|
|
Perfect Corpse, The
|
|
|
Viewing Ideas
|
|
Before Watching
Have students share what they know about bogs from firsthand experiences or
depictions on TV or in the movies. What do they think bogs are like? Discuss
with students what bogs are. (Bogs are spongy, water-soaked areas that have
layers of moss and peat and layers of other organic compounds such as organic
acids and aldehydes). How might the bodies discovered in bogs be different
from the human remains found at dry sites? (Bog environments—which are
characterized by a lack of oxygen in the peat—prevent bacteria from
growing and contain acids that make skin leathery and can preserve the soft
tissue of bodies. Bones often dissolve. The eyes, hair, skin, and inner organs
are sometimes well preserved, and the contents of the stomach can often be
analyzed. In a dry, open, aerobic environment, soft tissue decomposes over
time, and bones remain.) What can preserved bodies tell us? (The bodies
can potentially reveal information about when the people lived, how they lived,
and how they died.)
Have students research and map some of the regions where bogs are common and
where bog bodies have been found. (Some regions include North and Northwest
Europe, including the Netherlands, England, Wales, Ireland, Scotland, Denmark,
and Germany.)
In the program, the bog bodies are dated to the Early Iron Age. Have
students research the Stone Age, the Bronze Age, and the Iron Age. Students
should briefly describe each period, when it occurred, why dates for each age
are not uniform worldwide, and how its name may have been derived. (The ages
reflect growth and development. Dates differ in Europe and the Americas. Ages
and dates are best applied in relation to specific locations. The Stone Age
generally dates from about 2 million years ago to 4000 B.C. in Europe and
30,000 B.C. to 2500 B.C. in the New World. The Bronze Age dates to around 1500
B.C. in Europe. The Iron Age dates to about 1000 B.C. in southern Europe and
later in northern Europe. Cultures outside of Europe are not easily categorized
in this three-age system as they developed at different rates and, at times,
through different stages. Each age was named for the material that was
primarily used during that time to make tools and weapons.)
Organize students into six groups, three to take notes on information about
the bog body Oldcroghan Man and three to record information about Clonycavan
Man. Assign each set of the three groups one of the following topics: physical
characteristics of the body, techniques used to analyze the body and
conclusions drawn, and the possible reasons the body was put in the bog.
After Watching
Have students who took notes on the same topics meet, compare their notes,
and share what they learned.
Have each of the six groups meet, compare their notes, and share their
information with the class about their assigned topics. Discuss the conclusions
scientists drew about the bog bodies. Which conclusions did students have the
most confidence in? Why? Which conclusions did students have the least
confidence in? Why?
In the program, Oldcroghan Man's height is estimated to be almost two
meters. The estimate was obtained by measuring the body's arm span. Pair
students and have them measure each other's arm span and height. (When
measuring height, shoes should be off; when measuring arm span, measurements
should be taken across the back from fingertip to fingertip of outstretched
arms.) How do the two measurements compare? How consistent is the ratio of the
two measurements across the entire class? Have students compile and graph class
data in a scatter plot and show the best fit line.
Oldcroghan Man and Clonycavan Man were the subject of an 18-month
investigation by a team that included international scientists, museum
conservators, and historians. Make a chart or list on the board of each of the
kinds of scientists featured in the program, and have students describe the
different types of information each type contributed to this investigation.
Scientist |
Type
of Information
| |
Marie
Cassidy, state pathologist
|
used
modern forensic pathology to analyze injuries; measured height; noted skull
injuries
| |
Rolly
Reed, head of conservation at National Museum
|
reproduced
burial conditions in bog; took carbon-14 samples to date the bodies
| |
Isabella
Mulhall, Ned Kelly, and Tim Taylor, archeologists
|
reported
on overall condition of the body; had bodies scanned (both CT and MRI) to study
damage; read ancient writings to understand reasons for the deaths
| |
Patrick
Doyle, museum conservator
|
compared
condition of bodies to other bodies at the National Museum in Ireland; made
sure bodies didn't deteriorate during the investigation
| |
Don
Brothwell, soft tissue remains expert
|
provided
information on age and condition of tissue; analyzed hair along with
archeologists and conservation experts; analyzed stomach contents
| |
Michael
Macken, detective
|
participated
in fingerprint analysis
| |
Dr.
Andrew Wilson, paleodietary expert and bioarcheologist; Dr. Joan Fletcher,
professor
|
analyzed
fingernail growth to learn about season of death; analyzed hair and diet to
understand lifestyle
| |
Paul
Mulachy, archeologist
|
used
X-ray fluorescence of metal to find and date its chemical composition
| |
Valerie
Hall, environmental archeologist
|
analyzed
inhaled particles
| |
Miranda
Green, historian
|
offered
insight into sacrificial rituals
|
|
|