Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Donate Shop PBS Search PBS
Searching For Asian America
Rinku Sen Helen Zia Sheryl A. Levart

The Governor
Oklahoma Home
Angry Little Asian Girl
Learn More About the Program
Asian American Field Reports
Quiz Yourself
Take a Poll
Community Chats
Up and Coming Asian American Politicians
Foreign Doctors
Asian American Women in Media
Asian American Field Reports
Community Chats

Discussion 1: Asian American IdentityDiscussion 2: Beyond the Model Minority Myth
Experts Respond
The Experts
Quang BaoMitra KalitaSheryl LevartHelen ZiaMonami MaulikFranklin OdoRinku Sen

Click on each panelist's name or thumbnail to learn about them and to read their statement.

The Experts Respond

QUESTION: One of the problems with the Asian American community is that whenever somebody achieves a high level of mainstream success, theyre scrutinized for every little misstep or criticized for selling out and not doing enough to help advance other Asian Americans. Isnt it unrealistic to expect one individual to represent and be responsible for the whole community? I think this kind of attitude is self-defeating and one of the reasons Asian Americans cant get anywhere as a group.

FRANKLIN: Im not so sure that its true in every instance. I dont know, for example, if these kinds of criticisms are directed at me, working at a fairly high level at the Smithsonian. So it depends on the situation. To the extent that this happens, some of it could well be deserved. There are certainly people who achieve mainstream success by ignoring the rest of the community. Like Connie Chung, for example in her case, I think some of that criticism is deserved. Norm Mineta, Secretary of Transportation, has also been criticized for the way a lot of Filipino airport inspectors were treated - thats on his watch. On the flip side, any time you get into a position of mainstream visibility, there are underlying assumptions about being held to a higher standard, which can be difficult or impossible to meet. But I think if youre out there, youre fair game.

RINKU: I think it is unrealistic to expect one individual to represent their entire community. But I also think thats an inevitable reaction and stance of a minority community, much of which is deeply cut off from the economic or political benefits and the rights of other people in society. Any successful Asian in any field needs to be prepared to be highly scrutinized, certainly by their own community and possibly by other communities of color or low-income communities and so on.

By the same token, I think you have to hold people accountable to their own aspirations and claims. I dont expect most Asian American capitalists to fight for public benefits, for example, or for higher corporate taxes or for things that really are community oriented. That isnt what they got into capitalism for. However, I do expect that Asian journalists will be thorough and accurate, not disproportionately sympathetic to Asian communities but that they will stand up for journalistic standards and point out places where those havent been met. The same thing goes for Asian public officials and politicians. Those folks have pledged themselves to the public good, so if theyre not protecting the public, then, as Franklin said, they are fair game.

I do worry, though, about a tendency among some activists to write off whole sectors of people who have achieved a certain level of political or mainstream success. Many successful people can be allies to us on specific issues, if not on our whole agenda. Im not ready to give up all those potential allies, even if I have criticisms of particular things theyve done or decisions theyve made. I am also concerned about knee-jerk reactions that we have against leadership and success and an assumption that success requires having sold out in many ways, large and small. That assumption trickles down, so it affects not just the Norm Minetas, Gary Lockes and Connie Chungs, but also advocates, organizers, community leaders, city council members, school board members, and so on. And I worry about infighting within an Asian American liberation movement or racial justice movement.

We have to recognize that theres a fine line between principled political critique and self-righteousness or self-indulgence. And we have to really hold ourselves accountable to that line because its not appropriate for someone else to hold us accountable. We have to decide, where am I really making a principled critique and where am I just distracting myself from the real work that needs to be done.

MONAMI: The question of selling out is challenging one, particularly among people doing social justice work and people fighting for things like welfare, housing and immigration rights. As Rinku mentioned, I think its important to look beyond the fact of someone being Asian American and really scrutinize their political beliefs and actions. Its tough for Asian Americans, especially those who are marginalized, to hold Asian American leaders accountable. There isnt always a natural alliance simply because they are Asian American. I think we have to be more strategic about building allies among people who have power to move forward some of our issues. And its important to see the big picture. Where will this person be after this particular issue is over? Is this person a potential ally for the long term, someone who can help make fundamental, institutional changes beyond this issue?


Discussion 1: Asian American Identity

HomeFor TeachersResourcesCheck Local ListingsOrder VideoCreditsSite Map

Copyright 2004 National Asian American Telecommunications Association, Inc. All rights reserved. - Contact Us