Watch Online
Mending a Broken Heart
Skilled surgeons and an ingenious tool work together to repair young hearts.
Select text to jump ahead in the clip:
When your whole body was no
bigger than this and before
your mother even realized she
was pregnant your heart began
to beat even though it was no
more than a tiny crooked
tube.
With luck and a little care
and attention it should beat
2½ billion times before it
eventually gives out. For
many of us, though just as
the heart was the first organ
to go to work
it's also the first to fail
us. In the next hour we're
going to see some broken
hearts get mended and find
out how to keep them from
breaking too young. We're
starting here at Boston's
Children's Hospital
with a heart that's still an
infant's and that only a few
years ago might never have
grown older. Zachary's heart
problem was diagnosed before
he was born. WOMAN: We first
found out that he had
some cardiac issues on a
routine ultrasound on
February 19, 1998. Basically,
his heart looks like it was
put together in a
kindergarten art class. ALDA:
Zach's heart started to go
wrong
just a few weeks after he was
conceived. Instead of forming
two main pumping chambers--
one pushing blood to his
body, the other to his
lungs-- his heart formed only
one. He's still alive today
because of two operations
that have replumbed his heart
allowing its single chamber
to keep blood flowing
throughout his body. MOTHER:
That was good! You got it in
there!
The first surgery he had got
him till he was five months
old. At that point, we had to
have the next surgery or he
wouldn't have lived much
longer. And that surgery,
which he's under right now
would probably allow him to
live until he was four or
five, six or seven years old
but not much longer than that
because his body's going to
outgrow this procedure. And
this procedure's going to get
him until he's an old man.
ALDA:
So for the third time in his
young life Zach is prepared
for open-heart surgery. The
operation he's about to have
here at Children's Hospital
in Boston
is called the Fontan
procedure. In a normal heart
blood that is pumped around
the body by the left
ventricle arrives back at the
right ventricle to be pumped
to the lungs. But in Zach's
heart, there is no right
ventricle.
So to get blood to the lungs
a new route has to be built--
and that's what the Fontan
does-- it creates a tunnel
for the returning blood that
burrows straight through the
heart.
Now, a single heartbeat can
push blood around the body
through the tunnel and on to
the lungs. SURGEON: You all
set there, Bob?
Let's go on. ALDA: The
operation begins when a
heart-lung machine takes over
from Zach's own heart.
DOCTOR: Now the heart is
stopped right now
and is not getting any blood.
So that's why we need to move
along at this part of the
operation. ALDA: Surgeon
Richard Jonas has performed
scores of Fontan procedures--
perfecting his tailoring as
well as his surgical skills.
JONAS: Now we're going to
shape this Gore-tex patch...
ALDA: With Zach's heart cut
open Jonas starts to sew the
patch of cloth along its
inner wall.
We've got to think about how
this is going to be folded
over in a minute. When you
fold it over, is that... It's
going to make a tunnel, yeah.
That's how it becomes a
tunnel. Yeah, so this is the
bottom end of the tunnel
starting to take shape now.
ALAN: I can't quite tell why
it isn't in the shape of a
tunnel when you put it in.
Why do you have to sew it
into the shape of a tunnel?
JONAS: I guess it's not
really possible for
manufacturers to pre-form
something for us since every
child is a different shape
and size so we really do have
to custom-build components
to fit into an individual
child. It really is sort of
tailor-made specifically for
a child's situation. Okay,
well at this point we're
going to make the
fenestration. ALDA: With the
cloth sewn in place
Jonas uses a punch to makes a
small hole-- called a
fenestration-- in the side of
the tunnel. Creating a
deliberate leak like this
seems strange right now but
in the days to come
this little hole is to play a
critical role in saving
Zach's life. But for the
moment, there's no hint of
trouble. After being stilled
for 90 minutes Zach's heart
is slowly stirring back to
life. JONAS:
As the heart starts to get
that warm blood it will
gradually start to beat. You
can see the first blip-- the
top line there is the EKG.
There's a beat there. There's
another one.
There's another one. Yep,
there we go. ALDA: Twenty
minutes later Zach's rebuilt
heart is beating vigorously.
We're going to be off the
heart- lung machine in about
a minute. ALDA:
Zach's single ventricle is
now able to pump blood around
his body and through his
lungs almost like a normal
heart. But it's about to face
perhaps its greatest
challenge-- getting Zach
through the critical few days
following surgery. As it
turns out his rebuilt heart
comes close to being
overwhelmed by a simple cold.
ALDA: How is Zach doing now?
He's had one complication
following the surgery which
is he developed a lung
infection. It's the... And
that made it hard for the
heart if he hadn't had the
fenestration?
It makes it hard for blood to
go through the lungs and in
this adjustment period after
the Fontan without the
fenestration, he could have
gotten very sick. He could
have been, oh... stuck on a
ventilator for a long time.
And we've had children who've
had a Fontan operation and
this kind of lung infection
who have died. So the
fenestration... The
fenestration was vital. I
think so. ( coughing )
ALDA: Zach's cold lingers for
days but it never becomes
life-threatening thanks to
the fenestration. Here's why:
His infection is making it
hard for blood to flow
through his lungs, so hard
that his heart
may simply have been forced
to a halt. But by allowing
the backed-up blood to spill
out into the heart's main
chamber the fenestration is
relieving the pressure and
allowing his heart to keep
pumping.
Of course, not all his blood
is now going through his
lungs so it has a little less
oxygen than it should-- it's
a little bluer. But right
now, that's a small price to
pay.
MAN: This infection is
exactly the kind of
situation-- if he didn't have
a Fontan fenestration-- would
have resulted in a very high
mortality rate.
It's not unlikely he wouldn't
have made it if he didn't
have a fenestration. So the
fenestration probably saved
his life. Now he has lived
through this... this cold
which could have been fatal,
possibly. Now there comes a
point where you want to close
that hole eventually, right?
Why do you need to close the
hole? Because children can
tolerate being blue
pretty well for a period of
time. But it's not well
tolerated life-long. And so
if we left that hole open
eventually he would suffer
complications from being
blue. So that's why you've
got to close it
and that's why you invented
this? ALDA: "This" is a
deceptively simple little
device that closes holes in
hearts without surgery. LOCK:
And the whole thing now folds
up into something quite
small.
When I was a kid I used to do
amateur magic and that's how
you fold flowers that appear
out of nowhere. You're
kidding. Yeah, the whole
bouquet. You just fold it up
like that and you could get
it into a small space like
that. ALDA:
The small space in this case
is the tip of a catheter.
LOCK: That's what goes inside
the body. And we thread it up
through a vein in the leg and
up into the heart, and we
watch it under an X ray
fluoroscopic machine
and we know where the hole is.
And let's pretend that this
is the hole here. ALDA: Like
my magic flowers-- or a tiny
umbrella-- the device springs
open. LOCK: See it snap?
Yeah.
Then I pull it back like this
pushing it back... like that.
Wow. ALDA: This is
nine-year-old Josh. He's
lived with a fenestration for
six years now--
and it's time to close it.
The doctor was telling us
it's kind of like a
fine-tuning-- they got to
tune him up before they send
him out. ALDA: Josh's
blueness is visible in his
lips and fingernails. LOCK:
The drill in a patient with a
Fontan circulation is to give
them the best possible
circulation for the rest of
their life because it's a
little bit tenuous-- they
only have one ventricle.
And what we need to do is to
optimize that circulation you
know, so that they can be
pretty asymptomatic and be
very productive citizens into
their 40s and 50s and pay
taxes.
ALDA: Josh's tune-up will all
be done through a tiny hole
in his groin. Okay, let's
take this picture just like
this, guys. Inject. ALDA:
Injecting a liquid that shows
up black on the fluoroscope
reveals Josh's blood vessels
including the pulmonary
artery taking blood to his
lungs. LOCK: So you notice
the diameter here is probably
seven millimeters and it
drops to four millimeters
and then it goes to nine
millimeters. That's not a
very severe obstruction--
it's really only mild-- and
if he had a normal
circulation, we'd ignore it.
ALDA:
But since Josh's heart
already has a hard enough
time pumping blood to his
lungs Jim Lock plans to use
this metal coil-- called a
stent-- to open up the
constriction. LOCK:
He's going to hold this with
his beefy fist... so that it
don't move. And with my thin,
delicate fingers I'm going to
push it up. See it there?
Coming in...
coming in, coming in... Okay.
Blow the little balloon up
for me. Right, now slowly...
ALDA: A balloon inflated
within the stent expands it
to permanently hold open the
route
from the heart to the lungs.
LOCK: Okay, so this should be
very close to perfect. ALDA:
Now it's time to close the
fenestration. The twin
umbrellas are loaded into
their catheter
and threaded up into Josh's
heart. LOCK: Let go of the
wire. ALDA: The tunnel and
its hole are invisible in
this picture but the first
umbrella's arms are unfolding
on the outside of the hole.
LOCK: It's fully open. ALDA:
Then the second umbrella is
released. LOCK: We're going
to take a picture now
with all eight arms open--
one on the left side and one
on the right side-- and make
sure it's in the right place.
You ready, guy? Inject. ALDA:
Now the tunnel is visible on
the left side of the picture.
Some blood is leaking past
the umbrellas but that's
because their cloth mesh is
still porous. In the coming
months Josh's cells will grow
into the mesh, sealing the
hole tight.
The final act is to release
the catheter leaving the
umbrellas behind. LOCK: And
there it is! NURSE: It's all
done, okay? You're in the
recovery room.
It's all over, all right?
ALDA: Josh's blood oxygen--
which for years has been at
70%-- has jumped to the
mid-90s. Hey, big guy, how'd
you do? ALDA:
Just minutes after the
procedure and already Josh's
lips and nails are pinker.
He's pink! For the first
time. Look's good-- a little
dirty, but good. ( both
chuckling )
ALDA: For Josh and his
parents nine years of living
with his broken heart are
almost over. The odds are
good that his rebuilt heart
will now allow him a normal
life.
Meanwhile, Zachary is home in
Texas having fun. One day,
his fenestration will also
need closing. The fact that
it can be now done with Jim
Lock's little folding
umbrellas means
that, like Josh, a tune-up is
all he'll need for his heart
to take him into ripe old
age. Jim Wenzell flies planes
for a living or, at least, he
used to before his airline
grounded him when he was
diagnosed
Robot Heart Surgeon
Tiny robotic instruments replace doctors' hands and make surgery less invasive.
Select text to jump ahead in the clip:
with a dangerously narrowed
coronary artery. Today he's
at the Ohio State University
Medical Center where he's
about to be operated on by a
robot. Jim Wenzell is one of
the first patients in the
United States
to benefit from a technology
that promises to
revolutionize surgery yet
whose origins can be traced
back to a now distant war. (
theme from MASH playing ) It
was a war that also formed
the background for a
television series. MASH was
set in a mobile army surgical
hospital during the conflict
in Korea. The real MASH units
represented a major
breakthrough in battlefield
medicine.
Before the early 1950s and
the helicopter many soldiers
wounded in battle didn't
survive simply because they
couldn't be treated by a
trained surgeon quickly
enough.
Fast-forward to the 21st
century as viewed through a
promotional video made for
the Pentagon's Advanced
Research Projects Agency.
WOMAN: Med MASH check. ALDA:
In the mid-1990s, the goal of
a research program aimed at
bringing new technology to
battlefield medicine was to
shorten still further the
time between a soldier's
being wounded
and getting expert medical
attention. Five years ago, we
visited a mobile surgical
unit parked in peaceful Palo
Alto, California. If this
person had been wounded in
the battlefield and he
happened to be
lucky enough to have a surgeon
here... What's wrong with
him? ALDA: Jon Bowersox,
himself a surgeon was working
with a team of scientists and
engineers on a way to project
his expertise into the battle
zone
while he remains miles away.
BOWERSOX: What it looks like
is there's about an inch-long
hole in the small intestine.
If we didn't treat that, what
would happen is the casualty
would develop a severe
infection
and die in a relatively short
period of time. So what's
needed to take care of this
is emergency repair of the
intestinal injury. ALDA:
These were actually pig
intestines
from a local butcher's shop.
Poised above them was a pair
of mechanical hands. What do
these things do? How do
they... They get right down
in the wound? This is the
machinery? As you'll see...
Why don't we move them into
position here if you'd just
move our position control.
That's this red button? It
is. ( machine whirring )
Stop, please.
Good. So as you can see, just
like the surgeon's hands
they're placed right over the
site of the wounding
and these are instruments
that the surgeon normally
uses. ALDA: The armored
operating room was connected
to this tent
by a cable. But the plan was
for a wireless link so that
O.
R. and surgeon could be many
miles apart. So this is a
surgeon's workstation.
Instead of being at the
patient's side in the normal
operating room I put on these
polarized glasses that give
me 3-D vision.
Instead of talking directly to
my assistant I put on a pair
of stereo headphones. And
instead of picking up the
actual surgical instrument
handles I put my hands in the
half of them that are
attached to the console.
And now it's like being at
the patient's side. ALDA: Jon
was seeing a 3-D version of
the image shown in the
monitor that I was watching.
How much like the real
experience is it
when you were over there?
Well, I think the most
telling thing is every
surgeon that's used the
system after working with it
for about 15 or 20 minutes
will move their hand out of
the instrument handle
and try to push bowel out of
the way. It's getting in the
way. ALDA: Jon appeared to be
as dexterous with the remote
instruments as he was with
the normal ones-- aided as he
would be in a regular
operation
by a skilled assistant. Jon
could see Michelle in a small
monitor in his workstation
and together they speedily
repaired the wound. BOWERSOX:
As you can see now, I am able
to tie the knots in the
suture
just as if we were in the
actual operating room. So
would you like to have a go
at this? ALDA: Uh, yeah. Let
me try. I can't wait. This is
going to be
the first time I've ever done
this. ALDA: Despite years of
doing fake operations in a
fictional MASH unit, this was
the first time I'd tried
anything like the real thing.
And you need a pair of
glasses. Right, okay. ALDA:
Fortunately, it wasn't the
real thing. ALDA: Oh, oh, my
God! Oh, wait a minute.
( crew laughing ) I'm
terribly sorry. I banged into
the instrument and jammed it
into the guy's intestines.
ALDA ( over monitor ): Now,
Michelle, control yourself.
Snip, snip, okay. MICHELLE (
over monitor ): Alan? You're
ruining my image of you as
Hawkeye, you know that. ALDA
( over monitor ): I am not a
real doctor, I just play one
on TV.
( laughing ) ALDA: Now, I
need to pick this side up.
MICHELLE: Yeah, pick it up,
right where you are. Okay.
Now... have I got it?
Um... Okay. ALDA: Okay... oh,
okay, it went through. Do I
have too little of it? No,
that's just fine.
Oh, pull it with this? Yes.
Oh, I see, I see, pull it
with the right hand, okay.
And I can sort of ease this
down with the left hand. Grab
the tissue.
Pull it out. ALDA: I was just
one of many visitors to the
Pentagon-funded project who
got to try it out for
themselves. ALDA: There, I
did it. Yes, you did great.
I made a stitch, but the poor
guy-- I mean, he's going to
have cramps from that stitch.
ALDA: Another visitor to the
project in the mid-1990s was
an entrepreneur who saw in
the system
the answer to a surgeon's
dream-- the ability to
operate right inside a
patient with a pair of
miniaturized hands-- to
project their hands not so
much across space
as down into the patient's
body. And it's this idea that
five years later is being
tested here at Ohio State
University-- as a camera
plunges through the chest
wall of the coronary bypass
patient.
MAN: That's the heart
beating. And we're looking at
the chest wall and there's
the artery that we want. The
artery... that particular
artery runs up
underneath the breastbone
along the ribs. We plan on
using that artery. It's a
little blue streak there.
ALDA: The plan is to free the
artery from the chest wall
and sew it onto the patient's
coronary artery
just beyond the blockage.
This approach to coronary
bypasses is becoming
increasingly common. What's
different here is that the
job of harvesting the chest
artery will be done by a pair
of robot hands.
While operating, my hands...
all that motion will be
transferred to this miniature
hand, if you will, inside the
chest. This is the working
end of the system. If you
think about it, why do we
make big incisions?
We're working on small
arteries, we're using tiny
suture. Because our hands are
large-- that's why we make
big incisions. And what this
system allows us to do is
feel like our hands are
inside the chest
but we haven't made the big
incision. The first thing I
do is, I take off my shoes.
So I'll be using both feet
and both hands. So I take off
my shoes and then pull up to
the screen.
You can see that it's
binocular vision. We're going
to activate this now. ALDA:
Randy Wolf's workstation is
the commercialized version of
the one I checked out five
years ago.
The controls for moving the
instruments are now much more
sophisticated. WOLF: When I
turn my left hand like this,
it does it. When I pinch my
fingers together this pinches
together.
It feels very natural. I
pinch, I let go. I turn
right, I turn left. Any angle
my wrist makes, it makes at
the tip. And this is very
helpful in sewing vessels,
like this. You grab a suture,
you can run it like this.
I'll give you a more
panoramic view. Any wrist
motion is replicated. ALDA:
As Randy moves his hands at
the controls across the
operating room, his actions
are mirrored
by the arms of a robot inside
the patient's chest. WOLF:
The vessel is in this tissue
right here. So I'm very
gingerly, or gently, pulling
down on it to open that up.
And the first rib, the
highest rib, is right here.
Rib number one... number two
here... number three here...
number four here. MAN: This
is, in simple terms, fun.
It's fun because it allows us
to do something that we love
doing which is heart surgery
but allows us to do it in a
manner that is creative in a
manner that we think is going
to benefit the patient
by producing less trauma.
MICHLER: Okay, we're finished
with mobilization. Note the
time. So an hour-- exactly an
hour and 30 minutes. Okay?
All right?
Now that's long for us but
again, we were working under
more unusual circumstances
than usual. You didn't say
extenuating, did you?
( laughing ) We were working
under friendly fire. ALDA:
With the chest artery freed
the next job is to clip it so
that it can be safely
severed.
Robert Michler inserts the
instrument holding the clip.
MICHLER: How about right
there? ALDA: The clips will
seal the artery until it can
be sewn to the coronary.
MICHLER:
We'll give you scissors to
divide it. Okay? WOLF: Yep.
That looks good, don't you
think? Yep. Let's have the
scissors back.
There it is. See the artery?
That tube? So that's what
we're going to sew onto the
surface of the heart. ALDA:
At this point in the
operation, the robot's job is
over. Right now, the Ohio
State team has the F.
D.A.'s permission only to
harvest the artery with the
robot. Sewing it on to the
heart still has to be done by
hand. In the next phase of
the trial even this
attachment of the artery to
the coronary
will be done by the robot.
MICHLER: The whole sewing
onto the heart took us about
ten minutes to perform. So
once we have developed the
technology with the robot to
the point where we can take
the artery off of the chest
wall
in ten or 20 minutes it could
shorten this operation
dramatically from the several
hours to really under an
hour. ALDA: As well as being
far less traumatic for the
patient the robot system
could also make a big
difference
in the way surgeons learn new
techniques. Right now, Randy
Wolf spends a lot of time on
the road training surgeons in
the new technology. But that
will change. WOLF:
Let's say a Japanese surgeon
wants to learn this system
and they've got their first
case, they want me to help
them I don't have to fly to
Japan. We can go Internet 2,
we can bring the image up
we can hook up my system to
their system and I can mentor
them, tele-mentor them while
I'm sitting here at Ohio
State University in Columbus,
Ohio and they may be in
Tokyo, Japan.
I'll get a lot less
frequent-flyer miles but I
think I'll live longer. ALDA:
The next step for the robot
surgeon here at Ohio State is
to do a complete coronary
bypass operation--
something Randy Wolf has
already done with a robot in
Germany. Following that,
there are still more
ambitious possibilities
including doing heart surgery
inside an unborn child. WOLF:
What's exciting to me is it's
all imagination. You really
need to act like a little kid
with this technology and use
your imagination, because
that's the only limit. ALDA:
The Heart Factory
In the quest for the most reliable artificial heart, one device offers hope.
Select text to jump ahead in the clip:
This is the story of a
20-year effort to develop an
artificial heart. Luckily,
for one of the players in
this volleyball game it was
an effort that began to hit
its stride in the early
1990s.
Today the attempt to build a
permanent artificial
substitute for a failing
heart may be on the brink of
success. Whoa! That's it!
ALDA: Back in 1993, Mike
Dorsey's heart was so
diseased
that he was on the brink of
death. DORSEY: I was very
sick. If I'd have walked from
here to you I'd have been out
of breath for that time. You
know, I couldn't do nothing.
It gets a little frustrating
when your wife comes and
takes things from you, you
know and you can't carry
them, you know. She would
take them and carry them in
for me. I wanted to do it,
but just wasn't able to do
it. ALDA:
Mike Dorsey was rescued from
death by a pump implanted
under his own heart that
helped propel blood around
his body. It was almost 12
years earlier that the
artificial heart
first hit the world's
headlines. But Barney
Clarke's brave struggle to
live and his death after four
months cooled the early
enthusiasm for his artificial
heart-- the Jarvick-7.
After a few more unsuccessful
implants the device was
abandoned. But research on
mechanical hearts continued.
The most promising were pumps
that weren't intended to
replace the heart
but boost it. One of them was
called the Heartmate. The
designers of the Heartmate
took a novel approach to a
major problem of the
Jarvick-7: blood clots that
would form inside of it
and that could kill when they
broke off and traveled to the
lungs or brain. The
Heartmate's interior was
roughened so that a thin
layer of blood clots over its
entire surface and sticks
there firmly.
Mike Dorsey's problem-- one
that he shares with thousands
of others each year-- was a
weakening of his heart
muscles so that the main
pumping chamber, the left
ventricle
could no longer pump blood
around his body. Installing
the Heartmate begins with
cutting a hole in the left
ventricle and sewing in a
short tube. Then the electric
pump itself is implanted in
the upper abdomen.
Blood flows from the heart
through the pump then back to
the patient's aorta. By
February 1993, Mike Dorsey's
heart was near total failure.
His doctors estimated he had
just hours to live.
Only weeks before, the
Heartmate had been approved
by the Food and Drug