Visit Your Local PBS Station PBS Home PBS Home Programs A-Z TV Schedules Watch Video Support PBS Shop PBS Search PBS

Music and Evolution
Music and the Neanderthal's Communication

Scientist and author of The Singing Neanderthals: The Origins of Music, Language, Mind, and Body Stephen Mithen explains his theories about The Neanderthal’s musicality.

Get the Flash Player to see the wordTube Media Player.

Stephen Mithen: The Neanderthals—there’s no evidence that they had language. But they must have had a sophisticated form of communication. They were just like humans, they might would have had to have told other people how they’re feeling, they would have had to look after their children and nurture them. They had to have made plans for group hunting and general movement. So what sort of communications system did they have? Now I came to the conclusion which must have been based on high degrees of musicality. Because we can see traces of that in our nearest living relatives. This seems to be the only form of communication with that language that would have been complex to allow them to have function as a social group, and yet not gone that extra step to modern language. So I think they communicated by using sets of phrases, almost like musical phrases that would have had semantic meanings, phrases such as something that would translate into “Let us share meat,” “We’ll go hunting” or “How are you feeling?” but would have been expressed in musical tones, different types of pitches, different types of rhythms. They might have used these also to build a sense of group identity, very much how we use music today, especially for caring for infants, you know just like we do today with our youngest children before they got language, we sing to them and move them rhythmically . I’m sure the Neanderthals would have been doing exactly the same.

Bookmark    Print    Email    Comment/s (6)

(14 votes)
Loading ... Loading ...
6 comments
Kevin Fitzpatrick -- June 18th, 2009 at 12:54 am

Intriguing – look forward to seeing the broadcast to see if there are some additional lines of evidence to support his theory.

[...] Re: How did language originate? Turtle (and all interested) were you referring to this? Music and Evolution: Music and the Neanderthal’s Communication | Music Instinct | PBS Or just the nature of inflection in many forms of communication even among "lower" [...]

Stephen Dolle -- June 25th, 2009 at 5:49 pm

I watched the TV airing of this PBS piece last night, as I am a neuroscientist and musician. I will be making a presentation next week to a Southern California science center on what I would deliver in a workshop or keynote presentation on the rhythms of the brain.

I am an Afro Cuban percussionist and drum circle facilitator, and have undertaken research with rhythm and cognition, movement, and apply this to team building, communications, neuro disorders, and even sports like basketball and football. It all figures together.

I see a massive connection of music to human movement and communication, also seen in the dancing Cockatoo. I believe music originated as a training tool to replicate important sounds of everyday life. The role of birds as communicators to aid human and other animal survival has been well covered. Birds warn us of danger, sing us to sleep, are of a spiritual nature, and perhaps the first entertainers on Earth.

I believe music originated to enhance our survival thru improved movement and communications for social, reproductive, team work, and averting danger, i.e. recognizing critical sounds on Earth. When science measures the emotional response to music, what it is testing is really whether the person understands the “meaning” of various audible sounds, that I believe is in part passed on genetically (at least pre-wired), familarly, and easily learned thru life.

I believe our brains are pre-wired to process the sounds and movement we will see and hear in a lifetime. Movements outside of our audible range are still rhythmic, and serve us much in the same way as audible sound. We sense movement by way of our vestibular system: sight, sound, middle ear, mid-brain sensors, and body sensory. Our sense of smell can tells us direction when it is unclear.

I believe we sense sound vibration and movement also with our physical body, and that our body is able to carry out cognitive tasks to support multi-tasking by the brain. Using your body aids a specific type of intelligence. Our bodies are also pre-wired to recognize rhythmic patterns, with sensors in each of our joints. We can communicate, think, recall, and execute cognitive tasks in part with our bodies. That is why the brains of musicians are often thicker in certain cortex areas, having had music as a training tool.

I would be happy to share more of my rhythm and brain research with any in this program. I am now doing keynotes where I play and speak. Please contact DolleCommunications.com

Stephen Dolle -- June 25th, 2009 at 6:02 pm

The following is a language learning trial I’d like a school or teacher to try out.

I am a drum circle facilitator, and I believe that playing and listening to percussion in an “open format” strengthens the areas of the brain necessary in learning language. I have notice times when I play a lot, I am able to understand foreign languages in ways I would not normally pick up on.

Visualize how before a golfer or baseball player goes out to play, he/she takes numerous practice swings. The same holds for a person preparing for an exam. Well, is there some prep you might do to enhance learning in a language course?

I would propose a language class try 10-15 minutes at the beginning of each class playing small hand percussion in open format, in the hopes it may trigger the language centers of the brain. You could include another class or two as a control.

I’ve spoken about this to my colleages in drum circle facilitation, and there seems to be some concensus on the connection.

If you desire more information, contact me at Dolle Communications. Thanks.

[...] is important please From the origin of language thread (please remove if redundant) add this Music and Evolution: Music and the Neanderthal’s Communication | Music Instinct | PBS great thread btw [...]

Leotaurus -- October 23rd, 2009 at 9:58 am

Seem utopian and absurd. Neanderthals may live in today’s society
According to the appearance and the reconstructed skull of such people is very rare, their intellect is several times lower.
http://www.tiputeorija.lt/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=68&Itemid=76
http://video.google.com/videoplay?docid=-2707258963809688424#docid=7113880940822502772

post a comment
Please note that the WNET editorial staff reserves the right to not post comments it deems to be inappropriate and/or malicious in nature, as well as edit comments for length, clarity and fairness. No solicitations or advertisements will be allowed. Users may link to other Web sites relevant to discussion, but most often links to commercial Web sites will not be permitted.

YouTube iTunes

Produced by THIRTEEN WNET New York    ©2010 Educational Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved.