Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
POV home about Borders StoriesJourneyTalkSnapshotsGamesCams
POVs Borders
navigation map
border talk

featured guest
 Dennis Michelini


Border Talk Discussion - Join one now
CeciliaGilbertKateBorder TalkJourney


Your Questions   1 | 2 6 Questions

P.O.V.'s Borders visitors sent Dennis Michelini these questions in response to his work and his answers to P.O.V.'s initial 6 Questions. Read on!

The views expressed are those of Agent Dennis Michelini, and they do not represent the views of the U.S. Border Patrol nor the Immigration and Naturalization Service.


Question: Do you ever wish that you didn't have a job that brought you face to face with certain painful human realities — death, poverty, sacrifice, corruption, etc.? Every job has its moral complexities, but there are certainly jobs out there where you aren't forced to face them every day.


Dennis: It is not as horrifying as you make it sound. Moral complexities are always more complex when seen from a distance, when chatted about over coffee, or when soliloquized by a college professor. But when you're up to your elbows in these complexities it is evident, it becomes evident to you, that very quickly a decision must be made. A narcotics arrest transpires in seconds and yet a defense lawyer will have months to review the event. Graphed out on a timeline, it would resemble a teeter-totter way off center. Unfortunately it makes the act look hastily done and poorly thought out.

I suppose it is always better to do more in life than to do less. I also suppose it is better to ponder what you have done than to not. When you sit down at the end of the day to debate "certain painful human realities" at least, if you are following the "do more" theory of life, you are bringing something to the table. This isn't hubris or occupational boasting. When conversations are only hypothetical, they retain massive gray areas. Fantastically articulate points and counterpoints ricochet against one another. Indecision swells until the matter under discussion resembles a dense fog, and a judgment either way appears radical. You become intellectually frozen, and when asked murmur something scholastic, "It's a complicated issue. I don't really have an opinion on it." Something that if I were a little brighter I'd be saying to a few of these questions listed below. But when you have to do this thing, this point under debate, you do it. At times you move mechanically. Other times you are mindful and cognizant.

Question: When tracking immigrants crossing the border, did you ever considering helping them cross, as opposed to arresting them?


Dennis: No. In the smaller towns along the border you occasionally hear this question. From their perspective, what would a few more really matter — why wouldn't you just turn your back? The illegal crossers from Mexico have a tremendous advantage over those wishing to come the States from other corners of the globe. They have a relatively receptive community just on the northern side of the border. When somebody from Carrizo Springs, Eagle Pass or Laredo asks that question they don't imply that I let all the world's illegal crossers pass, just those from across the river. This country has an immigration policy, and there are legal ways to enter.

Question: What's your opinion of the "Wet Foot/Dry Foot" policy here in Florida? In light of the recent events regarding the over-200 Haitians to land in Miami, do you think they should be treated as the Cubans? Or as expressed in local newspaper editorials, the Cubans should be treated as the Haitians? Finally, do you feel this is reflecting the homeland security of protecting our borders since we have so many rafters and boat people coming ashore? Do you think our southern borders should be more heavily guarded to prevent these illegal entries?


Dennis: I hesitate to answer this question because I am not familiar with the specifics of the wet foot/dry foot policy in Florida. If there is unfairness, off hand I would attribute it to our political history with Cuba and the Cuban voting block within Miami.

Question: Dennis — from your last name — I'm guessing Italian. I'm curious about what border your family crossed in order to enter this country? And also out of curiosity, have you ever looked up the name of the border patrol agent who let them through?

Dennis: I believe both sides of my family came across about a hundred years ago in the New York area. I found one side of my family in the internet records from Ellis Island. The Border Patrol was not established at that time. My great grandparents would have entered through an Immigration Agent working at the port of Entry.

Question: I would welcome anyone who is looking for a better life. Unfortunately, the majority of immigrants in my neighborhood come here with one thing in mind: money to send back home. The money being made in this country is being sent out of it to support families in other countries. If we don't spend some of that income here, all Americans will soon be out of work. I also object to the majority being paid under minimum wage and without paying taxes. Please write back. I would love to hear other opinions.

Dennis: Fortunately for us, it is not against the law to send money to relatives who live in other countries, and we are equally fortunate not to live under a government so intrusive as to ban us from doing so. I've worked for less than minimum wage, and while laboring at that job I never imagined I'd be upsetting anybody. Enjoy your freedoms. If someone is living in a foreign culture, working for less than minimum wage, and sending what little they make back home, off hand I'd say they are a good, decent sort of folk, and nothing to be too upset about.


Your Questions 1 | 2 >

Next > "Sometimes it seems like the world is a dysfunctional place. My concerns are closer to home."

about Luis J. Rodriguez

 

Dennis Michelini is an agent pilot with the United States Border Patrol. He worked as a ranch hand, an English teacher, and a television weatherman before joining the Border Patrol as a pilot in Texas and Washington State.

more...

works


Read an editorial by Dennis Michelini, originally published in The New York Times:

Notes From Laredo: Following Footprints Across the Border


Find out more about the U.S. Border Patrol at their website.

 

Featured Guests
Sherman AlexieSHERMAN ALEXIE
Rebecca WalkerREBECCA WALKER
CAAAV
CAAAV: ORGANIZING ASIAN COMMUNITIES
Barbara Ehrenreich
BARBARA
EHRENREICH
Dan SteinDAN STEIN
Frank SharryFRANK SHARRY
Claire FoxCLAIRE FOX
Dennis MicheliniDENNIS MICHELINI
Luis J. RodriguezLUIS J. RODRIGUEZ
Elijah WaldELIJAH WALD
Dagoberto GilbDAGOBERTO GILB
   

 

 

Having trouble watching video? Get help.

Tell a friend about this project. | Sign up for P.O.V. newsletter and get Borders updates.


Copyright © 1995-2002 American Documentary, Inc.