Cast Iron Bird Gate Weight, ca, 1900
Appraised Value: $600 - $800 (1999)
$600 - $800 (2013)
IMAGE: 1 of 4
In early 2014, news broke of a California couple who had found buried treasure, in the form of $10 million in gold coins. The anonymous couple then hired a lawyer and spent months looking into the legality of their claim on the money. At the end of the investigation, the couple kept the gold. They had spent untold dollars in legal fees in order to find out what children learn on the playground: "Finders keepers, losers weepers." For a schoolyard taunt, the adage sums up centuries of common law surprisingly well. In general, lost property indeed belongs to the person who finds it, as long as he or she finds it in good faith.
Of course there are exceptions — so many, in fact, that law professor John Orth told Time magazine that whenever such situations are litigated, with multiple parties making claims on the property, "These cases are a mess."
But the messiness can often be resolved by answering a simple question: Did the original owner intentionally abandon the disputed item — say by throwing it in the garbage? If so, finders keepers. Or, did they accidentally misplace it? In such cases, the original owner might be able to stake a claim. After all, it's hard to imagine a judge awarding possession of a set of mislaid car keys to the guy who takes them out of the deadbolt on your front door.
Appraisal Video: (2:01)
Decorative Arts, Folk Art, Furniture, Musical Instruments
APPRAISER: The bird is the word... so to speak. And, actually, the word is also cast iron.
GUEST: Cast iron. Well, my dad and my Uncle Henry were in the scrap iron business back in the early '50s. And they acquired it from some street hoboes. (laughs)
APPRAISER: Street hoboes.
GUEST: Street hoboes from Baltimore who thought this might earn them a little pocket change. And so my dad and uncle eagerly took it off their hands and now I have it.
APPRAISER: First thing I want to tell you is what it is.
GUEST: That would be great.
APPRAISER: Because you've had trouble finding that out.
GUEST: We've been looking for many years.
APPRAISER: It's a gate weight.
APPRAISER: Most of the ones you see are shaped like cannonballs and they were commonly used in England in the 18th century and in America up through the mid-19th century. And the thing that's neat about this is it becomes more than just a piece of cast iron. It's a nice form. It's a bird. I think the reason that the beak is so pointed is so they could stick it in the post to hold the gate open. If they had something in their arms they were carrying it back and forth. Well, see how much it's worn off on the end? I think that paint loss is from sticking it in the wood. The other thing that's nice is it has its original multicolor paint decoration. Every town had a foundry where they made things like this: fireplace tools, kitchen items. You name it, and it was probably cast locally there in Baltimore. What you have is a very functional, but also very decorative item-- one of the things that we look for in American folk art. And on today's market in the condition that it's in, I'd say conservatively its auction estimate would be $600 to $800.
GUEST: Oh, great. (laughs) Lunch is on me. (laughs)
This website is produced for PBS Online by WGBH Boston. ©1997-2014 WGBH Educational Foundation.
ANTIQUES ROADSHOW is a trademark of the BBC and is produced for PBS by WGBH under license from BBC Worldwide.
WGBH and PBS are not responsible for the content of websites linked to or from ANTIQUES ROADSHOW Online.
PBS is a 501(c)(3) not-for-profit organization.