NFL Concussions: The 2012-13 Season In Review
Follow @jbrezlowFebruary 1, 2013, 2:15 pm ET
The 2012-13 NFL season has been a busy one in terms of concussion-related headlines. The past year saw more than 160 players go down with a head injury. Along the way, there have been landmark breakthroughs in brain research, a high-profile wrongful death lawsuit, and even a commentary on violence in football by President Obama. With Super Bowl XLVII just two days away, here is a look back at the top stories of the season:
08/07/2012: A year after the NFL moved up kickoffs by five yards, a study by the consulting firm Edgeworth Dynamics finds that the changes led to a 43 percent drop in the number of concussions reported during kickoffs from 2010 to 2011. Kickoffs are one of the more chaotic and dangerous plays in football.
09/05/2012: The NFL donates $30 million to the National Institutes of Health (NIH) for brain injury research. The unrestricted gift is the single-largest donation in league history. In the league’s press release announcing the gift, it points to chronic traumatic encephalopathy as one possible area of research. CTE, as the condition is known, is a degenerative brain condition associated with repeated head trauma. It can lead to dementia, memory loss, and depression, and has been documented in the brains of 50 deceased football players.
09/16/2012: New York Jets running back Shonn Greene is blasted on an illegal helmet-to-helmet hit by Steelers safety Ryan Mundy. Greene returns to the huddle, dazed and wobbly, until quarterback Mark Sanchez effectively removes him from the game by pushing him to the sidelines.
After a series of concussion tests in the locker room — which Jets officials say Greene passed — he is given the green light to return. Greene later says he does not remember Sanchez pushing him from the huddle. “I think what it was, when it first happened, I kind of got up too fast from the hit. I wasn’t all the way there. It was kind of shaky,” Greene tells ESPN.
The NFL’s Standardized Concussion Assessment Tool (pdf) lists six “obvious signs of disqualification” from play. They include confusion and amnesia.
09/30/2012: Detroit Lions receiver Calvin Johnson takes a helmet-to-helmet hit from Minnesota Vikings linebacker Chad Greenway. Johnson is tested for a concussion, but returns to the game about six minutes later. When the Lions return from a bye week after the Vikings game, Johnson is not listed on the injury report.
He goes on to tell reporters on at least three occasions he suffered a concussion, according to the Detroit Free Press. “It’s a part of football,” he says. “You get concussed, you gotta keep on playing.” The Lions dispute his account, however, and more than one month later issue a statement that says, “In response to the various reports … regarding Calvin Johnson and injuries, we reiterate that Calvin did not suffer a concussion at any time this season.”
09/30/2012: Jacksonville Jaguars receiver Laurent Robinson sustains his second concussion in as many weeks, and his third since the start of NFL training camp in July.
10/07/2012: Matt Cassel suffers a concussion after being hammered by Haloti Ngata of the Baltimore Ravens. Fans cheer as the struggling Kansas City Chiefs quarterback lay motionless on the field for several minutes after the hit. (Watch the hit here).
Following the game, Chiefs tackle Eric Winston rips the hometown crowd, telling reporters “we have a lot of problems as a society if people think that’s OK.” He adds:
10/14/2012: Washington Redskins safety Jordan Pugh exits a game against the Vikings twice in one quarter with a head injury. Pugh’s first injury comes with roughly four minutes left in the game. He is back on the field with 2:30 left on the clock after being cleared by the Redskins, according to the Associated Press, but is down again within 90 seconds. Following his second exit, Pugh is diagnosed with a head injury.
“[Pugh] comes on the sideline and [medical personnel] just told me Jordan’s out, and all of a sudden, he’s been cleared and he’s ready to go,” coach Mike Shanahan explained to reporters. “Then, at the end, they just told me that when he went down, he was dizzy, nauseous. He’s out.”
Pugh is listed on the team injury report the following week with a head injury, but does not miss any playing time.
10/17/2012: Steelers linebacker James Harrison tells the AP he’s begun installing an extra layer of military-grade protective padding inside his helmet. Harrison says he’s had “double digit” bouts with concussion-like symptoms over his career, and that since using the additional padding, he hasn’t “seen any spots or had any blackouts.”
10/19/2012: The NFL fines the Redskins $20,000 for violating league rules in their reporting of a head injury to rookie quarterback Robert Griffin III. Twelve days earlier, Griffin exited a game against the Atlanta Falcons after a hit to the head while scrambling along the sideline. (Watch the hit below). The team announced during the game that Griffin was “shaken up.” After the game, though, coach Mike Shanahan characterized the injury as a “mild concussion.”
“Clubs are required to provide accurate and timely injury information during games,” the NFL said in a statement.
11/07/2012: Chiefs quarterback Brady Quinn tells reporters he attempted to play through a concussion during a Week 8 game against the Oakland Raiders. Prior to the game, Quinn had spent three years as a backup. “I tried to stay in the game, because it was the first opportunity for me in a while,” he says. “I tried to play through it, and it’s my fault for not being smart about it.”
11/11/2012: Ten games into his most successful NFL season to date, San Francisco 49ers quarterback Alex Smith suffers a concussion against the St. Louis Rams. He stays in the game briefly, and despite a case of blurred vision, connects with receiver Michael Crabtree six plays later for a touchdown.
Smith is replaced by Colin Kaepernick, who goes on to permanently take over the quarterback position for the 49ers. Critics say coach Jim Harbaugh’s decision to stick with Kaepernick even after Smith returned to full health will only make players more reluctant to report head injuries.
“I feel like the only thing I did to lose my job was get a concussion,” Smith later says.
11/11/2012: Three starting quarterbacks — Jay Cutler of the Chicago Bears, Michael Vick of the Philadelphia Eagles, and the 49ers’ Alex Smith — leave games with head injuries. The NFL Players Association (NFLPA) responds by saying it will renew its call for independent neurologists on the sidelines of every NFL game.
An NFL spokesman, quoting Dr. Richard Ellenbogen, co-chair of the NFL’s head, neck and spine committee, says:
11/15/2012: NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell takes to Harvard University for a major address on player safety. Goodell tells the audience that in order to cut down on serious head injuries, the nation needs to scrap the “warrior mentality” that often keeps players from disclosing injuries. “Changing the culture in a way that reduces the injury risk to the maximum possible extent — especially the risk of head injury,” says Goodell, is the NFL’s “biggest challenge.”
11/16/2012: A joint investigation between FRONTLINE and ESPN finds the NFL’s retirement board awarded disability payments to at least three former players after determining football caused their brain injuries. The payments stand out because they came during a period in which the league’s top medical experts denied any link between professional football and long-term brain damage.
11/22/2012 – 11/26/2012: Nineteen players exit games with either a concussion or head injury during Week 12, the most of any week of the season.
12/03/2012: Researchers at Boston University announce they’ve discovered 28 new cases of CTE in deceased football players, including 15 who played in the NFL. The discovery more than doubles the number of documented cases connecting football to long-term brain disease.
12/04/2012: Former Steelers receiver Hines Ward says the best way to cut down on concussions is to get rid of helmets. As he tells The Dan Patrick Show:
12/17/2012: Commissioner Roger Goodell floats the idea of eliminating kickoffs altogether during an interview in the Dec. 17 issue of Time.
12/27/2012: New York Jets coach Rex Ryan tells reporters that third-string quarterback Greg McElroy — who just four days earlier was elevated to starter — hid concussion symptoms from the team’s medical staff. Several players tell ESPN that while trainers may not have known about McElroy’s symptoms, teammates did. “He definitely has that [warrior] mentality, but it got to the point where it was scaring him,” said left guard Matt Slauson, who was aware of McElroy’s condition.
01/07/2013: A study of 34 former NFL players by researchers at the University of Texas finds depression and cognitive damage is more prevalent among ex-players than in the general population. At the same time, researchers found no evidence of cognitive impairment in the majority of players in the study.
01/10/2013: The NIH says an examination of Junior Seau’s brain showed the former NFL linebacker suffered from CTE at the time of his suicide in May 2011 after more than 20 seasons in the league.
01/22/2013: Brain scans performed on five former NFL players reveal traces of the protein that causes CTE. The landmark study by researchers at UCLA marks the first time signs of the crippling disease have been identified among living players.
01/23/2013: Junior Seau’s family files a wrongful death lawsuit against the NFL, claiming the linebacker’s suicide was caused by head trauma he sustained over his 20 years in professional football. The lawsuit alleges the NFL deliberately hid from players the dangers of repetitive blows to the head.
01/25/2013: Ravens safety Bernard Pollard tells CBS Sports that the NFL’s renewed emphasis on player safety is threatening the league’s future.
“Thirty years from now, I don’t think it will be in existence,” said Pollard. “I could be wrong. It’s just my opinion, but I think with the direction things are going — where [NFL rules makers] want to lighten up, and they’re throwing flags and everything else — there’s going to come a point where fans are going to get fed up with it.”
01/27/2013: President Obama enters the conversation about violence in football, telling The New Republic that if he had a son, he’d think twice about letting him play the game. As the president put it:
01/29/2013: The NFLPA announces it will partner with Harvard University for a 10-year, $100 million study of 1,000 retired players. The study will focus, in part, on repetitive blows to the head and how they contribute to CTE. Research will also look beyond head trauma to examine everything from knee ligaments and heart function to psychological stress and the effects of long-term exposure to painkillers.
01/31/2013: The same day that the NFLPA reveals a survey that finds four in five NFL players do not trust their team’s medical staff, the NFL’s general counsel, Jeff Pash, says the league expects to have independent neurologists on the sidelines next season to help diagnose concussions.
SUPPORT PROVIDED BY
NEXT ON FRONTLINEObama at WarMay 26th
FRONTLINE Watch FRONTLINE About FRONTLINE Contact FRONTLINE
FRONTLINE is a registered trademark of WGBH Educational Foundation.
Web Site Copyright ©1995-2015 WGBH Educational Foundation
PBS is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization.