Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
Talk
Ridge Mahoney

RIDGE MAHONEY
From the Soccer Field

For the past three decades I've been a soccer writer, broadcaster, and journalist.


I Recommend...

Websites:

Soccer America
ESPNsoccernet
World Soccer
FIFA World Cup 2006

Books:

The Simplest Game by Paul Gardner
The Story of the World Cup by Brian Glanville
Offside: Soccer and American Exceptionalism by Andrei S. Markovits and Steven L. Hellerman
Fever Pitch by Nick Hornby
Football Against the Enemy by Simon Kuper
The Girls of Summer by Jere Longman

Crossing Borders

World Cup Conclusions

July 17, 2006

For me, the 2006 World Cup ended as it had begun, at least in the context of writing for POV's Borders | American ID.

In late April, while I was pondering ways of conveying to Americans the powerful nationalist forces of sports and their effects on a country's identity, the most vivid images I could recall were those of delirious Italian soccer fans taking to the streets, with persons of all ages swimming, wading or otherwise cavorting in the grand fountains of Rome and other historic cities. Those were scenes from July of 1982, after the Italians had won their third World Cup by beating [the former] West Germany, 3-1.

I also remember the 1998 World Cup vividly, when a multi-ethnic French team united a nation splintered by ethnic and sociological tensions for a few weeks. The celebrations after France won its first World Cup went on for three days. Thierry Henry, one of the stars of the current team who was just 20 in 1998, said the reaction stunned him. An elderly French woman tearfully thanked him for giving the nation its greatest moment since the Liberation. "That's when I realized how powerful sport is," he said, "even if I don't completely understand it."

Much of it happened again. During this year's tournament, the French players were again subjected to the right-wing vitriol of Jean-Marie LePen and his rantings of racial purity. French defender Lillian Thuram, an elegant black player whose own heritage links him to the island of Guadaloupe, spoke out publicly to contradict LePen, declaring that every player on the team considered himself a Frenchman proud to wear the jersey.

Meanwhile Italian fans celebrated again, and millions of them swarmed through dozens of cities on July 9 after the Italians defeated France in a penalty-kick shootout to win the World Cup final.

The match itself and its aftermath was tainted by a moment of madness from France's star midfielder, Zinedine Zidane, who viciously head-butted Italian defender Marco Materazzi in response to something Materazzi said. Zidane alleged Materazzi had besmirched his mother and sister, Materazzi insisted he said nothing about Zidane's mother.

Initial reports speculated that Materazzi perhaps had referred to Zidane's origins in a poor Algerian slum in north Marseille. Zidane is fiercely proud of his heritage, yet any real proof that Materazzi had called him a "dirty terrorist" or "dirty Muslim," as some news outlets reported, was not forthcoming. Materazzi denied this as well.

The issue at hand is excruciatingly volatile, with a complicated history. In 1998, France won the World Cup. Three years later, just a few weeks after the terrorist attacks of September 11th, 2001, a "reconciliation" match between Algeria and France — a former colony and its ex-master — turned bitter and ugly. Zidane and other players were called traitors to Islamic youth, chants supporting Osama bin Laden were heard. The match had to be stopped 15 minutes early when thousands swarmed onto the field.

This was a glimpse into the dark side of soccer nationalism; the "us versus them" mentality; the playing out of political and cultural mistrusts and outright hatreds on a soccer field.

Yet at the 2006 tournament, a meeting between Angola and its former colonizers Portugal turned out to be a soccer game, nothing more. Similarly, none of the historical animosity between Germany and Poland was apparent when they played before a mixed crowd of 70,000 in Dortmund. The din was deafening and passionate, not threatening or dangerous.

I observed much more than simple nationalism at the World Cup 2006. Skirmishes between rival supporters were few; instead, fans from dozens of nations flooded into city squares and designated "Fan Fests" to watch games, and these massive communal gatherings defined this year's competition as unique from the 17 that had preceded it.

American fans, who themselves numbered in the thousands, confessed to being overwhelmed by camaraderie and friendship. So minor is the sport in America that they often feel ignored if not disdained, but during this World Cup, they could truly and honestly believe they were at the center of the sporting universe.

In a segment of their American identity — its soccer team — American fans found communality with the rest of the world.

Older: Changing German Identity Revealed at World Cup

Link to this entry

Post a Comment:

Please note: Comments are reviewed before publication. All points of view are welcome, as long as they are presented as part of a civil exchange.

Name:

Email Address:

Your Website URL:

Remember this info?

Comments: (HTML for styling permitted)

Top of Page | Most Recent | View all entries by Ridge Mahoney


Past Entries
07/17
07/10
06/26
06/09
05/03
View all entries »

Recently Commented

"I don't totally agree with you. What about the national jubilation following the victory of the U.S. hockey team over the USSR in 1980? That was awesome! And everyone was excited about it."

—Joan

in response to
Sports and Nationalism »

Expand Your Borders
 World War on the Soccer Field
Soccer is more than just a game, it offers a snapshot of the state of the world. Tony Karon explains how matches on the field reflect conflicts off the field. He will also be writing about the World Cup at his own blog, Rootless Cosmopolitan.
 Soccer Diplomacy
In 1998, Iran knocked the U.S. out of contention in the World Cup in a thrilling, 2-1 match. PBS's Newshour wonders if a soccer match can lead to warming relations between the two nations.
 Soccer: A Matter of Love and Hate
A thoughtful and provocative essay on soccer and nationalism from The New York Review of Books.
 The Capitalism of Soccer
Slate magazine explains why soccer is more American than baseball.

American ID Home  |  Freedom  |  Democracy  |  Choice  |  Border Talk  |  For Educators  |  Resources  |  Credits  |  Site Map
POV's Borders: Home  |  About POV's Borders  |  Contact Us
POV: Home  |  About POV  |  POV Pressroom  |  POV Projects  |  Newsletter  |  About American Documentary
Copyright ©2006 American Documentary, Inc.