party that's going on simultaneously…
ROSS: Right.
MOYERS: …with the speech that Kennedy is giving on the floor?
ROSS: That's right.
MOYERS: If there's nothing untoward going on, if there's nothing but fun happening out there, why are they keeping you and other reporters out?
ROSS: I think there are certain scenes they would just as soon not have broadcast. Remarkable scenes of Senator Breaux, who looks like he likes a party, playing the washboard. He had a washboard hung over his chest. And this at the same time that Candidate Obama…
MOYERS: Barack Obama, the new star.
ROSS: The great speech of the convention is taking place.
OBAMA: I believe we can provide jobs to the jobless, homes to the homeless.
MOYERS: It wasn't until I watched your reports on ABC that I realized that while the convention was going on, many of the elected officials are at these private events. What does that tell you?
ROSS: That tells me what are they there for? Senator Baucus was at this…
MOYERS: Montana.
ROSS: …fancy restaurant in Boston. The convention was underway. The American Gas Association which apparently put up some $600,000 as its entertainment budget at the Republican and Democratic Convention. Was spending some of it at a restaurant called Torch. Great restaurant in Boston. And its top people and Senator Baucus were all there together as the convention was underway.
MOYERS: Is it a coincidence that Senator Baucus is from Montana and the gas industry wants to drill a lot more for gas in Montana?
ROSS: I don't think it's a coincidence. And I don't think it's a coincidence that he's the ranking member on the Senate Finance Committee.
MOYERS: And what's this?
ROSS: This was the invitation to a party for the blue dog Democrats…
MOYERS: Southern Democrats.
ROSS: Southern Democrats.
MOYERS: Conservative…
ROSS: Conservative Democrats. And it was with the Neville Brothers. Lot of money spent here. And everybody…
ROSS: American Hospital, Met Life, Home Depot, Edison Electric, Distilled Spirits Council, the liquor industry, Clear Channel, Comcast, Altria, that's Phillip-Morris, that's its new name. Every single company or trade group here has a major issue before Congress.
MOYERS: Many of these companies you just named and others paid for big parties at the Democratic Convention. And they're doing the same thing for the Republican Convention. How do you explain that?
ROSS: Well, there's no ideology here involved. They want to have their bets placed on both the red and the black. They want their bets placed on both parties. Whoever's going to be in power, they're going to have a say.
MOYERS: What do you expect when the Republicans gather here in New York next week?
ROSS: I think they'll easily match. They will no doubt outdo the Democrats. The Republicans are not burdened by any notion of trying to say we're against this. The Democrats have a problem with hypocrisy.
They say they oppose the influence of big money in politics, yet they take it. Republicans have no such inhibitions. And they don't even begin to think about this being a problem.
MOYERS: I understand the chairman of the House Financial Services Committee Michael Oxley, is being thrown a big party by the financial industry here in New York. Why would they be doing that?
ROSS: The financial services industry has so many issues before someone like Oxley. He's a master of this.
He can control which bills get through committee, which bills are considered. There are small provisions sometimes in these bills that mean literally billions of dollars for major corporations, things we'll never even find out about.
MOYERS: The MBNA America Bank is honoring Roy Blunt? Who is Roy Blunt?
ROSS: Roy Blunt is the number three Republican of the House.
MOYERS: Very powerful?
ROSS: Extremely powerful. He is very close to Majority Leader DeLay. And MBNA is simply the largest credit card issuer in the country. And they have hundreds of issues before Congress.
MOYERS: Among the many parties reportedly taking place in New York next week, the Edison Electric Institute, Southern Co, and 28 other sponsors will host a Lynyrd Skynyrd concert this week for two of their powerful friends in the Senate, southerners Lindsey Graham and Saxby Chambliss.
And the Nuclear Energy Institute, the National Mining Association and the American Gas Association will be throwing a honky-tonk salute for Texas congressman Joe Barton, chairman surprise, surprise of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce, which oversees their industries.
MOYERS: But is it possible that what they all they want is a good time?
ROSS: Well, I keep asking that question, you know? What's wrong with a good party? And the fact is that's what's really happening here is money for access.
One lobbyist put it quite clearly. Said, "We are dancing together. And it's not quite clear who's leading. But we are dancing together and that's how the game works."
MOYERS: Ross says that's why some 20 companies were willing to sponsor that Caribbean beach party in Boston for retiring Senator John Breaux of Louisiana. The companies were approached by lobbyists, one of whom used to be Breaux's chief of staff, to contribute to the party in honor of Breaux.
MOYERS: Why would these big companies be throwing a party for an outgoing senator?
ROSS: Well, that was a huge thank you. One big thank you by 20 major corporations who are all approached to put up the money for this blow-out bash with the dancers on stilts and the Caribbean bands.
MOYERS: Corporations didn't come to him?
ROSS: Didn't go to him. They were approached and asked if they wanted to contribute. And the companies say they can't really say no. Do you want to run the risk of offending Senator Breaux?
And it's the same thing with the Republicans. Senator Frist, the Republican leader in the Senate, has done the same thing for the big bash he's planning to throw here in New York.
MOYERS: There is a solicitation from Senator Frist's fundraisers that actually say this party is hugely the success of this party is hugely important to Senator Frist.
ROSS: And that's a message that no lobbyist or no corporate executive is going to ignore. That means if he asks, you'd better say yes if you want to do business with him. If you want to offend him, go right ahead. But nobody really wants to do that who has issues before Congress.
MOYERS: Well, help us to understand this because the Frist invitation says $250,000 will get you ten tickets and several other little benefits. And it says that the funds that this money will go to the global HIV/AIDS campaign. What's going on there?
ROSS: This is a new… I would call it a scam. They have created charities which essentially will become fronts for lavish parties at the convention. And the Republicans are in the forefront here. Senator Frist's charity is run by the same people who run his political campaign.
It has no office. It has no staff. It has no history of having any events prior to this or any events scheduled in the future. And the people in the watch charities say this is an outrageous example of how the tax laws are used because charities get certain special benefits and they're very hard to regulate. And by calling yourself a charity, he's able essentially to throw all this huge party for all his friends, impress his fellow senators. And, in fact, the companies that give the money will find it to be tax deductible.
MOYERS: Tax deductible.
ROSS: It's a contribution to charity.
MOYERS: Even though it's benefiting a politician.
ROSS: That's right.
ROSS: This is a way to get around the restrictions imposed by McCain-Feingold on soft money. Now, certainly some money seems to be going to some AIDS operation. I'm not sure what it is. They're not sure what it is. You ask them, they say, "Well, we're going to figure that out." But the fact is the intent here is not to raise lots of money for AIDS. The intent is to throw a big event for Senator Frist. Make him a big man here in New York at the convention.
MOYERS: And what do they ultimately get from that?
ROSS: Well, they get Senator Frist remembering who they were. "We gave to your charity. And we want to come by and see you and talk about an issue that's of importance to us." No one's saying, "I want your vote on this issue." This is more about the access game in Washington. The ability to have time with Senator Frist which is very valuable.
I doubt that most of Senator Frist's constituents would have the same access that some of these big companies will have after they give money to his charity, the ones very important to him.
MOYERS: And this gift is tax deductible? Ultimately, the taxpayer is going to pick up the tab, right?
ROSS: Best I know, the contributions to these newly-created charities, absolutely tax deductible. And the other money is spent as part of a business expense.
Same thing as hiring a lobbyist, also deductible, a business expense. It's money that is in the millions of dollars, tens of millions. And despite all the reforms, all the talk about trying to end the influence of corporate money. There is no requirement for these companies to ever, ever reveal how much they're spending.
MOYERS: Brian Ross, thank you very much and ABC News, for doing this.
ROSS: Thank you very much.
BRANCACCIO: Brian Ross will be all over town next week, crashing A-list parties and watching as money and politics mingle.
You can see his series "The Money Trail" each night on World News Tonight, as part of ABC News coverage of the Republican National Convention.
|