September 27, 2013
To The Contrary Panel To The Contrary Panel

This week on To The Contrary, our panelists discuss the Catholic Church's role in society, a former nun who says the Church should reconsider celibacy, and the gap between men and women when it comes to political donations.

On the panel this week: Former Bush White House Aide Mercedes Viana Schlapp, Progressive Commentator Patricia Sosa, Conservative Commentator Darlene Kennedy, Author and Political Analyst Lara Brown

Here are some of their thoughts:

 

Catholic Church & Social Issues
The pope made comments condeming abortion a week after saying the Church should not focus on divisive social issues.
 
Patricia Sosa: "i think Pope Francis wants to have his cake and eat it too, and only time will tell if he can get away with it."
 
Darlene Kennedy: "[The pope’s] intent in the comment was to say that there are many issues that we have to address in the Catholic Church.”
 
Lara Brown: "The pope was trying to contextualize the abortion debate within the larger conversation of all of the Church’s teachings."
 
Mercedes Viana Schlapp: "The pope’s got the right tone, and that’s something that’s been missing in the Catholic Church for a long time."
 
 
An Unquenchable Thirst
Author Mary Johnson's book discusses celibacy in the Catholic Church.
 
Patricia Sosa: "Kudos to Mary Johnson for telling the story [and talking about] what it means to try and live a celibate life."
 
Mercedes Vianaa Schalpp on celibacy: "The priest is there on-call for you" when others may have their attention "divided" with family commitments.
 
Lara Brown: "When human beings are in control of what it means to be faithful to God, there are these really huge problems."
 
DarleneKennedy: "The rule of celibacy is not part of the dogma [of the Catholic Church], it is a tradition."
 
 
Donor Gap
Women trail men in terms of political donations.
 
Lara Brown: on why women don't donate as much: "They tend not to be strategic and they tend to be more risk-averse than men. "
 
Darlene Kennedy: "Let’s not forget women who are in partnerships... maybe they as a couple agree, and they’re donating together."
 
Mercedes Viana Schlapp: "We have to engage women and say, 'Look, you donate, you get the candidates you want in office.'"
 
Patricia Sosa: "There’s a whole network of Latinas that are out there that are networking and donating and are very active"
 
 
 
For more discussion, be sure to tune in to To The Contrary! If you want to know when it'll be on in your area, click here.